Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T04:44:09.009Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

OLIVER CROMWELL AND THE ‘CROMWELLIAN’ SETTLEMENT OF IRELAND*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 November 2010

JOHN CUNNINGHAM
JOHN CUNNINGHAM*
Affiliation:
National University of Ireland, Galway
*
The Moore Institute for Research in the Humanities and Social Studies, National University of Ireland, Galway, University Road, Galway, Irelandjfacunningham@gmail.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Oliver Cromwell remains a deeply controversial figure in Ireland. In the past decade, his role in the conquest has received sustained attention. However, in recent scholarship on the settlement of Ireland in the 1650s, he has enjoyed a peculiarly low profile. This trend has served to compound the interpretative problems relating to Cromwell and Ireland which stem in part from the traditional denominational divide in Irish historiography. This article offers a reappraisal of Cromwell's role in designing and implementing the far-reaching ‘Cromwellian’ land settlement. It examines the evidence relating to his dealings with Irish people, both Protestant and Catholic, and his attitude towards the enormous difficulties which they faced post-conquest. While the massacre at Drogheda in 1649 remains a blot on his reputation, in the 1650s Cromwell in fact emerged as an important and effective ally for Irish landowners seeking to defeat the punitive confiscation and transplantation policies approved by the Westminster parliament and favoured by the Dublin government.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 53 , Issue 4 , December 2010 , pp. 919 - 937
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

I would like to acknowledge funding received for this research as an Irish Research Council for the Humanities and Social Sciences Postgraduate Scholar and the support provided by the Moore Institute for Research in the Humanities and Social Studies. I am also grateful to Professor Nicholas Canny for his comments on an earlier draft of the article.

References

1 P. W. Joyce, A concise history of Ireland (New York, NY, 1903), p. 310.

2 Denis Murphy, Cromwell in Ireland (Dublin, 1883).

3 James Scott Wheeler, Cromwell in Ireland (New York, NY, and Dublin, 1999); Micheál Ó Siochrú, God's executioner: Oliver Cromwell and the conquest of Ireland (London, 2008).

4 John Morrill, ‘The Drogheda massacre in Cromwellian context’, in David Edwards, Padraig Lenihan, and Clodagh Tait, eds., Age of atrocity: violence and political conflict in early modern Ireland (Dublin, 2007), p. 265.

5 John P. Prendergast, The Cromwellian settlement of Ireland (2nd edn, London, 1870), p. xvi.

6 T. C. Barnard, Cromwellian Ireland (Oxford, 1975).

7 Barnard, T. C., ‘Planters and policies in Cromwellian Ireland’, Past and Present, 61, (1973), pp. 31–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 David Stevenson, ‘Cromwell, Scotland and Ireland’, in John Morrill, ed., Oliver Cromwell and the English revolution (London, 1990), pp. 149–80; Barry Coward, The Cromwellian Protectorate (Manchester, 2002), pp. 139–58.

9 Martyn Bennett, Oliver Cromwell (London, 2006), p. 221; Peter Gaunt, Cromwell (Oxford, 1996), p. 153.

10 Morrill, ‘The Drogheda massacre’, p. 265. My italics.

11 Patrick Little, ‘Cromwell and Ireland before 1649’, in idem, ed., Oliver Cromwell: new perspectives (London, 2009), pp. 116–41.

12 Ibid., pp. 118–19.

13 Gardiner, Samuel, ‘The transplantation to Connaught’, English Historical Review, 14, (1899), pp. 700–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at p. 707; John Morrill, Oliver Cromwell (Oxford, 2007), p. 70.

14 Gardiner, ‘The transplantation’, p. 708.

15 Patrick Corish, ‘The Cromwellian regime, 1650–1660’, in T. W. Moody, F. X. Martin, and F. J. Bryne, eds., A new history of Ireland, iii: Early modern Ireland, 1534–1691 (Oxford, 1976), p. 364; Ó Siochrú, God's executioner, p. 235; Herlihy, Kevin, ‘The Cromwellian government and the transplantation to Connacht’, Cathair na Mart, 13, (1993), pp. 72–7Google Scholar.

16 Gardiner, ‘The transplantation’, p. 708.

17 This evidence is discussed in John Cunningham, ‘Transplantation to Connacht, 1641–1680: theory and practice’ (Ph.D. thesis, NUI, Galway, 2009), pp. 70–82.

18 Prendergast, Cromwellian settlement, p. xxviii.

19 Cunningham, ‘Transplantation to Connacht, 1641–1680’, pp. 32–46.

20 Lord deputy and council to the lord protector, Dublin, 14 Nov. 1654, in Robert Dunlop, ed., Ireland under the commonwealth (2 vols., Manchester, 1913), ii, p. 458.

21 Commissioners of parliament to the lord protector, Dublin, 18 Apr. 1654, in ibid., pp. 419–21.

22 C. H. Firth and R. S. Rait, eds., Acts and ordinances of the English interregnum (3 vols., London, 1911), ii, pp. 598–603.

23 Ian Gentles, The new model army in England, Scotland and Ireland, 1645–1653 (Oxford, 1992), pp. 421–2.

24 Donagan, Barbara, ‘The web of honour: soldiers, Christians, and gentlemen in the English civil war’, Historical Journal, 44, (2001), pp. 365–89CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.

25 Henry Ireton to Thomas Preston, Waterford, 30 July 1650, in Edmund Borlase, The history of the Irish rebellion (Dublin, 1743), appendix, p. 42.

26 Gentles, The new model army, pp. 421–2.

27 Commissioners for settling Ulster to the commissioners of parliament, Londonderry, 24 Apr. 1653, in Dunlop, ed., Ireland under the commonwealth, ii, pp. 338–9.

28 Cunningham, ‘Transplantation to Connacht’, pp. 119–30.

29 Cromwell's articles for the Protestant party in Ireland, 26 Apr. 1650, in J. T. Gilbert, ed., A contemporary history of Ireland (3 vols., Dublin, 1879–80), ii, pp. 393–6.

30 Borlase, History of the Irish rebellion, appendix, p. 22.

31 Firth and Rait, eds., Acts and ordinances, ii, pp. 598–603.

32 Copy of judgement by the commissioners appointed for relief upon articles on the case of the Viscount Montgomery of Ards, Westminster, 25 Mar. 1653, The National Archives (TNA), State Papers (SP) 63/286/65.

33 Copy of further judgement by the commissioners for relief upon articles of war on the case of Viscount Ardes, Westminster, 5 Aug. 1653, TNA, SP 63/286/68.

34 News from London, 5 Aug. 1653, in O. Ogle et al., eds., Clarendon state papers (5 vols., Oxford, 1869–1970), ii, p. 240.

35 Oliver Cromwell to Fleetwood, 12 Dec. 1653, in John Prendergast and Charles Russell, eds., The Carte manuscripts in the Bodleian Library, Oxford (London, 1871), p. 137.

36 Copy of further judgement by the commissioners for relief upon articles of war on the case of Viscount Ardes, Westminster, 5 Aug. 1653, TNA, SP 63/286/68; ruling of the committee for articles in the case of Lord Clandeboye [Clanbrassil], Westminster, 22 Aug. 1653, Bodleian Library (Bodl.), Carte MS 74, fo. 119.

37 The Instrument of Government, 16 Dec. 1653, in Samuel Gardiner, ed., Constitutional documents of the puritan revolution (3rd edn, Oxford, 1906), pp. 405–18.

38 Reply to the English officers in Cork and Youghal, 14 Nov. 1649, in S. C. Lomas, ed., The letters and speeches of Oliver Cromwell (3 vols., London, 1904), iii, pp. 416–17.

39 John Percivale to Sir Paul Davys, London, 27 June 1654, in Historical Manuscripts Commission (HMC), Report on the manuscripts of the earl of Egmont (2 vols., London, 1905–9), i, pp. 544–5; Firth and Rait, eds., Acts and ordinances, ii, pp. 933–7.

40 Firth and Rait, eds., Acts and ordinances, ii, pp. 1015–16.

41 Declaration of the lord lieutenant of Ireland for the undeceiving of deluded and seduced people, 1650, in Lomas, ed., Letters and speeches, ii, pp. 5–23.

42 The explanations upon the articles for the surrender of the Leinster army, Kilkenny, 12 May 1652, in Dunlop, ed., Ireland under the commonwealth, i, p. 202.

43 Petition of Sir Richard Barnewall, Sir John Bellew, Patrick Netterville, and Laurence Dowdall, Mar. 1655, National Library of Ireland (NLI), Bellew MS 31,966.

44 Further instructions unto Charles Fleetwood esq., lieutenant general of the horse, Miles Corbet esq., and John Jones esq. (London, 1653).

45 Reasons humbly offered by the petitioners, submittees upon Kilkenny articles, against their transplantation, Mar. 1655, NLI, Bellew MS 31,966; commissioners of parliament to the lord protector, Dublin, 18 Apr. 1654, in Dunlop, ed., Ireland under the commonwealth, ii, p. 421.

46 Oliver Cromwell to the commissioners of parliament, Whitehall, 29 Mar. 1654, in Dunlop, ed., Ireland under the commonwealth, ii. p. 414.

47 Commissioners of parliament to the lord protector, Dublin, 18 Apr. 1654, in ibid., pp. 419–21; instructions to Captain Richard Kingdon and William Rowe, Dublin, 18 May 1654, Bodl., Carte MS 63, fos. 632–6.

48 Extract of a petition from persons, evidently Old English proprietors of rank, in McNeill, Charles, ‘Report on the Rawlinson collection of manuscripts’, Analecta Hibernica, 1, (1930), pp. 12–178Google Scholar, at p. 20.

49 Charles Fleetwood to John Thurloe, Dublin, 2 June 1654, in Thomas Birch, ed., A collection of the state papers of John Thurloe (7 vols., London, 1742), ii, p. 343.

50 Ibid.

51 Peter Talbot to the bishop of Clonmacnoise, Antwerp, 3 July 1654, in Patrick Moran, Historical sketch of the persecutions suffered by the Catholics of Ireland under the rule of Cromwell and the puritans (2nd edn, Dublin, 1884), pp. 297–8.

52 John Percivale to Sir Paul Davys, London, 13 June 1654, HMC, Egmont MSS, i, pp. 542–3.

53 True account of the late bloody and inhumane conspiracy against his highness the lord protector and this commonwealth (London, 1654), pp. 35, 64–5, 79, 86.

54 Order of the council of state for the release of Nicholas Netterville, taken in the late general search, 25 July 1654, in Calendar of State Papers (CSP) Domestic: Interregnum, 1654, p. 263.

55 Report on the case of Oliver Fitzwilliam of Merrion, 6 Apr. 1654, Bodl., Firth MS C 5, fos. 299–312.

56 Oliver Cromwell to the commissioners of parliament, Whitehall, 16 Feb. 1654, ibid., fos. 298–9.

57 The state of the case touching the manor of Merrion, ibid., fos. 252–8; report on the case of Oliver Fitzwilliam of Merrion, 6 Apr. 1654, ibid., fos. 299–312.

58 Council day's proceedings, 14 Aug. 1654, in CSP Domestic: Interregnum, 1654, p. 301.

59 C. H. Firth, ed., Memoirs of Edmund Ludlow (2 vols., Oxford, 1894), i, p. 426.

60 Michéal Ó Siochrú, Confederate Ireland, 1642–1649: a constitutional and political analysis (Dublin, 1998), p. 257.

61 William Shaw Mason, A statistical account, or parochial survey of Ireland (4 vols., Dublin, 1814–19), iii, p. 586.

62 Ibid.; Richard Bellings to Ormond, 18 Feb. 1651, in J. T. Gilbert, ed., History of the confederation and war in Ireland, 1641–1649 (7 vols., Dublin, 1882–91), vii, pp. 362–7.

63 Ordinance of the lord protector for John Grace, 30 Aug. 1654, in Shaw Mason, A statistical account, iii, pp. 585–6.

64 Henry Lawrence to the Irish council, Whitehall, 21 Dec. 1655, in ibid., pp. 587; ibid., p. 588; Oliver Cromwell to Charles Fleetwood, Whitehall, 9 Aug. 1655, in Sheffield Grace, Memoirs of the family of Grace (London, 1827), p. 39.

65 Instructions to the lord deputy and council, 17 Aug. 1654, in Dunlop, ed., Ireland under the commonwealth, ii, p. 442.

66 Order concerning the Kilkenny articles, 30 Nov. 1654, in ibid., pp. 462–3.

67 Speech of Oliver Cromwell, 3 Sept. 1654, in Lomas, ed., Letters and speeches, ii, p. 359.

68 Letter from Dublin, 6 Feb. 1655, in Mercurius Politicus, 15 Feb.–22 Feb. 1655 (London, 1655), pp. 5,136–7.

69 The great case of transplantation in Ireland discussed (London, 1655).

70 Charles Fleetwood to John Thurloe, Dublin, 7 Feb. 1655, Thurloe state papers, iii, p. 139.

71 Ibid.

72 Letter from Dublin, 6 Feb. 1655, in Mercurius Politicus, 15 Feb.–22 Feb. 1655, pp. 5,136–7; Charles Fleetwood to John Thurloe, Dublin, 7 Feb. 1655, Thurloe state papers, iii, p. 139.

73 Charles Fleetwood to John Thurloe, 28 Feb. 1655, in Thurloe state papers, iii, p. 183.

74 Ibid.

75 Charles Fleetwood to John Thurloe, 5 Mar. 1655, in ibid., p. 196.

76 Order of the lord deputy and council concerning the Leinster officers, Dublin, 3 Apr. 1655, NLI, Bellew of Mountbellew papers, MS 31,966.

77 Order of the lord protector on the humble petition of the inhabitants of the Towne of Fethard, Whitehall, 7 Aug. 1655, NLI, D 7,404.

78 Order on the petition of Nicholas Barnewall, 5 Apr. 1655, King's Inns Library (KIL), Prendergast MS 1, p. 260; order on the case of Lady Frances Butler, 20 July 1658, KIL, Prendergast MS 2, pp. 682–4; order on the case of John Prendergast and Widow Brookes, 2 May 1654, ibid.; letter of the lord protector on behalf of Viscount Ikerrin, 27 Feb. 1656, ibid., p. 479; letter of the lord protector on behalf of Thomas Walsh, 15 July 1656, ibid., pp. 481–2; letter of the lord protector on behalf of Edmund Plunkett, 21 Oct. 1656, ibid., p. 482; letter of the lord protector on behalf of Mr. Prendergast, 4 July 1657, ibid., p. 491.

79 Prendergast, Cromwellian settlement, pp. 116–17; W. F. T. Butler, Confiscation in Irish history (Dublin, 1917), pp. 138–9; Pádraig Lenihan, Consolidating conquest: Ireland, 1603–1727 (Harlow, 2008), p. 140.

80 Cunningham, ‘The transplantation to Connacht, 1641–1680’, pp. 224–5.

81 Further instructions unto Charles Fleetwood esq., lieutenant general of the horse, Miles Corbet esq., and John Jones esq., pp. 25–6.

82 Letter of the lord protector on behalf of Lord Courcy, Whitehall, 26 Apr. 1655, in Lomas, ed., Letters and speeches, iii, p. 465.

83 Ibid.

84 Ibid.

85 Patrick Adair, A true narrative of the rise and progress of the presbyterian church in Ireland (Belfast, 1866), pp. 201–2.

86 James Seaton Reid, The history of the presbyterian church in Ireland (3 vols., London, 1834–51), ii, p. 275; Murphy, Cromwell in Ireland, passim; Moran, Historical sketch of the persecutions, passim.

87 Dunlop, ed., Ireland under the commonwealth, i, p. cxxxvi.

88 Bottigheimer, Karl, ‘The restoration land settlement: a structural view’, Irish Historical Studies, 18, (1972), pp. 1–21CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at p. 5; Barnard, ‘Planters and policies’, pp. 31–69.

89 Barnard, ‘Planters and policies’, p. 54; David Stevenson, Scots covenanters and Irish confederates (Belfast, 1981), p. 287.

90 ‘The Roman Catholicks of Ireland their answers relating to proposals offered in order to the settlement of Ireland, by the Commissioners from the Convention of Ireland in 1660’, Gilbert Library, Dublin, Gilbert MS 219, pp. 256–79.

91 Robert Simington, The transplantation to Connaught, 1654–1658 (Dublin, 1970), p. xxiv; Sarah Barber, ‘Settlement, transplantation and expulsion: a comparative study of the placement of peoples’, in Ciarán Brady and Jane Ohlmeyer, eds., British interventions in early modern Ireland (Cambridge, 2005), pp. 280–98; extracts from Dungarvan Observer, 1915, National Archives of Ireland, CO451.

92 Barry Coward, Oliver Cromwell (Harlow, 1991), p. 73; Ivan Roots, ‘Union and disunion in the British Isles, in idem, ed., Into another mould: aspects of the interregnum (Exeter, 1998), p. 16; Christopher Hill, Collected essays (3 vols., Brighton, 1985), iii, p. 87; John Gillingham, Cromwell: portrait of a soldier (London, 1976), p. 113; Simon Robins, God's general: Cromwell the soldier (Stroud, 2003), p. 139.