Hostname: page-component-7bb8b95d7b-w7rtg Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-09-20T07:02:22.086Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Nothing Special to Offer the Negro”: Revisiting the “‘Debsian View’ of the Negro Question”

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 November 2008

William P. Jones
William P. Jones
Affiliation:
University of Wisconsin, Madison
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Since the early twentieth century Eugene V. Debs and his essay “The Negro in the Class Struggle” have been cited repeatedly as examples of an alleged indifference among white radicals to African Americans and the historical significance of racism in the United States. A close reading of the essay reveals just the opposite. Not only did Debs support African Americans' struggle for equality, he believed that it was critical to the realization of America's democratic promise. That position alienated him from other white Socialists, but it won the admiration of African American radicals including W.E.B. Du Bois and A. Philip Randolph. This essay examines how Debs's essay came to be interpreted as a capitulation to racism and, over time, alleged indifference to African Americans and the significance of racism in the history of the United States.

Type
Classics Revisited
Information
International Labor and Working-Class History , Volume 74 , Issue 1 , Fall 2008 , pp. 212 - 224
Copyright
Copyright © International Labor and Working-Class History, Inc. 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

2. Socialist and Communist are capitalized when referring to the parties or their members and not when referring to ideologies. Debs, Eugene V., “The Negro in the Class Struggle,” International Socialist Review (November 1903)Google Scholar, reprinted in Debs, Eugene V., Writings and Speeches of Eugene V. Debs (New York, 1948), 63–66, quote on 63Google Scholar; Craig, Robert H., Religion and Radical Politics: An Alternative Christian Tradition in the United States (Philadelphia, 1992), 91–92Google Scholar; Roediger, David R., Working Toward Whiteness: How America's Immigrants Became White, The Strange Journey from Ellis Island to the Suburbs (New York 2005), 214Google Scholar; Lichtenstein, Nelson, The Most Dangerous Man in Detroit: Walter Reuther and the Fate of American Labor (New York, 1995), 371Google Scholar; Singh, Nikhil Pal, Black is a Country: Race and the Unfinished Struggle for Democracy (Cambridge, 2004), 25Google Scholar; Bates, Beth Tompkins, Pullman Porters and the Rise of Protest Politics in Black America, 1925–1945 (Chapel Hill: 2001), 37Google Scholar; Pfeffer, Paula F., A. Philip Randolph, Pioneer of the Civil Rights Movement (Baton Rouge, 1990), 11Google Scholar. For similar interpretations of Debs see, among others, Sitkoff, Harvard, A New Deal for Blacks: The Emergence of Civil Rights as a National Issue: The Depression Decade (New York, 1978), 20Google Scholar; Bush, Roderick D., We Are Not What We Seem: Black Nationalism and Class Struggle in the American Century (New York, 2000), 113Google ScholarPubMed; Foley, Barbara, Radical Representations: Politics and Form in U.S. Proletarian Fiction, 1929–1941 (Durham, NC, 1993), 173Google Scholar.

3. Debs, “Negro in the Class Struggle,” 65.

4. Debs, “Negro in the Class Struggle,” 66; “Negro Resolution” reprinted in Debs, “The Negro and his Nemesis,” Writings and Speeches of Eugene V. Debs, 68. Despite their repetition of Debs's statement, scholars rarely cite the original essay. Louisiana plank quoted in Kipnis, Ira, The American Socialist Movement, 1897–1912 (New York, 1952), 130–131Google Scholar; Foner, Philip S., American Socialism and Black Americans: From the Age of Jackson to World War II (Westport, CT, 1977), 343Google Scholar. Nick Salvatore presented a more nuanced view of Debs's racial politics but quoted the infamous statement to illustrate that “Along with most Socialists, Debs shared a class analysis of racial prejudice but had shorn it of much of the violent racism that motivated other comrades,” Eugene V. Debs: Citizen and Socialist (Champaign, 1982), 226. See also Green, James, Grass-Roots Socialism: Radical Movements in the Southwest, 1895–1943 (Baton Rouge, 1978)Google Scholar and Ginger, Ray, The Bending Cross: A Biography of Eugene Victory Debs (New Brunswick, NJ, 1949)Google Scholar.

5. Roediger, David, “‘Labor in White Skin’: Race and Working Class History,” in Towards the Abolition of Whiteness: Essays on Race, Politics and Working Class History (New York, 1994), 21–38Google Scholar; Singh, Nikhil Pal, “Retracing the Black-Red Thread,” American Literary History 15.4 (2003), 830–840CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6. Foley, Neil, The White Scourge: Mexicans, Blacks, and Poor Whites in Texas Cotton Culture (Berkeley, 1997) 94–117Google Scholar; Green, Grass-Roots Socialism, 94–125; Appeal to Reason quoted in Shannon, David A., The Socialist Party of America: A History (New York, 1955), 52Google Scholar; Roediger, David, “Gaining a Hearing for Black-White Unity: Covington Hall and the Complexities of Race, Gender and Class,” in Towards the Abolition of Whiteness: Essays on Race, Politics and Working Class History (New York, 1994), 142–144Google Scholar.

7. “Negro Resolution,” 68; Foner, American Socialism, 98.

8. Debs, “The Negro and the Class Struggle,” 65–66; Letwin, Daniel, “Interracial Unionism, Gender, and ‘Social Equality’ in the Alabama Coalfields, 1878–1908,” Journal of Southern History (Aug. 1995): 519–554CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Painter, Nell Irvin, “ ‘Social Equality’ and ‘Rape’ in the Fin-de-Siècle South,” Southern History Across the Color Line (Chapel Hill, 2002), 112–133Google Scholar.

9. Debs, “The Negro and His Nemesis,” 69.

10. Debs, “The Negro and His Nemesis,” 70–71; Blight, David W., Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory (Cambridge, 2001), 15–18Google Scholar; Roediger, David, The Wages of Whiteness: Race and the Making of the American Working Class (New York, 1991), 176Google Scholar; Ginger, The Bending Cross, 42–43; Salvatore, Eugene V. Debs, 105; Kantrowitz, Stephen, Ben Tillman and the Reconstruction of White Supremacy (Chapel Hill, 2000), 248, 252, 265Google Scholar.

11. Debs, “The Negro and His Nemesis,” 72–73, 71. Paul Gilroy attributes a similarly Hegelian analysis to Du Bois in The Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double Consciousness (Cambridge, 1993), 50–52. David Roediger attributes it to Frantz Fanon and George Rawick, who followed Debs by over half a century, Wages of Whiteness, 14, 17 n.31,32.

12. Bederman, Gail, Manliness and Civilization: A Cultural History of Gender and Race in the United States, 1880–1917 (Chicago, 1996), 25Google Scholar; Debs, “The Negro and the Class Struggle,” 64; Salvatore, Eugene V. Debs, 105; Debs, “The Negro and His Nemesis,” 73.

13. Bois, W.E.B. Du, The Souls of Black Folk: With an Introduction and Notes by Farah Jasmine Griffin, (New York, 2003), 99, 9Google Scholar; Lewis, David Levering, W.E.B. Du Bois: Biography of a Race (New York, 1993), 291Google Scholar.

14. Reed, Adolph L. Jr., W.E.B. Du Bois and American Political Thought: Fabianism and the Color Line (New York, 1997), 92Google Scholar; Griffin, Introduction to Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk, x; Bois, W.E.B. Du, “The Social Equality of Whites and Blacks,” Crisis 21 (November, 1920): 16Google Scholar; Debs, “The Negro and His Nemesis,” 72.

15. Roediger, Wages of Whiteness, 8, 11; Singh, Black is a Country, 47, 89; Reed, W.E.B. Du Bois, 92; Lewis, Biography of a Race, 421; Du Bois quoted in Lewis, David Levering, W.E.B. Du Bois: The Fight for Equality and the American Century, 1919–1963 (New York, 2000), 204Google Scholar.

16. Lewis, Biography of a Race, 333–354; Fink, Leon, Progressive Intellectuals and the Dilemmas of Democratic Commitment (Cambridge, 1998), 126–131Google Scholar; Spero and Harris, The Black Worker, 405; Rubinow, I.M., “Socialism and the Negro,” The New York Call (May 19, 1912), 13Google Scholar; “W.E.B. Du Bois, “Socialism and the Negro Problem,” New Review: A Critical Survey of International Socialism (February 1, 1913), 139–141.

17. Debs quoted in Fink, Progressive Intellectuals, 324, n. 47; James, Winston, Holding Aloft the Banner of Ethiopia: Caribbean Radicalism in Early Twentieth-Century America (New York, 1998), 127Google Scholar; Randolph quoted in Anderson, Jervis, A. Philip Randolph: a Biographical Portrait (Berkeley, 1986), 76Google Scholar; Taylor, Cynthia, A. Philip Randolph: The Religious Journey of an African American Leader (New York, 2006), 29Google Scholar.

18. Spero, Sterling D. and Harris, Abram L., The Black Worker: The Negro and the Labor Movement (New York, 1931), reprinted with preface by Herbert Gutman (New York, 1972), 405, 415Google Scholar; Gilmore, Glenda Elizabeth, Defying Dixie: The Radical Roots of Civil Rights, 1919–1950 (New York, 2008), 59, 61, 65Google Scholar.

19. Doerfler, Ernest, “Socialism and the Negro Problem,” American Socialist Quarterly 2 (1933): 31, 33Google Scholar; Lamont, Margaret I., “The Negro's Stake in Socialism,” American Socialist Quarterly 4 (March 1935): 42, 48, 41Google Scholar.

20. Green, Grass-Roots Socialism, 421–422; Glenn, John M., Highlander: No Ordinary School, 1932–1962 (Lexington, KY, 1988), 21, 68,Google Scholar; Edgerton, John, Speak Now Against the Day: The Generation Before the Civil Rights Movement in the South (Chapel Hill, 1994), 158Google Scholar; Foner, American Socialism, 362–364; Lamont, “The Negro's Stake in Socialism,” 47.

21. On links between race and class politics during the Cold War, see Hall, Jacqueline Dowd, “The Long Civil Rights Movement and the Political Uses of the Past,” Journal of American History 91 (March 2005): 1233–1263CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Debs Centennial Committee, Socialist Society, “Eugene Victor Debs (1855–1955): The Centennial Year” (New York, 1956), Wisconsin Historical Society Library Pamphlet Collection, Madison, WI; Frank Zeidler in “A Tribute to a great American, Eugene V. Debs (1855–1926),” November 5, 1955, Wisconsin Historical Society Library Pamphlet Collection; “The Shame of Milwaukee,” Time, April 2, 1956: 23; Thomas, Norman, “A Socialist Reports on Socialism,” New York Times Magazine, October 30, 1955: 15, 38, 42, 47Google Scholar; Du Bois, W.E.B., “If Eugene Debs Returned,” American Socialism (January, 1956)Google Scholar; Randolph quoted in Hedgeman, Anna Arnold, The Trumpet Sounds: A Memoir of Negro Leadership (New York, 1964), 186Google Scholar.

22. Charmichael, Stokely and Hamilton, Charles V., Black Power: The Politics of Liberation (New York, 1992), 41Google Scholar; Cruse, Harold, The Crisis of the Negro Intellectual: From its Origins to the Present (New York, 1967), 547Google Scholar.

23. Elbaum, Max, Revolution in the Air: Sixties Radicals turn to Lenin, Mao and Che (New York, 2002), 49–52, 102–105Google Scholar; Joseph, Peniel E., Waiting ‘Til the Midnight Hour: A Narrative History of Black Power in America (New York, 2006), 272–275Google Scholar; Foner, American Socialism and Black Americans, 343. Radosh, Ronald included “The Negro in the Class Struggle” in a collection of Debs's writing, stating that Debs “argued that the Negro question could be reduced to a simple ‘labor question,’ and that concern with questions of ‘social equality’ was a subterfuge meant to hide the real issue, ‘economic freedom,” Debs (Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1971), 60Google Scholar.

24. Reviews by Holt, Thomas, Journal of American History, (March, 1979): 1164–1165CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Miller, Sally M., American Historical Review, (December, 1978): 1325–1326CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cruse, Harold W., Journal of Negro History, (July, 1978): 253–257CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For competing assessments of the Communist Party see Kelley, Robin D.G., Hammer and Hoe: Alabama Communists during the Great Depression (Chapel Hill, 1990)Google Scholar and Arnesen, Eric, “No ‘Graver Danger’: Black Anticommunism, the Communist Party, and the Race Question,” Labor: Studies in Working-Class History of the Americas (Winter 2006): 13–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar.