Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-v9fdk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-11T08:57:48.746Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

From immigration over redistributive attitudes to welfare spending. The moderating role of social program design

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 August 2022

Leonce Röth Open the ORCID record for Leonce Röth [Opens in a new window] ,
Dennis Spies  and
Alexander Schmidt-Catran Open the ORCID record for Alexander Schmidt-Catran [Opens in a new window]
Leonce Röth*
Affiliation:
University of Cologne, Cologne, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany
Dennis Spies
Affiliation:
Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf, Düsseldorf, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany
Alexander Schmidt-Catran
Affiliation:
Goethe-University Frankfurt, Frankfurt, Hesse, Germany
*
*E-mail: Leonce.roeth@uni-koeln.de
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Whereas individual-level studies find that encompassing welfare states might in general be incompatible with large-scale immigration, studies on welfare spending find inconclusive results. We address this puzzle by pointing to the moderating role of social program design. We separate programs according to their degree of natives’ interest based on coverage, generosity and stratification characteristics for the social areas of unemployment, sickness/disability, and pensions for 18 OECD countries. We then test the moderating effect of natives’ interest on the impact of immigration on individual support for social spending and actual social spending in the three areas. Our results indicate that programs do react to immigration by decreasing support and budgets when natives’ interest is low, whereas programs where the interest of natives is high tend to increase individual support and spending.

Keywords

immigrationwelfare stateredistributionwelfare attitudesretrenchment
Type
Research Article
Information
European Political Science Review , Volume 14 , Issue 4 , November 2022 , pp. 498 - 519
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of European Consortium for Political Research

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Afonso, A. (2015), ‘Choosing whom to betray: populist right-wing parties, welfare state reforms, and the trade-off between office and votes’, European Political Science Review 7(2): 271–292.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alesina, A. and Glaeser, E.L. (2004), Fighting Poverty in the US and Europe: A World of Difference, Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alesina, A., Harnoss, J. and Rapoport, H. (2018a), Immigration and the Future of the Welfare State in Europe. https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs−01707760/.Google Scholar
Alesina, A., Miano, A. and Stantcheva, S. (2018b), Immigration and Redistribution (No. w24733), Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Alesina, A., Murard, E. and Rapoport, H. (2019), Immigration and Preferences for Redistribution in Europe (No. w25562), Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Allport, G.W. (1954), The Nature of Prejudice, Cambridge, MA: Perseus.Google Scholar
Andreß, H.J. and Heien, T. (2001), ‘Four worlds of welfare state attitudes? A comparison of Germany, Norway, and the United States’, European Sociological Review 17(4): 337–356.Google Scholar
Armingeon, K., Engler, S., Leemann, L., et al. (2020), Comparative Political Data Set 1960–2018, Bern: Institute of Political Science, University of Berne.Google Scholar
Auspurg, K., Brüderl, J. and Wöhler, T. (2019), ‘Does immigration reduce the support for welfare spending? A cautionary tale on spatial panel data analysis’, American Sociological Review 84(4): 754–763.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baldwin, K. and Huber, J.D. (2010), ‘Economic versus cultural differences: forms of ethnic diversity and public goods provision’, American Political Science Review 104(4): 644–662.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Banting, K., Johnston, R., Kymlicka, W. and Soroka, S. (2006), ‘Do multiculturalism policies erode the welfare state? An empirical analysis’, in K. Banting and W. Kymlicka (eds), Multiculturalism and the Welfare State: Recognition and Redistribution in Contemporary Democracies, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 49–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barrett, A. and McCarthy, Y. (2008), ‘Immigrants and welfare programs: exploring the interactions between immigrant characteristics, immigrant welfare dependence, and welfare policy’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy 24(3): 542–559.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bay, A.H. and Pedersen, A.W. (2006), ‘The limits of social solidarity – basic income, immigration and the legitimacy of the universal welfare state’, Acta Sociologica 49(4): 419–436.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bean, C. and Papadakis, E. (1998), ‘A comparison of mass attitudes towards the welfare state in different institutional regimes, 1985–1990’, International Journal of Public Opinion Research 10(3): 211–236.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bechert, I. and Quandt, M. (2010), ISSP Data Report: Attitudes towards the Role of Government. GESIS Schriftenreihe Bd. 6, Bonn: GESIS. http://www.ssoar.info/ssoar/handle/document/20006.Google Scholar
Beck, N. and Katz, J.N. (1995), ‘What to do (and not to do) with time-series cross-section data’, American Political Science Review 89(3): 634–647.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bell, A. and Jones, K. (2015), ‘Explaining fixed effects: random effects modelling of time-series cross-sectional and panel data’, Political Science Research and Methods 3(1): 133–153.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berry, W.D., Golder, M. and Milton, D., (2012), ‘Improving tests of theories positing interaction’, The Journal of Politics 74(3): 653–671.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blalock, H.M. (1967), Toward a Theory of Minority-Group Relations, New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Boeri, T. (2010), ‘Immigration to the land of redistribution’, Economica 77(308): 651–687.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bonoli, G. and Natali, D., (2012), ‘The politics of the ‘new’ welfare states: analysing reforms in Western Europe’, in Bonoli, G. and Natali, D. (eds), The Politics of the New Welfare State, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 3–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brady, D. and Finnigan, R. (2014), ‘Does immigration undermine public support for social policy?’, American Sociological Review 79(1): 17–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brooks, C. and Manza, J., (2007), Why Welfare States Persist: The Importance of Public Opinion in Democracies, Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brücker, H., Epstein, G.S., McCormick, B., Saint-Paul, G, Venturini, A. and Zimmermann, K. (2001), Managing migration in the European welfare state. In Boeri, T., Hanson, G. and McCormick, B. (eds), Immigration Policy and the Welfare System: A Report for the Fondazione Rodolfo Debenedetti, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 1–168.Google Scholar
Bryan, M.L. and Jenkins, S.P. (2016), ‘Multilevel modelling of country effects: a cautionary tale’, European Sociological Review 32(1): 3–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burgoon, B., Koster, F. and Van Egmond, M. (2012), ‘Support for redistribution and the paradox of immigration’, Journal of European Social Policy 22(3): 288–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burgoon, B. and Rooduijn, M. (2021), ‘Immigrationization’ of welfare politics? Anti-immigration and welfare attitudes in context’, West European Politics 44(2): 177–203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cappelen, C. and Midtbø, T. (2016), ‘Intra-EU labour migration and support for the Norwegian welfare state’, European Sociological Review 32(6): 691–703.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cappelen, C. and Peters, Y. (2018), ‘The impact of intra-EU migration on welfare chauvinism’, Journal of Public Policy 38(3): 389–417.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crepaz, M. (2008), Trust Beyond Borders: Immigration, the Welfare State, and Identity in Modern Societies, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Crepaz, M. and Damron, R., (2009), ‘Constructing tolerance: how the welfare state shapes attitudes about immigrants’, Comparative Political Studies 42(3): 437–463.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cuddy, A.J., Fiske, S.T. and Glick, P. (2008), ‘Warmth and competence as universal dimensions of social perception: the stereotype content model and the BIAS map’, Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 40: 61–149.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dahlberg, M., Edmark, K. and Lundqvist, H. (2012), ‘Ethnic diversity and preferences for redistribution’, Journal of Political Economy 120(1): 41–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eger, M.A. (2010), ‘Even in Sweden: the effect of immigration on support for welfare state spending’, European Sociological Review 26(2): 203–217.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eger, M.A. and Breznau, N. (2017), ‘Immigration and the welfare state: a cross-regional analysis of European welfare attitudes’, International Journal of Comparative Sociology 58(5): 440–463.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Esping-Andersen, G. (1990), The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Fellowes, M.C. and Rowe, G. (2004), ‘Politics and the new American welfare states’, American Journal of Political Science 48(2): 362–373.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fenwick, C. (2019), ‘The political economy of immigration and welfare state effort: evidence from Europe’, European Political Science Review 11(3): 357–375.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Finseraas, H. (2008), ‘Immigration and preferences for redistribution: an empirical analysis of European survey data’, Comparative European Politics 6(4): 407–431.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, C. (2004), ‘The changing color of welfare? How Whites’ attitudes toward Latinos influence support for welfare’, American Journal of Sociology 110(3): 580–625.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, C. (2012), Three Worlds of Relief: Race, Immigration, and the American Welfare state from the Progressive Era to the New Deal, Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Freeman, G.P. (1986), ‘Migration and the political economy of the welfare state’, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 485(1): 51–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Garand, J. C., Xu, P. and Davis, B.C. (2017), ‘Immigration attitudes and support for the welfare state in the American mass public’, American Journal of Political Science 61(1): 146–162.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gaston, N. and Rajaguru, G. (2013), ‘International migration and the welfare state revisited’, European Journal of Political Economy 29(1): 90–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gilens, M. (1995), ‘Racial attitudes and opposition to welfare’, The Journal of Politics 57(4): 994–1014.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gilens, M. (1999), Why Americans Hate Welfare: Race, Media, and the Politics of Antipoverty Policy, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldschmidt, T. (2015), ‘Anti-immigrant sentiment and majority support for three types of welfare’, European Societies 17(5): 620–652.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Green-Pedersen, C. (2001), ‘Welfare-state retrenchment in Denmark and the Netherlands, 1982–1998: the role of party competition and party consensus’, Comparative Political Studies 34(9): 963–985.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hainmueller, J., Mummolo, J. and Xu, Y., (2019), ‘How much should we trust estimates from multiplicative interaction models? Simple tools to improve empirical practice’, Political Analysis 27(2): 163–192.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harell, A., Soroka, S. and Iyengar, S. (2016), ‘Race, prejudice and attitudes toward redistribution: a comparative experimental approach’, European Journal of Political Research 55(4): 723–744.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hartmann-Hirsch, C. (2010), ‘The state of the Luxembourg’s welfare state: the effects of the crisis on a corporatist model shifting to a universalistic model’, CEPS Instead. No 2010-44.Google Scholar
Hero, R.E. and Preuhs, R.R., (2007), ‘Immigration and the evolving American welfare state: examining policies in the U.S. States’, American Journal of Political Science 51(3): 498–517.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hjerm, M. and Schnabel, A. (2012), ‘How much heterogeneity can the welfare state endure? The influence of heterogeneity on attitudes to the welfare state’, Nations and Nationalism 18(2): 346–369.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Huang, X., Kaushal, N. and Wang, J. S. H. (2021), ‘What explains the gap in welfare use among immigrants and natives?’, Population Research and Policy Review 40(4): 819–860.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Huber, E. and Stephens, J.D. (2001), Development and Crisis of the Welfare State: Parties and Policies in Global Markets, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Katznelson, I. (2005), When Affirmative Action was White: An Untold History of Racial Inequality in Twentieth-Century America, New York: W. W. Norton & Company.Google Scholar
Kearns, A, Bailey, N., Gannon, M., Livingston, M. and Leyland, A. (2014), ‘“All in it together”? Social cohesion in a divided society: attitudes to income inequality and redistribution in a residential context’, Journal of Social Policy 43(3): 453–477.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kim, D. and Lee, D. (2021), ‘Immigration and the pattern of public spending: evidence from OECD countries’, International Tax and Public Finance 28(4): 1014–1034.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Korpi, W. and Palme, J. (1998), ‘The paradox of redistribution and strategies of equality: welfare state institutions, inequality, and poverty in the western countries’, American Sociological Review 63(5): 661–687.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Korpi, W. and Palme, J. (2003), ‘New politics and class politics in the context of austerity and globalization: welfare state regress in 18 countries, 1975–95’, The American Political Science Review 97(3): 425–446.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kulin, J., Eger, M.A. and Hjerm, M. (2016), ‘Immigration or welfare? The progressive’s Dilemma revisited’, Socius: Sociological Research for a Dynamic World 2: 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kumlin, S. and Rothstein, B. (2010), ‘Questioning the New Liberal Dilemma: immigrants, social networks, and institutional fairness’, Comparative Politics 43(1): 63–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Larsen, C.A. (2008), ‘The institutional logic of welfare attitudes’, Comparative Political Studies 41(2): 145–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Larsen, C.A. (2011), ‘Ethnic heterogeneity and public support for welfare: is the American experience replicated in Britain, Sweden and Denmark?’, Scandinavian Political Studies 34(4): 332–353.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, T.L. and Fiske, S.T. (2006), ‘Not an outgroup, not yet an ingroup: immigrants in the stereotype content model’, International Journal of Intercultural Relations 30(6): 751–768.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, W., Roemer, J. and Van der Straeten, K. (2006), ‘Racism, xenophobia, and redistribution’, Journal of the European Economic Association 4(2–3): 446–454.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lieberman, R.C. (1998), Shifting the Color Line: Race and the American Welfare State, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Lieberman, R.C. (2003), ‘Race and the limits of solidarity: American welfare state development in comparative perspective’, in Schram, S.F. and Fording, R.C. (eds), Race and the Politics of Welfare Reform, Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press, pp. 23–46.Google Scholar
Lipsmeyer, C.S. and Zhu, L. (2011), ‘Immigration, globalization, and unemployment benefits in developed EU states’, American Journal of Political Science 55(3): 647–664.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Luttmer, E.F.P. (2001), ‘Group loyalty and the taste for redistribution’, Journal of Political Economy 109(3): 500–528.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Luttmer, E.F.P. and Singhal, M. (2011), ‘Culture, context, and the taste for redistribution’, American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 3(1): 157–179.Google Scholar
Manza, J. (2000), ‘Race and the underdevelopment of the American welfare state’, Theory and Society 29(6): 819–832.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mau, S. and Burkhardt, C. (2009), ‘Migration and welfare state solidarity in Western Europe’, Journal of European Social Policy 19(3): 213–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mau, S. and Veghte, B. (2007), Social Justice, Legitimacy and the Welfare State, Aldershot: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Miller, D. (2001), Principles of Social Justice, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Morissens, A. and Sainsbury, D. (2005), ‘Migrants’ social rights, ethnicity and welfare regimes’, Journal of Social Policy 34(4): 637–660.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mouritsen, P. and Olsen, T. (2013), ‘Denmark between liberalism and nationalism’, Ethnic and Racial Studies 36(4): 691–710.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Muñoz, J. and Pardos-Prado, S. (2019), ‘Immigration and support for social policy: an experimental comparison of universal and means-tested programs’, Political Science Research and Methods 7(4): 717–735.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nannestad, P. (2007), ‘Immigration and welfare states: a survey of 15 years of research’, European Journal of Political Economy 23(2): 512–532.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
OECD (2019a), Social Expenditure Database, Paris: OECD. Retrieved 01 January 2020 http://www.oecd.org/els/soc/expenditure.htm.Google Scholar
OECD (2019b), Public Spending on Incapacity. Paris: OECD. Retrieved 01 January 2020. https://data.oecd.org/socialexp/public-spending-on-incapacity.htm.Google Scholar
Pierson, P. (1994), Dismantling the Welfare State? Reagan, Thatcher and the Politics of Retrenchment, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pierson, P. (1996), ‘The new politics of the welfare state’, World Politics 48(2): 143–179.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pierson, P. (2001), The New Politics of the Welfare State, Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Quadagno, J. (1994), The Color of Welfare: How Racism Undermined the War on Poverty, Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Quillian, L. (1995), ‘Prejudice as a response to perceived group threat: population composition and anti-immigrant and racial prejudice in Europe’, American Sociological Review 60(4): 586–611.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rathgeb, P. (2021), ‘Makers against takers: the socio-economic ideology and policy of the Austrian Freedom Party’, West European Politics 44(3): 635–660.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reese, E. (2005), Backlash against Welfare Mothers: Past and Present, Berkeley: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reeskens, T. and Van Oorschot, W. (2012), ‘Disentangling the “New Liberal Dilemma”: on the relation between general welfare redistribution preferences and welfare chauvinism’, International Journal of Comparative Sociology 53(2): 120–139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Römer, F., Röth, L. and Zobel, M. (2022), ‘Policymaking on immigrant welfare rights. The populist and the mainstream right’, Journal of European Public Policy (forthcoming).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Röth, L., Afonso, A., and Spies, D.C. (2018), ‘The impact of populist radical right parties on socio-economic policies’, European Political Science Review 10(3): 325–350.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sainsbury, D. (2012), Welfare States and Immigrant Rights: The Politics of Inclusion and Exclusion, Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schlueter, E. and Wagner, U. (2008), ‘Regional differences matter examining the dual influence of the regional size of the immigrant population on derogation of immigrants in Europe’, International Journal of Comparative Sociology 49(2–3): 153–173.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schmidt, A.W. and Spies, D.C. (2014), ‘Do parties “playing the race card” undermine natives’ support for redistribution? Evidence from Europe’, Comparative Political Studies 47(4): 519–549.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schmidt-Catran, A.W. and Fairbrother, M. (2016), ‘The random effects in multilevel models: getting them wrong and getting them right’, European Sociological Review 32(1): 23–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schmidt-Catran, A.W. and Spies, D.C. (2016), ‘Immigration and welfare support in Germany’, American Sociological Review 81(2): 242–261.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Senik, C., Stichnoth, H. and Van der Straeten, K. (2008), ‘Immigration and natives’ attitudes towards the welfare state: evidence from the European Social Survey’, Social Indicators Research 91(3): 345–370.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Skocpol, T. (1988), ‘The limits of the New Deal System and the roots of contemporary welfare dilemmas’, in Weir, M., Orloff, A.S. and Skocpol, T. (eds), The Politics of Social Policy in the United States, Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp. 293–311.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Soroka, S.N., Johnston, R., Kevins, A., Banting, K. and Kymlicka, W. (2016), ‘Migration and welfare state spending’, European Political Science Review 8(2): 173–194.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Soss, J., Schram, S.F., Vartanian, T.P. and O’Brien, E. (2001), ‘Setting the terms of relief: explaining state policy choices in the devolution revolution’, American Journal of Political Science 45(2): 378–395.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Starke, P. (2006), ‘The politics of welfare state retrenchment: a literature review’, Social Policy & Administration 40(1): 104–120.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Steele, L.G. (2016), ‘Ethnic diversity and support for redistributive social policies’, Social Forces 94(4): 1439–1481.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Swedish Institute for Social Research (2015a), Social Insurance Entitlement Dataset, Stockholm: Swedish Institute for Social Research. Retrieved: 15 January 2019. http://www.spin.su.se/datasets/sied.Google Scholar
Swedish Institute for Social Research (2015b), Social Citizenship Indicator Program, Stockholm: Swedish Institute for Social Research. Retrieved: 15 January 2019. https://www.sofi.su.se/spin/about-the-project/social-citizenship-indicator-program-scip−1930−2005−1.202043.Google Scholar
Tajfel, H., Billig, M.G., Bundy, R.P. and Flament, C. (1971), ‘Social categorization and intergroup behaviour’, European Journal of Social Psychology 1(2): 149–178.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
United Nations (2009) Trends in International Migrant Stock: The 2008 Revision, New York: United Nations.Google Scholar
Van Oorschot, W. (2006), ‘Making the difference in social Europe: deservingness perceptions among citizens of European welfare states’, Journal of European Social Policy 16(1): 23–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wagner, U., Christ, O., Pettigrew, T. F., Stellmacher, J. and Wolf, C. (2006). ‘Prejudice and minority proportion: Contact instead of threat effects’, Social psychology quarterly 69(4), 380–390.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walter, S. (2010), ‘Globalization and the welfare state: testing the microfoundations of the compensation hypothesis’, International Studies Quarterly 54(2): 403–426.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Walter, S. (2017), ‘Globalization and the demand-side of politics: how globalization shapes labor market risk perceptions and policy preferences’, Political Science Research and Methods 5(1): 55–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wright, M. and Reeskens, T. (2013), ‘Of what cloth are the ties that bind? National identity and support for the welfare state across 29 European countries’, Journal of European Public Policy 20(10): 1443–1463.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Xu, P. (2017), ‘Compensation or retrenchment? The paradox of immigration and public welfare spending in the American States’, State Politics & Policy Quarterly 17(1): 76–104.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Xu, Y, Hainmueller, J., Mummolo, J. and Liu, L. (2017), INTERFLEX: Stata Module to Estimate Multiplicative Interaction Models with Diagnostics and Visualization. Statistical Software Components, Boston College: Department of Economics.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: PDF

Röth et al. supplementary material

Online Appendix

Download Röth et al. supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 1.8 MB