Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-xbtfd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T07:02:05.816Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Why Sanctions Seldom Work: Reflections on Cultural Property Internationalism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 October 2005

David Lowenthal
David Lowenthal
Affiliation:
Department of Geography, University College London. Email: d.lowenthal@ucl.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Heritage piety departs ever farther from reality. High-minded admonitions broaden the gulf between what happens to cultural property and what virtuous stewards feel should happen. Ever more of our patrimony gets looted, destroyed, mutilated, shorn of context, hidden from scrutiny, inadequately stored, poorly conserved, eBayed. Merryman cites three causes: the animus of UNESCO and archaeology against marketing cultural property, the sanguine view that trafficking abuse can be quashed by state fiat and moral suasion, and excessive constraint against heritage export by blanket diktats from source nations (and tribes and ethnic groups). These evils endure because heritage stewards commonly subscribe to four underlying sacrosanct fictions. (1) The heritage of all humanity deserves to be preserved in toto. (2) Cultural heritage matters above all for the information it can yield. (3) Collecting is reprehensible; it must be circumscribed if not outlawed. (4) Nations and tribes are enduring entities with sacred rights to time-honored legacies. I show why these views are mistaken yet remain embedded in heritage philosophy and protocol. In particular, although heritage is piously declared the legacy of all mankind, chauvinist sentiment continues to impede internationalism, partly because it buttresses the credentials of those in charge, who are forced into moral postures that promise unachievable stewardship. National and local self-esteem are holy writ for UNESCO and other cultural property agencies. Equating heritage with identity justifies every group's claim to the bones, the belongings, the riddles, and the refuse of every forebear back into the mists of time. All that stands in the way of everyone's reunion with all their ancestors and ancestral things is its utter impossibility. Heritage professionals once seen as selfless are now targets of suspicion, often thought backward looking, deluded, self-seeking, or hypocritical. Small wonder that militant reformers who seek to suppress illicit cultural property dealings by treaties, court decisions, government fiats, and the moral artillery of shame and guilt are viewed with an increasingly cynical eye.

Type
RESPONSE ARTICLE
Information
International Journal of Cultural Property , Volume 12 , Issue 3 , August 2005 , pp. 393 - 423
Copyright
© 2005 International Cultural Property Society

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abrahams, Roger D., and George Foss. Anglo-American Folksong Style. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1968.
Achebe, Chinua. “The Igbo World and Its Art.” In his Hopes and Impediments: Selected Essays. London: Heimann, 1988.
Anderson, Benedict. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso, 1983.
Appadurai, Arjun. “The Past as a Scarce Resource.” Man 16 (1981): 201–19.Google Scholar
Awekotuku, Ngahuia Te. “More than Skin Deep: Ta Moko Today.” In Barkan and Bush, Claiming the Stones/Naming the Bones, 243–58.
Baers, N. S., and F. Snickars, eds. Rational Decision-Making in the Preservation of Cultural Property. Berlin: Dahlem, 2001.
Barkan, Elazar. “Amending Historical Injustices: The Restitution of Cultural Property—An Overview.” In Barkan and Bush, Claiming the Stones/Naming the Bones, 16–46.
Barkan, Elazar, and Ronald Bush, eds. Claiming the Stones/Naming the Bones: Cultural Property and the Negotiation of National and Ethnic Identity. Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute, 2002.
Barkan, Elazar. “Introduction,” In Barkan and Bush, Claiming the Stones/Naming the Bones, 1–15.
Bator, Paul. The International Trade in Art. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1982.
Bell, Diane. Ngarrindigeri Wurruwarrin: A World That Is, Was, and Will Be. North Melbourne: Spinefex, 1998.
Blom, Philipp. To Have and to Hold: An Intimate History of Collectors and Collecting. London: Allen Lane, 2002.
Borges, Jorge Luis. “The Library of Babel” [1941]. In Jorge Luis Borges, Collected Fictions, 112–18. New York: Penguin, 1998.
Borofsky, Robert. Making History: Pukapukan and Anthropological Constructions of Knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987.
Boyes, Georgina. The Imagined Village: Culture, Ideology and the English Folk Revival. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1993.
Brown, Michael F. Who Owns Native Culture? Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2003.
Brown, Michael F. “Heritage Trouble: Recent Work on the Protection of Intangible Cultural Property.” International Journal of Cultural Property 12 (2005): 40–61.Google Scholar
Browne, Thomas. Hydriotaphia: Urne-Buriall, or, a Brief Discourse of the Sepulchral Urnes Lately Found in Norfolk [1658]. In his Works, edited by Geoffrey Keynes, 1: 129–72. London: Faber & Faber, 1928.
Butts, David J. “‘Nga tukemata: nga taonga o Ngati Kahungunu’ (The Awakening: The Treasures of Ngati Kahungunu).” In Gathercole and Lowenthal, The Politics of the Past, 107–17.
Carlin, John. “Records Everywhere, but How Are They Going to Survive?” The Record 5:1 (Sept. 1998): 1–3.Google Scholar
Chamberlin, Russell. “Culture or Plunder?” History Today 52:5 (May 2002): 38–39.Google Scholar
Cobb, Richard. French and Germans, Germans and French: A Personal Interpretation of France under Two Occupations. Hanover, NH: University Press of New England, 1983.
Creamer, Howard. “Aboriginal Perceptions of the Past.” In Gathercole and Lowenthal, The Politics of the Past, 130–40.
Cultural Rights, and Wrongs. Paris: UNESCO/Institute of Art and Law, 1998.
Davis, Natalie Zemon. “Who Owns History?” Studia Historica 61 (1994): 19–34.Google Scholar
Dennen, Johan van der. “Ethnocentrism and In-Group/Out-Group Differentiation.” In The Sociobiology of Ethnocentrism: Evolutionary Dimension of Xenophobia, Discrimination, Racism and Nationalism, edited by Vernon Reynolds, Vincent Falger, and Ian Vine, 1–47. London: Croom Helm, 1986.
Draaisma, Douwe. Metaphors of Memory: A History of Ideas about the Mind. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.
Edwards, Amelia. A Thousand Miles Up the Nile [1877], reprint of 1888 ed. London: Century, 1982.
Eisenstein, Elizabeth L. The Printing Press as an Agent of Change: Communications and Cultural Transformations in Early-Modern Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979.
Ely, David. Time Out. London: Secker & Warburg, 1968.
Evans-Pritchard, Deirdre. “The Portal Case: Authenticity, Tourism, Traditions, and the Law.” Journal of American Folklore 100 (1987): 287–92.Google Scholar
Fara, Patricia. “Northern Possession: Laying Claim to the Aurora Borealis.” History Workshop Journal 42 (1996): 37–57.Google Scholar
Featherstone, Mike. “Archiving Cultures.” British Journal of Sociology 51 (2000): 161–84.Google Scholar
Freud, Sigmund. “Constructions in Analysis” [1937]. In The Complete Psychological Works, 23: 268–69. London: Hogarth Press and the Institute of Psycho-Analysis, 1964.
Gathercole, Peter, and David Lowenthal, eds. The Politics of the Past. London: Unwin Hyman, 1990.
Geary, Patrick. The Myth of Nations: The Medieval Origins of Europe. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2002.
Gerstenblith, Patty. “Cultural Significance and the Kennewick Skeleton: Some Thoughts on the Resolution of Cultural Heritage Disputes.” In Barkan and Bush, Claiming the Stones/Naming the Bones, 162–97.
Good, Diane L. “Sacred Bundles: History Wrapped Up in Culture.” History News 45:4 (July–August 1990): 13–14, 27.Google Scholar
“‘The Good Collector’: Fabulous Beast or Endangered Species?” Forum. Public Archaeology 1 (2000): 73–81.
Gordon, Christopher. National Cultural Policy in Italy: A Report for the Council of Europe. Strasbourg: Council of Europe, 1995.
Greenfield, Jeanette. The Return of Cultural Treasures. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989.
Griffiths, Tom. Hunters and Collectors: The Antiquarian Imagination in Australia. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press, 1996.
Hallman, Robert. “Museums and Cultural Property: A Retreat from the Internationalist Position.” International Journal of Cultural Property 12(2) (2005): 201–223.Google Scholar
Harris, Neil. “Collective Possessions: J. Pierpont Morgan and the American Imagination.” In his Cultural Excursions, 250–75. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1990.
Harwit, Martin. An Exhibit Denied: Lobbying the History of Enola Gay. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1996.
Hawthorne, Nathaniel. The English Notebooks, edited by Randall Stewart. New York: Modern Language Association of America, 1941.
Howell, Signe. “Whose Knowledge and Whose Power? A New Perspective on Cultural Diffusion.” In Counterworks: Managing the Diversity of Knowledge, edited by Richard Fardon, 164–81. London: Routledge, 1995.
Hughes, Robert. Culture of Complaint: The Fraying of America. New York: Oxford University Press, 1993.
International Cultural Heritage Conventions. US/ICOMOS Scientific Journal II:1. Washington, D.C.: 2000.
Italy, Ministry of Foreign Affairs. An Evaluation of Cultural Policies in Italy. Strasbourg: Council of Europe, 1995.
Jarves, James Jackson, The Art-Idea: Sculpture, Painting and Architecture in America. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1864.
Kasfir, Sidney Littlefield, and Labiyi Babalola Joseph Yai. “Authenticity and Diaspora.” In “Views and Visions,” 190–97.
Kirschenblatt-Gimblett, Barbara. “Intangible Heritage as Metacultural Production.” In “Views and Visions,” 52–65.
Koczka, Charles S. “The Need for Enforcing Regulations on the International Art Trade.” In Messenger, Ethics of Collecting Cultural Property, 185–98.
Küchler, Suzanne. “The Place of Memory.” In The Art of Forgetting, edited by Adrian Forty and Suzanne Küchler, 53–72. Oxford: Berg, 1999.
Leach, Edmund. “Tribal Ethnography: Past, Present, Future.” In History and Ethnography, edited by Elizabeth Tonkin, Maryon McDonald, and Malcolm Chapman, 34–47. Association of Social Anthropologists Monograph 27. London: Routledge, 1989.
Lem, Stanislaw. The Cyberiad: Fables for the Cybernetic Age [1967]. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1985.
Lockwood, Allison. Passionate Pilgrims: American Travelers in Great Britain, 1800–1914. New York: Cornwall Books for Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 1981.
Lowenthal, David. “The Timeless Past: Some Anglo-American Historical Preconceptions.” In Memory and American History, edited by David Thelen, 134–51. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1990.
Lowenthal, David. The Heritage Crusade and the Spoils of History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
Lowenthal, David. White Elephants and Ivory Towers: Embattled Museums? 3rd Annual A. W. Franks Lecture. London: British Museum, 1999.
Lowenthal, David. “The Heritage Crusade and Its Contradictions.” In Giving Preservation a History: Histories of Historic Preservation in the United States, edited by Max Page and Randall Mason, 19–43. New York: Routledge, 2004.
Lowenthal, David. “Archives, Heritage, and History.” In Archives, Documentation, and Institutions of Social Memory, edited by Francis X. Blouin and William G. Rosenberg. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, forthcoming.
Lyons, Claire. “Objects and Identities: Claiming and Reclaiming the Past.” In Barkan and Bush, Claiming the Stones/Naming the Bones, 116–37.
Marcus, George E. “Censorship in the Heart of Difference: Cultural Property, Indigenous Peoples' Movements, and Challenges to Western Liberal Thought.” In Censorship and Silencing: Practices of Cultural Regulation, edited by Robert C. Post, 221–42. Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute, 1998.
Marks, Peter. “The Ethics of Art Dealing.” International Journal of Cultural Property 7 (1998): 116–27.Google Scholar
Matsuda, David. “The Ethics of Archaeology, Subsistence Digging, and Artifact Looting in Latin America.” International Journal of Cultural Property 7 (1998): 87–98.Google Scholar
Melikian, Souren. “A Degree of Destruction Unprecedented ….” Art Newspaper 52 (October 1995): 29.Google Scholar
Menand, Louis. “Johnny Be Good.” New Yorker, 13 January 1997: 4–5.
Merryman, John Henry. “A Licit International Trade in Cultural Objects.” International Journal of Cultural Property 4 (1995): 13–60.Google Scholar
Merryman, John Henry. “Cultural Property Internationalism.” International Journal of Cultural Property 12 (2005): 1–29.Google Scholar
Messenger, Phyllis Mauch. The Ethics of Collecting Cultural Property: Whose Culture? Whose Property? Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1989.
Michaels, Walter Benn. “Race into Culture.” Critical Inquiry 18 (1992): 655–85.Google Scholar
Muensterberger, Werner. Collecting: An Unruly Passion. Psychological Perspectives. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1994.
Mulvaney, John. “A Question of Values: Museums and Cultural Property.” In Who Owns the Past? edited by Isabel McBryde, 86–98. Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1985.
Munz, Peter. Our Knowledge of the Growth of Knowledge. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1985.
Nicholson, Claudia J. “Advisors to Partners: Bridging the Cultural Gap.” History News 50:4 (Autumn 1995): 10–13.Google Scholar
Niedzielski-Eichner, Nora. “Art Historians and Cultural Property Internationalism.” International Journal of Cultural Property 12(2) (2005): 183–200.Google Scholar
Novick, Peter. That Noble Dream: The “Objectivity Question” and the American Historical Profession. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988.
O'Donnell, James J. Avatars of the Word from Papyrus to Cyberspace. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1998.
O'Hanlon, Michael. “Collecting among the Wahgi.” British Museum Society Bulletin 62 (Winter 1989): 11–5.Google Scholar
O'Regan, Stephen. “Maori Control of the Maori Heritage.” In Gathercole and Lowenthal, The Politics of the Past, 95–106.
Ortiz, George. “The Collector and the Regulation of the Art Market.” In La Libre circulation des collections d'objets d'art [Etudes en droit de l'art], 147–58. Zurich: Schulthess Polygraphischer Verlag, 1992.
Ortiz, George. “In Pursuit of the Absolute, Art of the Ancient World from the George Ortiz Collection.” Catalogue, Royal Academy of Arts, London, March 1994.
Paredes, J. Anthony. “Preface.” In Intellectual Property Rights for Indigenous Peoples, edited by Tom Greaves. Oklahoma City: Society for Applied Anthropology, 1994.
Peacock, Alan. A Future for the Past. London: British Academy, 1994.
Pearce, Susan, ed. Objects of Knowledge. London: Athlone, 1990.
Pendergast, David M., and Elizabeth Graham. “The Battle for the Maya Past: The Effects of International Looting and Collecting in Belize.” In Messenger, Ethics of Collecting Cultural Property, 51–60.
Posey, Darrell Addison. “Selling Grandma: Commodification of the Sacred through Intellectual Property Rights.” In Barkan and Bush, Claiming the Stones/Naming the Bones, 201–23.
Postman, Neil. Building a Bridge to the 18th Century: How the Past Can Improve Our Future. New York: Viking, 1999.
Prott, Lyndel. “International Movement of Cultural Objects.” International Journal of Cultural Property 12(2) (2005): 225–248.Google Scholar
Rabchuk, Gord. “Life after the ‘Big Bang’: Business Archives in an Era of Disorder.” American Archivist 60 (1997): 4–43.Google Scholar
Raven, James. Lost Libraries: The Destruction of Great Book Collections since Antiquity. London: Macmillan/Palgrave, 2004.
Renfrew, Colin. Loot, Legitimacy and Ownership: The Ethical Crisis in Archaeology. London: Duckworth, 2000.
Rosenberg, Daniel. “Early Modern Information Overload.” Journal of the History of Ideas 64 (2003): 1–9.Google Scholar
Rosenzweig, Roy. “Scarcity or Abundance? Preserving the Past in a Digital Era.” American Historical Review 108 (2003): 735–62.Google Scholar
Roth, Darlene. “The Mechanics of a History Business.” The Public Historian 1:3 (Spring 1979): 26–40.Google Scholar
Sawyer, Deborah C. “The Pied Piper Goes Electronic.” Futurist 33:2 (February 1999): 42–46.Google Scholar
Schlesinger, Arthur M. Jr. The Disuniting of America: Reflections on a Multicultural Society. New York: W. W. Norton, 1992.
Sease, Catherine. “Code of Ethics for Conservation.” International Journal of Cultural Property 7 (1998): 98–115.Google Scholar
Secrest, Meryle. Duveen: A Life in Art. New York: Knopf, 2004.
Shestack, Alan. “The Museum and Cultural Property: The Transformation of Institutional Ethics.” In Messenger, Ethics of Collecting Cultural Property, 93–101.
Shyllon, Folarin. “The Right to a Cultural Past: African Viewpoints.” In Cultural Rights and Wrongs, 103–19.
Simmel, Georg. “The Concept and Tragedy of Culture” [Logos 2, 1911–1912]. In Simmel on Culture: Selected Writings, edited by David Frisby and Mike Featherstone, 55–75. London: Sage, 1997.
Smith, Anthony D. “The Problem of National Identity: Ancient, Medieval and Modern.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 17 (1994): 375–99.Google Scholar
Smith, M. Estellie. “The Process of Sociocultural Continuity.” Current Anthropology 23 (April 1982): 127–35.Google Scholar
St Clair, William. Lord Elgin and the Marbles. 3rd rev. ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1998.
St Clair, William. “The Elgin Marbles: Questions of Stewardship and Accountability.” International Journal of Cultural Property 8 (1999): 391–521.Google Scholar
Suagee, Dean B. “Cultural Rights, Biodiversity and the Indigenous Heritage of Indian Tribes in the United States.” In Cultural Rights and Wrongs, 81–102.
Sutter, Sem C. “The Lost Jewish Libraries of Vilna and the Frankfurt Institut zur Erforschung der Judenfrage.” In Raven, Lost Libraries, 219–35.
Temkin, Ann. “Strange Fruit.” In Mortality/Immortality? The Legacy of 20th-Century Art, edited by Miguel Angel Corzo, 45–50. Los Angeles: Getty Conservation Institute, 1999.
Thoden van Velzen, Diura. “The World of Tuscan Tomb Robbers: Living with the Local Community and the Ancestors.” International Journal of Cultural Property 5 (1996): 111–26.Google Scholar
Thomas, Nicholas. Possessions: Indigenous Art/Colonial Culture. London: Thames and Hudson, 1999.
Trouillot, Michel-Rolph. Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History. Boston: Beacon, 1995.
“Views and Visions of the Intangible.” Museum International 56: 1–2 (May 2004).
Wade, Edwin L. “The Ethnic Art Market in the American Southwest, 1880–1980.” In Objects and Others: Essays on Museums and Material Culture, edited by George W. Stocking Jr., 167–91. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1985.
Wareham, Evelyn. “‘Our Own Identity, Our Own Taonga, Our Own Coming Back’: Indigenous Voices in New Zealand Record-Keeping.” Archivaria, no. 52 (Fall 2001): 26–46.Google Scholar
Zimmerman, Lawrence J. “When Data Become People: Archaeological Ethics, Reburial, and the Past as Public Heritage.” International Journal of Cultural Property 7 (1998): 69–86.Google Scholar