Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-lnqnp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T14:23:12.891Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Consciousness, Supervenience, and Identity: Marras and Kim on the Efficacy of Conscious Experience

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 September 2012

LIAM P. DEMPSEY
LIAM P. DEMPSEY*
Affiliation:
Trent University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In this paper, I argue that while supervenience accounts of mental causation in general have difficulty avoiding epiphenomenalism, the situation is particularly bad in the case of conscious experiences since the function-realizer relation, arguably present in the case of intentional properties, does not obtain, and thus, the metaphysical link between supervenient and subvenient properties is absent. I contend, however, that the identification of experiential types with their neural correlates dispels the spectre epiphenomenalism, squares nicely both with the phenomenology of embodiment and the subjectivity of experience, and does not conflict with the supposed multiple realizability of consciousness.

Les explications en termes de survenance de la causalité mentale en général évitent difficilement l’épiphénoménalisme. La situation s’aggrave dans le cas d’expériences conscientes, puisque la relation entre la fonction et sa réalisation, dont on peut soutenir qu’elle est présente dans le cas des propriétés intentionnelles, n’a pas cours. Ainsi, le lien métaphysique entre les propriétés survenantes et sous-jacentes est absent. Je soutiens cependant que l’identification de types expérienciels à leurs corrélatifs neuraux dissipe le spectre de l’épiphénoménalisme. Elle s’aligne harmonieusement tantôt sur la phénoménologie de l’incarnation (embodiment), tantôt sur la subjectivité de l’expérience, et n’entre pas en conflit avec la présumée réalisabilité multiple de la conscience.

Type
Articles
Information
Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review / Revue canadienne de philosophie , Volume 51 , Issue 3 , September 2012 , pp. 373 - 395
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Philosophical Association 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Alexander, Samuel 1920 Space, Time, and Deity, Two Volumes. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Armstrong, David 1968 A Materialist Theory of Mind. New York: Humanities Press.Google Scholar
Block, Ned 1978 “Troubles with Functionalism.” Reprinted in The Nature of Mind. Ed. Rosenthal., D. M.Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1991, 211–228.Google Scholar
Block, Ned 1995 “The Mind as the Software of the Brain.” Reprinted in Philosophy of Mind: A Guide and Anthology. Ed. Heil., J.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004, 267–270.Google Scholar
Block, Ned and Fodor, Jerry 1972 “What Psychological States are Not.” Philosophical Review 81: 159–181.Google Scholar
Chalmers, David 1996 The Conscious Mind. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Chalmers, David 2002 “Consciousness and Its Place in Nature.” In Philosophy of Mind: Contemporary and Classical Readings. Ed. Chalmers., D.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 247–72.Google Scholar
Cytowic, Richard 2002 Synesthesia: A Union of the Senses. Cambridge: MIT Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Damasio, Antonio 1994 Descartes’ Error. New York: Grosset-Putnam.Google Scholar
Damasio, Antonio 1999 The Feeling of What Happens. New York: Harcourt, Brace and Co.Google Scholar
Dempsey, Liam P. 2002 “Chalmers’s Fading and Dancing Qualia: Consciousness and the ‘Hard Problem’.” Southwest Philosophy Review 18: 65–80.Google Scholar
Dempsey, Liam P. 2004 “Conscious Experience, Reduction, and Identity: Many Explanatory Gaps, One Solution.” Philosophical Psychology 17: 225–245.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dempsey, Liam P. 2009a “Thinking-Matter Then and Now: The Evolution of Mind-Body Dualism.” History of Philosophy Quarterly 26: 43–61.Google Scholar
Dempsey, Liam P. 2009b Shades of Experience: Consciousness and the Metaphysics of Mind-Brain Identity. Saarbrücken: VDM Verlag.Google Scholar
Dempsey, Liam P. and Shani, Itay 2009 “Dynamical Agents: Consciousness, Causation, and Two Specters of Epiphenomenalism.” Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 8: 225–243.Google Scholar
Dempsey, Liam P. and Shani, ItayForthcoming “Stressing the Flesh: In Defense of Strong Embodied Cognition.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research.Google Scholar
Feigl, Herbert 1967 “The ‘Mental’ and the ‘Physical’: the Essay with a Postscript.” Minneapolis: University of Minneapolis Press.Google Scholar
Fodor, Jerry 1974 “Special Sciences (or: the disunity of science as a working hypothesis).” Synthese 28: 97–15.Google Scholar
Fodor, Jerry 1989 “Making Mind Matter More.” Philosophical Topics 17: 59–79.Google Scholar
Hardin, C. L. 1994 “Color and Illusion.” In Mind and Cognition: a Reader. Ed. Lycan., W.Cambridge, MA: Blackwell, 555–567.Google Scholar
Hill, Christopher 1991 Sensations: A Defense of Type Materialism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Hurvich, Leo M., Jameson, Dorothea, and Cohen, Joseph D. 1968 “The Experimental Determination of Unique Green in the Spectrum.” Perception and Psychophysics 4: 65–68.Google Scholar
Kim, Jaegwon 1989 “The Myth of Non-Reductive Materialism.” Reprinted in his Supervenience and Mind: Selected Philosophical Essays. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993, 265–284.Google Scholar
Kim, Jaegwon 1992a “Downward Causation in Emergentism and Nonreductive Physicalism.” In Emergence or Reduction? Essays on the Prospects of Nonreductive Materialism. Eds. Beckerman, A., Flohr, H., and Kim, J.. Berlin: de Gruyter, 119–138.Google ScholarPubMed
Kim, Jaegwon 1992b “Multiple Realization and the Metaphysics of Reduction.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 52: 1–26.Google Scholar
Kim, Jaegwon 1998 Mind in a Physical World. Cambridge: MIT Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kim, Jaegwon 2003 “Blocking Causal Drainage and Other Maintenance Chores with Mental Causation.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 67: 151–176.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kim, Jaegwon 2005 Physicalism, or Something Near Enough. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Lepore, Ernest and Loewer, Barry 1987 “Mind Matters.” Journal of Philosophy 84: 630–642.Google Scholar
Lepore, Ernest and Loewer, Barry 1989 “More on Making Mind Matter.” Philosophical Topics 17: 175–191.Google Scholar
Levine, Joseph 1983 “Materialism and Qualia: The Explanatory Gap.” Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 64: 354–361.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lewin, Roger 1980 “Is Your Brain Really Necessary?” Science 210: 1232–1234.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lewis, David 1966 “An Argument for the Identity Thesis.” Journal of Philosophy 67: 203–211.Google Scholar
Lewis, David 1972 “Psychophysical and Theoretical Identification.” American Journal of Philosophy 50: 249–58.Google Scholar
Lewis, David 1980 “Mad Pain and Martian Pain.” Reprinted in The Nature of Mind. Ed. Rosenthal., D. M.Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1991, 229–233.Google Scholar
Libet, Benjamin 1999 “Do We Have Free Will?” Journal of Consciousness Studies 6: 47–58.Google Scholar
Marras, Ausonio 1993a “Supervenience and Reducibility: An Odd Couple.” Philosophical Quarterly 43: 215–222.Google Scholar
Marras, Ausonio 1993b “Materialism, Functionalism, and Supervenient Qualia.” Dialogue 32: 475–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marras, Ausonio 2000 “Critical Notice of Jaegwon Kim’s Mind in a Physical World.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy 30: 137–160.Google Scholar
Marras, Ausonio 2002 “Kim on Reduction.” Erkenntnis 57: 231–257.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marras, Ausonio 2007 “Kim’s Supervenient Argument and Non-Reductive Physicalism,” Erkenntnis 66: 305–327.Google Scholar
Marras, AusonioForthcoming. “The Prospects for Nonreductive Physicalism.” ErkenntnisGoogle Scholar
Nida-Rumelin, Martine 1996 “An Actual Case of Qualia Inversion?” Philosophical Studies 82: 145–57.Google Scholar
Perry, John 2001 Knowledge, Possibility, and Consciousness. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Putnam, Hillary 1963 “Brains and Behavior.” Reprinted in The Nature of Mind. Ed. Rosenthal., D. M.Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1991, 151–159.Google Scholar
Putnam, Hillary 1967 “The Nature of Mental States.” Reprinted in The Nature of Mind. Ed. Rosenthal., D. M.Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1991, 197–203.Google Scholar
Shoemaker, Sydney 1984 “Causality and Properties.” Reprinted in Identity, Cause, and Mind. New York: Oxford University Press, 2003, 206–233.Google Scholar
Smart, J. J. C. 1959 “Sensations and Brain Processes.” Philosophical Review 68: 141–156.Google Scholar