Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-8bhkd Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-13T01:52:41.976Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Villain, victim or prophet?: William Gregory and the Great Famine

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 February 2015

Brian M. Walker
Brian M. Walker*
Affiliation:
School of Politics, International Studies and Philosophy, Queen's University of Belfast
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The name of Sir William Gregory features in most modern accounts of Ireland in the nineteenth century. It is fair to say, however, that usually he is regarded as a ‘villain’. Gregory is very widely known as the author of a piece of legislation introduced as part of relief measures during the Famine which sought to limit aid to those with a quarter acre or under of land and which became known as the Gregory clause or the quarter acre clause. An article in the New York Times on 16 July 2002 about the dedication of an Irish famine memorial in New York described the 5 million-dollar monument as follows: ‘The quarter-acre size of the monument adheres to the infamous Gregory clause passed by the British parliament in 1847, which decreed that cottiers whose plots exceeded that size would not be eligible for relief. The cottage is roofless because many farmers tore the thatches off their homes to prove destitution and qualify for relief.’ Most modern academic accounts of the Famine have been very critical of Gregory. It is widely accepted that the purpose of the Gregory clause was to assist landlords to clear their estates of pauperised smallholders who were paying little or no rent. This measure has been seen by some as leading to mass evictions and causing the clearance of many small farmers and labourers throughout Ireland.

Type
Research Article
Information
Irish Historical Studies , Volume 38 , Issue 152 , November 2013 , pp. 579 - 599
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Hansard 3, xci, 589–90 (29 Mar. 1847).

2 O’Brien, George The economic history of Ireland, from the union to the famine (1921, reprint, Clifton, N.J., 1972), p. 278.Google Scholar

3 O’Rourke, John The history of the great Irish famine of 1847, with notices of earlier Irish famines (Dublin, 1875; third edition, Dublin, 1902), pp 330–3.Google Scholar

4 Mitchel, John The last conquest of Ireland (perhaps), ed. Patrick Maume (1861; reprint Dublin, 2005), p. 126.Google Scholar

5 Jenkins, Brian Sir William Gregory of Coole: the biography of an Anglo-Irishman (Gerrards Cross, 1986), pp 73–5;Google Scholar McCabe, Desmond ‘Gregory, Sir William Henry’ in D.I.B. Google Scholar

6 Walker, B.M. ‘Politicians, elections and catastrophe: the general election of 1847’ in Irish Political Studies, 22, no.1 (Mar. 2007), pp 1–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

7 Walker, B.M. (ed.), Parliamentary election results in Ireland, 1801–1922 (Dublin, 1978).Google Scholar

8 The Times, 7 Mar. 1892; Tuam Herald, 19 Mar. 1892; Galway Vindicator, 9 Mar. 1892.

9 Jenkins, Gregory, p. 84.Google Scholar

10 Sir William Gregory, K.C.M.G., formerly member of parliament and sometime governor of Ceylon: an autobiography, ed. Lady Gregory (London, 1894), p. 140; see also Jenkins, Gregory, pp 95–6.Google Scholar

11 Tóibín, Colm Lady Gregory’s toothbrush (London, 2002), p. 25.Google Scholar

12 Jenkins, Gregory, p. 95.Google Scholar

13 Reported in Tuam Herald, 8 Dec. 1849.

14 Jenkins, Gregory, pp 129–34.Google Scholar

15 Freeman’s Journal, 28 Oct. 1879. I am grateful to Paul Bew for this reference.

16 Nation, 8 Nov.1879.

17 Donnelly, J.S. jr. The great Irish potato famine (Stroud, 2001), pp 65–100.Google Scholar

18 Jenkins, Gregory, pp 71–2.Google Scholar

19 The Times, 13 Mar. 1847.

20 The Times, 30 Mar. 1847.

21 Hansard 3, xci, 592–4 (29 Mar. 1847).

22 Sir William Gregory, ed. Lady Gregory, p. 135.

23 The Times, 30 Mar. 1847.

24 Moran, Gerard Sending out Ireland’s poor; assisted emigration to North America in the nineteenth century (Dublin, 2004), pp 70–80.Google Scholar

25 See Walker, ‘Politicians, elections and catastrophe, especially p. 31.Google Scholar

26 Freeman’s Journal, 2 Aug. 1847.

27 Clare Journal, 2 Aug. 1847.

28 Clare Journal, 19 Aug. 1847.

29 Galway Mercury, 7 Aug. 1847; Western Star, 14 Aug. 1847.

30 Tuam Herald, 21 Aug.1847.

31 Tuam Herald, 28 Aug. 1847.

32 Transactions of the central relief committee of the Society of Friends during the famine in Ireland (1852: reprint, Dublin, 1996), pp 455–6.

33 First annual report of the commissioners for administering the laws for relief of the poor in Ireland, H. C. 1847–8, xxxiii, p. 13.

34 Clarendon, Lord to Russell, , 8 Oct. 1847 (Bodl., out-letter book, MS Clarendon deposit Irish, vol. 1, f. 73).Google Scholar

35 Clarendon, Lord to Russell, 4 Jan. 1848 (Bodl., out-letter book, MS Clarendon deposit Irish, vol. 2, ff 61–2.Google Scholar

36 First report from the select committee of the house of lords appointed to inquire into the operation of the Irish poor law, H.C. 1849, xvi, 361.

37 Ibid,, 4991–3, 6890.

38 Ibid., 4993.

39 Ibid., 6178.

40 Ibid., 1991–2021.

41 Donnelly, Great Irish potato famine, pp 150–3.Google Scholar

42 Ibid., pp 139–40.

43 Curtis, L. Perry The depiction of eviction in Ireland, 1845–1910 (Dublin, 2011), pp 27–56;Google Scholar O’Neill, T.P. ‘Famine evictions’ in King, Carla (ed.), Famine, land and culture in Ireland (Dublin, 2000), pp 29–70.Google Scholar

44 Jenkins, Gregory, pp 117–18.Google Scholar

45 Copy of letter from Gregory, William to Kelly, Rev. M. conveyed to DrDerry, John March 1852 (Gregory papers, Emory University, box 21, folder 2).Google Scholar

46 Tuam Herald, 4 Apr. 1857.

47 The Times, 7 Mar.1892.

48 Irish Times, 8 Mar. 1892.

49 Galway Vindicator, 9 Mar. 1892.

50 Tuam Herald, 12 and 19 Mar. 1892.

51 Sir William Gregory, ed. Lady Gregory, pp 133–6.

52 Freeman’s Journal, 15 Nov. 1894.

53 Hansard 3, xci, 589–90 (29 Mar. 1847).

54 Donnelly, Great Irish potato famine, p. 102.Google Scholar

55 O’Rourke, History of the great Irish famine, p. 331.Google Scholar

56 Jenkins, Gregory, pp 72–3.Google Scholar

57 A bibliography of parliamentary debates of Great Britain (London, 1956), p. 14.

58 MacKnight, Thomas The Right Honourable Benjamin Disraeli, M.P., a literary and political biography (second edn, 1854; reprint, London, 2006) pp 433–4.Google Scholar

59 Falkiner, C. L. revised by Gray, Peter ‘Gregory, Sir William Henry (1816–1892)’ in Oxford D.N.B.Google Scholar

60 Hansard 3, xci, 585–7 (29 Mar. 1847).

61 Mitchel, Last conquest, p. 126.Google Scholar

62 O’Rourke, History of the great Irish famine, pp 330–4.Google Scholar

63 O’Brien, Economic history, p. 278.Google Scholar

64 Davitt, Michael The fall of feudalism in Ireland or the story of the land league revolution (1904; reprint, Shannon, 1970), p. 68.Google Scholar

65 Sullivan, A.M. The story of Ireland (Dublin, 1905), pp 565–6.Google Scholar

66 O’Neill, T.P. ‘The organization and administration of relief, 1845–52’ in Edwards, R.D. and Williams, T.D. (eds), The great famine: studies in Irish history, 1845–52 (Dublin, 1956), pp 240–1, 253–4.Google Scholar

67 Woodham-Smith, Cecil The great hunger: Ireland, 1845–1849 (New York and London, 1962), p. 363.Google Scholar

68 Donnelly, James S. jr, The land and the people of nineteenth-century Cork: the rural economy and the land question (London, 1975), pp 98–100.Google Scholar

69 Ibid., p. 112.

70 Daly, Mary E. The famine in Ireland (Dundalk, 1986), pp 94–5.Google Scholar

71 Donnelly, James S. jr ‘The administration of relief, 1847–51’ in Vaughan, W. E. (ed.), A new history of Ireland, v: Ireland under the union, i, 1801–70 (Oxford, 1989), pp 317, 323–7.Google Scholar

72 Donnelly, James S. jr ‘Mass eviction and the great famine: the clearances revisited’ in Póirtéir, Cathal (ed.), The great Irish famine (Cork, 1995), pp 159–60.Google Scholar

73 Donnelly, Great potato famine, p.111.Google Scholar

74 Kinealy, Christine This great calamity: the Irish famine, 1845–1852 (Dublin, 1994) pp 213–23.Google Scholar

75 Kinealy, Christine A death dealing famine: the great hunger in Ireland (London, 1997) pp 123–4.Google Scholar

76 Tóibín, Colm and Ferriter, Diarmaid The Irish famine (2001, London, 2004 edn), pp 3–5.Google Scholar

77 The New York Review of Books, 9 Aug. 2001.

78 Tóibín, Lady Gregory’s toothbrush, pp 26–32.Google Scholar

79 Crowley, John Smyth, William J. and Murphy, Mike (eds), Atlas of the great Irish famine (Cork, 2012);Google Scholar Coogan, T.P. The famine plot: England’s role in Ireland’s greatest tragedy (Basingstoke, 2012);Google Scholar Delaney, Enda The curse of reason: the great Irish famine (Dublin, 2012);Google Scholar Kelly, John The graves are walking: the history of the great Irish famine (London, 2012).Google Scholar

80 Kelly, Graves are walking, p. 250;Google Scholar Delaney, Curse of reason, p. 173.Google Scholar

81 McCaffrey, L.J. Daniel O’Connell and the repeal year (Lexington, Kentucky, 1996), pp 20–37:Google Scholar Gray, Peter The making of the Irish poor law, 1815–43 (Manchester, 2009), pp 324–31.Google Scholar

82 McCaffrey, Daniel O’Connell and the repeal year, p. 36; Nation, 4 Feb. 1843.Google Scholar

83 Tuam Herald, 21 Jan. 1843.

84 In the case of the elections see Walker, ‘Politicians, elections and catastrophe’, pp 29–33.Google Scholar

85 Mitchel, Last conquest, p. 142.Google Scholar

86 Daly, Irish famine, p. 85.Google Scholar

87 Woodham-Smith, Great hunger, p. 333.Google Scholar

88 Donnelly, Great Irish potato famine, p. 116.Google Scholar

89 Gráda, Cormac Ó Great Irish famine (London, 1989), p. 55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

90 Third annual report of the commissioners for administering the laws for relief of the poor in Ireland, H.C.1850, xxvii, p. 471.

91 Moran, Sending out Ireland’s poor, p. 75 Google Scholar

92 Ibid., p. 74.

93 Mitchel, Last conquest, pp 139–40.Google Scholar

94 Gráda, Cormac Ó Black ’47 and beyond: the great Irish famine in history, economy and memory (Princeton, 1999), p. 121.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

95 Woodham-Smith, Great hunger, pp 247–8.Google Scholar

96 Moran, Sending out Ireland’s poor, p. 52.Google Scholar

97 Times, 31 Dec. 1881.

98 The author gratefully acknowledges financial assistance from the British Academy to visit Gregory archives in Atlanta and Oxford.