VP89 A Preliminary Equity Checklist To Support The HTA Process

Abstract

Introduction

There is increased recognition of the need to include equity considerations in HTA. Despite this, a recent World Health Organization report has found that this is seldom the case. We developed a preliminary version of an equity checklist in the hopes that tangible guidance will increase such analyses in the future and contribute to smart capability building.

Methods

The checklist is based on the Equity Framework for HTA developed by Culyer & Bombard (2012). The elements presented in the framework were revised to follow the stepwise HTA process. A comprehensive literature search was used to update and complete the elements. The checklist was then piloted in an HTA in 2018 and subsequently further refined through a workshop during a national HTA conference in Canada.

Results

These steps resulted in a 27-item checklist leading to consider different aspects of the three major phases in the HTA process. The scoping phase brings questions relative to defining and contextualizing equity, such as highlighting potential minority groups and including vulnerability factors in the logic model. The development phase leads methodological approaches facilitating the analysis of inequities as well as considering contextual realities leading to inequities. The last phase, drafting of recommendations, aims to be aware of the evidence synthesis approaches as well as the various aspects to ensure recommendations consider existing inequities and avoid contributing to their development.

Conclusions

Given the essence of HTA to protect health by ensuring optimal technologies and interventions are adopted to the benefit of all system users, the consideration of inequities should constitute an integral part of its process. The use of a pragmatic and simple checklist to aid the planning of an HTA could contribute to greater consideration of inequities in the future. A movement in this direction could also lead to greater methodological developments for health equity analysis in HTA.