Published online by Cambridge University Press: 25 March 2010
This article considers how and why the campaign to reform manners spread from England to Ireland in the 1690s. Together with the links and resemblances between the English and Irish campaigns, the distinctive aspects of the latter are discussed. Important to the Irish activity were the shock of the catholic revanche of 1685–90; the powerful tradition of providential explanation for the recurrent crises; the tense and increasingly competitive relations between the Church of Ireland and the Presbyterians; the rapid growth of Dublin (the main centre for reforming activity) and its attendant social and economic difficulties; and the sense of cultural difference between protestants and catholics. The campaign included an assault on heterodox ideas, notably those of Toland and Molesworth, and paralleled the retributive measures taken against the Irish catholics in the same period.
1 The exception is Phillips, W. A., ed., History of the Church of Inland (3 vols., Oxford, 1933), III, 260Google Scholar.
1 In the growing literature on the English societies, I have followed: Bahlman, D. W. R., The moral revolution of 1688 (New Haven, 1957)Google Scholar;Craig, A. G., ‘The movement for the reformation of manners, 1688-1715’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Edinburgh University, 1980)Google Scholar;Curtis, T. C. & Speck, W. A., ‘The societies for the reformation of manners’, Literature and History, III (1976)Google Scholar;Duffy, E., ‘Primitive Christianity revived’, in Baker, D., ed., Renaissance and renewal in Christian history: studies in church history, XIV (Oxford, 1977)Google Scholar;Hayton, D., ‘Moral reform and country politics in the late seventeenth-century house of commons’, Past & Present, CXXVIII (1990)Google Scholar;Isaacs, T., ‘The anglican hierarchy and the reformation of manners’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, XXXIII (1982)Google Scholar;Portus, G. V., Caritas Anglieana (London, 1912)Google Scholar;Spurr, J., ‘“Virtue, religion and government”: the anglican uses of providence’, in Harris, T., Seward, P. and Goldie, M., eds., The politics ofreligion in Resteration England (Oxford, 1990)Google Scholar.
3 An account of the progress of the reformation of mourns in England and Inland, 3rd edn (London, 1701), p. IGoogle Scholar;Boyte, J., A sermon preach't before the societies for reformation in Dublin, 6 01. 1697/8 (Dublin, 1698), p. 21Google Scholar;Nicholson, C., A method of charity-schools (Dublin, 1712), p. 31Google Scholar;A short account of the several kinds of societies…for the carrying on the reformation of manners (London, 1700), p. 1Google Scholar;Woodward, J., An account of the rise and progress of the religious societies, and edn (London, 1698), pp. 64, 89–90Google Scholar.
4 For these feelings: Cambridge University Library, Add. MSS, 1/8, 65, 92, 95; Strype correspondence; St John's College, Cambridge, MSS 067, Bishop Dopping's diary; Marsh's library, Dublin, MSS Z2.2.3, Marsh's, Archbishop diary, partly printed in The Irish Ecclesiastical Journal, V, no. 98 (1848), 51-4, 132-4, 148Google Scholar; ibid. MSS Z1.1.16(1); Lambeth Palace Library, MSS 3152 (Bishop Digby's diary); Gilmore, M. E., ‘Anthony Dopping and the Church of Ireland, 1685-95’ (unpublished M.A. dissertation, Queen's University Belfast, 1988)Google Scholar;Lawlor, H. J., ed., The diary of William King, D.D. (Dublin, 1903)Google Scholar.
5 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/8.
6 Ibid. Add. MSS 1/8, 92; Emlyn, T., A sttmm preach'd before the societies for reformation of manners in Dublin: Octob. the 4th, 1698 (Dublin, 1698), p. 11Google Scholar;Hamilton, William, The exemplary life…of Janus BomeU, esq., 3rd edn (London, 1707), pp. 46, 56-8, 63-4, 66Google Scholar;Lawrence, R., The interest of Ireland in its trade and wealth stated (2 parts, Dublin, 1682), 1, chs. 2-3Google Scholar;Weld, N., A sermon preach'd at New-Row, being a thursday-luture, July 15th, 1714 (Dublin, 1714), p. 15Google Scholar.
7 Society for promoting Christian knowledge, London (S.P.C.K.), Abstract letter book (A.L.B.), 7, no. 4855; McClure, E., ed., A chapter m English Church history: being the minutes of the Society for promoting Christian knowledge (London, 1888), p. 211Google Scholar;Statutes at large, passed in the parliaments held in Ireland (21 vols., Dublin, 1765-1786), IV, 152–7 (6 Anne, c. xiv)Google Scholar; Steele, R., Tudor and Stuart proclamations (2 vols., Oxford, 1910), II, nos. 1357, 1362, 1432, 1433 (Ireland)Google Scholar.
8 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/65; Wetenhall, E., Pastoral admonitions directed by the bishop of Cork to all under kis charge. Wkereunto is added a sermon reflecting on the late sufferings and deliverances of the protestants in the said county and city. Preached at Whitehall (Cork, 1691). pp. ii-iv, viii-x, 14-15, 33–4Google Scholar.
9 Camb. Univ. lib., Add. MSS 1/77; Trinity College, Dublin (T.C.D.), 1995-2008 (correspondence of Archbishop William King), 278; Lambeth Palace, MSS 942 (Gibson pa pen), 79; ‘Archbishop Marsh's diary’, Irish Eccl. Jnl. V, 148Google Scholar; Moody, T. W. & Vaughan, W., eds., A new history tf Ireland, IV (Oxford, 1986), 2Google Scholar.
10 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/81; Marsh's Lib., MSS Za.2.3, p. 35; T.C.D., MSS 1995-9008/398, 400; Christ Church, Oxford, Wake MSS, 12/216; Boyse, J. and Weld, N., Two sermons preach't on a day of fasting and hmmliation kept by the protestant dissenters in Dublin (Dublin, 1695), p. 19Google Scholar; Hamilton, William, A discourse concerning zeal, against immorality and prophaneness deliver'd in two sermons in St Micheal's church Dublin, October. 29, and November 26. 1699 (Dublin, 1700), p. 48Google Scholar;Synge, E., Thankfulness to Almighty God (Dublin, 1711), p. 20Google Scholar.
11 March's Lib., MSS Z2.2.3, pp. 24-6; T.C.D., MSS 1995-2008/170; J. C. Beckett, ‘The government and the Church or Ireland under William III and Anne’, reprinted in Beckett, Confrontations: studies in Irish history (London, 1972), pp. 88–96; Gilmore, ‘Anthony Dopping and the Church of Ireland’, ch. 6.
12 Walkington, E., A sermon preached Octob. 23.1692 (Dublin, 1692), pp. 14–18Google Scholar; Wetenhall, E., A sermon preached Octob. 23.1692 (Dublin, 1692), pp. 17–18.Google Scholar More generally on these sermons, see Barnard, T. C., ‘The uses of 23 October 1641 and Irish protestant celebrations’, English Historical Review, CVI (1991), 889–920CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
13 Marsh's Lib., MSS Z2.2.3, pp. 26, 27; Beckett, J. C., Protestant dissent in Ireland, 1687-1780 (London, 1948), pp. 31–2Google Scholar;Journals of the house of lords of the kingdom of Ireland, 1634-1800 (8 vob., Dublin, 1779-1800), 1, 465.Google Scholar For the 1692 parliament, see also: McGuire, J. I., ‘The Irish parliament of 1692’, in Bartlett, T. and Hayton, D., eds., Penal era and golden age (Antrim, 1979)Google Scholar.
14 T.C.D., MSS 1995-2008/204, 255, 260, 268, 272, 274, 301, 312, 337, 355, 374; Beckett, J. C., ‘William King's administration of the diocese of Derry, 1691-1703’, Irish Historical Studies, IV (1944-1945). 165–79Google Scholar;Foley, S., An exhertation to the inhabitation of Down and Connor concerning the religious education of their children (Dublin, 1695)Google Scholar; Gilmore, ‘Anthony Dopping and the Church of Ireland’, ch. 7.
15 T.C.D., MSS 1995-3008/268, 278, 301.
16 Lambeth Palace, MSS 942/96. For Marsh's travels through his diocese, Marsh's Lib., MSS Za.9.3, pp. 34-5.
17 A judicious contemporary summed up King thus: ‘he is a mighty positive man and when in the right of an admirable disposition to push a thing to the utmost. But ‘tis at the same time his misfortune to have the same teal to drive matters if he happens to be in the wrong’: P.R.O., SP 63/363, 393. A recent succinct and penetrating assessment is by P. H. Kelly, ‘Archbishop William King (1650-1719) and colonial nationalism’, in Brady, C., ed., Worsted in the game: losers in lrish history (Dublin, 1989)Google Scholar.
18 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/79, 80. 82, 84, 85; Marsh's Lib, MSS Z2.2.3, pp. 25-29, 36; T.C.D., MSS 1995-2008/553; Lambeth Palace, MSS 929/41; 942/65, 79, 86, 96; Bodleian Library, Oxford (Bodl), Smith MSS 52/55, 63, 67, 68, 75; McCarthy, M., All scholars and gentltmen: Marsh's Library (Dublin, 1980), ch. 1Google Scholar;Swift, J., Miscellaneous and autobiographical pieces, ed., Davis, H. (Oxford, 1962), pp. 211–12Google Scholar.
19 Bodl., Smith MSS 52/25; Barnard, ‘The uses of 23 October 1641’; Hoppen, K. T., The common scientist in the seventeenth century (London, 1970), pp. 33-5, 187, 193Google Scholar.
20 Lambeth Palace, MSS 942/96; Pollard, Thomas, The necessity and advantages of family prayer in two sermons (Dublin, 1696), sig. [a2]-[a2]vGoogle Scholar.
21 Scroggi, Benedict, A sermon preached btfott the rtligious societies in the City of Dublin, on the 39th of Siplem. 1695 (Dublin, 1695), PP. 39–66.Google Scholar For similar rules in England: Gloucestershire County Record Office, D.3549, Lloyd-Baker MSS, box 77b, bundle p; Woodward, , An account, pp. 64, 120–30Google Scholar.
22 Bishop Dopping to Abp. of Canterbury, 25 March 1693; and paper in favour of a regal visitation, Nottingham University Library, Portland MSS, Pw A 2373, 2374; Beckett, , ‘William King's administration’; Beckett, Protestant dissent in Ireland, pp. 36–41Google Scholar;Browne, Peter, A sermon preached at St Bride's church, Dublin, 04 17. 1698 (Dublin, 1698), pp. 11-12, 15-16, 23–4Google Scholar;Isaacs, , ‘The Anglican hierarchy and the reformation of manners’, pp. 393–402Google Scholar.
23 T.C.D., MSS 750/1, p. 222; S.P.C.K., A.L.B., 9, no. 5964; Bodl., Ballard MSS 8, fo. 22; Christ Church, Wake MSS 12/354-4; King, W., The mischief of delaying sentence against an evil work (Dublin, 1707)Google Scholar.
24 Marsh's Lib., MSS Za, 3.3, p. 27; Journals of the house of comments of the kingdom of Ireland (21 vols., Dublin, 1796-1802), 11, 123, 124, 125, 127, 137Google Scholar; Lords' Jnl. Ireland, 1, 465, 554, 558, 559, 578Google Scholar; Statutes at Large…in Ireland, III, 314-17 (7 William III, c. xvii).
25 Dublin Municipal Archives, City Hall, Dublin, MR/18, Monday book 1658-1712, p. 130A; National Library of Ireland, Dublin (N.L.I.), MSS 11048/54; Kilkenny Municipal Archives, ‘White book’, p. 6; Bodl., Carte MSS 36, fo. 454; Barnard, T. C., Cromwellian Ireland (Oxford, 1975), p. 40Google Scholar;Mulcahy, M., ed., Calendar of Kinsale documents (2 vols., Kinsale, 1988-1989), 1, 54, 91, 101Google Scholar;ODilaigh, B., ed., Corporation book of Ennis (Dublin, 1990), pp. 58–9Google Scholar;Pender, S., ed., Council books of the corporation of Waterford (Dublin, 1964), p. 296.Google Scholar Waterford had also seen acute tension between protestants and catholics in 1690: Gilmore, , ‘Anthony Dopping and the Church of Ireland’, pp. 45–9Google Scholar.
26 Public Record Office of Northern Ireland, Belfast, D.1759/1A/1, Co. Antrim presbytery minutes 1654-8; Gillespie, R., ‘The presbyterian revolution in Ulster 1660-1690’, in Shieli, W. J. and Wood, D., eds., The churches, Ireland and the Irish: studies in church history, XXV (Oxford, 1989), 159–70Google Scholar;Latimer, W. T., ‘The old session book of Templepatrick presbyterian church’, Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland, 5th series, v (1895), 132-3; XI (1901), 164, 263–4Google Scholar.
27 Commons' Jnl. Ireland, II, 61-2, 64, 78, 80, 105Google Scholar; Lords' Jnl. Ireland, 1, 498, 502, 503Google Scholar; Statutes at large…in Ireland, III, 275-7, 314-16 (7 William III, cc. IX, XVII).
28 For the English developments, Bahlman, , The moral revolution, pp. 19-24, 39-41. 44-9. 68-70, 74-8, 80–101Google Scholar; Curtis, and Speck, , ‘The societies for the reformation of manners’, pp. 47-8, 59–60Google Scholar;Isaacs, , ‘The Anglican hierarchy and the reformation of manners’, pp. 395–403Google Scholar.
29 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 5/248, 251; Boyse, , A sermon preach't…6 Jan. 1697/8, sig. A2, pp. 5, 22Google Scholar;A discourse against profane swearing and cursing (Dublin, 1698), p. 30Google Scholar;Emlyn, , A sermon preach'd… oct the 4th, 1698, pp. 6, 11-12, 15–16Google Scholar;Sindare, A., A sermon preach'd before the societies for reformation of manners in Dublin, 04 the 11th, 1699 (Dublin, 1699), p. 24Google Scholar;Woodward, , An account, PP. 89-91Google Scholar.
30 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/85; Emlyn, , A sermon preach'd… October the 4th, 1698, pp. 1, 11, 18Google Scholar; Hamilton, , A discourse concerning teal, pp. 14, 54–6Google Scholar;Ircdcll, F., A sermon preached before the societies for reformation of manners; 04 22. 1701 (Dublin, 1701), p. 4Google Scholar;Weld, N., A sermon before the societies for reformation of manners in Dublin: preached in New-Row, April the 26th. 1698 (Dublin, 1698), pp. 12–13Google Scholar.
31 Boyse, , A sermon preach't…6 Jan. 1697/8, p. 7Google Scholar; Browne, , A sermon preached… April 17. 1698, pp. 27–31Google Scholar; Hamilton, , A discourse concerning teal, pp. 10, 14–16Google Scholar;Higgins, F., A sermon preach'd …at Christ-Church, Dublin; on Tuesday the 28th of August (Dublin, 1705), pp. 10-11, 16–17Google Scholar; King, , The mischief of delaying sentence, pp. 23, 30Google Scholar; Sindare, , A sermon preach'd… April the 11th. 1699, p. 21Google Scholar; Williams, D., A sermon preach'd before the societies for reformation of manners in Dublin: 07 the 18th, 1700 (Dublin, 1700), pp. 11, 14Google Scholar.
32 Barnard, ‘The uses of 23 October 1641’;J. Boyse, A sermon preach'd at Dublin on the 23d of October, 1703, in Boyse, , Sermons preachd on various subjects (Dublin, 1708)Google Scholar, with separate title-page and pagination, pp. 20-1, 55-7; Boyse, , A sermon preach't…6 Jan. 1697/8, pp. 6–8Google Scholar; Hamilton, , A discourse concerning zeal, p. 28Google Scholar; Records of the general synod of Ulster from 1691-1820 (3 vols., Belfast, 1890-1898), 1, 30Google Scholar; Sinclare, , A sermon preached… April the 11th, 1699, pp. 9, 12–15Google Scholar; Steele, , Tudor and Stuart proclamations, II, nos. 1391, 1393 (Ireland)Google Scholar; Weld, , A sermon… April the 26th. 1698, pp. 12–13Google Scholar; Williams, , A sermon preach'd… July the 18th, 1700, pp. 19-21, 23–4Google Scholar.
33 A discourse against profane swearing and cursing, p. 23; Emlyn, , A sermon preach'd… October the 4th, 1698, p. 7Google Scholar.
34 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/80, 82; Bulkelly, J., Short and plain directions for the observation of the Lords day (Dublin, 1697)Google Scholar;Mulcahy, , ed., Calendar of Kinsale documents, 1, 101, 113, 116, 120Google Scholar; Records of the general synod of Ulster, 1, 33; Woodward, , An account, p. 64Google Scholar.
35 Dickson, D., ‘Capital and country: 1600-1800’, in Cosgrove, A., ed., Dublin though the ages (Dublin, 1988), p. 66Google Scholar;Dickson, , ‘The place of Dublin in the eighteenth-century Irish economy’, in Devine, T. M. and Dickson, D., eds., Ireland and Scotland 1600-1850 (Edinburgh, 1983), pp. 178–9Google Scholar;Emlyn, , A sermon preach'd… October the 4th, 1698, pp. 16–17. On godly reformation in English towns:Google ScholarClark, P., ‘“The Ramoth-Gilead of the Good”: urban change and political radicalism at Gloucester 1540-1640’, in Clark, P., Smith, A. G. R. and Tyacke, N., eds., The English commonwealth 1547-1640 (Leicester, 1979), pp. 175–6Google Scholar;Slack, P., ‘Poverty and politics in Salisbury, 1597-1666’, in Clark, P. and Slack, P., eds., Crisis and order in English towns 1500-1700 (London, 1972), pp. 181–7Google Scholar;Slack, P., Poverty and policy in Tudor and Stuart England (London, 1988), pp. 149–52Google Scholar.
36 T.C.D., MSS 750/1, p. 222; Boyse, A sermon preach't…6 Jan. 1697/8, sig. [A2]v; Iredell, A sermon prtaeh'd… April 22. 1701, p. 15; Sindare, A sermon preach'd… April the IIth. 1699, pp. 6, 16, Woodward, An account, p. 91.
37 Irwin, C. H., A history of Prtsbyteriansm in Dublin and the south and west of Ireland (Dublin, 1890), p. 35.Google Scholar A recent estimate suggests that by 1700 more than half Ulster's protestants were presbyterians, ‘and probably close to half those in Ireland as a whole’: Connolly, S., in Maguire, W. A., ed., Kings in conflict: the revolutionary war in Ireland and its aftermath 1689-1750 (Belfast, 1990), p. 167.Google Scholar This seems to me an over-estimate.
38 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/85; B.L., Add. MSS 7030a, Harley MSS, paper from the primate of Ireland, 1719, about the numbers of papists and dissenters; Christ Church, Wake MSS 13. for. 59. 90.
39 Camb. Univ. lib., Add. MSS 1/85; Lambeth Palace, MSS 942/96; Emlyn, A sermon preach'd… October the 4th, 1698, pp. 11, 15; Hamilton, A discourse concerning zeal, pp. 14-15; Milling, John, A discourst concerning man, as he is a religious creature: to the societies for the reformation of manners in the city of Dublin, 05 the 18th, 1703 (Dublin, 1703), pp. vi–viiGoogle Scholar; Woodward, An account, p. 91.
40 That dissent was prevalent is suggested by the reprint in Dublin in 1698 of An enquiry into the occasional conformity of dissenters in cases of preferment, even before there was a sacramental test to be evaded.
41 Nottingham Univ. Lib., PwA 1322, 2691a; Christ Church, Oxford, Evelyn MSS, bound letters, fo. 654v; An apology for Mr Toland, in a Utter from himself to a member of the house of commons in Ireland (London, 1702), p. 6Google Scholar;Gilbert, J. T., ed., Calendar of the ancient records of Dublin (19 vols, Dublin, 1889-1944), VI, 253Google Scholar;ton, D. Hay, ‘The crisis in Ireland and the disintegration of Queen Anne's last ministry’, Irish Hist. Studies, XXII (1981), 197-8, 205Google Scholar;Hayton, , ‘Ireland and die English ministers, 1707-16’ (unpublished D.Phil, dissertation, Oxford, 1975), pp. 237–8Google Scholar.
42 On politics at this time, see: D. Hayton, ‘The beginnings of the “undertaker system”’, in Bartlett and Hayton, eds., Penal era and golden age; Szechi, D. and Hayton, D., ‘John Bull's other kingdoms: Scotland and Ireland’, in Jones, C., ed., Britain in the first age of party 1680-1750 (London, 1987), pp. 265-72Google Scholar. For die mixed support for the Dublin societies: Browne, A sermon preached... April if. 1698; Wetenhall, E., Two sermons preached to the religious societies in St Michael's church, Dublin (Dublin, 1701)Google Scholar; and, in England, Hayton, , ‘Moral reform and country polities’, pp. 72–89Google Scholar.
43 T.C.D., MSS 847; N.L.I., MSS 8238/26; S.P.C.K., Minute book, 1 (1698-1706), pp. 233, 238; 2-4 (1706-9), pp. 145, 176; CS 2/6, fo. 28V; CS 2/21, lbs. 22-22v; A.L.B., 5, no. 4049; 7, nos. 4904, 5126; Bodl., Clarendon state papers, 88, fo. 260; Burtchaell, G. D. and Sadleir, T. U., Alumni Dublinenses (Dublin, 1935), p. 692Google Scholar; McClure, ed., A chapter in English church history, pp. 3 &n. 45, 91, 221, 222. Generally on the family: Barnard, T. C., ‘The political, material and mental culture of the Cork settlers, c. 1650-1700’, in Flanagan, P. O., Cork: history and society (Dublin, 1993)Google Scholar; R. and Loeber, M. S., ‘The lost architecture of the Wexford plantation’, in Whelan, K., ed., Wexford: history tad society (Dublin, 1987), p. 199Google Scholar.
44 Bodl., Lister MSS 35, fos. 116, 119, 121; ibid. Tanner MSS 36, fo. 227; Burtchaell, and Sadleir, , Alumni Dublinenses, p. 110Google Scholar; Hoppen, , The common scientist, pp. 29, 40Google Scholar; Hoppen, K. T., ‘The papers of the Dublin philosophical society 1683-1708’, Analecta Hibernica, XXX (Dublin, 1982), 222Google Scholar.
45 T.C.D., MSS 750/1, pp. 101-4; 1995-2008/636, 649, 654; Lambeth Palace, MSS 942/96, 171; P.R.O., SP 63/363, 198; Nottingham Univ. Lib., Pw A 2324-2334; Bulkelly, , Short and plain directions; Commons' Jnl. Ireland, II, 190, 317Google Scholar; Hamilton, , Life of Bonnell, p. 232Google Scholar; Hardy, W. J., ed., Calendar of the Middlesex county records. Sessions book 1689 to 1709 (London, 1903), pp. 57, 60, 64Google Scholar; Hist. MSS Comm., Portland MSS, VI, 482; McClure, , A chapter in English church history, pp. 30, 32, 34, 35, 36, 67, 70, 71, 76, 159, 211Google Scholar; Schwarz, Hillel, The French prophets: the history of a millenarian group in eighteenth-century England (Berkeley, 1980), pp. 53, 79-80, 86, 92, 171, 273–5.Google Scholar Bulkeley's father, though the builder of a church on his Co. Wicklow estate, was said to frequent conventicles in the early 1680s. Bodl., Carte MSS 154, fo. 90v; Hist. MSS Comm., Ormonde MSS, new series, VII, 19, 66.
46 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 2/208, 225, 226, 232; T.C.D., MSS 750/8, p. 206; Hamilton, , Life of Bonnell, pp. XV, 132-3, 178-80, 191-2, 232Google Scholar.
48 Boyse, A sermon preach't… 6 Jan. 1697/8, sig. A2-[A2] v, p. 14; A discount against profant swearing and cursing, pp. 30-5; Iredell, , A sermon preached… April 32. 1701, p. 15Google Scholar; King, , The mischief of delaying sentence, pp. 24–34Google Scholar; Hamilton, , Discourse concerning zeal, pp. 23-8, 30-1, 37–8Google Scholar; Sinclair, , A sermon preach'd… April the 11th. 1699, p. 24Google Scholar; Weld, , A sermon before the societies… April the 26th. 1698, p. 13Google Scholar; Wetenhall, , Two sermons, pp. 55–9Google Scholar
49 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add MSS 1/85; R.C.B., P. 327/4/1, lbs. 86, 91v, 97v; Browne, , A sermon preached… April 17. 1698, pp. 11, 39Google Scholar; Emlyn, , A sermon preach'd… October the 4th, 1698, p. 6Google Scholar; Flying Post, 3-5 Oct. 1700; Iredell, , A sermon preached… April 22. 1701, p. 9Google Scholar; Mulcahy, , Calendar of Kinsale documents, II, 12, 27, 60, 66–7Google Scholar; Statutes at large…in Ireland, IV, 161; Woodward, , An account, p. 91Google Scholar.
50 A discourse against profane swearing and cursing, p. 30.
51 Browne, A sermon preached… April 17. 1698; A discourse against profane swearing and cursing; S.P.C.K., A.L.B., 6, no. 4450.
52 Curtis, and Speck, , ‘The societies for the reformation of manners’, pp. 56–8Google Scholar; Hayton, , ‘Moral reform and country polities’, pp. 61–83Google Scholar; Slack, , Poverty and policy, pp. 196–8Google Scholar.
53 Browne, , A sermon preached… April 17. 1698, pp. 21–2Google Scholar; Hamilton, , Discourse concerning zeal, pp. 34. 37; Wetenhall, Two sermons, sig. [A4]Google Scholar.
54 B.L., Add. MSS 4759; Cullen, L. M., ‘Economic development’, in Moody, and Vaughan, , eds., A new history of Ireland, IV, 135Google Scholar; Barnard, ‘The Cork settlers’; Barnard, ‘The uses of 23 October 1641’; Nicholson, , A method of charity-schools, p. 15Google Scholar; Sekora, J., Luxury: the concept in western thought (London and Baltimore, 1977)Google Scholar;Wetenhall, , A sermon preached Octob. 13. 1692, p. 18Google Scholar.
55 Statutes at large…in Ireland, III, 503 (10 William III, c. xi); IV, 166-7 (6 Anne, c. xvii), 301-6 (11 Anne, cc. v, vi). For gambling in Ireland: Chatsworth House, Derbyshire, Bolton Abbey MSS 279, account of 2nd Lord Cork's ‘play money’ to 5 March 1662 [3]; Christ Church, Oxford, Evelyn MSS, bound letters, fo. 657; Barnard, ‘The Cork settlers’; Beckett, J. C., The cavalier duke: a lift of James Butler, 1st duke of Ormond (Belfast, 1990), pp. 128–9Google Scholar; H J & Butler, H E, eds., The black book of Edgeworthstown (London, 1927), pp. 17-19, 23–4Google Scholar; MacLysaght, E., Short study of a transplanted family (Dublin, 1935), pp. 32, 41–2Google Scholar; Memoirs of the lift of… Thomas late Marquess of Wharton (London, 1715), p. 69.Google Scholar For theological objections, Wood, T., ‘Seventeenth-century English casuists on betting and gambling’, Church Quarterly Review, CXLIX (1950), pp. 159–74Google Scholar.
56 Browne, , A strmon preached… April 17. 1698, pp. 21–2Google Scholar; Hamilton, , A discourse conctrning zeal, p. 37Google Scholar; Woodward, , An account, pp. 90–1Google Scholar.
57 Some of this teaching is considered in Barnard, ‘The uses of 23 October 1641’.
58 Nottingham Univ. Lib., PwA 2373; The charge given by Narcissus [Marsh] lord-archbishop of Casshell to kis clergy (Dublin, 1694), P. 12Google Scholar;Constitutions and canons ecclesiastical (Dublin, [1715]), p. 11 (canon xii)Google Scholar; Hamilton, , A discourse concerning zeal, p. 11Google Scholar; Leslie, John, Articles to be inquired of by the churchwardens and questmen of every parish (Dublin, 1667), pp. 7–8.Google Scholar
59 For the passage of the ‘penal laws’: Kelly, P., ‘Lord Galway and the penal laws’, in Caldicott, C. E. J., Gough, H. and Pittion, J.-P., eds., The Huguenots and Ireland (Dun Laoghaire, 1987)Google Scholar; J. G. Simim, ‘The Bishops' Banishment Act of 1697’ and ‘The making of a penal law’, reprinted in Simms, War and politics in Ireland 1649-1730, eds. D. W. Hayton and G. O'Brien (London, 1986). Disagreements over the use of the Irish language are evident from: S.P.C.K., A.L.B., 6, no. 5289; Barnard, , ‘The uses of 23 October 1641’; Lords' Jnl. Ireland, 1, 622, 624, 634Google Scholar; Sindare, , A sermon preach'd before the societies… April the 11th, 1699, p. 16Google Scholar; Wetenhall, , A sermon preached Octob. 23. 1692, p. 17Google Scholar. I intend to consider elsewhere protestant attitudes to, and use of, the Irish language.
60 Statutes at large… in Ireland, II, 151-3 (10 & 11 Car. I, c. v ); 511-15 (14 & 15 Car. II, c. xviii); Barnard, , Cromwellian Ireland, p. 40Google Scholar; Gillespie, R., Colonial Ulster: the settlement of East Ulster 1600-41 (Cork, 1985), pp. 106, 159, 186Google Scholar. On the English situation: Clark, P., ‘The alehouse and the alternative society’, in Pennington, D. H. and Thomas, K. V., eds., Puritans and Revolutionaries (Oxford, 1978)Google Scholar;Clark, P., The English alehouse (London, 1983)Google Scholar;Fletcher, A., Reform in At provinces: government in Stuart England (New Haven and London, 1986), pp. 229–52Google Scholar; Walter, J. and Wrightson, K., ‘Dearth and the social order in early modern England’, Past & Present, LXXI (1976), 29, 38–9Google Scholar;Wrightson, K., ‘Alehouses, order and reformation in rural England 1590-1660’, in E. & Yeo, S., eds., Popular culture and class conflict 1330-1914 (Brighton, 1981)Google Scholar.
61 , Clark, The English alehouse, pp. 126-7, 147-8Google Scholar; Gogarty, T., ed., Council book of the corporation of Droghouda…1649 to 1734, I (Drogheda, 1915), 157, 332Google Scholar.
62 Christ Church, Wake MSS 12, To. 190; Hull, C. H., ed., The economic writings of Sir William Petty (2 vols., Cambridge, 1899), 1, 146, 215, 218; II, 589Google Scholar;MacLysaght, E., Irish life in the seventeenth century (Shannon, 1969 edn), pp. 251–3Google Scholar.
63 N.L.I., MSS 4908; Bodleian, Carte MSS 36, fo. 454.
64 M B.L., Add. MSS 46938/86; Christ Church, Evelyn MSS, bound letters, fo. 654v; ibid, box IV, excise totals, and debts of Dublin brewers; Barnard, Cromwellian Ireland, pp. 40-1.
65 English reformers also worried about the young: Collinson, P., The religion of protestants (Oxford, 1982), pp. 224–30Google Scholar;Green, I., ‘“For children in yeeres and children in understanding”: the emergence of the English catechism under Elizabeth and the early Stuarts’, Jnl. Ectl. Hist., XXXVN (1986), 408-9, 418–21;Google ScholarIngram, M. J., Quack courts, sex and marriage in England 1570-1640 (Cambridge, 1987), pp. 264, 365Google Scholar.
66 On the religious complexion of Dublin: An abstract of the number of protestant and popish foutfits in Ireland (Dublin, 1736), pp. 3–6Google Scholar; Dickson, ‘Capital and country: Dublin 1600-1800’, p. 74; The place of Irish servants in protestant society cries out for research. For the moment, see: Canny, N., The upstart earl: a study in the social and mental worlds of Richard Boyle first earl of Cork (Cambridge, 1982), pp. 193–4CrossRefGoogle Scholar; , Hull, ed., Writings of Petty, 1, 144Google Scholar; MacCarthy-Morrogh, M., The Munsttr plantation (Oxford, 1986), p. 283Google Scholar; Statutes at large…in Ireland, iv, 148-51 (6 Anne, c. xiii). My remarks are also based on the transcripts of Bishop Nicholson of Derry's diaries in the Cumbria County Library, Carlisle (formerly at Tullie House) and Bishop Edward Synge's correspondence with his daughter, in private possession in London.
67 Lambeth Palace, 942/96; Nottingham Univ. Lib., PwA 2373.
68 T.C.D., MSS 1995-2008/2425; Mulcahy, Calendar of Kinsale documents, 1, 54, 91, 101.
69 Bossy, J., ‘The counter-reformation and the people of catholic Ireland, 1596-1641’, in Williams, T. D., ed., Historical Studies, VIII (Dublin, 1971)Google Scholar; Connolly, S. J., ‘Religion, work-discipline and economic attitudes: the case of Ireland’, in Devine, and Dickson, , eds., Ireland and Scotland 1600-1850, p. 243Google Scholar; Corish, P. J., The Irish catholic experience: a historical survey, (Dublin, 1985), pp. 106-9, 115–21Google Scholar.
70 The act of 1689 had debarred socinian doctrines from toleration. Bennett, G. V., ‘Conflict in the church’, in Holmes, G. S., ed., Britain after the glorious revolution (London, 1969), pp. 161–5Google Scholar; Holmes, G., The trial of Dr Sacheverell (London, 1973), pp. 23–6Google Scholar; MacLachlan, H. J., Socinianism in seventeenth-century England (Oxford, 1951), pp. 294–321Google Scholar; A short account of the several kinds of societies, p. 1.
71 T.C.D., MSS 668/1, proceedings of Irish convocation, 8 Feb. 1703 [4], 11 Feb. 1703 [4], 26 Feb. 1703 [4], 8 March 1704 [5]; 668/2, p. 28 ; Browne, P., A Utter in answer to a book entitled, Christianity not mysterious (London, 1697)Google Scholar; Browne, , A sermon preached… April 17. 1698, p. 37Google Scholar; Winnett, A. R., Peter Browne: provost, bishop and metaphysician (London, 1974), pp. 169–71Google Scholar.
72 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 5/160; Higgins, F., A sermon preach'dat the royal chappel at WhiteHall; on Ash-Wednesday, Febr. 36, 1706/7 (London, 1707), pp. 13–14Google Scholar.
73 For an account which particularly stresses Toland's Irish links, see: J. G. Simms, ‘John Toland, a Donegal heretic’, reprinted in Simms, War and politics in Ireland, pp. 31-48.
74 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/84; T.C.D., MSS 750/1, p. 96; Lambeth Palace, 942/133; Bodl. Ballard MSS 8, To. 76; Beer, E. S. de, ed, The correspondence of John Locke, VI (Oxford, 1981), 40-1, 83, 132–3Google Scholar; A letter to J. C. Esq; upon Mr Toland's book (Dublin, 1697), pp. 1–4Google Scholar.
75 An apology for Mr Toland in a letterfrom himself, pp. 3—14, 19, 44—5; Browne, , A letter in answer to a book, pp. 144–45, ‘64-9, 171-2Google Scholar; Beer, de, ed., The correspondence of Locke, VI, 83, 163-4, 192Google Scholar.
76 Camb. Univ. lab., Add. MSS 5/248; An apology for Mr Toland, pp. 20-3; Commons' Jnl. Ireland, II, 190; Beer, de, ed., Correspondence of Locke, VI, 192Google Scholar.
77 P.R.O., Belfast, Dio. 4/15/2/3 (Foy to King, 18 Sep. 1697); Statute at large in Inland, III, 251 (7 William III, c. ii).
78 Molesworth, R., Some considerationsfor the promoting of agriculture, and employing the poor (Dublin, 1723), PP. 31, 39-40 42–3Google Scholar. The suggestion that William Molyneux spoke up for Toland, though not implausible, is less likely: Simms, J. G., William Molyneux of Dublin (Dublin, 1982), p. 88Google Scholar.
79 Lords' Jnl. Ireland, 1, 607, 619, 625, 628, 629, 630-1, 632Google Scholar.
80 T.C.D., MSS 750/1, p. 91.
81 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/84; T.C.D., MSS 750/1, 96; Lambeth Palace, MSS 942/133; Browne, , A Letter in answer to a book, pp. 145, 162, 166Google Scholar.
82 The main link was apparently Daniel Williams, a minister in Dublin until 1688, and thereafter in close touch with the Irish dissenters. He helped Toland financially in the 1690s. B.L., Add. MSS 4276, fo. 223; S.P.C.K., A.L.B., 8, no. 5289; Heinemann, F. H., ‘John Toland, France, Holland and Dr Williams’, Review of English Studies, XXV (1949), 346–9Google Scholar; Thomas, R., Daniel Williams, ‘presbyterian bishop’ (London, 1964), pp. 3, 7, 17Google Scholar; Williams, D., The protestants deliverance from the Irish rebellion (London, 1690), sig. A2; Williams, A sermon preach'd… July the 18th, 1700Google Scholar.
83 Bodl., Ballard MSS 8, fo. 76; Beer, de, ed., Correspondence of John Locke, IV, 164Google Scholar.
84 An apology for Mr Toland, pp. 14, 15; Barnard, ‘The uses of 23 October 1641’; Goldie, M., ‘John Locke and Anglican royalism’, Political Studies, XXXI (1983), 71Google Scholar; Harris, T., ‘Introduction’, in Harris, , et.al., eds., The politics of religion in Restoration England, pp. 14—15Google Scholar; Kenyon, P., Revolution principles: the politics of party 1689-1720 (Cambridge, 1977), ch. 5CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Nicholson, , A method of charity-schools, p. 31Google Scholar.
85 Kilkenny Municipal Archives, Minute book 1690-1717, pp. 41, 46, 56; Commons' Jnl. Ireland, II, 229–30Google Scholar; Gilbert, , ed., Calendar of the ancient records of Dublin, VI, 140-1, 152Google Scholar; Pender, , ed., Council books of Waterford, p. 329Google Scholar; Vigors, P. D., ed., ‘Extracts from the old corporation books of New Ross, Co. Wexford’, Jnl. Royal Soc. of Antiquaries of Ireland, 5th series, XI (1901), 54Google Scholar.
86 Camb. Univ. Lab., Add. MSS 4/63; 5/248; Browne, P., Sermons on various subjects (2 vols., London, 1749), I, 48–198Google Scholar.
87 Commons Jnl. Ireland, II, 262, 280Google Scholar.
88 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 4/63; P.R.O., SP. 63/363, 379; Bodl., Ballard MSS 36, fo. 25; Boyse, J., The difference between Mr E[mlyn] and the protestant dissenting ministers of D[ublin], (Dublin?, [1703])Google Scholar; Dublin intelligence, no. 74, 19 June 1703; A sober expostulation with the gentlemen and citizens of Mr Emlin's juries in Dublin (Dublin, 1703)Google Scholar; A true narrative of the proceedings of the dissenting ministers of Dublin against Mr Thomas Emlyn… Annis 1702, 3, 4, 5 (London, 1719)Google Scholar.
89 J. Boyse, A vindication of the true deity of our blessed saviour (Dublin, reprinted London, 1703); Milling, A discourse concerning man, as he is a religious creature.
90 T.C.D., MSS 668/1, 8 & 9 Feb. 1703 [4], 4 March 1703 [4], 8 March 1704 [5], 668/2, p. 28; 668/3, 9 Feb- ‘703 [4]. 2 March 1703 [4]; Lords’ Jnl. Ireland, II, 414Google Scholar.
91 For the emergence of this measure, Beckett, , Protestant dissent in Ireland, pp. 43–52;Google ScholarWar and politics in Ireland, pp. 263-76.
92 P.R.O., SP 63/363, 11, 198, 262-3; D.N.B.; MacLysaght, E., ed., The Kenmore manuscripts (Dublin, 1942), pp. X, 3-6, 10-11, 13, 27-8, 32–4Google Scholar.
93 London, 1700.
94 [Nicholson, E.], An Answer to Mr AsgilFs book (Dublin, 1702)Google Scholar; Nicholson, E., A between two friends (Dublin, 1711), pp. v–viGoogle Scholar; [Stearne, John], The death and burial of John Asgill, with some other verses occasioned by his books (Dublin, 1702), pp. 6, 16Google Scholar.
95 Tenison was a kinsman of Archbishop Tenison of Canterbury. Burke's Irish family (London, 1976), p. 1099Google Scholar; Malcomson, A. P. W., ‘The Foster family and the parliamentary borough of Dunleer, 1683-1800’, Jnl. Co. Louth Archaeological & Historical Society, XVII 157–8Google Scholar. For further evidence of Tenison's interest in religious reform: T.C.D., MSS 668/1, 16 March 1704 [5].
96 P.R.O., SP 63/363, II, 198-9, 262-3; Commons' Jnl. Ireland, II, 317, 325, 334, 336, 353, 357, 359. 362Google Scholar.
97 P.R.O., SP 63/363, 52; 63/364, 81, 107; Commons' Jnl. Ireland, II, 317, 326, 329, 345Google Scholar. The English act was 9 & 10 William III, c. 32.
98 P.R.O., SP 63/365, 25; 63/366, 319-20; Lords' Jnl. Ireland, II, 89, 95Google Scholar.
99 Bodl., Ballard MSS 8, fos. 34v, 40v-41; Curtis, E., ed., ‘Address of the bishop and clergy of Cloyne to the Queen, 1711’ Jnl. Cork Historical and Archaeological Society, XLVI (1941), 139–42Google Scholar; Hayton, , ‘Ireland and the English ministers’, pp. 126-24, 234-5, 277-93, 308Google Scholar; Hayton, , ‘Tories and whigs in Co. Cork, 1714’, Jnl. Cork Historical and Archaeological Society, LXXX (1975), 84–8Google Scholar.
100 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 5/160; T.C.D., MSS 750/3/2, pp. 177-8; 1995-2008/1352, 1354; Bulkeley, R., An answer to several treatises lately published on the subject of the prophets (London, 1708)Google Scholar; Bulkeley, , preface to Warnings of the eternal spirit, spoken by… Abraham Whitro (London, 1709)Google Scholar; Mr. Higgins's printed case relating to Sir Rich. Bulkley (Dublin, 1711)Google Scholar; Hoppen, , The common scientist, p. 186Google Scholar; Schwarz, , The French prophets, pp. 83, 115-16, 119, 131–2Google Scholar; Spinckes, N., The new pretenders to prophecy re-examined (London, 1710), pp. xii-xiii, 19–21Google Scholar.
101 For the 1709 bill, Lords' Jnl. Ireland, II, 257, 258, 271, 272, 273, 285, 287, 289Google Scholar; for 1711, ibid. II 373, 375, 376; for ‘7’3- ibid 426, 427, 428, 430.
102 Commons' Jnl. Ireland, II, 773Google Scholar; Flying Post, nos. 3433, 3442; Hayton, D., ed., ‘An Irish parliamentary diary from the reign or Queen Anne’, Analecta Hibernua, XXX (1982), 138, 144Google Scholar; Lords' Jnl. Ireland, II, 441, 442Google Scholar. On Molesworth's later activities, Stewart, M. A., ‘John Smith and the Molesworth circle’, Eighteenth-century Ireland, II (1987)Google Scholar.
103 T.C.D., MSS 1995-2008/1524; Lords' Jnl. Ireland, II, 460Google Scholar.
104 Bodl., Ballard MSS 8, fos. 56, 118; Christ Church, Wake MSS 13, fos. 116, 132, 136, 155, 182; Bolton, T., A sermon preach'd… on Monday, October 23. 1721 (Dublin, 1721), pp. 17, 29, 34, 45Google Scholar; Forster, N., A sermon preached… on Sunday, November, 5th. 1721 (Dublin, 1721), pp. 21–2Google Scholar; Remarks, &c, ‘upon Dr Bolton’s sermon, 23 Oct. 1721’ ([1722]); Synge, E., A sermon against persecution on account of religion (Dublin, 1721), pp. 19–20Google Scholar; Tyrrell, Duke, A sermon preach'd… on Friday October 23rd 1719 (Dublin, 1719), pp. 26–7Google Scholar.
105 St Mary's church, Shandon, Cork, Minute book of the Green Coat hospital; Christ Church, Wake MSS 13, fo. 76; Bacon, B., A sermon preach'd…on Sunday the twenty-third of October, 1743 (Dublin, 1743), pp. 19–20Google Scholar; Cobbe, R. Chaloner, The duty and manner of rejoicing for national deliverances (Dublin, 1759), pp. 11–12Google Scholar; Davies, Richard, Repentance OUT best preservative against the plague (Cork, 1721), p. 7Google Scholar; Marlay, G., A sermon preach'd… on Wednesday the 23rd of October, 1745 (Dublin, 1745), pp. 14–15Google Scholar; Nicholson, , A method of charity-schools, p. 30Google Scholar; Story, J., A sermon preached…on the fifth of November, 1737 (Dublin, 1737), pp. 13-14, 24, 26–7Google Scholar; Young, Edward, A sermon, preached… October 23, 1763 (Dublin, 1763), pp. 15–16Google Scholar.
106 Liechty, J., ‘Irish evangelicalism, Trinity College Dublin and the mission of the Church of Ireland at the end of the eighteenth century’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, St Patrick's College, Maynooth, 1987)Google Scholar; Phillips, , History of the Church of Ireland, III, 259–60Google Scholar.
107 Slack, , Poverty and polity, pp. 148–56Google Scholar; Wrightson, K., English socuty 1580-1680 (London, 1982), pp. 212–13Google Scholar; Wrightson, K. and Levine, D., Poverty and piety in an English village: Terling 1535-1700 (London, 1979)Google Scholar. For wider perspectives: Briggs, R., Communities of belief (Oxford, 1989)Google Scholar; Hsia, R. P., Social discipline in the reformation: central Europe 1550-1750 (London, 1989)Google Scholar.
108 Ingram, M. J., ‘Religion, communities and rural discipline in late sixteenth and early seventeenth century England’, in Greyerz, K. von, ed., Religion and society in early modern Europe (London, 1984), pp. 177–93Google Scholar.
109 Dickson, D., ‘An economic history of the Cork region in the eighteenth century’ (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Trinity College Dublin, 1977), pp. 21-31, 419-20, 641–3Google Scholar; Gillespie, , Colonial Ulster, pp. 171–94Google Scholar; MacCarthy-Morrogh, , The Munster plantation, pp. 253–9Google Scholar; Robinson, P., The plantation of Ulster (Dublin, 1984), chs. 7 & 9Google Scholar.
110 Gillespie, , ‘The presbyterian revolution in Ulster’, pp. 159–70Google Scholar; Latimer, , ‘The old session book of Templepatrick’, V, 131–4Google Scholar; XI, 164-74, 259-72; Records of the general synod of Ulster, 1, passim.
111 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 1/82; T.C.D., MSS 750/4/2, p. 47; 1995-2008/204, 254, 260, 268, 272, 273, 312, 495, 986; Lambeth Palace, 929/41; 942/96; S.P.C.K., A.L.B., 9, no. 5964; Pollard, The necessity and advantage of family prayer, sig. [a2]-[a2]v; Travers, John, A sermon preach'd… on Monday the fifth of November, 1711 (Dublin, 1711), pp. 19–20Google Scholar; Wetenhall, , Pastoral admonitions, pp. viii–xGoogle Scholar
112 T.C.D., MSS 1995-2008/1083.
113 Cullen, L. M., Anglo-Irish trade 1650-1800 (Manchester, 1968), pp. 39–44Google Scholar; Cullen, ‘Incomes, social classes and economic growth in Ireland and Scotland, 1600-1900’, in Devine, and Dickson, , eds., Ireland and Scotland 1600-1850, pp. 248–52Google Scholar; Dickson, D., ‘The place of Dublin in the 18th-century Irish economy’, pp. 178–81Google Scholar.
114 Camb. Univ. Lib., Add. MSS 4/63; P.R.O., SP 63/363, 373; Bodl., Ballard MSS 36, fo. 24; R.C.B., P. 273/6/1, p. 3; Synge, E., A sincere Christian and convert from the Chunk of Rome, exemplified in the life of Daniel Herly, a poor Irish peasant, new edn (London, 1746), p. 42Google Scholar.
115 In 1717 young men belonging to a Cork prcsbyterian meeting-house formed a religious society. How long it survived is unclear, Cork Archives Institute, U.87/1.