Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-7cvxr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T04:40:35.340Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Scottish Franchise: Lobbying during the Cromwellian Protectorate

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Ellen D. Goldwater
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Scholars whose speciality is Scottish church history have long been aware that in 1657 members of two factions of the Scottish Presbyterian church came to London to debate before the Lord Protector the method of selecting ministers for Scottish parishes, but these historians have overlooked some of the Scots' other activities. A close look at parliamentary happenings reveals that these men, Resolutioners and Remonstrants, were also deeply involved in secular politics. Their disagreements were not confined to church matters, for during their stay these groups lobbied vigorously both in parliament and in the council of state, taking opposing positions as to what should be the qualifications for voting in Scotland. In this country, most Scots had been disenfranchised since the conclusion of the Civil War and their defeat at the hands of Cromwell's soldiers. The problem to be resolved was which and how many past adherents of the Stuart cause in Scotland should now be allowed to vote and hold office.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 21 , Issue 1 , March 1978 , pp. 27 - 42
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1978

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Gardiner, Samuel R., Constitutional documents of the puritan revolution (Oxford, 1889), pp. 449–50. 456–7. 459–60.Google Scholar

2 Diary of Sir Archibald Johnston of Warriston, ed. by Paul, G. M., Fleming, D. H., Ogilvie, J. D. (Edinburgh, 1911, 1919, 1940), iii, 89.Google Scholar

3 The letters and journals of Robert Baillie, ed. by Laing, David (3 vols.: Edinburgh, 1842), iii, 354.Google Scholar

4 Warriston, , Diary, iii, 354.Google Scholar

5 Gardiner, Samuel R., History of the commonwealth and protectorate, new ed. (4 vols.: London, 1903), ii, 140, 282Google Scholar; III, 102–4. Donaldson, Gordon, James V to James VII (New York, 1966), p. 347.Google Scholar

6 Gardiner, , Constitutional documents, p. 410.Google Scholar

7 Pinckney, Paul J., ‘The Scottish representation in the Cromwellian parliament of 1656’, Scottish Historical Review, xlvi (10, 1967), passim.Google Scholar

8 Gardiner, , Commonwealth and protectorate, i, 340Google Scholar. Donaldson, , James V to James VII, p. 342.Google Scholar

9 Scotland, Laws, Statutes, The acts of the parliaments of Scotland and the government during the commonwealth, vi, part 2 (printed by authority of the Lords Commissioners of Her Majesty's treasury, 1872), 831.Google Scholar

10 Baillie, , Journals, iii, 282.Google Scholar

11 A collection of the state papers of John Thurloe, Esq., secretary, first to the council of state, afterwards to the two protectors, Oliver and Richard Cromwell, ed. by Birch, Thomas (7 vols.: London, 1742), v, 323.Google Scholar

12 Baillie, , Journals, iii, 318.Google Scholar

13 Warriston, , Diary. Stephen, William (ed.), Register of the consultations of the ministers of Edinburgh and some other brethren of the ministry (2 vols.: Edinburgh, 1930).Google Scholar

14 Gardiner, , Commonwealth and protectorate, i, 14, 352.Google Scholar

15 Gardiner, , Constitutional documents, p. 410.Google Scholar

16 Great Britain, Parliament, Journals of the house of commons (London, 1813), vii, 499–501Google Scholar. Gardiner, , Constitutional documents, p. 450.Google Scholar

17 British Museum. Lansdowne MSS, 821, fo. 350, Bridges to Henry Cromwell, 3 Oct. 1657 as quoted by Firth, Charles H., ‘Cromwell and the crown’, English Historical Review, xviii (1903).Google Scholar

18 Warriston, , Diary, iii, 72–3.Google Scholar

19 For traditional view of Scottish delegation: Gardiner, , Commonwealth and protectorate, iii, 173Google Scholar; Trevor-Roper, H. R., ‘Oliver Cromwell and his parliaments’ in Essays presented to Sir Lewis Namier, ed. by Pares, Richard (London, 1956), p. 31.Google Scholar

20 Burnet, Gilbert, Bishop Burnet's history of his own time (4 vols.: London, 1840), 3rd edn, 1, 177.Google Scholar

21 Baillie, , Journals, iii, 361, 373.Google Scholar

22 Pinckney, , ‘Scottish Representation’, p. 108Google Scholar. Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 90Google Scholar. Warriston, , Diary, iii, 93.Google Scholar

23 Warriston, , Diary, iii, 81, 88.Google Scholar

24 Commons Journal, vii, 557.Google Scholar

25 The Clarke papers, selections from papers of William Clarke, ed. by Firth, C. H. (4 vols.: London, 1891–1901), iii, 96.Google Scholar

26 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 30.Google Scholar

27 Baillie, , Journals, iii, 361.Google Scholar

28 Firth, Charles H. and Davies, Godfrey, Regimental history of Cromwell's army (2 vols.: Oxford, 1940), i, 83.Google Scholar

29 The diary of Thomas Burton, ed. by Rutt, John Towill (4 vols.: London, 1828), ii, 250.Google Scholar

30 Baillie, , Journals, iii, 361Google Scholar; Warriston, , Diary, iii, 73.Google Scholar

31 DNB: Archibald Campbell, eighth earl of Argyll.

32 Gardiner, , Constitutional documents, pp. 450, 459.Google Scholar

33 Warriston, , Diary, iii, 83.Google Scholar

34 Baillie, , Journals, iii, 354.Google Scholar

35 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 39Google Scholar. Warriston, , Diary, iii, 82.Google Scholar

36 Warriston, , Diary, iii, 81Google Scholar. Burton, , Diary, ii, 248–51.Google Scholar

37 Baillie, , Journals, iii, 353.Google Scholar

38 Commons journals, vii, 557Google Scholar. Burton, , Diary, ii, 253Google Scholar. Warriston, , Diary, iii, 81.Google Scholar

39 Baillie, , Journals, iii, 238.Google Scholar

40 Donaldson, Gordon and Morpeth, Robert S., Who's who in Scottish history (Oxford, 1973): Robert Baillie.Google Scholar

41 Eyre-Todd, George, History of Glasgow (3 vols.: Glasgow, 1931), ii, 250–300, passim.Google Scholar

42 Scottish Burgh Records Society, Extracts from the records of the burgh of Glasgow, 1630–62 (Glasgow, 1882), pp. 247, 319, 347.Google Scholar

43 Baillie, , journals, iii, 322.Google Scholar

44 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 42–3.Google Scholar

45 Warriston, , Diary, iii, liiiGoogle Scholar. Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 42.Google Scholar

46 Warriston, , Diary, iii, 83.Google Scholar

47 Warriston, , Diary, iii, 86.Google Scholar

48 Commons journal, Vii, 575Google Scholar. Burton, , Diary, ii, 306–8Google Scholar. Warriston, , Diary, iii, 88.Google Scholar

49 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 44.Google Scholar

50 Warriston, , Diary, iii, 81.Google Scholar

51 Burton, , Diary, ii, 253.Google Scholar

52 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 43.Google Scholar

53 Warriston, , Diary, iii, 83–4.Google Scholar

54 Great Britain, Public Records Office, Calendar of state papers domestic, 1657–55, 44Google Scholar. Baillie, , Journals, p. 361.Google Scholar

55 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 114–15, 121.Google Scholar

56 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 126–7.Google Scholar

57 For Godfrey in the 1656–7 session: Goldwater, Ellen D., ‘Two Cromwellian parliaments: politics, patronage and procedure’ (unpubl. Ph.D. dissertation: City University of New York, 1973), 148–53Google Scholar. Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 49, 92, 93, 97, 101.Google Scholar

58 Firth, Charles H., The last years of the protectorate (2 vols.: New York, 1964), ii, 2–4Google Scholar. Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 47.Google Scholar

59 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, xivGoogle Scholar. Baillie, , Journals, iii, 361.Google Scholar

60 Scotland, , Acts, vi, 907, 913.Google Scholar

61 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 129.Google Scholar

62 Glasgow Records, pp. 388–9.

63 Ibid. p. 393.

64 Ibid. p. 399.

65 Ibid. pp. 406–7.

66 Donaldson, and Morpeth, , Who's who in Scottish History: James Sharp.Google Scholar

67 Underdown, David, ‘The Independents again’, Journal of British Studies, xiii (11 1, 1968), 83–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Baillie, , Journals, iii, 325, 332, 346.Google Scholar

68 Stephen, , Consultations, ii, 97.Google Scholar

69 Hexter, J. H., Reappraisals in history (New York, 1961), pp. 163–4Google Scholar. Underdown, David, Pride's Purge (Oxford, 1971), p. 64.Google Scholar

70 Henderson, B. L. K., ‘The commonwealth charters’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 3rd series, vi (1912), passim.Google Scholar