Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-s2hrs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-11T12:33:45.278Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Liberty or dignity: community treatment orders and rights

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 May 2013

J. Lally
J. Lally*
Affiliation:
Department of Psychiatry, Clinical Science Institute, National University of Ireland, Galway (NUIG), Ireland
*
*Address for correspondence: Dr J. Lally, MB, MSc, MRCPsych, Department of Psychiatry, Clinical Science Institute, National University of Ireland, Galway (NUIG), Galway, Ireland. Email john.lally@kcl.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The use of community treatment orders (CTOs) remains controversial despite their widespread use in a number of different countries. The focus of a CTO should be on individuals with severe and enduring mental disorders, typically requiring adherence with recommended outpatient treatment in the community and requiring that they allow access to members of the clinical team for the purpose of assessment. There is no current provision for CTOs under Irish mental health legislation, although patients who are involuntarily detained under the MHA 2001 (Ireland) can be granted approved leave from hospital. This provision allows for the patient to be managed in the community setting, though, while technically on leave, they remain as inpatients detained under the MHA 2001 (Ireland). This article describes the use of CTOs and considerations relating to their implementation. There is discussion of the ethical grounds and evidence base for their use. Ethical considerations such as balancing autonomy against health needs and the utilisation of capacity principles need to be weighed by clinicians considering the use of CTOs. Though qualitative research provides some support for the use of CTOs, there remains a clear lack of robust evidence based findings to support their use in terms of hospitalisation rates, duration of illness remission and improved social functioning.

Keywords

Community treatment ordersethicsinvoluntary treatmentmental health act
Type
Review Article
Information
Irish Journal of Psychological Medicine , Volume 30 , Issue 2 , June 2013 , pp. 141 - 149
Copyright
Copyright © College of Psychiatrists of Ireland 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Appelbaum, PS (1994). Almost a Revolution: Mental Health Law & the Limits of Change. Oxford University Press: New York.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Appelbaum, PS (2001). Thinking carefully about outpatient commitment. Psychiatric Services 52, 347–350.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Appelbaum, PS (2005). Assessing Kendra's law: five years of outpatient commitment in New York. Psychiatric Services 56, 791–792.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Appelbaum, PS, Lidz, CW, Meisel, A (1987). Informed Consent: Legal Theory and Clinical Practice. Oxford University Press: Oxford.Google Scholar
Atkinson, JM, Garner, HC (2002). Least restrictive alternative – advance statements and the new mental health legislation. Psychiatric Bulletin 26, 246–247.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Borum, R, Swartz, M, Riley, S, Swanson, J, Hiday, VA, Wagner, R (1999). Consumer perceptions of involuntary outpatient commitment. Psychiatric Services 50, 1489–1491.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Brophy, L, Ring, D (2004). The efficacy of involuntary treatment in the community. Social Work in Mental Health 2, 157–174.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Care Quality Commision (2010). Monitoring the Use of the Mental Health Act in England 2009/10. Care Quality Commision: London, UK.Google Scholar
Care Quality Commission MHA Quality Report (2012). Monitoring the Use of the Mental Health Act in England 2011/12. Care Quality Commision: London, UK.Google Scholar
Churchill, R (2005). International Experiences of Using Community Treatment Orders. Institute of Psychiatry: London.Google Scholar
Collins, AA, Remington, G, Coulter, K, Birkett, K (1996). Depression in schizophrenia: a comparison of three measures. Schizophrenia Research 20, 205–209.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Crawford, MJ, Hopkins, W, Henderson, C (2000). Concerns over reform of the Mental Health Act. British Journal of Psychiatry 177, 563.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Crawford, MJ, Gibbon, R, Ellis, E, Waters, H (2004). In hospital, at home, or not at all. Psychiatric Bulletin 28, 360–363.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
David, A, Buchanan, A, Reed, A, Almeida, O (1992). The assessment of insight in psychosis. British Journal of Psychiatry 161, 599–602.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dawson, J (1991). Community treatment orders. Otaga Law Review 17, 410–425.Google Scholar
Dawson, J (2002). Randomised controlled trials of mental health legislation. Medical Law Review 10, 308–321.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dawson, J (2005). Community Treatment Orders: International Comparisons. Faculty of Law, University of Otago: New Zealand.Google Scholar
Dawson, J (2006). Fault-lines in community treatment order legislation. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 29, 482–494.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dawson, J (2009). Community treatment orders in New Zealand. International Psychiatry 6, 59–60.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dawson, J, Mullen, R (2008). Insight and use of community treatment orders. Journal of Mental Health 17, 269–280.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dawson, J, Romans, S (2001). Uses of community treatment orders in New Zealand: early findings. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 35, 190–195.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dawson, J, Szmukler, G (2006). Fusion of mental health and incapacity legislation. The British Journal of Psychiatry 188, 504–509.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Department of Health (2006). Mental Health Bill: Regulatory Impact Assessment. The Stationery Office: London, UK.Google Scholar
Department of Health (2007). Mental Health Act 2007. The Stationery Office: London, UK.Google Scholar
Dressing, H, Salize, H (2004). Compulsory admission of mentally ill patients in European Union member states. Social psychiatry and psychiatric epidemiology 39, 797–803.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fistein, EC, Holland, AJ, Clare, IC, Gunn, MJ (2009). A comparison of mental health legislation from diverse Commonwealth jurisdictions. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 32, 147–155.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fulford, B, Christodoulou, GN, Stein, DJ (2011). Values and ethics: perspectives on psychiatry for the person. International Journal of Person Centered Medicine 1, 131–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gibbs, A, Dawson, J, Ansley, C, Mullen, R (2005). How patients in New Zealand view community treatment orders. Journal of Mental Health 14, 357–368.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Girgis, S, Spence, S (2003). Is it worth treating mentally ill roofless people? Schizophrenia Research 60, 284–285.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Green, MF (1996). What are the functional consequences of neurocognitive deficits in schizophrenia? American Journal of Psychiatry 153, 321–330.Google ScholarPubMed
Grisso, T, Appelbaum, PS (1995a). Comparison of standards for assessing patients’ capacities to make treatment decisions. American Journal of Psychiatry 152, 1033–1037.Google ScholarPubMed
Grisso, T, Appelbaum, PS (1995b). The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. III: abilities of patients to consent to psychiatric and medical treatments. Law and Human Behaviour 19, 149–174.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Heaton, RK, Gladsjo, JA, Palmer, BW, Kuck, J, Marcotte, TD, Jeste, DV (2001). Stability and course of neuropsychological deficits in schizophrenia. Archives of General Psychiatry 58, 24–32.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hiday, VA (2003). Outpatient commitment: the state of empirical research on its outcomes. Psychology Public Policy and Law 9, 8–32.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Irani, F, Kalkstein, S, Moberg, EA, Moberg, PJ (2011). Neuropsychological performance in older patients with schizophrenia: a meta-analysis of cross-sectional and longitudinal studies. Schizophrenia Bulletin 37, 1318–1326.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Keefe, RS, Bilder, RM, Davis, SM, Harvey, PD, Palmer, BW, Gold, JM, Meltzer, HY, Green, MF, Capuano, G, Stroup, TS, McEvoy, JP, Swartz, MS, Rosenheck, RA, Perkins, DO, Davis, CE, Hsiao, JK, Lieberman, JA (2007). Neurocognitive effects of antipsychotic medications in patients with chronic schizophrenia in the CATIE trial. Archives of General Psychiatry 64, 633–647.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
King, M, Barcham, C, Carr, J (2008). Workbook to Support Implementation of the Mental Health Act 1983 as Amended by the Mental Health Act 2007. DH: London.Google Scholar
Kisely, SR, Campbell, LA, Preston, NJ (2005). Compulsory community and involuntary outpatient treatment for people with severe mental disorders. Cochrane Database Systematic Review 3, 1–21.Google Scholar
Kisely, SR, Campbell, LA, Preston, NJ (2011). Compulsory community and involuntary outpatient treatment for people with severe mental disorders. Cochrane Database Systematic Review 2, 1–37.Google Scholar
Koegel, P, Burnam, MA, Farr, RK (1988). The prevalence of specific psychiatric disorders among homeless individuals in the inner city of Los Angeles. Archives of General Psychiatry 45, 1085–1092.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lawton-Smith, S, Dawson, J, Burns, T (2008). Community treatment orders are not a good thing. The British Journal of Psychiatry 193, 96–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Macpherson, R, Molodynski, A, Freeth, R, Uppal, A, Steer, H, Buckle, D, Jones, A (2010). Supervised community treatment: guidance for clinicians. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 16, 253–259.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Manning, C, Molodynski, A, Rugkåsa, J, Dawson, J, Burns, T (2011). Community treatment orders in England and Wales: national survey of clinicians’ views and use. The Psychiatrist 35, 328–333.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McEvoy, JP, Apperson, LJ, Appelbaum, PS, Ortlip, P, Brecosky, J, Hammill, K, Geller, JL, Roth, L (1989). Insight in schizophrenia. Its relationship to acute psychopathology. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 177, 43–47.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
McGurk, SR, Twamley, EW, Sitzer, DI, McHugo, GJ, Mueser, KT (2007). A meta-analysis of cognitive remediation in schizophrenia. American Journal of Psychiatry 164, 1791–1802.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Mental Welfare Commission (2011). A Report Into the Use of Compulsory Community Treatment in Scotland. Mental Health Commission for Scotland: Edinburgh, Scotland.Google Scholar
Moncrieff, J, Smyth, M (1999). Community treatment orders – a bridge too far? Psychiatric Bulletin 23, 644–646.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mullen, R, Gibbs, A, Dawson, J (2006). Family perspective on community treatment orders: a New Zealand study. International Journal of Social Psychiatry 52, 469–478.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Munetz, MR, Galon, PA, Frese, FJ III (2003). The ethics of mandatory community treatment. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law 31, 173–183.Google ScholarPubMed
Munoz, M, Vazquez, C, Koegel, P, Sanz, J, Burnam, MA (1998). Differential patterns of mental disorders among the homeless in Madrid (Spain) and Los Angeles (USA). Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 33, 514–520.Google ScholarPubMed
Nelson, EA, Maruish, ME, Axler, JL (2000). Effects of discharge planning and compliance with outpatient appointments on readmission rates. Psychiatric Services 51, 885–889.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
NHS Information Centre (2012). Inpatients formally detained in hospitals under the Mental Health Act 1983 and patients subject to supervised community treatment – England, 2011–2012. Annual figures, England.Google Scholar
NHS Information Centre, For Health and Social Care (2009). In-patients formally detained in hospitals under the Mental Health Act 1983 and patients subject to supervised community treatment: 1998–99 to 2008–09. The Health and Social Care Information Centre.Google Scholar
O'Reilly, R (2004). Why are community treatment orders controversial? Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 49, 579–584.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
O Reilly, RL, Keegan, DL, Elias, JW (2000). A survey of the use of community treatment orders by psychiatrists in Saskatchewan. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 45, 79–81.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
O'Reilly, RL, Keegan, DL, Corring, D, Shrikhande, S, Natarajan, D (2006). A qualitative analysis of the use of community treatment orders in Saskatchewan. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 29, 516–524.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Phelan, JC, Sinkewicz, M, Castille, DM, Huz, S, Muenzenmaier, K, Link, BG (2010). Effectiveness and outcomes of assisted outpatient treatment in New York state. Psychiatric Services 61, 137–143.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Pinfold, V, Bindman, J (2001). Is compulsory community treatment ever justified? Psychiatric Bulletin 25, 268–270.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Power, P (1999). Community treatment orders: the Australian experience. The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry 10, 9–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Romans, S, Dawson, J, Mullen, R, Gibbs, A (2004). How mental health clinicians view community treatment orders: a national New Zealand survey. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 38, 836–841.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Russell, BJ (2011). How research ethics’ protections can contribute to public policy: the case of community treatment orders. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 34, 349–353.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Saks, ER (2002). Refusing Care: Forced Treatment and the Rights of the Mentally Ill. University of Chicago Press: Chicago, USA.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schwartz, K, O'Brien, A, Morel, V, Armstrong, M, Fleming, C, Moore, P (2010). Community treatment orders: the service user speaks exploring the lived experience of community treatment orders. International Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation 15, 39–50.Google Scholar
Spence, S, Stevens, R, Parks, R (2004). Cognitive dysfunction in homeless adults: a systematic review. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 97, 375–379.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Steadman, HJ, Gounis, K, Dennis, D, Hopper, K, Roche, B, Swartz, M, Robbins, PC (2001). Assessing the New York City involuntary outpatient commitment pilot program. Psychiatric Services 52, 330–336.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Stefan, S (1987). Preventive Commitment: The Concept and its Pitfalls. V s.n.: Westport, CT.Google Scholar
Swanson, JW, Swartz, MS, Borum, R, Hiday, VA, Wagner, HR, Burns, BJ (2000). Involuntary out-patient commitment and reduction of violent behaviour in persons with severe mental illness. British Journal of Psychiatry 176, 324–331.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Swartz, MS, Swanson, JW (2004). Involuntary outpatient commitment, community treatment orders, and assisted outpatient treatment: what's in the data? Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 49, 585–591.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Swartz, MS, Swanson, JW, Steadman, HJ, Robbins, PC, Monahan, J (2009). New York State Assisted Outpatient Treatment Program Evaluation. Duke University School of Medicine: Durham, NC.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Swartz, MS, Swanson, JW, Wagner, HR, Burns, BJ, Hiday, VA, Borum, R (1999). Can involuntary outpatient commitment reduce hospital recidivism? Findings from a randomized trial with severely mentally ill individuals. American Journal of Psychiatry 156, 1968–1975.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Swartz, MS, Swanson, JW, Wagner, HR, Hannon, MJ, Burns, BJ, Shumway, M (2003). Assessment of four stakeholder groups’ preferences concerning outpatient commitment for persons with schizophrenia. American Journal of Psychiatry 160, 1139–1146.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Vollmann, J, Bauer, A, Danker-Hopfe, H, Helmchen, H (2003). Competence of mentally ill patients: a comparative empirical study. Psychological Medicine 33, 1463–1471.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wahl, OF (1995). Media Madness: Public Images of Mental Illness. Ruther University Press: New Brunswick, NJ.Google Scholar
Weiden, PJ, Kozma, C, Grogg, A, Locklear, J (2004). Partial compliance and risk of rehospitalization among California Medicaid patients with schizophrenia. Psychiatric Services 55, 886–891.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed