Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T13:26:52.307Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Southern Uplands geology: an historical perspective

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 November 2011

Gilbert Kelling
Gilbert Kelling
Affiliation:
Gilbert Kelling, Basin Dynamics Group, School of Earth Sciences & Geography,Keele University, Staffordshire, U.K.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

ABSTRACT

For more than two centuries the rocks of the Southern Uplands have provided successive generations of geologists with both illumination and frustration. This area furnished vital evidence to support Hutton's ideas of petrogenesis and his cyclical view of earth history. However, for much of the succeeding century construction of a credible and consistent stratigraphy and structure eluded the best efforts of the many workers drawn to this region. It was an English-born schoolmaster, Charles Lapworth, inspired by the ideas of foreign practitioners and fascinated by the hitherto-despised graptolite, who applied a technique (zonal stratigraphy) and developed a structural paradigm (isoclinal folding) that provided an elegant and coherent solution to the myriad problems bequeathed by previous attempts.

So persuasive was Lapworth's model that the Geological Survey deployed its two finest mappers, Peach and Horne, to re-examine the entire region, using Lapworth's techniques. The outcome of that 10-year task is the monumental publication commemorated here. That work, and the ideas it espoused, remained virtually unchallenged for more than half a century and contributed to the application and elaboration of then-new geotectonic ideas, such as the geosynclinal concept.

However, in the 1950s the application of new or neglected techniques (way-up criteria, turbidite sedimentology, greywacke petrography, microstructural analysis, etc.) led to drastic reappraisal of prevailing structural and stratigraphic models and introduced a new paradigm (colloquially termed the ‘Southern Uplands paradox’) that envisaged a dominant role for strike-parallel major reverse faults. In contrast to Lapworth's shale-based approach this new model focussed on evidence derived predominantly from the thick intervening greywacke sequences. Investigations led by the Edinburgh and St Andrews schools extended and amplified this new interpretation of Southern Uplands geology, elucidated details of the palaeogeographic setting and the evolution of both the depositional basins and the source areas, and suggested comparisons with other parts of the Caledonian-Appalachian orogen.

The advent of plate tectonics revived interest in the Southern Uplands, first as a candidate subduction-related margin, then in the late 1970s an accretionary prism origin was proposed for the Southern Uplands imbricate thrust stack. The attractions of this hypothesis were manifest and it stimulated renewed activity by academics and the Geological Survey. Significant inconsistencies and perturbations in the simple accretionary prism concept have emerged from these more detailed studies and a range of convergence zone scenarios has been proposed. A Geological Society Meeting on the topic in 1986 furnished much new data and ideas but failed to yield conceptual consensus. Thus, as yet the latest Southern Uplands Controversy remains unresolved.

Changes in the level of geological research activity in the Southern Uplands can be assessed from an analysis of the numbers of relevant publications appearing over five-year intervals. This survey reveals a pattern that broadly accords with the narrative outlined above and supports the concept of two complete and one as-yet incomplete cycles of model development and adoption. Each of these developmental cycles appears to follow the progression of stages in scientific development identified by Thomas Kuhn and common to many scientific disciplines.

Keywords

bibliometrygraptolitesgreywackeshistoryimbricate thrustsisodinal foldsturbidites
Type
Research Article
Information
Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of The Royal Society of Edinburgh , Volume 91 , Issue 3-4: The Southern Uplands Terrane: Tectonics and Biostratigraphy within the Caledonian Orogen , 2000 , pp. 323 - 339
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Society of Edinburgh 2000

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Anderson, T. B. 1962. The Stratigraphy, Sedimentology and Structure of the Silurian Rocks of the Ards Peninsula, County Down (Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, University of Liverpool).Google Scholar
Anderson, T. B. & Oliver, G. J. H. 1986. The Orlock Bridge Fault: a major late Caledonian sinistral fault in the Southern Uplands terrane, British Isles. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh: Earth Sciences 11, 203–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bailey, E. B. 1930. New light on sedimentation and tectonics. Geological Magazine 67, 77–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bailey, E. B. 1952. Geological Survey of Great Britain. London: Thos. Murby.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bailey, E. B. & McCallien, W. J. 1957. The Ballantrae Serpentine, Ayrshire. Transactions of the Edinburgh Geological Society 17, 33–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bamford, D., Nunn, K., Prodehl, C. & Jacob, B. 1978. LISB IV: Crastal structure of Northern Britain. Geophysical Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society 54, 43–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bluck, B. J. 1983. Role of the Midland Valley of Scotland in the Caledonian Orogeny. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh: Earth Sciences 74, 119–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brewer, J. A., Matthews, D. H., Warner, M. R., Hall, J., Smythe, D. K. & Whittington, R.J. 1983. BIRPS deep seismic reflection studies of the British Caledonides. Nature 305, 206–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Craig, G. Y. & Walton, E. K. 1959. Sequence and structure in the Silurian rocks of Kirkcudbrightshire. Geological Magazine 96, 209–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dana, J. D. 1873. On some results of the earth's contraction from cooling, including a Discussion of the origin of mountains and the nature of the earth's interior. American Journal of Science, Ser. 5. 423–43; 6, 6–14, 104–15, 161–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dewey, J. F. 1969. Evolution of the Appalachian/Caledonian orogen. Nature 222, 1247–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dewey, J. F. 1971. A model for the Lower Palaeozoic evolution of the Southern margin of the early Caledonides of Scotland and Ireland. Scottish Journal of Geology 1, 219–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dott, R. H. 1974. The geosynclinal concept. In Dott, R. H. & Shaver, R. H. (eds) Modern and Ancient Geosynclinal Sedimentation, Tulsa, Oklahoma: Society of Paleontologists and Mineralogists, 1–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Floyd, J. D. 1994. The derivation and definition of the ‘Southern Upland Fault’: a review of the Midland Valley–Southern Uplands Terrane boundary. Scottish Journal of Geology 30, 51–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geikie, A. 1868. On the order of succession among the Silurian rocks of Scotland. Transactions of the Geological Society of Glasgow 3, 74–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geikie, A. 1871. Memoirs of the Geological Survey, Scotland. Explanation of Sheet 15. Dumfriesshire (north-west part); Lanarkshire (south part); Ayrshire (south-east part). Edinburgh: Her Majesty's Stationery Office.Google Scholar
Geikie, A. 1885. Text Book of Geology, 2nd edn. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Geikie, A. 1899. (ed.). James Hutton's ‘Theory of the Earth’ (Vol. 111). London: The Geological Society (facsimile edition issued 1997).Google Scholar
Green, J. F. N. 1924. The structure of the Bowmore-Portaskaig district of Islay. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 80, 72–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Greig, D. C. 1971. Institute of Geological Sciences: British Regional Geology—The South of Scotland (3rd Edition). Edinburgh: Her Majesty's Stationery Office.Google Scholar
Hall, J. 1815. On the vertical position and convolutions of certain strata and their relation with granite. Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 1, 79–87.Google Scholar
Hall, J. 1859. Palaeontology. Geological Survey of New York 3, pt.l, 66–96.Google Scholar
Hall, J., Powell, D. W., Warner, M. A., El-Isa, Z. H. M., Adesanya, O. & Bluck, B. J. 1983. Seismological evidence for shallow crystalline basement in the Southern Uplands of Scotland. Nature 305, 418–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hamilton, B. 1984. The contributions of Gustav Linnarsson to British stratigraphic geology. Geologiska Foreningens a Stockholm Forhandlingar 106, 185–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harkness, R. 1851. On the Silurian rocks of Dumfriesshire and Kirkcudbright. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 1 46–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harkness, R. 1856. On the lowest sedimentary rocks of the south of Scotland. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 12, 238–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harkness, R. 1873. The Southern Uplands of Scotland. Nature 9, 22–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hartley, J. J. 1925. The Borrowdale Volcanic Series between Windermere and Coniston. Proceedings of the Geologists' Association, London 36, 203–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hinde, G. J. 1890. Notes on Radiolaria from the Lower Palaeozoic rocks (Llandeilo–Caradoc) of the South of Scotland. Annals and Magazine of Natural History Ser. 6, 6, 40–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hsu, K. J. 1973. The Odyssey of Geosyncline. In Ginsburg, R.N. (ed.) Evolving Concepts in Sedimentology, 66–92. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Hutton, J. 1795. Theory of the Earth, Vol. 1, 421–85.Google Scholar
I.G.S. 1982. Institute of Geological Sciences—Annual Report for 1980 and 1981. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office.Google Scholar
Jameson, R. 1805. Transition Rocks of South Scotland. In A Mineralogical Description of the County of Dumfries, 44–78. Edinburgh: Bell and Bradfute.Google Scholar
Jones, O. T. 1938. On the evolution of a geosyncline. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 94, lx–cx.Google Scholar
Kelling, G. 1958. The Ordovician Rocks of the Rhinns of Galloway (Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, University of Edinburgh).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kelling, G. 1961. The stratigraphy and structure of the Ordovician rocks of the Rhinns of Galloway. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 117, 37–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kelling, G. 1964. The petrology and sedimentation of Upper Ordovician rocks in the Rhinns of Galloway, south-west Scotland. Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 65, 107–37.Google Scholar
Kelling, G. 1982. Is the Geosyncline dead? Geology Teaching 6, 117–23.Google Scholar
Kelling, G., Davies, P. & Holroyd, J. 1987. Style, scale and significance of sand bodies in the Northern and Central Belts, southwest Southern Uplands. Journal of the Geological Society, London 144, 787–805.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kelling, G. & Holroyd, J. 1978. Clast size, shape and composition in some ancient and modern fan gravels. In Stanley, D.J. & Kelling, G. (eds) Sedimentation in Submarine Canyons, Fans and Trenches, 138–59. Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania: Dowden, Hutchinson and Ross.Google Scholar
Kemp, A. E. S. 1987. Evolution of Silurian depositional systems in the Southern Uplands, Scotland. In Leggett, J. K. & Zuffa, G. G. (eds) Marine Clastic Sedimentology, 124–55. London: Graham and Trotman.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kuenen, P. H. 1953. Graded bedding, with observations on Lower Palaeozoic rocks of Britain. Verhandelingen der Koninklijke Neder-landse Akademie van Wettenschappen, Afd. Natuurkunde, Ser 1–20, 1–52.Google Scholar
Kuhn, T. S. 1962. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Kuhn, T. S. 1970. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions 2nd edition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Lapworth, C. 1870. On the Lower Silurian rocks of Galashiels. Geological Magazine, Decade 11, 204–9; 279–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lapworth, C. 1878. The Moffat Series. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 34, 240–346.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lapworth, C. 1879. On the tripartite classification of the Lower Palaeozoic rocks. Geological Magazine, Decade 2 6, 1–15.Google Scholar
Lapworth, C. 1882. The Girvan Succession. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 38, 537–666.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lapworth, C. 1883a. Review of Text-book of Geology, by Archibald Geikie. Geological Magazine, Decade 2 10, 39–42; 80–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lapworth, C. 1883b. The Secret of the Highlands. Geological Magazine, Decade 2 10, 120–28; 193–9; 337–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lapworth, C. 1889. On the Ballantrae rocks of the South of Scotland, and their place in the Upland sequence. Geological Magazine, Decade 3 6, 20–24; 59–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lapworth, C. 1899. The Survey Memoir on the Scottish Uplands. Geological Magazine, Decade 4 6, 472–79; 510–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lapworth, C. & Wilson, J. 1871. On the Silurian rocks of the counties of Roxburgh and Selkirk. Geological Magazine, Decade 1 8, 456–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leggett, J. K. 1979. Oceanic sediments from the Ordovician of the Southern Uplands. In Harris, A. L., Holland, C. H. & Leake, B.E. (eds) The Caledonides of the British Isles—Reviewed, Geological Society, London, Special Publication 8, 495–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leggett, J. K., McKerrow, W. S. & Eales, M. H. 1979. The Southern Uplands of Scotland: a Lower Palaeozoic accretionary prism. Journal of the Geological Society, London 136, 755–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leggett, J.K., McKerrow, W. S. & Soper, N. J. 1983. A model for the crustal evolution of southern Scotland. Tectonics 2, 187–210.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leith, C.K. 1914. Structural Geology. New York: Harper.Google Scholar
Lindström, M. 1958. Different phases of tectonic deformation in the Rhinns of Galloway. Nature, 182, 48–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lyell, C. 1839. On the occurrence of Graptolites in the Slate of Galloway. Proceedings of the Geological Society of London 3, 28–9.Google Scholar
Macgillivray, W. 1834. Account of the central portion of the great Mountain range of the South of Scotland. Report of the British Association. 4th Meeting (Glasgow), 650–56.Google Scholar
McKenzie, D. H. 1956. A structural profile south of Eyemouth, Berwickshire. Transactions of the Edinburgh Geological Society 16, 248–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McKerrow, W. S. 1987. The Southern Uplands Controversy. Journal of the Geological Society, London 144, 735–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McKerrow, W. S., Leggett, J. K. & Eales, M. H. 1977. Imbricate thrust model for the Southern Uplands of Scotland. Nature 267, 237–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McKerrow, W. S. et al. 1987. The Southern Uplands Controversy: a thematic set of articles. Journal of the Geological Society, London 144, 735–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Milne, D. 1834. On the geology of Berwickshire. tReport of the British Association, 4th Meeting (Glasgow), 624–8.Google Scholar
Mitchell, A. H. G. & McKerrow, W. S. 1975. Analogous evolution of the Burma orogen and the Scottish Caledonides. Bulletin of the Geological Society of America 86, 305–15.2.0.CO;2>CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moore, J. C. 1840. On the rocks which form the west shore of the bay of Loch Ryan. Proceedings of the Geological Society of London 3, 277–8.Google Scholar
Moore, J. C. 1856. On the Silurian rocks of Wigtownshire. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 12, 359–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murchison, R. I. 1839. The Silurian System. London: John Murray.Google Scholar
Murchison, R. I. 1851. On the Silurian rocks of the South of Scotland. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 7, 138–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murphy, F. C. & Hutton, D. H. W. 1986. Is the Southern Uplands of Scotland really an accretionary prism? Geology 14, 354–7.2.0.CO;2>CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicol, J. 1844. Guide to the Geology of Scotland. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd.Google Scholar
Nicol, J. 1848. On the geology of the Silurian rocks in the valley of the Tweed. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 4, 195–209.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nicol, J. 1850. Observations on the Silurian rocks of the south-east of Scotland. Journal of the Geological Society of London 6, 53–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oldroyd, D. R. 1990. The Highlands Controversy. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Peach, B. N. 1892. On a widespread radiolarian chert of Arenig age from the Southern Uplands of Scotland. Report of the British Association, 18th Meeting (Dundee), 711–16.Google Scholar
Peach, B. N. & Horne, J. 1899. The Silurian Rocks of Britain, Vol. 1: Scotland. Memoirs of the Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. Glasgow: HMSO.Google Scholar
Powell, D. W. 1971. A model for the Lower Palaeozoic evolution of the southern margin of the early Caledonides of Scotland and Ireland. Scottish Journal of Geology 7, 369–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pringle, J. 1948. The Geological Survey and Museum: British Regional Geology—The South of Scotland, 2nd edition, revised. London: Her Majesty's Stationery OfficeGoogle Scholar
Pringle, J. & Eckford, R. 1945. Structures in Silurian greywackes near Innerleithen. Peeblesshire. Transactions of the Edinburgh Geological Society 14, 5–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ritchie, M. & Eckford, R. J. A. 1935. The ‘Haggis Rock’ of the Southern Uplands. Transactions of the Edinburgh Geological Society 13, 371–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rushton, A. W. A., Stone, P. & Hughes, R. A. 1996. Biostratigraphical control of thrust models for the Southern Uplands of Scotland. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh: Earth Sciences 86 (for 1995), 137–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rust, B. R. 1965. The stratigraphy and structure of the Whithorn area of Wigtownshire. Scottish Journal of Geology 1, 101–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stone, P. 1992. Geology of the Rhins of Galloway District. Sheets 1 and 3 (Scotland). Memoir of the Geological Survey, Scotland.Google Scholar
Stone, P. 1999. Peach and Horne in the Southern Uplands. The Edinburgh Geologist 32, 8–10.Google Scholar
Strachan, I. 1971. A synoptic supplement to: ‘A Monograph of British Graptolites’ by Miss Elles, G. L. and Miss Wood, E. M. R.. Monograph of the Palaeonotographical Society.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taylor, A. 1885. Obituary Notice of Joachim Barrande. Transactions of the Edinburgh Geological Society 5, 29–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Toghill, P. 1969. The graptolite assemblages and zones of the Birkhill Shales (Lower Silurian) at Dobb's Linn. Palaeontology 11, 654–83.Google Scholar
Toghill, P. 1970. The south-east limit of the Moffat Shales in the upper Ettnck Valley region, Selkirkshire. Scottish Journal of Geology 6, 233–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walker, R. G. 1973. Mopping up the turbidite mess. In Ginsburg, R. N. (ed.) Evolving Concepts in Sedimentology, 1–37. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University PressGoogle Scholar
Walton, E. K. 1955. Silurian greywackes in Peeblesshire. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Section B 65, 327–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walton, E. K. 1961. Some aspects of the succession and structure in the Lower Palaeozoic rocks of the Southern Uplands of Scotland. Geologisches Rundschau 50, 63–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walton, E. K. 1963. Sedimentation and structure in the Southern Uplands. In Johnson, M. R. W. & Stewart, F. H. (eds) The British Caledonides, 91–7. Edinburgh: Oliver and BoydGoogle Scholar
Warren, P. T. 1964. The stratigraphy and structure of the Silurian (Wenlock) rocks south-east of Hawick, Roxburghshire, Scotland. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 120, 193–218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Williams, A. 1959. A structural history of the Girvan district, southwest Ayrshire. Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 63, 629–67.Google Scholar
Williams, A. 1962. The Barr and Lower Ardmillan Series (Caradoc) of the Girvan district, south-west Ayrshire. Geological Society, London, Memoir 3.Google Scholar
Wilson, J. T. 1966. Did the Atlantic close and then reopen? Nature 211, 676–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar