The 2019 coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is an infectious disease, which derives from severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infection. The first case of COVID-19 was reported in Wuhan, Hubei Province, China, in December 2019. Unfortunately, the number of infections increased rapidly and quickly spread to most of the provinces in China and most countries around the world, resulting in the COVID-19 pandemic. The World Health Organization has identified it as a major global public health emergency; however, there is no specific treatment for COVID-19 at present.
COVID-19 is mainly transmitted by droplets, contact with contaminated surfaces, and aerosolized virus. Reference Lu, Liu and Jia1 According to the possible presence of SARS-CoV-2 in saliva, aerosols may play a role in SARS-CoV-2 transmission in dentistry. Reference Sabino-Silva, Jardim and Siqueira2 Dentistry presents unique challenges that may make them more susceptible to SARS-CoV-2.
Since January 2020, most provinces and cities in China have adopted a first-level emergency response to public health emergencies. The unique characteristics of dental treatments and the high risk of cross-infection prompted the suspension of all routine dental treatment services. Reference Yang, Zhou, Liu and Tan3 Our hospital immediately instituted several measures to prevent COVID-19 infection, as follows.
Methods
Treat Only Oral Emergencies
During the outbreak of COVID-19, we adopted the general principle of treating only dental emergencies, Reference Meng, Hua and Bian4 including acute toothache, oral and maxillofacial trauma, maxillofacial space infection, temporomandibular joint dislocation, tooth trauma, spontaneous gingival bleeding, pericoronitis, and other critical patients, which were based on the health commission, dentistry-related professional societies, and quality control centers in many provinces and cities of China.
Suspended Treatment Management
Due to the outbreak of COVID-19, medical resources were used for the prevention of COVID-19, resulting in some non-emergency diseases not being treated in a timely manner. To solve this problem, our hospital had adopted telemedicine measures. First, a 24-hour hotline was provided to patients by the specialist team. Second, video consultation was provided for patients whose problems couldn’t be solved by a telephone consultation. Third, common scientific articles and videos were pushed for advice in which urgent cases must come to the hospital and introduce self-treatment methods of each non-urgent disease for patients on the official website and WeChat. Reference Guo, Wu and Xie5
Three-Level Pre-Examination and Triage Test and 2-Body Temperature Tests
To prevent cross-infection, the hospital instituted a 3-level pre-examination and triage test and 2-body temperature tests, patient health card status inquiry, personal itinerary query within 15 days, and prehospital screening of epidemiological history and body temperature. Three-level pre-examination and triage means patients must undergo 3 pre-examinations before meeting with the dentist: question and triage at the hospital entrance, more triage at the guidance desk in the outpatient hall, and before meeting the dentist in the consultation room. For the 2-temperature tests, the patient’s temperature was taken at the hospital entrance and again at the guidance desk in the outpatient hall. At the pre-examination and triage guidance desk in the outpatient hall, all patients were registered and their basic information was recorded (body temperature, ID number, telephone number, address) to facilitate future epidemiological investigations. Patients with a body temperature of 37.3°C or the epidemiological history of COVID-19 were persuaded to go to the nearest designated hospital to determine whether they were positive for COVID-19, as well as to track where they were going. Patients with suspected or diagnosed COVID-19 were sent to designated hospitals that have isolation and treatment capabilities. The pre-examination and triage flow chart is shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1 Flow Chart of Outpatient Triage.
Personnel Management
Training
All staff, including medical staff, management personnel, and cleaner, received rigorous training in COVID-19 prevention via several online and on-site courses taught by infectious disease specialists. Personnel were required to master the knowledge of how to prevent COVID-19. Their knowledge was assessed by an examination after training, and anyone who failed could not be assigned to work.
Scheduling Personnel
During the epidemic, the entire staff were evaluated daily using the WeChat app to determine whether they had any symptoms indicative of the COVID-19 infection. Only staff members who met the following criteria could be assigned to work in the dental emergency facilities: no fever, cough, fatigue, or other symptoms of potential COVID-19 infection; no history of non-local contact (outside of Changsha) within 14 days; and no history of possible exposure to the virus.
Three-Level Protection for Medical Personnel
The medical staff of our hospital carried out three-level protection. The three-level protection of medical personnel is shown in Figure 2 and described, as follows.
Figure 2 Medical Personnel Graded Protection.
Primary Protection
Oral medicine staff was required to wear disposable work caps, surgical masks, and overalls, and they could wear either protective goggles or face shields and disposable latex or nitrile gloves, if necessary.
Secondary Protection
Disposable work caps, surgical masks, protective goggles or face shields, disposable isolation work clothes or surgical scrubs, and disposable gloves were required.
Third-Level Protection
Disposable protective clothing, including disposable work caps, N95 type respirator, protective goggles or face shields, disposable latex gloves, and anti-leakage shoe covers, must also be worn by patients with confirmed or suspected COVID-19.
Managing Dental Practice
Preparing Examination and Treatment Instruments
Nurses were required to familiarize themselves with the routine and steps involved in oral examinations and treatments, to ensure that all necessary instruments and equipment were prepared in advance, and to avoid going in and out of the clinic during the examination to reduce pollution and cross-infection.
Gargle Before Oral Examination and Treatment
Patients were instructed to gargle with 1% povidone iodine for 2 minutes before treatment, which can reduce the number of microorganisms in droplets and aerosols produced by oral procedures and surgery, Reference Izzetti, Nisi, Gabriele and Graziani6 and patients were shown how to seal their mouths around the mouths of a disposable water cup.
Implement the 4-Hand Operation
During the COVID-19 epidemic, every dental chair in our hospital was equipped with a doctor and a nurse, and a 4-handed operation was carried out during oral examination and treatment. This arrangement can improve the efficiency and quality of the surgical procedure and is conducive to infection control. Reference Li and Meng7
Suctioning Saliva During Oral Treatment
The use of strong and weak attractors to rapidly suction saliva can also help reduce the production of droplets and aerosols during oral procedures. It is worth noting that, when using a weak attractor, patients were advised not to close their lips and bite the suction head.
Use a Rubber Dam to Isolate the Surgical Field
The teeth are isolated using a rubber dam after induction of local anesthesia during the COVID-19 pandemic, and 75% ethanol cotton balls are used to disinfect the affected teeth and rubber dam in the surgical field. We recommend using a 3D rubber barrier without perforating because it is more convenient and quick to operate.
Strict Enforcement of Hand Hygiene
All medical and nonmedical staff were required to strictly follow the principle of good hand hygiene during and after all examinations and treatments. The consultation room was equipped with qualified detergent, hand disinfectant, and hand-drying facilities.
Results
On January 23, 2020, Hunan Province launched the first-level response to this major public health emergency of COVID-19, which has been downgraded to a second-level response since March 9. We described some measures taken to prevent COVID-19 transmission during the oral examinations and treatment in our hospital. From January 24, 2020, to March 8, 2020, a total of 4272 patients received oral treatment in our hospital. The dental emergency types were pulpitis (1842), periapical periodontitis (1146), pericoronitis (626), tooth trauma (420), cracked tooth (71), periodontal abscess (37), disorders of the temporomandibular joint (23), dislocation of the temporomandibular joint (21), periapical abscess (20), and others (66).
All patient basic information was registered. If a patient is confirmed with COVID-19, the information is recorded to facilitate future epidemiological investigations, which are provided to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Through 3-level pre-examination and triage testing and 2-body temperature tests, we screened 50 patients with a body temperature greater than 37.3°C, 36 patients with respiratory symptoms, and 20 patients with an epidemiological history from January 24, 2020, to March 8, 2020. The CDC provides free polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests for them. Two of them have been diagnosed with COVID-19.
We did PCR tests for all staff during the epidemic. In addition, the PCR test is also required if medical personnel have a suspected symptom or epidemiological history of COVID-19, which is evaluated daily using the WeChat app. A total of 726 PCR tests were conducted in our staff. A dentist was detected as a suspected case. The CDC quarantined her and the 16 people who came in contact with her for 14 days. Fortunately, COVID-19 was ruled out for all of them.
After implementing epidemic prevention measures, the number of outpatients in our hospital decreased from 1340 to 95 per day. After the epidemic situation was controlled, our hospital began to gradually resume routine oral examination and treatment on March 9, 2020. The number of outpatients in our hospital increased to 699 per day between March 10 and March 31 and increased to 1383 per day between April 1 and July 31. The number has since returned to the normal level. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we have followed the guidelines. All staff or patients were not infected with COVID-19. Suspected cases among them were confirmed, but, after PCR testing, results were negative.
Discussion
We adopted the general principle of treating only dental emergencies during the outbreak of COVID-19, patients with nonacute or subacute conditions were routinely given health guidance and drug treatment, and surgery was postponed appropriately. Reference Guo, Xie, Liang and Wu8 The hospital implemented online and telephonic bookings to minimize on-site registration and to actively guide patients to see a dentist. Appointment times were staggered to reduce patient aggregation and avoid cross-infection.
It is very important to follow up the guideline of 3-level pre-examination and triage testing and 2-body temperature tests. Two COVID-19 patients were screened through the guideline, avoiding cross-infection and better protecting the safety of medical staff and patients. According to a systematic review, 88.7% of patients have symptoms of fever, which is the most obvious symptom of COVID-19. Reference Rodriguez-Morales, Cardona-Ospina and Gutiérrez-Ocampo9 Stomatological hospitals and dental clinics can’t test for COVID-19, so checking patient temperatures and asking about the history of epidemiology are the simplest and most economical ways to screen patients.
Medical institutions have been faced with a critical shortage of protective equipment during the COVID-19 epidemic. The evidence-based medical study has found that there is no statistically significant difference in the efficacy of N95 respirators and surgical masks in the prevention of non-aerosol infection. Reference Long, Hu and Liu10 It is suggested that N95 respirators should not be recommended for non-high-risk medical staff who are not in close contact with infected or suspected patients.
To minimize the possibility of cross-infection, it is very necessary to follow up some dental practices, such as preparing examination and treatment instruments, patient gargling before oral examination and treatment, implementing the 4-hand operation, suctioning saliva, using a rubber dam, and strictly enforcing hand hygiene.
However, the pandemic is still spreading worldwide. Therefore, all oral medicine institutions should develop and follow emergency management protocols to prevent the spread of COVID-19. Dental health workers should follow up the requirements and procedures required to prevent COVID-19.
Conclusions
When only oral emergencies are treated during the outbreak of COVID-19, telemedicine measures, such as a 24-hour hotline, video consultation, common scientific articles, and videos, are needed. To prevent cross-infection, it is necessary for stomatological hospitals or clinics to institute 3-level pre-examination and triage testing and 2-body temperature tests. Medical staff should be required to follow strict procedures of 3-level protection. It is also necessary to strengthen the training of hospital infection for oral medical staff. Practical recommendations for managing treatment include patient gargling before oral examination and treatment, implementing the 4-hand operation, suctioning saliva, using a rubber dam, and strictly enforcing hand hygiene. These preventive measures for COVID-19 in dental treatments can be used as a reference for oral clinics and stomatological hospitals.
Acknowledgments
We would like to thank TopEdit (www.topeditsci.com) for the English language editing of this manuscript.
Financial Support
Our study was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of Hunan Province (No. 2019JJ80054 and No. 2019JJ80055), the Scientific Research Project of the Hunan Health Commission (No. B2019133), Research Project Funding of the Changsha Municipal Health and Family Planning Commission (No. 201809), Health Care Special Fund Research Project of Hunan Province (No. B2020-07), and Clinical Medical Technology Innovation Guiding Project of Hunan Province (No. 2020SK53206).
Conflict of Interest Statement
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
Open access
