Hostname: page-component-6bf8c574d5-gr6zb Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-02-22T09:52:50.008Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

To err is human: US rating agencies and the interwar foreign government debt crisis

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 April 2011

MARC FLANDREAU ,
NORBERT GAILLARD  and
FRANK PACKER
MARC FLANDREAU
Affiliation:
Graduate Institute for International and Development Studies, Geneva, and CEPR, London, marc.flandreau@graduateinstitute.ch
NORBERT GAILLARD
Affiliation:
Sciences Po, Paris, gaillard@alumni.princeton.edu
FRANK PACKER
Affiliation:
Bank for International Settlements, Hong Kong, Frank.Packer@bis.org
Get access

Abstract

This article provides a new perspective on the interwar foreign debt crisis by analysing original data on the credit ratings, market yields and subsequent performance of government borrowers in the New York market. We focus on the four agencies that are known to have been operating at the time (Fitch, Moody's, Poor's and Standard Statistics). We provide a description of the rise of the market for grades and gather information on the products sold, price schedules, etc. We find that rating agencies did exhibit features similar to those that have attracted considerable interest recently: namely, they did not react until the crisis had already begun and then implemented massive downgrades. We conclude by suggesting that, given the less than stellar record of the agencies, their emergence in the 1930s as a regulatory tool will have to be explained in future research.

Type
Research Article
Information
European Review of Economic History , Volume 15 , Issue 3 , December 2011 , pp. 495 - 538
Copyright
Copyright © European Historical Economics Society 2011

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Afonso, A. (2003). Understanding the determinants of sovereign debt ratings: evidence for the two leading agencies. Journal of Finance and Economics 27 (1), pp. 56–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Altman, E. (1989). Measuring corporate bond mortality and performance. Journal of Finance 44, pp. 909–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atkinson, T. R. (1967). Trends in Corporate Bond Quality. NBER.Google Scholar
Babson, R. W. (1910). Sources of market news. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 35 (135), pp. 617–28.Google Scholar
Benmelech, E. and Dlugosz, J. (2009). The credit rating crisis. NBER Working Papers 15045.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berghoff, H. (2008). Civilizing capitalism? The beginnings of credit rating in the United States and Germany. Inaugural Lecture at the German Historical Institute, Washington, 14 November.Google Scholar
Bhatia, A. (2002). Sovereign credit ratings methodology: an evaluation. IMF Working Paper, WP/02/170.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (1943). Banking and Monetary Statistics 1914–1941. Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Bolton, P., Freixas, X. and Shapiro, J. D. (2009). The credit ratings game. EFA Bergen Meetings Paper, 14 February.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Breger, L., Goldberg, L. and Cheyette, O. (2003). Market implied ratings. Barra Credit Series, Research Insights.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cantor, R. and Mann, C. (2003). Measuring the performance of corporate bond ratings. Moody's Special Comment.Google Scholar
Cantor, R. and Mann, C. (2007). Analyzing the tradeoff between ratings accuracy and stability. Journal of Fixed Income. Spring, pp. 60–8.Google Scholar
Cantor, R. and Packer, F. (1994). The credit rating industry. Federal Reserve Bank of New York Quarterly Review, Summer–Fall, pp. 1–26.Google Scholar
Cantor, R. and Packer, F. (1996). Determinants and impact of sovereign credit ratings. Economic Policy Review, October, pp. 37–53.Google Scholar
Cantor, R. and Packer, F. (1997). Differences of opinion and selection bias in the credit rating industry. Journal of Banking and Finance 21, pp. 1395–1417.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carruthers, B. and Cohen, B. (2006). The mechanization of trust: credit rating in 19th-c. America. Working paper.Google Scholar
Chandler, A. (1956). Henry Varnum Poor: Business Editor, Analyst, and Reformer. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Contreras, M. (1990). Debt, taxes, and war: the political economy of Bolivia, c. 1920–1935. Journal of Latin American Studies 22, pp. 265–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dominguez, K. M., Fair, R. C. and Shapiro, M. D. (1988). Forecasting the Depression: Harvard versus Yale. American Economic Review 78 (4), pp. 595–612.Google Scholar
Edwards, G. (1928). Government control of foreign investments. American Economic Review 18 (4), pp. 693–700.Google Scholar
Eichengreen, B. (1989). The US capital market and foreign lending, 1920–1955. In Sachs, J. (ed.), Developing Country Debt and the World Economy. Cambridge, MA: NBER, pp. 237–48.Google Scholar
Eichengreen, B. and Lindert, P. (1989). The International Debt Crisis in Historical Perspective. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Eichengreen, B. and Portes, R. (1986). Debt and default in the 1930s: causes and consequences. European Economic Review 30, pp. 599–640.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eichengreen, B. and Werley, C. (1988). How the bondholders fared: realized rates of return on foreign dollar bonds floated in the 1920s. Working Paper No. 8869, University of California, Berkeley.Google Scholar
Favero, G. (2007). Weather forecast or rain-dance? On inter-war business barometers. Working paper, University of Venice.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Federal Reserve Committee on Branch, Group, and Chain Banking (1932). 225 bank suspensions: case histories from examiners’ reports.Google Scholar
Ferri, G., Liu, L.-G. and Stiglitz, J. (1999). The procyclical role of rating agencies: evidence from the East Asian crisis. Economic Notes, Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena SpA, no. 3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fitch (2007). Sovereign Rating Transition and Default Study 1995–2006. 7 February.Google Scholar
Fitch (various years). Fitch Bond Books.Google Scholar
Flandreau, M. (2003). Caveat emptor – coping with sovereign risk under the international gold standard, 1871–1913. In Flandreau, M., Holtfrerich, C.-L. and James, H. (eds.), International Financial History in the Twentieth Century: System and Anarchy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gaillard, N. (2008). Les méthodologies de notation souveraine. Unpub. dissertation, Institut d'Etudes Politiques de Paris.Google Scholar
Grieser, N. J. (1938). The British investor and his sources of information. MSc (Econ) dissertation, University of London.Google Scholar
Hanley, J. and McNeil, B. (1982). The meaning and use of the area under a receiver operating characteristic curve. Radiology 134 (1), pp. 29–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hanley, J. and McNeil, B. (1983). A method of comparing the areas under receiver operating characteristic curves derived from the same cases. Radiology 148 (3), pp. 839–43.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Harold, G. (1934). Do bond ratings forecast the market? Barron's 14 (53).Google Scholar
Harold, G. (1938). Bond Ratings as an Investment Guide. New York: Ronald Press Co.Google Scholar
Hickman, W. B. (1953). The Volume of Corporate Bond Financing Since 1900. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Hickman, W. B. (1958). Corporate Bond Quality and Investor Experience. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Hickman, W. B. (1960). Statistical Measures of Corporate Bond Financing since 1900. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
James, H. (2001). The End of Globalization: Lessons from the Great Depression,. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Jüttner, J. D. and McCarthy, J. (2000). Modelling a rating crisis. Unpublished manuscript, Macquarie University, Sydney.Google Scholar
Klug, A., Landon-Lane, J. S. and White, E. N. (2005). How could everyone have been so wrong? Forecasting the Great Depression with the railroads. Explorations in Economic History 42 (1), pp. 27–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lamar, W. R. (1907). Investments: What and When to Buy. The Use of Statistics in Accumulating Wealth. Wellesley Hills, MA: The Babson System.Google Scholar
Lauer, J. (2008). From rumor to written record: credit reporting and the invention of financial identity in nineteenth-century America. Technology and Culture 49 (2), pp. 301–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lewis, C. (1938). America's Stake in International Investments. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.Google Scholar
Madden, J., Nadler, M. and Sauvain, H. (1937). America's Experience as a Creditor Nation. New York: Prentice-Hall.Google Scholar
Mintz, I. (1951). Deterioration in the Quality of Foreign Bonds Issued in the United States 1920–30. Cambridge, MA: NBER.Google Scholar
Moody's Investors Service (1919). The credit of foreign governments. Moody's Investment Letter. 3 April.Google Scholar
Moody's Investors Service (1924). Foreign and American Government Securities.Google Scholar
Moody's Investors Service (1995). Corporate Bond Defaults and Default Rates 1970–1994.Google Scholar
Moody's Investors Service (1997). Historical Default Rates of Corporate Bond Issuers, 1920–1996.Google Scholar
Moody's Investors Service (2003). Sovereign Bond Defaults, Rating Transitions and Recoveries (1985–2002). February.Google Scholar
Moody's Investors Service (2007). Sovereign Defaults and Recovery Rates, 1983–2006. June.Google Scholar
Moody's Investors Service (2009). Corporate Default and Recovery Rates, 1920–2008. Special Comment. February.Google Scholar
Moody's Investors Service (various years). Moody's Manuals.Google Scholar
Morrow, D. W. (1927). Who buys foreign bonds? Foreign Affairs 5 (2), pp. 219–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morton, W. A. (1939). Liquidity and solvency. American Economic Review 29 (2), pp. 272–85.Google Scholar
Nash, R. L. (1889). Fenn's Compendium of the English and Foreign Funds. London: Effingham Wilson.Google Scholar
Norris, J. (1978). R. G. Dun & Co, 1841–1900: The Development of Credit Reporting in the Nineteenth Century. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
Partnoy, F. (2006). How and why credit rating agencies are not like other gatekeepers. In Fuchita, Y. and Litan, R. E. (eds.), Financial Gatekeepers: Can they Protect Investors? Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press and the Nomura Institute of Capital Markets Research.Google Scholar
Partnoy, F. (2009). Historical perspectives on the financial crisis: Ivar Kreuger, the credit-rating agencies, and two theories about the function, and dysfunction, of markets. Yale Journal on Regulation 26, pp. 431–43.Google Scholar
Poor's (various years), Poor's Volumes.Google Scholar
Reinhart, C. M. (2002). Sovereign credit ratings before and after financial crises. In Levich, R., Majnoni, G. and Reinhart, C. (eds.), Ratings, Rating Agencies and the Global Financial System. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers.Google Scholar
Reisen, H. and Von Maltzan, J. (1999). Boom and bust and sovereign ratings. OECD Development Centre, Working Papers No. 148.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rippy, J. F. (1950). A bond-selling extravaganza of the 1920's. Journal of Business of the University of Chicago 23 (4), pp. 238–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sandage, S. (2005). Born Losers: A History of Failure in America. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Skreta, V. and Veldkamp, L. (2009). Ratings shopping and asset complexity: a theory of ratings inflation. Journal of Monetary Economics 56 (5), pp. 678–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Standard Statistics Company (various years). Standard Bond Descriptions.Google Scholar
Standard & Poor's (2007). Sovereign Defaults And Rating Transition Data: 2006 Update. February.Google Scholar
Standard Statistics (1931). A Forecaster's View of Forecasting. New York: Standard Statistics.Google Scholar
Sy, A. (2004). Rating the rating agencies: anticipating currency crises or debt crises? Journal of Banking & Finance 28 (11), pp. 2845–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sylla, R. (2002). An historical primer on the business of credit rating. In Levich, R., Majnoni, G. and Reinhart, C. (eds.), Ratings, Rating Agencies and the Global Financial System. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers.Google Scholar
Tomz, M. (2007), Reputation and International Cooperation. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
US Congress, Senate (1931–2). Sale of Foreign Bonds or Securities in the United States: Hearings before the Committee on Finance. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
White, E. N. (2009). Lessons from the history of bank examination and supervision in the United States 1863–2008. Paper prepared for the conference on ‘Financial Market Regulation after Financial Crises: The Historical Experience’.Google Scholar
Wigmore, B. (1985). The Crash and Its Aftermath: A History of Securities Markets in the United States. New York: Greenwood Press.Google Scholar
Winkler, M. (1933). Foreign Bonds – An Autopsy. New York: Roland Swain Co.Google Scholar
Young, R. (1930). Handbook on American Underwriting of Foreign Securities. Washington, DC: US Department of Commerce.Google Scholar