Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T18:53:34.008Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

National humiliation and the Great Hunger: fast and famine in 1847

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Peter Gray
Peter Gray*
Affiliation:
Department of History, University of Southampton
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

On Wednesday 24 March 1847 a national day of fast and humiliation was observed throughout the United Kingdom, imploring, in the words of the royal proclamation, ‘the removal of those heavy judgments which our manifold sins and provocations have most justly deserved’. The fast-day was marked by a general stoppage of work and the opening of places of worship for special services. Substantial collections for the relief of famine distress in Ireland and the Scottish Highlands were made at church and chapel doors as the congregations retired. The effect was, as one Hampshire clergyman observed, dramatic: ‘The whole nation has this day lamented their sins and prayed for pardon; imagination can scarcely picture a more affecting scene than that of millions of people, assembled at the same moment in the presence of the Almighty, imploring his forgiveness, praying for grace to amend their lives, and deprecating the continuance of his displeasure.’

What was the meaning of this seemingly archaic reaction to the Irish Famine? Considered through the filter of late twentieth-century religious scepticism, it might appear at best a marginal distraction from the catastrophic drama of the Famine, at worst a cynical attempt by the political establishment to lay a moral smokescreen around the question of responsibility for famine relief by reviving pre-modern conceptions of divine agency. To understand the significance of the fast-day and its repercussions, however, it is necessary to recognise the extent to which a Christian — and more particularly a Protestant evangelical — world-view permeated early Victorian British society.

Type
Research Article
Information
Irish Historical Studies , Volume 32 , Issue 126 , November 2000 , pp. 193 - 216
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 2000

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The Examiner, 20 Mar. 1847.

2 Trollope, W., Three sermons having reference to the prevailing famine (Cambridge, 1847), p. 51Google Scholar.

3 Bourke, Austin, ‘Potato blight in Europe in 1845: the scientific controversy’ in his ‘The visitation of God’? The potato and the Great Irish Famine, ed. Hill, Jacqueline and Gráda, Cormac Ó (Dublin, 1993), pp 129-39Google Scholar; Gray, Peter, ‘Potatoes and providence: British government’s responses to the Great Famine’ in Bullán, i. no. 1 (1994), pp 75–90Google Scholar.

4 Lee, James, Our guilt and our duty, as a people: a sermon preached in the parish church of Market-Drayton, on Wednesday, March 24th 1847, being the day appointed by Her Majesty for a general fast (Market Drayton, 1847), pp 12–13Google Scholar.

5 For a more detailed account of the formation of reconstructive policy see Gray, Peter, Famine, land and politics: British government and Irish society, 1843-1850 (Dublin, 1999), chs 4-6Google Scholar.

6 Russell to Archbishop of Canterbury, 8 Sept. 1846 (P.R.O., Russell papers, PRO 30/22/5C, ff 78-9); ‘A form of prayer to Almighty God; for relief from dearth and scarcity now existing in parts of the United Kingdom’ in British Magazine, xxx (Nov. 1846), p. 567.

7 Circular letters to the clergy of the diocese of Armagh, from the lord primate, as ordinary of the diocese’, 16, 21 Oct. 1846, in British Magazine, xxx (Nov. 1846), pp 567-70.

8 Routh to Trevelyan, 21 Nov. 1846 (Correspondence, from July 1846 to January 1847, relating to the measures adopted for the relief of distress in Ireland (Commissariat series), pp 289-90 [761], H.C. 1847, li, 289-90).

9 The Spectator, 17 Oct. 1846; Shaftesbury diary, 14 Oct. 1846 (Southampton University Library, Shaftesbury papers, SHA/PD/4).

10 Broughton diary, 29 Oct. 1846 (B.L., Broughton papers, Add. MS 43748, ff 57-8).

11 Hansard 3, lxxxviii, 772-8 (17 Aug. 1846).

12 Brent, Richard, Liberal Anglican politics: Whiggery, religion and reform, 1830-1841 (Oxford, 1987), pp 59–63, 137Google Scholar.

13 The Times, 24 Dec. 1846; Illustrated London News, 16, 23 Jan. 1847.

14 Morpeth diary, 7 Jan. 1847 (Castle Howard, J19/8/14).

15 The Nonconformist, 4 Nov. 1846, 13 Jan. 1847.

16 Broughton diary, 16 Jan. 1847 (B.L., Broughton papers, Add. MS 43749, f. 85); Christian Observer, Mar. 1847, p. 191.

17 ‘Report of Revs R. Townsend and C. Caulfield to Skibbereen Relief Committee’ in The Examiner, 9 Jan. 1847.

18 George Grey to Revs C. Caulfield and R.Townsend, 9 Dec. 1846 (P.R.O., HO 122/19, ff 197-200); Trevelyan to Hankey, 17, 24 Dec. 1846 (Bodl., Trevelyan letter-books, x, ff 157, 218); Trevelyan to Russell, 26 Dec. 1846 (ibid., ff 235-6).

19 Trevelyan to Labouchere, 15 Dec. 1846 (West Sussex R.O., Bessborough papers, F 338).

20 Trevelyan to Routh, 5 Dec. 1846 (Correspondence relating to the relief of distress (Commissariat series), p. 332 [761], H.C. 1847, li, 332).

21 Wood to Russell, 21 Dec. 1846 (P.R.O., Russell papers, PRO 30/22/5F, ff 248-9).

22 Devon to Stephen Spring Rice, 31 Dec. 1846 (N.L.I., Monteagle papers, MS 13396/3); Lansdowne to Russell, 30 Dec. 1846 (P.R.O., Russell papers, PRO 30/22/5G, ff 121-2).

23 Wood to Russell, 6 Jan. 1847 (P.R.O., Russell papers, P.R.O. 30/22/6A, ff 72-5); Russell to Spring Rice, 1 Jan. 1847 (N.L.I., Monteagle papers, MS 13397/5); Grey to Wood, 4 Jan. 1847 (Cambridge University Library, Hickleton papers, A4/58/1).

24 Devine, T.M., The Great Highland Famine: hunger, emigration and the Scottish Highlands in the nineteenth century (Edinburgh, 1988), pp 102-45Google Scholar.

25 British Association minute book (N.L.I., MS 2022, ff 1-3); memo: ‘London Committee on Irish Relief, 24 Jan. 1847 (N.L.I., Monteagle papers, MS 13397/10).

26 Leeds Mercury, 9 Jan. 1847.

27 Trevelyan to Kingscote, 4 Jan. 1847 (Bodl., TreveIyan letter-books, xi, ff 32-6).

28 British Association minute book, 12-13,27 Jan., 3, 26 Mar. 1847 (N.L.I., MS 2022, ff 40-41, 43, 96, 200-2, 252-3).

29 Report of the British Association for the relief of the extreme distress in Ireland and Scotland, with correspondence of the agents, tables, etc., and a list of subscribers (London, 1849), pp 12–13, 29-31.

30 Thomas Walker to Wood, 7 Jan. 1847 (Cambridge University Library, Hickleton papers, A4/181).

31 Russell to Bessborough, 1 Mar. 1847 (P.R.O., Russell papers, PRO 30/22/6B, ff 172-3); Bessborough to Russell, 3 Mar. 1847 (ibid., ff 84-60; Archbishop of Canterbury to Russell, 6 Mar. 1847 (ibid., ff 203-6).

32 The Tablet, 27 Mar. 1847.

33 Brady to Labouchere, 27 Mar. 1847 (West Sussex R.O., Bessborough papers, F 338).

34 Hansard 3, lxxxix, 203-4 (21 Jan. 1847); The Record, 1, 4 Mar. 1847.

35 The Observer, 28 Mar. 1847.

36 Harrison, Benjamin, The religious care of the church’s sanctuaries and the religious education of her children: a charge delivered to the clergy of the archdeaconry of Maidstone (London, 1847), pp 29–30Google Scholar.

37 Carter, T.T., Three sermons, connected with the national fast day, March 24th (Windsor, 1847)Google Scholar.

38 The Nonconformist, 10, 17 Mar. 1847; Philips, A.R., Our sin and our duty: a sermon, preached in Blakeney tabernacle, Gloucestershire, on occasion of the national fast (London, [1847])Google Scholar.

39 Prayer to Almighty God, offered up in all the German synagogues of the British Empire … on Sabbath, October 17th, 5607 … to avert the calamitous consequences of the famine (London, 1846); The Times, 25 Mar. 1847.

40 A Layman, ‘How shall we keep the fast?’ in The Times, 23 Mar. 1847.

41 Gaye, C.H., The general fast, in prospect and retrospect: two sermons preached respectively on the Sunday next after the fast and on the evening of the fast day, at Archbishop Tenison’s chapel, St James’s, Westminster (London, 1847), pp 8–10Google Scholar.

42 Morpeth diary, 24 Mar. 1847 (Castle Howard, J19/8/14).

43 The Record, 29 Mar. 1847.

44 Broughton diary, 11-12 May 1847 (B.L., Broughton papers, Add. MS 43750, ff 42-3).

45 Leeds Mercury, 27 Mar. 1847; Hansard 3, xci, 366-7 (23 Mar. 1847).

46 [Central Relief Committee], Transactions of the Central Relief Committee of the Society of Friends during the famine in Ireland in 1846 and 1847 (Dublin, 1852), p. 6Google Scholar.

47 Morning Chronicle, 23 Mar. 1847; The Record, 29 Mar. 1847; The Tablet, 27 Mar. 1847.

48 A Conscientious Enquirer, ‘On the national fast’ in The Observer, 28 Mar. 1847.

49 The Record, 1 Apr. 1847.

50 Sunday Times, 21 Mar. 1847.

51 ‘The farce of the national fast’ in Sunday Times, 7 Mar. 1847.

52 Illustrated London News, 27 Mar. 1847.

53 Belfast News-Letter, 26 Mar. 1847.

54 ‘On the providence of God’ and ‘The Irish priest; or, What for Ireland?’ in Belfast People’s Magazine: a monthly periodical, published under the sanction of the Belfast Working Class Association, i (Oct. 1847), pp 229-31, 236.

55 Dublin Evening Mail, 22 Mar. 1847.

56 The Tablet, 27 Mar. 1847.

57 Dublin Evening Mail, 26 Mar. 1847.

58 Badham, Leslie, A sermon, preached in St Stephen’s chapel, Frensham, diocese of Winchester, in aid of the Irish relief funds (Godalming, [1847])Google Scholar. See also Driscoll, Charles, The difficulty of showing mercy to the afflicted: a sermon, preached for the famine in Ireland, at St Luke’s church, Chelsea, February 28, 1847 (London, 1847)Google Scholar.

59 Matthew, H.C.G., Gladstone, 1809-74 (Oxford, 1986), p. 97Google Scholar; Shaftesbury diary, 24 Mar. 1847 (Southampton University Library, Shaftesbury papers, SHA/PD/4).

60 Bennett, W.J.E., Sins of the church and people: a sermon preached at St Paul’s, Knightsbridge, on the vigil of the Annunciation, 1847, being also the national fast day (London, 1847)Google Scholar; Pusey, E.B., Chastisements neglected forerunners of greater: a sermon preached at Margaret chapel, on the vigil of the Annunciation, being the day appointed for a general fast and humiliation before Almighty God (London, 1847)Google Scholar.

61 Hilton, Boyd, The age of atonement: the influence of evangelicalism on social and economic thought, 1785-1865 (Oxford, 1988), pp 3–26, 108-14Google Scholar.

62 Eardley-Wilmot, E.R., The threatened famine a divine judgment for national unfaithfulness: a sermon, preached to the parish church of Kenilworth … Oct. 25, 1846 (London, 1846), p. 25Google Scholar. See also Vansittart, Charles, A sermon on famine: the expediency of a public fast, and the duty of personal abstinence in the present time of dearth (London, 1847)Google Scholar.

63 Gamier, Thomas, A sermon, preached in obedience to the queen‘s letter, in behalf of the suffering Irish and Scotch … 28th February 1847 (Winchester, [1847])Google Scholar; Cox, J.E., ‘National judgments: a sermon preached in St Dunstan’s church, Stepney … 21 February 1847’ in The Pulpit, li (1847), p. 156Google Scholar.

64 Crosthwaite, J.C., The unfruitful fig-tree: a sermon, preached in the church of St Mary-at-Hill, London, on … the day appointed for the general fast (London, 1847)Google Scholar.

65 Gregg, T.D., The evils of Ireland: their true source and only sufficient remedy (London, 1847)Google Scholar.

66 McNeile, Hugh, The famine a rod of God; its provoking cause — its merciful design: a sermon preached in St Jude’s church, Liverpool, on Sunday, February 28, 1847 (London, 1847)Google Scholar.

67 Divine judgments: an address lately transmitted to the archbishop of Canterbury … from members of the United Church of England and Ireland, resident in Dublin’ in The Record, 29 Mar. 1847.

68 The archbishop’s reply, 13 March’ (ibid.).

69 Bishop of St Asaph’s sermon, Westminster Abbey, in The Times, 25 Mar. 1847. Tresham Gregg answered the bishop with the argument that ‘of two men who die by the same visitation, one may experience it as a mercy, the call of a ministering spirit who summons him to glory, and the other be made to feel that he is, in its endurance, the object of the wrath of God’ (Gregg, Evils of Ireland, p. 11).

70 Bishop of St Asaph’s sermon, in The Times, 25 Mar. 1847.

71 [Philipotts, Henry], A sermon, preached in St John’s chapel, Torquay, on Wednesday, 24th March 1847, being the day appointed for a general fast and humiliation before God (Exeter, 1847)Google Scholar.

72 Blomfield, C.J., ‘The nation’s resource in the time of trouble: a sermon’ in The Pulpit, li (1847), pp 249-54Google Scholar.

73 Carter, Three sermons, pp 12-13.

74 Mr Brookfield’s sermon, St James’s, Westminster, in The Times, 25 Mar. 1847.

75 Gilby, F.D., The famine in Ireland and parts of Scotland: a sermon preached in pursuance of the queen’s letter, in St James’ church, Cheltenham, on Sunday, February 14th 1847 (Cheltenham, 1847), pp 8–9Google Scholar.

76 Lilley, Edmund, A sermon on behalf of the distressed Irish and Scotch, preached in obedience to Her Majesty’s letter, in Peckham chapel, Surrey (London, 1847)Google Scholar.

77 [Chalmers, Thomas], ‘Political economy of a famine’ in North British Review, vii (May 1847), pp 247-90Google Scholar; see also Hilton, Age of atonement, pp 108-12.

78 Oxford Protestant Magazine, i (Mar. 1847), pp 37-40.

79 Gaye, General fast, p. 42.

80 Sulivan, H.W., Christian compassion: a sermon preached in obedience to the queen’s letter in behalf of the starving Irish, on Sunday, 31st January 1847 (London, 1847), pp 10–11Google Scholar. See also Hatherell, J.W., Faith in God: a nation’s support in time of dearth … a sermon, preached in obedience to the queen’s letter (London, 1847)Google Scholar.

81 A sermon on the occasion of the Irish famine, preached January 24th, 1847 (Hadleigh, [1847]); see also Mr Gleadall’s sermon at the Foundling Hospital chapel, London, in The Times, 25 Mar. 1847.

82 The Nonconformist, 19 Aug., 2 Sept. 1846.

83 Martineau, James, Ireland and her famine: a discourse preached in Paradise St chapel, Liverpool, on Sunday January 31st, 1847 (London, [1847])Google Scholar.

84 Green, S.G., ‘The general fast: a sermon preached on the 24th of March last’ in Baptist Record, iv (Apr. 1847), pp 278-84Google Scholar.

85 Christian Examiner, ii (Jan. 1847), p. 388.

86 For lay use of liberal providentialism see Lord Robert Grosvenor’s speech at the Mile End relief meeting for Ireland, 25 Feb. 1847, in Freeman’s Journal, 2 Mar. 1847.

87 For a rare Malthusian example in the charity sermons, by a Church of Ireland evangelical preaching in aid of the conversionist Coast and Island Society, see Lowe, J.B., The Christian’s faith and duty in the time of famine practically considered, in two sermons (London, 1847)Google Scholar.

88 Trevelyan, C.E., The Irish crisis (London, 1848), p. 1Google Scholar.

89 Standish Haly to Trevelyan, 20 Oct. 1847 (P.R.O., T 64/367 A/2).

90 British Magazine, xxxi (Feb. 1847), p. 221; Driscoll, The difficulty of showing mercy, p. iii.

91 The Times, 6 Jan., 8 Mar. 1847.

92 Ibid., 24Mar. l847.

93 Ibid., 26Mar. 1847.

94 Greville, C.C.F., The Greville memoirs (second part): a journal of the reign of Queen Victoria from 1837 to 1852, ed. Reeve, Henry (3 vols, London, 1885), iii, 71 (23 Mar. 1847)Google Scholar.

95 Shaftesbury diary, 11 Jan. 1847 (Southampton University Library, Shaftesbury papers, SHA/PD/4).

96 Lady’s Newspaper, 16 Jan., 27 Mar. 1847.

97 Rev. Algernon Peyton to Russell, 20 Mar. 1847 (P.R.O., Russell papers, PRO 30/22/6B, ff 271-2).

98 Trevelyan to the editor, The Times, 12 Oct. 1847.

99 Dublin Evening Mail, 18, 20 Oct. 1847.

100 The Times, 9 Oct. 1847; The Examiner, 16 Oct. 1847.

101 The Times, 9 Oct. 1847.

102 [Drummond?] to Trevelyan, 14 Oct. 1847 (P.R.O., T 64/367A/2).

103 T. C. Foster to the editor, The Times, 13 Oct. 1847.

104 Moore, Daniel, ‘The Christian uses of national and individual chastisement: a harvest thanksgiving sermon, preached in Camden church, Camberwell, on Sunday morning, October 17, 1847’ in The Pulpit, lii (1847), pp 321-8Google Scholar. For similar examples see Vere, Aubrey de, English misrule and Irish misdeeds: four letters from Ireland addressed to an English member of parliament (repr., Port Washington, 1970, of orig. ed., London, 1848), pp 29–30Google Scholar.

105 Hughes, Hugh, ‘Gratitude for divine blessings: a harvest sermon … preached in St John’s church, Clerkenwell, on Sunday morning, October 17, 1847’ in The Pulpit, lii (1847), pp 350-56Google Scholar.

106 British Association minute book: finance sub-committee, 24 Feb. 1848 (N.L.I., MS 5218, f. 124).

107 Shaftesbury diary, 20 Oct. 1847 (Southampton University Library, Shaftesbury papers, SHA/PD/5).

108 Memo: extract of a letter from Liverpool, 23 Oct. 1847 (P.R.O., T 64/367A/2).

109 Trevelyan to Jones Loyd, 25 Oct. 1847 (ibid.); Report of the British Association, pp 29-31.

110 Clarendon to Trevelyan, 27 Oct. 1847 (P.R.O., T 64/367A/2).

111 Dublin Evening Mail, 15 Oct. 1847.

112 The Tablet, 16, 23 Oct. 1847.

113 Quoted ibid., 23 Oct. 1847.

114 Christian Observer, Feb. 1847, p. 128; Mar. 1847, p. 191.

115 See Society for Protecting the Rights of Conscience: prospectus (Dublin, 1851).

116 A brief account of the famine in Ireland (London, 1847), pp 20-22.

117 East, John, Glimpses of Ireland in 1847 (London, 1847), pp 52-5, 78-92, 105Google Scholar.

118 Gregg, John, A missionary visit to Achill and Erris, and other parts of the county of Mayo (Dublin, 1850)Google Scholar.

119 [Whately, Richard], Address to the clergy and other members of the established church, on the use and abuse of the present occasion for the exercise of beneficence (Dublin, 1847), p. 6Google Scholar; Whelan, Irene, ‘The stigma of souperism’ in Póirtéir, Cathal (ed.), The Great Irish Famine (Cork, 1995), pp 135-54Google Scholar.

120 McNeile, Hugh, ‘Practical Christianity: a sermon … preached in Christ Church, Dorset Square, on Sunday morning, June 13, 1847’in The Pulpit, li (1847), pp 453-60Google Scholar.

121 McNeile, Hugh, National sin — what is it? A letter to the Rt Hon. Sir George Grey (3rd ed., London, 1849), pp 3–7Google Scholar.

122 Illustrated London News, 15 Sept., 17 Nov. 1849.

123 See Gray, Peter, ‘ “Shovelling out your paupers”: the British state and Irish famine migration, 1846-50’ in Patterns of Prejudice, xxxiii, no. 4 (1999), pp 47–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

124 Earlier versions of this paper were read at the Famine Conference, St Michael’s College, Toronto, in November 1996, and at Concordia University, Montreal, in September 1997. I would like to thank the respective organisers for providing these opportunities to discuss the issues raised in this paper. Thanks are also due to David Brown for allowing me to use his transcripts of the Shaftesbury diary.