Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-lnqnp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T12:39:55.440Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Northern Foundations and the Shaping of Southern Black Rural Education, 1902–1935

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

James D. Anderson
James D. Anderson*
Affiliation:
University of Illinois (Urbana)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Northern Philanthropists and Their Interest in Black Rural Education

During the first two decades of the twentieth century an educational awakening stirred the American South. Stimulated by Northern philanthropists and their Southern agents, the region experienced a remarkable expansion of its public educational system. In many states laws were changed to strengthen the constitutional basis of public education. The value of schoolhouses increased, illiteracy rapidly decreased, local taxes multiplied, school terms were extended, and teachers' salaries increased considerably. Historians generally view this organized school campaign as the official launching of the Southern education movement. To be sure, white missionaries and black leaders had campaigned for universal education in the South since the Reconstruction era, but in the dawn of the twentieth century white Southerners made their first vigorous, large-scale efforts to improve the region's schools. The success of the Southern education movement was a result of the combined efforts of industrial philanthropists and Southern white educators. These two groups formed a powerful new force in the struggle to determine the purpose of Southern education for both whites and blacks. The alliance between Northern businessmen-philanthropists and Southern white school officials was ratified by the creation of two major educational organizations, the Southern Education Board in 1901 and the General Education Board in 1902. The policies and programs formed by these boards profoundly shaped Southern black public education during the first half of the twentieth century.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 18 , Issue 4 , Winter 1978 , pp. 371 - 396
Copyright
Copyright © 1978 by New York University 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

1 Harlan, Louis, Separate and Unequal: Public School Campaigns and Racism in the Southern Seaboard States 1901–1915 (Chapel Hill, North Carolina, 1958, [1968 Atheneum edition]), p. 79; Dabney, Charles W., Universal Education in the South, Vol. II (Chapel Hill, North Carolina, 1936); Knight, Edgar W., Public Education in the South (New York, 1922), p. 433; Vann Woodward, C., Origins of the New South, 1877–1913 (Baton Rouge, 1951, [1974 edition]), pp. 395–400.Google Scholar

2 Woodward, , Origins of the New South, p. 401; Ogden, Robert C., Samuel C. Armstrong: A Sketch (New York, 1894); Mitchell, Samuel C., “Robert Curtis Ogden: A Leader in the Educational Renaissance of the South,” unpublished Biography, Ogden Papers; Enck, Henry S., “The Burden Borne: Northern White Philanthropy and Southern Black Industrial 'Education, 1900–1915” (Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Cincinnati, 1971), pp. 47–60; For a detailed analysis of the Hampton program of industrial education see Anderson, James D., “The Hampton Model of Normal School Industrial Education, 1868–1900,” forthcoming in Franklin, Vincent P. and Anderson, James D. (editors), New Perspectives on Black Educational History (Boston: Hall, G. K., 1978).Google Scholar

3 Enck, , “The Burden Borne,” pp. 41, 51, 60; Harlan, , Separate and Unequal, pp. 75–76, 79–82, 85–87; Ogden, Robert C. to Gilman, Arthur Mrs. (May 12, 1903), Box 6, Ogden Papers, Library of Congress; Harlan, Louis, Booker T. Washington: The Makings of a Black Leader, 1856–1901 (New York [1975 edition] 1972), pp. 62, 284.Google Scholar

4 Ware, Louise, George Foster Peabody: Banker, Philanthropist, Publicist (Athens, Georgia, 1951), pp. 162, 170, 215; Enck, , “The Burden Borne,” pp. 72–81.Google Scholar

5 Enck, , “The Burden Borne,” pp. 77–78; Ware, , George Foster Peabody, p. 214; Harlan, , Separate and Unequal, pp. 75–76; Harlan, , Booker T. Washington, p. 238.Google Scholar

6 Brooks, John Graham, An American Citizen: The Life of William Henry Baldwin, Jr. (Boston, 1910), pp. 33–38, 53–54, 80, 191, 204–215; Dabney, , Universal Education in the South, Vol. II, pp. 145–149; Enck, , “The Burden Borne,” pp. 60–71; Harlan, , Separate and Unequal, pp. 76–78; Anderson, James D., “Education for Servitude: The Social Purposes of Schooling in the Black South, 1870–1930” (Ph.D. Dissertation, Urbana, University of Illinois, 1973), see Chapter 5 for an extended discussion of the Baldwin-Washington relationship.Google Scholar

7 Enck, , “The Burden Borne,” p. 60; Woodward, , Origins of the New South, p. 292; Dabney, , Universal Education in the South, Vol. II, p. 149; Anderson, , “Education for Servitude,” pp. 214–216; see Anderson, pp. 190–210 for more specific information on Baldwin's role in raising funds for Tuskegee and industrial education.Google Scholar

8 For the philanthropists' investment in the Southern cotton economy see Enck, , “The Burden Borne,” pp. 152–164; Anderson, James D., “The Southern Improvement Company: Northern Reformers' Investment in Negro Cotton Tenancy 1900–1920,” Journal of Agricultural History, Vol. 52 (January, 1978): pp. 111–131; for an excellent treatment of urban interest in organizing American agriculture, see Danbom, David Byers, “The Industrialization of Agriculture, 1900–1930” (Ph.D. Dissertation, Stanford University, 1974), pp. 77, 84.Google Scholar

9 Ogden, Robert C. to Gilman, Arthur Mrs. (May 12, 1903), Box 6, Ogden, , “Speech on Negro Education” (1900), Box 22, Ogden Papers; Anderson, , “Education for Servitude,” p. 217; Anderson, , “The Southern Improvement Company”; Ogden, to McKinney, H. W. (April 30, 1898), Box 6, Ogden Papers.Google Scholar

10 Peabody, George F. to Goetchius, Henry R. (January 30, 1911), Box 57; Peabody, to Jordan, G. G. (December 18, 1907), Box 6; Peabody, to Smith, Colonel James (March 20, 1906), Box 57, Peabody, George F. Papers, Library of Congress; Anderson, “Education for Servitude,” p. 217.Google Scholar

11 Peabody, George F. to Wilson, President Woodrow (May 20, 1918), Box 75, Peabody Papers.Google Scholar

12 Baldwin, William H., “Present Problem of Negro Education,” Proceedings of the Second Capon Springs Conference for Education in the South (Capon Springs, West Virginia, 1899), pp. 104–106; Baldwin, to Bassett, John Spencer (May 27, 1904), Washington, Booker T. Papers, Library of Congress.Google Scholar

13 Baldwin, William H. Jr., to Thompson, N. F. (April 15, 1900), Box 792, Washington Papers; Baldwin, , “Present Problem of Negro Education,” pp. 105–107; Anderson, , “Education for Servitude,” pp. 206–210; Gutman, Herbert, “The Negro and the United Mine Workers of America,” in Jacobson, Julius, The Negro and the American Labor Movement (New York, 1968), p. 411; Aptheker, Herbert (ed.), “Some Unpublished Writings of DuBois, W. E. B.,” Freedomways, Vol. 5 (Winter, 1965): 128.Google Scholar

14 See Carnegie's, Andrew address in “The Work and Influence of Hampton,” Proceedings of a Meeting held in New York City (February 12, 1904) by the Armstrong Association, p. 7; Carnegie, Andrew, “The Education of the Negro: A National Interest,” Address at the Twenty-fifth Anniversary of the Founding of Tuskegee Institute (April 5, 1906), Box 253, Carnegie, Andrew Papers, Library of Congress; Dillard, James H. as quoted in Enck, “The Burden Borne,” p. 156; Walter, H. Page as quoted in Rusnak, Robert Jay, “Walter Hines Page and The World's Work: 1900–1913“ (Ph.D. Dissertation, University of California, Santa Barbara, 1973), p. 260; Wilcox, William G., “The Builder of Tuskegee,” The Trustees of the Slater Fund, John F., Occasional Papers No. 17 (Lynchburg, Virginia, 1916), p. 18.Google Scholar

15 Baldwin, , “The Present Problem of Negro Education,” 104–106; this address was also given at the 1899 American Social Science Association in Saratoga, New York and printed in the Journal of Social Science, No. 37 (December, 1899): 52–58.Google Scholar

16 Gates, Frederick T. to Washington, Booker T. (December 15, 1899), Washington Papers; Gates to Washington (February 9, 1901), Washington Papers; Fosdick, Raymond B., Adventure in Giving: The Story of the General Education Board (New York, 1962), pp. 4–7; Gates, Frederick T., “Autobiography of Frederick T. Gates,” p. 459, unpublished in the General Education Board Papers in the Rockefeller Foundation Archives (hereafter listed as the GEB Papers).Google Scholar

17 Baldwin, William H. Jr., to Washington, Booker T. (November 6, 1901), Washington Papers; Fosdick, , Adventure in Giving, pp. 9, 13, 338; The Buse Notes, pp. 30–34 (an incomplete manuscript on the history of the GEB), Box 338, GEB Papers; Nielson, Waldemar A., The Big Foundations (New York, 1972), pp. 333–336.Google Scholar

18 Baldwin, William H. Jr., to Washington, Booker T. (June 23, 1903), Washington Papers; Fosdick, , Adventure in Giving, pp. 12–13, 327; Harlan, , Separate and Unequal, pp. 86–87; Bond, Horace Mann, Negro Education in Alabama: A Study in Cotton and Steel (Kingsport, Tennessee 1939 [1969 Atheneum edition]), p. 272; Jones, Thomas Jesse, Negro Education: A Study of Private and Higher Schools for Colored People in the United States (Washington, D. C, 1917), pp. 81–95.Google Scholar

19 The Minutes of the General Education Board from January 1902 to November 1960, pp. 142–143, GEB Papers; Buttrick, Wallace, Address to Harvard University Graduate School of Education (April 29, 1922), Box 303, GEB Papers; Buttrick's reports on conferences with Southern school superintendents, Boxes 209 and 304, GEB Papers; For a sampling of the School Inspectors' reports see Cloyd, David E., Heck, William H. and Wiliams', W. T. B. reports in Boxes 200, 209, 260, and 718, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

20 Buttrick, Wallace, Address to Harvard University Graduate School of Education, Box 303, GEB Papers; Buttrick, Wallace to Gates, Frederick T. (October 14, 1904) and Gates, to Buttrick, (October 20, 1904), Box 716, GEB Papers; Green, Jerome D., Buttrick, Wallace and Flexner, Abraham, Confidential Report to the Members of the General Education Board (October 22, 1914), Box 331, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

21 Report of the Special Committee on the Education of the Negro (May 25, 1911), Box 722, GEB Papers; Buttrick, Wallace to Rockefeller, John D. Jr. (February 5, 1914), Box 203, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

22 Report of the Special Committee on the Education of the Negro; Davis, Jackson to Flexner, Abraham (July 29, 1919), Box 36, GEB Papers; Fosdick, , Adventure in Giving, pp. 90–91; Smith, S. L., Builders of Goodwill: The Story of the State Agents of Negro Education in the South 1910 to 1950 (Nashville Tennessee, 1950).Google Scholar

23 Smith, , Builders of Goodwill, pp. 11, 17–18; Report of Special Committee on the Education of the Negro; Swearingin, J. E. to Sage, E. C. (June 6, 1919), Box 131, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

24 Smith, , Builders of Goodwill, p. 9; Bond, , Negro Education in Alabama, p. 272. For information on the educational activities of the State Supervisors there are hundreds of reports in the GEB Papers: Mississippi, Box 98; Virginia Boxes 187 and 188; Arkansas, Box 25; North Carolina, Box 115; South Carolina, Box 131; Tennessee, Box 158; Georgia, Box 67; Alabama, Box 17; Louisiana, Box 88.Google Scholar

25 Annual Report of the General Education Board 1918–1919 (New York: GEB, 1920), p. 54; Favrot, Leo M., “Report of Arkansas State Supervisor of Negro Schools for November 1913” (December 8, 1913), Box 25, GEB Papers; Newbold, N. C., “The Jeanes Supervising Industrial Teachers: Some Things They Helped to do Last School Year” (October 25, 1917), Box 115, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

26 “North Carolina Biennial Report of the State Agent of Negro Rural Schools-1917,” Box 115, GEB Papers; “Annual Report of Arkansas Supervisor of Negro Schools,” Box 25, GEB Papers; General Education Board: Review and Final Report, 1902–1964, (New York, 1964), pp. 20–21.Google Scholar

27 Ibid.; For information on summer school activities see reports for Arkansas, Box 25; Hampton Institute, Box 176; Tuskegee Institute, Box 6; Georgia, , Box 68; Alabama, Box 13; “Summary of Reports from Summer Schools for Negro Teachers—1921,” Box 302; “Summary Reports…. 1930,” Box 302; “Report on Special Teachers and In-Service Training of Rural Teachers in Summer Schools for Negroes — 1935,” Box 302, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

28 Redcay, Edward E., County Training Schools and Public Secondary Education for Negroes in the South (Washington, D.C., 1935), pp. 24–45; Favrot, Leo Mortimer, A Study of County Training Schools for Negroes in the South (Charlottesville, Virginia, 1923), pp. 8–26; Presson, John A., Annual Report of Educational Activities in Negro Schools (Little Rock, Arkansas, 1922), pp. 22–23; Annual Report of the General Education Board (New York, 1918), p. 51.Google Scholar

29 Ibid.Google Scholar

30 Favrot, , County Training Schools For Negroes in the South, pp. 12, 31–32; Presson, , Report of Educational Activities in Negro Schools, pp. 22–23.Google Scholar

31 Redcay, , County Training Schools, p. 38; Sibley, James L. to Flexner, Abraham (January 16, 1915), Box 17, GEB Papers; Faurot, Leo M., “The Industrial Movement in Negro Schools” (June 9, 1913), Box 25, GEB Papers; Godard, George D., “Report of Georgia State Supervisor of Negro Rural Schools for February 1914” (March 2, 1914), Box 67, GEB Papers; Fosdick, , Adventure in Giving, p. 101; Favrot, , County Training Schools for Negroes in the South, p. 9.Google Scholar

32 Smith, S. L., “Report of Tennessee State Supervisor of Negro Rural Schools for September 1914” (October 5, 1914), Box 158, GEB Papers; Favrot, , County Training Schools for Negroes in the South, p. 27; Presson, , Report of Educational Activities in Negro Schools, p. 21; Smith, S. L., “Report of Tennessee State Supervisor of Negro Rural Schools for October 1914” (November 5, 1914), Box 158, GEB Papers; Buttrick, Wallace to Gates, Frederick T. (October 14, 1904), Box 716, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

33 Davis, Jackson, County Training Schools, Reprinted from the Southern Workman (October 1918), p. 8; Favrot, , County Training Schools for Negroes in the South, p. 27.Google Scholar

34 Favrot, Leo M., “The Industrial Movement in Negro Schools” (June 9, 1913), Box 25, GEB Papers; Presson, John A., “Report of Arkansas State Supervisor of Negro Rural Schools for January 1917” (February 5, 1917), Box 25, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

35 Smith, S. L., “Report of Tennessee State Supervisor of Negro Rural Schools for October 1915” (November 5, 1915), Box 158, GEB Papers; Dillard, James H. to Newbold, N. C. (September 25, 1915), Box 286, GEB Papers; Davis, Jackson to Flexner, Abraham (October 2, 1915), Box 286, GEB Papers; See Reports on Georgia County Training Schools for June 1916 and May 1918, Box 68, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

36 Davis, Jackson to Flexner, Abraham (October 2, 1915); Davis, Jackson to Dillard, James H. (September 28, 1915); Davis, Jackson to Flexner, Abraham (October 14, 1915); Godard, George D. to Flexner, Abraham (October 15, 1915); Wright, Arthur D. to Flexner, Abraham (October 16, 1915); Flexner, Abraham to Davis, Jackson, Godard, George D. and Wright, Arthur D. (October 8, 1915); Davis, Jackson to Sage, E. C. (March 11, 1916), all above letters in Box 286, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

37 Slater Fund, John F., Suggested Course for County Training Schools (Lynchburg, Virginia, 1917).Google Scholar

38 Favrot, , County Training Schools for Negroes in the South, pp. 36–38; Redcay, , County Training Schools, 33–37; Favrot, , “The Industrial Movement in Negro Schools”; For detailed information on subjects taught in the Training School see Summary Reports from County Training Schools, Box 294, GEB Papers.Google Scholar

39 Wilkerson, Doxey A., Special Problems of Negro Education, United States Advisory Committee on Education, Staff Study Number 12 (Washington, D.C. 1939), pp. 39–40.Google Scholar

40 Redcay, , County Training Schools, pp. 78–84. 100.Google Scholar

41 Enck, Henry Snyder, “The Buden Borne: Northern White Philanthropy and Southern Black Industrial Education, 1900–1915” (University of Cincinnati, Ph.D. dissertation, 1970), see chapter 4 on “Philanthropic Motivation”; Dillard, James H., Rose, Wickliffe and Fosdick, Raymond to Members of the General Education Board (October 6, 1922), Box 331, GEB Papers, p. 24.Google Scholar