Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-8ctnn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T13:27:04.009Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A BLURRED CASE

The Diversity Defense for Affirmative Action in the U.S.

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 June 2020

Ashley Brown Burns  and
William Darity Jr.
Ashley Brown Burns*
Affiliation:
Department of Political Science, Tulane University
William Darity Jr.
Affiliation:
Sanford School of Public Policy, Department of African & African American Studies, Department of Economics, Duke University
*
*Corresponding author: Ashley Brown Burns, Department of Political Science, Tulane University, 316 Norman Mayer Building, New Orleans, LA 70118. E-mail: aburns5@tulane.edu
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Much of the pivotal debate concerning the validity of affirmative action is situated in a legal context of defending or challenging claims that there may be broad societal gains from increased diversity. Race-conscious affirmative action policies originally advanced legal sanctions to promote racial equity in the United States. Today, increasingly detached from its historical context, defense or rejection of affirmative action is otherwise upheld to achieve diversity. A “diversity” rationale for affirmative action calls for increasing tolerance of the “other,” reducing negative stereotypes, and moderating prejudice as goals—all objectives that deviate from the former aim of race-targeted inclusion intended to resolve racial discrimination in employment and college admissions. Diversity policy provides a tapered defense for affirmative action, one detached from principles of justice and equity. The current article suggests that, despite the fact that the ostensible benefits of “racial inclusion as diversity” may be the remaining legal prop for affirmative action in the U.S., there is a need to consider whether diversity intrinsically can engender the benefits that affirmative action policy seeks to provide.

Keywords

Racial EquitySocial JusticeSegregationIntegrationDiversityAffirmative ActionSocial Exclusion
Type
State of the Discipline
Information
Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race , Volume 16 , Issue 2 , Fall 2019 , pp. 341 - 356
Copyright
Copyright © Hutchins Center for African and African American Research 2020 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

REFERENCES

Alagna, Sheryle, Reddy, Diane, and Collins, Daniel (1982). Perceptions of Functioning in Mixed-Sex and Male Medical Training Groups. Journal of Medical Education, 57(10): 801–803.Google ScholarPubMed
Allen, Richard, Dawson, Gail, Wheatley, Kathleen, and White, Charles (2008). Perceived Diversity and Organizational Performance. Employee Relations, 30(1): 20–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Allport, Gordon (1954). The Nature of Prejudice. Cambridge, MA: Addison-Wesley.Google Scholar
Ancona, Deborah, and Caldwell, David (1992). Rethinking Team Composition from the Outside In. In Gruenfeld, Deborah (Ed.), Research on Managing Groups and Teams, pp. 21–37. Stamford, CT: JAI Press.Google Scholar
Ashforth, Blake, and Mael, Fred (1989). Social Identity Theory and the Organization. The Academy of Management Review, 14(1): 20–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Astin, Alexander W. (1993a). Diversity and Multiculturalism on the Campus. Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning, 25(2): 44–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Astin, Alexander W. (1993b). The Jossey-Bass Higher and Adult Education Series. What Matters in College? Four Critical Years Revisited. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
Bantel, Karen, and Jacksonl, Susan(1989). Top Management and Innovations in Banking: Does the Composition of the Top Team Make a Difference? Strategic Management Journal, 10: 107–124.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bar, Michaela, Niessen, Alexandra, and Ruenzi, Stefan (2007). The Impact of Work Group Diversity on Performance: Large Sample Evidence from the Mutual Fund Industry. University of Cologne. Koeln, Germany: Center for Financial Research.Google Scholar
Barsade, Sigal, Ward, Andrew, Turner, Jean, and Sonnenfeld, Jeffrey (2000). To Your Heart’s Content: A Model of Affective Diversity in Top Management Teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 45: 802–836.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berrey, Ellen (2015). The Enigma of Diversity: The Language of Race and the Limits of Racial Justice. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bogan, Vicki, Just, David, and Dev, Chekitan (2013). Team Gender Diversity and Investment Decision-Making Behavior. Review of Behavioral Finance, 5(2): 134–152.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bottger, Preston, and Yetton, Phillip (1988). An Integration of Process and Decision Scheme Explanations of Group Problem Solving Performance. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 42(2): 234–249.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowen, William, and Bok, Derek (1998). The Shape of the River: Long-term Consequences of Considering Race in College and University Admissions. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bowen, William, Bok, Derek, and Burkhart, Glenda (1999). A Report Card on Diversity: Lessons for Business from Higher Education. Harvard Business Review, 77: 138–149.Google ScholarPubMed
Brickson, Shelley (2000). The Impact of Identity Orientation on Individual and Organizational Outcomes in Demographically Diverse Settings. The Academy of Management Review, 25(1): 82–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burt, Ronald S. (1982). Toward a Structural Theory of Action Network Models of Social Structure, Perception, and Action. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Carpenter, Mason (2002). The Implications of Strategy and Social Context for the Relationship Between Top Management Team Heterogeneity and Firm Performance. Strategic Management Journal , 23(3): 275–284.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chang, Mitchell J. (1996). Racial Diversity in Higher Education: Does a Racially Mixed Student Population Affect Educational Outcomes? PhD diss., University of California, Los Angeles, CA.Google Scholar
Chang, Mitchell J. (1997). Racial Diversity: A Compelling Interest for Higher Education. Paper presented at the22nd Annual Meeting of the Association for the Study of Higher Education, Albuquerque, NM.Google Scholar
Chang, Mitchell J. (1999). Does Racial Diversity Matter?: The Educational Impact of a Racially Diverse Undergraduate Population. Journal of College Student Development, 40(4): 377–395.Google Scholar
Chang, Mitchell, Witt-Sandis, Daria, and Hakuta, Kenji (1999). The Dynamics of Race in Higher Education: An Examination of The Evidence. Equity & Excellence in Education, 32(2): 12–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Conrad, Cecilia (1995). The Economic Cost of Affirmative Action. In Simmis, Margaret (Ed.), Economic Perspectives on Affirmative Action, pp. 31–54 . Washington DC: Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies.Google Scholar
Cottom, Tressie McMillan (2018). Thick: And Other Essays. New York: The New Press.Google Scholar
Cox, Taylor (1993). Cultural Diversity in Organizations: Theory, Research and Practice. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishing.Google Scholar
Dameron, Stephainie, and Joffre, Olivier (2007). The Good and the Bad: The Impact of Diversity Management on Co-operative Relationships. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 18(11): 2037–2056.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ely, Robin, and Thomas, David (2001). Cultural Diversity at Work: The Moderating Effects of Diversity Perspectives on Work Group Processes and Outcomes. Administrative Science Quarterly, 46(2): 229–273.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Filley, Alan, House, Robert, and Kerr, Steven (1976). Managerial Process and Organizational Behavior. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman, and Co.Google Scholar
Flagg, Barbara (2004). Diversity Discourses. Tulane Law Review, 78: 827–851.Google Scholar
Gilliard, Michelle (1996). Racial Climate and Institutional Support Factors Affecting Success in Predominantly White Institutions: An Examination of African American and White Student Experiences. PhD diss., University of Michigan.Google Scholar
Gurin, Patricia, Dey, Eric, Hurtado, Sylvia, and Gurin, Gerald (2002). Diversity and Higher Education: Theory and Impact on Educational Outcomes. Harvard Educational Review, 72(3): 330–367.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gurin, Patricia, Nagda, Biren, and Lopez, Gretchen (2004). The Benefits of Diversity in Education for Democratic Citizenship. Journal of Social Issues , 60(1): 17–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glazer, Nathan (1998). In Defense of Preference. Affirmative Action is Bad. Banning it is Worse. New Republic, 218: 18–25.Google Scholar
Gratz v. Bollinger (2003). 539 U.S. 244.Google Scholar
Greenberg, Jack (2002). Affirmative Action in Higher Education: Confronting the Condition and Theory. Boston College Law Review, 43: 521–621.Google Scholar
Grutter v. Bollinger (2003). 539 U.S. 306.Google Scholar
Hambrick, Donald, Cho, Theresa, and Chen, Ming-Jer (1996). The Influence of Top Management Team Heterogeneity on Firms’ Competitive Moves. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41(4): 659–684.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harrison, David, Price, Kenneth and Bell, Myrtle (1998). Beyond Relational Demography: Time and the Effects of Surface- and Deep-Level Diversity on Work Group Cohesion. The Academy of Management Journal , 41(1): 96–107.Google Scholar
Haslerig, Siduri, Bernhard, Laura, Fuentes, Marcia, Panter, A. T., Daye, Charles, and Allen, Walter (2013). A Compelling Interest: Activating the Benefits of Classroom-level Diversity. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 6(3): 158–173.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hoffman, L. Richard (1979). Applying Experimental Research on Group Problem Solving to Organizations. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 15(3): 375–391.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hopwood v. State of Texas (1996). 236 F.3d 256.Google Scholar
Hurtado, Sylvia (1990). Campus Racial Climates and Educational Outcomes. PhD diss., University of California, Los Angeles. Ann Arbor: University Microfilms International, No. 9111328.Google Scholar
Hurtado, Sylvia (1992). The Campus Racial Climate. The Journal of Higher Education, 63(5): 539–569.Google Scholar
Hurtado, Sylvia (2001). Linking Diversity and Educational Purpose: How Diversity Affects the Classroom Environment and Student Development. In Gary, Orfield (Ed.), Diversity Challenged: Evidence on the Impact of Affirmative Action, pp. 187–203. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Publishing Group and The Civil Rights Project at Harvard University.Google Scholar
Hurtado, Sylvia, Dey, Eric, and Trevino, Jesus (1994). Exclusion or Self-segregation?: Interaction Across Racial/ethnic Groups on Campus. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA.Google Scholar
Hurtado, Sylvia, Milem, Jeffrey, Clayton-Pedersen, Alma, and Allen, Walter (1999). Enacting Diverse Learning Environments: Improving the Climate for Racial/Ethnic Diversity in Higher Education Institutions . ASHE-ERIC Higher Education Report Series 26(8). Washington, DC: George Washington University Graduate School of Education.Google Scholar
Hurtado, Sylvia, Milem, Jeffrey, Clayton-Pedersen, Alma, and Allen, Walter (1998). Enhancing Campus Climates for Racial/Ethnic Diversity: Educational Policy and Practice. Review of Higher Education, 21(3): 279–302.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ibarra, Herminia and Smith-Lovin, Lynn (1997). New Directions in Social Network Research on Gender and Organizational Careers. In Cary, Cooper and Susan, Jackson (Eds.), Creating Tomorrow’s Organizations: A Handbook for Future Research in Organizational Behavior, pp. 361–393. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Jackson, Susan (1992). Consequences of Group Composition for the Interpersonal Dynamics of Strategic Issue Processing. In Huff, Ann and Paul, Shrivastava (Eds.), Advances in Strategic Management, pp. 345–382. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.Google Scholar
Jackson, Susan, and Joshi, Aparna (2004). Diversity in Social Context: A Multi-attribute, Multilevel Analysis of Team Diversity and Sales Performance. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 25(6): 675–702.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jackson, Susan, Joshi, Aparna, and Erhardt, Niclas (2003). Recent Research on Team and Organizational Diversity: SWOT Analysis and Implications. Journal of Management, 29(6): 801–830.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jehn, Karen, Northcraft, Gregory, and Neale, Margaret (1999). Why Differences Make a Difference: A Field Study of Diversity, Conflict, and Performance in Workgroups. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(4): 741–763.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Johnson v. Board of Regents of the University of Georgia (2001). 263 F.3d 1234Google Scholar
Joshi, Aparna, Jackson, Susan (2008). Managing Workforce Diversity to Enhance Cooperation in Organizations. In West, Michael, Dean, Tjosvold, and Smith, Ken (Eds.), International Handbook of Organizational Teamwork and Cooperative Working , pp. 277–296. New York: Wiley.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Joshi, Aparna (2006). The Influence of Organizational Demography on the External Networking Behavior of Teams. Academy of Management Review, 31(3): 583–595.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kilduff, Martin, Angelmar, Reinhard, and Mehra, Ajay (2000). Top Management-team Diversity and Firm Performance: Examining the Role of Cognitions. Organization Science, 11(1): 21–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kochan, Thomas, Bezrukova, Katerina, Ely, Robin, Jackson, Susan, Joshi, Aparna, Jehn, Karen, Leonard, Jonathan, Levine, David, and Thomas, David (2003). The Effects of Diversity on Business Performance: Report of a Feasibility Study of the Diversity Research Network. Human Resource Management, 42: 3–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Komaromy, Miriam, Grumbach, Kevin, Drake, Michael, Vranizan, Karen, Lurie, Nicole, Keane, Dennis, and Bindman, Andrew (1996). The Role of Black and Hispanic Physicians in Providing Health Care for Underserved Populations. New England Journal of Medicine, 334(20): 1305–1310.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kuh, George (1993). In Their Own Words: What Students Learn Outside the Classroom. American Educational Research Journal, 30(2): 277–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lawrence, Charles (2001). Two Views of the River: A Critique of the Liberal Defense of Affirmative Action. Columbia Law Review, 101: 928–975.Google Scholar
Ledesma, Maria (2013). Revisiting Grutter and Gratz in the Wake of Fisher: Looking Back to Move Forward. Equity & Excellence in Education, 46(2): 220–235.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Liff, Sonia (1997). Two Routes to Managing Diversity: Individual Differences or Social Group Characteristics. Employee Relations, 19(1): 11–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lindeman, Marjaana, and Sundvik, Lilli (1995). Evaluative Bias and Self-enhancement Among Gender Groups. European Journal of Social Psychology, 25: 269–280.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
MacDonald, Heather (1993). The Diversity Industry. The New Republic, July: 22–26.Google Scholar
Marcolino, Leandro, Jiang, Albert, Tambe, Milind (2013). Multi-agent Team Formation: Diversity Beats Strength? In Rossi, Francesca (Ed.), Proceedings of the Twenty-Third International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI ‘13), pp. 279–285. Beijing, China: AAAI Press.Google Scholar
Mannix, Elizabeth, and Neale, Margaret (2005). What Differences Make a Difference?: The Promise and Reality of Diverse Teams in Organizations. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 6(2): 31–55.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Maruyama, Geoffrey, Moreno, Jose, Gudeman, Roxane, and Marin, Patricia (2000). Does Diversity Make a Difference?: Three Research Studies on Diversity in College Classrooms. Washington, DC: ERIC Clearinghouse.Google Scholar
McLeod, Poppy, Lobel, Simon, and Taylor, Cox (1996). Ethnic Diversity and Creativity in Small Groups. Small Group Research, 2(27): 248–264.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Milem, Jeffrey (1992). The Impact of College on Students’ Racial Attitudes and Levels of Racial Awareness. PhD diss., University of California, Los Angeles, CA.Google Scholar
Milem, Jeffrey (1994). College, Students, and Racial Understanding. Thought & Action, 9(2): 51–92.Google Scholar
Milem, Jeffrey (1997). Key Educational Outcomes of Diversity for College and University Faculty. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Educational Publishing Group.Google Scholar
Milem, Jeffrey (1998). Attitude Change in College Students: Examining the Effects of College Peer Groups and Faculty Reference Groups. Journal of Higher Education, 69(2): 117–140.Google Scholar
Milem, Jeffrey, and Hakuta, Kenji (2000). The Benefits of Racial and Ethnic Diversity in Higher Education. In Wilds, Deborah (Ed.), Minorities in Higher Education, 1999-2000, Seventeenth Annual Status Report , pp. 39–63. Washington, DC: American Council on Education.Google Scholar
Milem, Jeffrey (2003). The Educational Benefits of Diversity: Evidence from Multiple Sectors. In Chang, Mitchell, Witt, Daria, Jones, James, and Hakuta, Kenji (Eds.), Compelling Interest: Examining the Evidence on Racial Dynamics in Higher Education, pp. 126–169. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Milliken, Frances, and Martins, Luis (1996). Searching for Common Threads: Understanding the Multiple Effects of Diversity in Organizational Groups. Academy of Management Review, 2 (2): 402–433.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nemeth, Charlan (1985). Dissent, Group Process, and Creativity. Advances in Group Processes, 2: 57–75.Google Scholar
Nemeth, Charlan (1986). Differential Contributions of Majority and Minority Influence. Psychological Review, 93(1): 23–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Orfield, Gary, and Dean, Whitla (1999). Diversity and Legal Education: Student Experiences in Leading Law Schools. Cambridge, MA: Civil Rights Project at Harvard University.Google Scholar
Page, Scott (2010). Diversity and Complexity. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pager, Devah (2007). Marked: Race, Crime and Finding Work in an Era of Mass Incarceration. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Parker, Eugene, and Pascarella, Ernest (2013). Effects of Diversity Experiences on Socially Responsible Leadership Over Four Years of College. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 6(4): 219–230.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pascarella, Ernest, Edison, Marcia, Nora, Amaury, Hagedorn, Linda, and Terenzini, Patrick (1996). Influences on Students’ Openness to Diversity and Challenge in the First Year of College. The Journal of Higher Education, 67(2): 174–195.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pelled, Lisa, Eisenhardt, Kathleen, and Xin, Katherine (1999). Exploring the Black Box: An Analysis of Work Group Diversity, Conflict ,and Performance. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(1): 1–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pettigrew, Thomas, and Tropp, Linda (2006). A Meta-Analytic Test of Intergroup Contact Theory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90(5): 751–783.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Putnam, Robert (2000). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York: Simon & Schuster.Google Scholar
Putnam, Robert (2007). E Pluribus Unum: Diversity and Community in the Twenty-first Century. The 2006 Johan Skytte Prize Lecture. Scandinavian Political Studies, 30: 137–174.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Regents of the University of California v. Bakke (1978). 438 U.S. 265.Google Scholar
Rentsch, Joan, and Klimoski, Richard (2001). Why Do ‘Great Minds’ Think Alike?: Antecedents of Team Member Schema Agreement. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 22: 107–122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Richard, Orlando (2000). Racial Diversity, Business Strategy, and Firm Performance: A Resource-Based View. Academy of Management Journal, 43: 164–177.Google Scholar
Schwenk, Charles and Joseph, Valacich (1994). Effects of Devil’s Advocacy and Dialectical Inquiry on Individuals Versus Groups. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 59(2): 210–222.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shaw, Marvin, Robbin, Rhona, and Belser, James R. (1981). Group Dynamics: The Psychology of Small Group Behavior, 3rd. Ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Siciliano, Julie (1996). The Relationship of Board Member Diversity to Organizational Performance. Journal of Business Ethics, 15(12): 1313–1320.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simons, Tony, Pelled, Lisa, and Smith, Ken A. (1999). Making Use of Difference: Diversity, Debate, and Decision Comprehensiveness in Top Management Teams. Academy of Management Journal, 42: 662–673.Google Scholar
Smith, Daryl (1995). The Drama of Diversity and Democracy. Washington DC: Association of American Colleges and Universities.Google Scholar
Smith v. University of Washington Law School (2000). 233 F.3d 1188, 1200-01 (9th Cir.)Google Scholar
Tajfel, Henri (1978). Differentiation Between Social Groups: Studies in the Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations . Cambridge, MA: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Terenzini, Patrick, Rendon, Laura, Lee Upcraft, M., Millar, Susan, Allison, Kevin, Gregg, Patricia, and Jalomo, Romeo (1994a). The Transition to College: Diverse Students, Diverse Stories. Research in Higher Education, 35(1): 57–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Terenzini, Patrick, Springer, Leonard, Pascarella, Ernest, and Nora, Amaury (1994b). The Multiple Influences of College on Students’ Critical Thinking Skills. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Association for the Study of Higher Education, Tucson, AZ.Google Scholar
Timmerman, Thomas (2000). Racial Diversity, Age Diversity, Interdependence, and Team Performance. Small Group Research, 31(5): 592–606.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Watson, Warren, Kumar, Kamalesh, and Michaelsen, Larry (1993). Cultural Diversity’s Impact on Interaction Process and Performance: Comparing Homogeneous and Diverse Task Groups. Academy of Management Journal, 36(3): 590–602.Google Scholar
Webber, Sheila, and Donahue, Lisa (2001). Impact of Highly and Less Job-Related Diversity on Work Group Cohesion and Performance: A Meta-Analysis. Journal of Management, 27(2): 141–162.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wise, Lois, and Tschirhart, Mary (2000). Examining Empirical Evidence on Diversity Effects: How Useful Is Diversity Research for Public-Sector Managers? Public Administration Review, 60: 386–394.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Warikoo, Natasha (2016). The Diversity Bargain: And Other Dilemmas of Race, Admissions, and Meritocracy at Elite Universities. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wrench, John. (2012). Diversity Management and Discrimination: Immigrants and Ethnic Minorities in the EU. United Kingdom: Ashgate Publishing Limited.Google Scholar
Wygant v. Jackson Board of Education (1986). 476 US 267.Google Scholar
Zweigenhaft, Richard, and Domhoff, William (2003). Blacks in the White Elite: Will the Progress Continue? Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.Google Scholar