Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T06:01:55.510Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Banamba slave exodus of 1905 and the decline of slavery in the Western Sudan*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Richard Roberts  and
Martin A. Klein
Richard Roberts
Affiliation:
Stanford University
Martin A. Klein
Affiliation:
University of Toronto
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

One of the most important changes to take place during the early colonial period was the transformation from slave labour to free labour. In French West Africa this resulted not from a policy decision by the French administration but from the massive departure of slaves in those societies most reliant on slave labour. The focal event was an exodus from Banamba, a Maraka town which had been a major centre both of the slave trade and of the exploitation of slave labour. During the period before the Banamba exodus, tensions were building up within various slave societies, tensions that reflected themselves in a gradual filtering away of slaves and in occasional slave revolts. The French were generally afraid to deal with these tensions and limited themselves to stopping the slave trade while reinforcing allied élites, most of whom were slave owners. There were three major factors in the exodus:

(1) Massive enslavement during the late nineteenth century created large reservoirs of slaves who were homogeneous and remembered a free state.

(2) The closing-off of recruitment pushed slave-owners to exploit slave labour more systematically.

(3) With the end of warfare and the opening of new opportunities in the cities and in the Senegambian peanut fields, slaves had increasing opportunities to go elsewhere.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 21 , Issue 3 , July 1980 , pp. 375 - 394
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1980

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 The Middle Niger valley is the area once dominated by the Bambara, up-river from the flood-plain of the interior delta, better watered than the Malinke-dominated Upper Niger region.

2 The subject of slavery and colonial rule is poorly treated, but see Smith, M. G., ‘Slavery and Emancipation in Two Societies,’ in The Plural Society in the British West Indies (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1965), 116–161Google Scholar; Grace, John, Domestic Slavery in West Africa (New York, 1975)Google Scholar; Derman, William, Serfs, Peasants and Socialists (Berkeley and Los Angeles, 1973)Google Scholar; Igbafe, Philip, ‘Slavery and Emancipation in Benin’, Journal of African History, xvi (1975), 409–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cooper, FrederickFrom Slaves to Squatters: Plantation Labor and Agriculture in Zanzibar and Coastal Kenya, 1890–1925, forthcoming.Google Scholar

3 The events are briefly discussed in Bouche, Denise, Les Villages de liberté en Afrique noire française 1887–1910 (Paris, 1968), 75CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Renault, François, L'abolition de l'escalavage au Sénégal (Paris, 1972) 59–62Google Scholar. For reference to similar events in Nigeria see Klein, Martin and Lovejoy, Paul, ‘Slavery in West Africa’, in Hogendorn, Jan and Gemery, Henry (eds.), The Uncommon Market (New York, 1979), 195–6Google Scholar; Lovejoy, Paul, ‘Indigenous African slavery’, Historical Reflections/Reflexions Historiques, vi (1979)Google Scholar; Oroge, E. A., ‘The institution of slavery in Yorubaland with particular reference to the nineteenth century’, unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Birmingham, 1971, 360–75.Google Scholar

4 Oral data used in this paper was gathered for Roberts' thesis. Tapes have been deposited at the Institut de Sciences Sociales, Bamako, and the Archives for Traditional Music at Indiana University.

5 On the Sisé foundation traditions see Roberts, Richard, ‘Long distance trade and production: Sinsani in the nineteenth century’, Journal of African History, xxi, 2 (1980).Google Scholar

6 The term ‘plantation’ as a specific form of African commercial agriculture using slave labour has been discussed by Lovejoy, Paul, ‘Plantations in the economy of the Sokoto caliphate’, Journal of African History, xix (1978)Google Scholar; Lovejoy, Paul, ‘The characteristics of plantations in the nineteenth century Sokoto caliphate (Islamic West Africa)’, American Historical Review, lxxiv (1979)Google Scholar; Cooper, Frederick, Plantation Slavery on the East Coast of Africa (New Haven, 1977)Google Scholar; Hogendorn, Jan, ‘The economics of slave use on two “plantations” in the Zaria Emirate of the Sokoto Caliphate’, International Journal of African Historical Studies x (1977).Google Scholar

7 Curtin, Philip, The Atlantic Slave Trade: a Census (Madison, 1969)Google Scholar; Curtin, Philip, Economic Change in Precolonial Africa: Senegambia in the Era of the Slave Trade (Madison, 1975)Google Scholar; Bazin, Jean, ‘Guerre et servitude á Ségou’, in Meillassoux, Claude (ed.), L'Esclavage en Afrique Précoloniale (Paris, 1975)Google Scholar; Roberts, R., ‘Production and reproduction of warrior states: Segu Bambara and Segu Tokolor’, International Journal of African Historical Studies, xiii (1980).Google Scholar

8 Roberts, , ‘Production and Reproduction….’Google Scholar

9 On the portions of slaves drawn from wars and kidnappings see the argument by Curtin, , Senegambia, chapter 6Google Scholar. Kidnapping continued throughout the Western Sudan, see Bechet, Eugene, Cinq Ans de Séjour en Soudan Français (Paris, 1899) p. 37Google Scholar; Pietri, Camille, Les Français au Niger (Paris, 1885), pp. 302–27Google Scholar. The Futanke of Segu raided southward into Geniekalari, the Bani, and into the Wasulu regions, see Gallieni, J. S., letter 14 October 1880Google Scholar, Archives Nationales, Republic of Senegal, Section Afrique Occidentale Française (hereafter, ASAOF).

10 The most recent attempt to measure the trans-Saharan slave trade is Austen, Ralph, ‘A census of the Trans-Saharan slave trade or approximating the uncountable’, in Hogendorn, Jan and Gemery, Henry (eds.), The Uncommon Market (New York, 1979)Google Scholar. See also Baier, Stephen and Lovejoy, Paul, ‘The Tuareg of the Central Sudan’, in Miers, Suzanne and Kopytoff, Igor, Slavery in Africa (Madison, 1975)Google Scholar; Edmond and Suzanne Bernus, ‘L'évolution de la condition servile chez les Touregs Kelgres’, in Meillassoux, Esclavage; Meyers, Allen, ‘Class, ethnicity and slavery: the origins of the Moroccan “Abid”’, International Journal of African Historical Studies, x (1977).Google Scholar

11 On the operation and role of the Bamako grain market, see Roberts, R., ‘The emergence of a grain market in Bamako, 1883–1908’, Canadian Journal of African Studies xiv, 1 (1980).Google Scholar

12 Meillassoux, Claude has collected the oral traditions of Banamba in 1967Google Scholar. On the basis of the chief list, which contains seventeen names, there was a cumulative reign of 116 years; this suggests an 1850s date. Personal communication, July 1977Google Scholar. See also Delafosse, Maurice, Haut-Sénégal-Niger (Paris, reprinted 1972), i, p. 277Google Scholar; Delafosse, Maurice, ‘Monographie historique du cercle de Bamako’, Renseignements Coloniaux (1910)Google Scholar. Archival sources support the immigration from Sokolo, see Notice sur le Cercle de Sokolo, 31 December 1891Google Scholar, ASAOF 1 G323; politique, Rapport, Région du Sahel, 25 June 1896Google Scholar, Archives Nationales, Republic of Mali (hereafter AM), 1 E 11.

13 Gallieni, J. S., ‘Les résultats de la campagne, 1887–88’, Bulletin de la Société de Géographie de Paris, x (1889)Google Scholar; Fawtier, , Rapport, 26 June 1905Google Scholar, Kayes ASAOF 15 G 170.

14 Mage, E. M., Voyage au Soudan Français (Paris, 1868), p. 168Google Scholar; Soleillet, Paul, Voyage á Ségou, 1878–79, redigé d'après les notes et journaux par Gabriel Gravier (Paris, 1887), p. 468.Google Scholar

15 Bulletin agricole et commercial, Bamako, June 1890Google Scholar, AM 1 R 31; Commandant of Medine to Commandant of Kayes, 24 Aug. 1898Google Scholar, ASAOF 15 G 116.

16 Commandant of Bamako, letter, 1 May 1886Google Scholar, AM 1 E 18.

17 Baillaud, Emile, Sur les routes du Soudan (Toulouse, 1902), p. 295Google Scholar; Captain Besançon, Rapport sur la tournée, 1897Google Scholar, AM 1E 19.

18 Service géographique, Population du Soudan d'après renseignements reçus, 1 April 1899Google Scholar, AM 1 D 21; Rapport politique, Bamako, May 1907Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19; Brevi, J. C.é, Etude sur l'esclavage, Cercle de Bamako, 1904Google Scholar, ASAOF K 19. Senegalese archives contain two series of slavery reports: those commanded by Grodet in 1894 and those by Roume, in 1904Google Scholar. The quality of these reports is highly variable; but used together with travellers' accounts and oral data they form a core of any detailed study of slavery in the Western Sudan. The reports are filed under ASAOF K14 and K19.

19 For a discussion of the different kinds of slave communities, see Lovejoy and Klein, ‘Slavery in West Africa’.

20 Claude Meillassoux, ‘Etat et conditions des esclaves à Gumbu (Mali) au XIXe siècle’, in Meillassoux, Esclavage; Pollet, Eric et Winter, Grace, La Société soninké (Djahunu, Mali) (Brussels, 1971).Google Scholar

21 Miers, and Kopytoff, , ‘African “slavery” as an institution of marginality’, in Slavery in AfricaGoogle Scholar. See also Klein, and Lovejoy, , ‘Slavery in West Africa’.Google Scholar

22 Rapport sur l'esclavage, Bamako, 1904Google Scholar, ASAOF K 19.

23 Baillaud, , Sur les routes du Soudan, 294.Google Scholar

24 This is an argument made by Genovese, Eugene in Roll, Jordan, Roll (New York, 1972)Google Scholar and The World the Slave-holders Made: Two Essays in Interpretation (New York, 1971)Google Scholar. It is also crucial to Cooper, Plantation Slavery.

25 Interview, Karamoko Sumaré, 6 January 1977Google Scholar, Segu. See also reports on slavery in Segu in ASAOF K 15 and K 19; Coste, , Coutumier juridiques, Segu, 1897Google Scholar, ASAOF 1 G 229; Penel, Julian, ‘Coutumes Soudanaises: Les coutumes des Malinkés, Sarakollés ou Soninkés, Khassonkés’, unpublished manuscript (1895)Google Scholar, Bibliothèque Nationale, i, 84.Google Scholar

26 See for contrast Hill, Polly, ‘From slavery to freedom: the case of farm slavery in Nigerian Hausaland’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, xviii (1976), 400–1.Google Scholar

27 Roberts, R., ‘Long distance trade and production’.Google Scholar

28 If all slaves did not know how to weave, all second-generation slaves did; interviews with Kuma, Baba, 13 March 1977Google Scholar, Segu; Binké Kuma, Baba, 19 December 1976Google Scholar, Sinsani; Sanogo, Amadu, 8 January 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani; Suragassi, Demba, 18 February 1977Google Scholar, Segu. Female slaves spun cotton into thread; for an excellent discussion of the capacity of female spinners see Meillassoux, , ‘Gumbu’, pp. 249–50Google Scholar. On the activities of slaves without weaving skills see the following interviews: Kuma, Baba, 28 December 1977Google Scholar, Segu; Binké, Kuma (session 1), 19 December 1976Google Scholar, Sinsani; Sanogo, Amadu, 8 January 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani; Suragassi, Demba, 18 February 1977Google Scholar, Segu. For those engaged in ancillary trading activities, the interviews with Haidara, Yahaya, 30 December 1976Google Scholar, Sinsani; Koné, Malamine, 7 February 1977Google Scholar, Segu; Koné, Sidi Yaya, 1 February 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani; al hajj Mangané, Ibrahim, 4 January 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani; Sumaré, Karamako, 6 January 1977Google Scholar, Segu. And finally, on the contribution of enslaved artisans see the interview with Koné, Sidi Yaya, 1 February 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani, whose grandfather had a jonbugu composed exclusively of slaves.

29 Interviews Biné Kuma, Baba (session 1), 19 February 1976Google Scholar, Sinsani; Sukulé, Binké, 21 March 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani; al hajj Mangané, Moktar, 19 February 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani; Sako, Baba, 9 January 1977Google Scholar, Segu; Sanogo, Amadu, 8 January 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani; Kouyaté, Musa, 26 January 1977Google Scholar, Segu. See also Brevié, , Rapport sur l'esclavage, Bamako, 1904Google Scholar, ASAOF K 19; Rapport sur la captivité, Segu, 1904Google Scholar, ASAOF K 19; Coste, , Coutumier juridiques, cercle de Segou, 1 April 1897Google Scholar, ASAOF 1 G 229.

30 In Gumbu, the kome xoore often possessed one or two slaves, and in Bouna, slaves occasionally had as many as ten slaves, see Meillassoux, , ‘Gumbu’, 240;Google Scholar Boutillier, ‘Les trois esclaves’, in Meillassoux, , Escalavage, 278Google Scholar. Data on jonmajon is drawn from the following interviews: Sisé, Amadu, 1 February 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani: Kuma, Baba (session 2), 13 March 1977Google Scholar, Segu; Sako, Baba, 9 January 1977Google Scholar, Segu; Sanogo, Amadu, 8 January 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani; Suragassi, Demba, 18 February 1977Google Scholar, Segu; Tigana, Temba (of Banamba), 24 February 1977Google Scholar, Segu; Traoré, Babajé (session 2), 19 February 1977Google Scholar, Sinsani; Traoré, Dahou, 11 February 1977Google Scholar, Sibila; Traoré, Mama, 10 February 1977Google Scholar, Niaro.

31 Péroz, Etienne, Au Soudan Français: Souvenirs de Guerre et de Mission (Paris: 1889), pp. 189–90Google Scholar. Note this area is quite far from the Maraka zones of the Middle Niger valley.

32 Klein, and Lovejoy, , 184–90Google Scholar; Meillassoux, , ‘Gumbu’.Google Scholar

33 Penel, , ‘Coutumes’, i, 96Google Scholar; Meillassoux, , ‘Gumbu’, 224Google Scholar. Among the Maraka, the slave child bore its mother's jamu or family name.

34 Klein, and Lovejoy, , 189–90.Google Scholar

35 Bouche, , 68Google Scholar; Brevié, , Rapport sur l'esclavage, ASAOF K 19;Google Scholar Rapport politique, Médine, , March 1901Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 1/14.

36 Brevié, Rapport sur l'esclavage, ASAOF K 19.Google Scholar

37 Ably, summed up in Renault (1972).Google Scholar

38 ASAOF K 11.

39 Renault, (1972), 30–38.Google Scholar

40 Renault, (1972), 48–50;Google Scholar ASAOF K 12 and K 25.

41 Kanya-Forstner, A. S., The Conquest of the Western Sudan: A Study in French Military Imperialism (Cambridge, 1969), 10.Google Scholar

42 Instructions to Commandant Djenné, 1893Google Scholar, ASAOF 1 D 137.

43 Général, Ordre 185 of 18 December 1888Google Scholar, ASAOF 15 G 154.

44 Archinard, to Gov. Sénégal, n.d. (probably 1888–1889)Google Scholar, ASAOF K 12; Bouche, , 60–64.Google Scholar

45 Grodet, to Commandant Région Sud, 12 September 1894Google Scholar, Archives Nationales, Section Outre-Mer, Paris (henceforth ANSOM), Soudan XIV 1. See also ASAOF 15 G 157.

46 Emmanuel Ghomsi, ‘Le Gouverneur Albert Grodet au Soudan Français (Novembre 1893 à Juin 1895)’, Maitrise, Mémoire de, Université de Dakar, 1968.Google Scholar

47 While not revoking Grodet's decrees, Trentinian made clear his desire that they not be rigorously enforced: ‘The decisions taken by my predecessor on the subject of the trade and circulation of captives within the colony appears to have given rise to certain misunderstandings which has led to them being applied with too much rigour’, Circular, 8 of 22 July 1895Google Scholar, ASAOF 15 G 157. As late as 1898, the French were taxing slave caravans though the trade was illegal. Comm. Médine, to Comm. Kayes, 24 August 1898Google Scholar, ASAOF 15 G 116. See also Trentinian's, circular 87 of 27 January 1899Google Scholar, ASAOF 15 G 162.

48 Ponty's title was Délégué Général, but he was as much a governor as any other.

49 Bouche, , 58–60Google Scholar; Rapport politique, 12 April 1900, ASAOF 2 G 1/12.

50 Decree, of 11 October 1900Google Scholar, ASAOF K 15; Bouche, , 102–103.Google Scholar

51 Circular, of 1 February 1901Google Scholar, ASAOF K 15.

52 Instruction accompanying decree of 10 November 1903, ASAOF K 16; see also Secretary-General Martial Merlin to Governor General, August 1904Google Scholar, ASAOF, M 79.

53 Circular, of 10 December 1903, ANSOM Sénégal, xiv, 28.Google Scholar

54 Roberts, , ‘The Emergence of a Grain Market in Bamako.’Google Scholar

55 Roberts, , ‘The Maraka…’, ch. 7.Google Scholar

56 Bouche, , 94–6Google Scholar; ASAOF 13 G 197–99 and 237; see esp. monthly report of 5 December 1896.

57 Rapport politique et militaire, Bamako, Month of July 1895Google Scholar, AM 1 E 18.

58 Rapport politique et militaire, Bamako, Month of August, 1895Google Scholar. AM 1 E 18.

59 Pollet and Winter quote an informant in Jahunu who described this process: ‘Mix male and female slaves in the same field, say the informants, and that will put them to shame,’ Société Soninké, p. 244.Google Scholar

60 Ponty, Wm., politique, Rapport, Haut-Sénégal-Niger, Month of February 1901Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 1–14. See also letter, commandant of Bamako, 1 March 1890Google Scholar, 1 March 1890, AM 1 E 18; Rapport politique et militaire, January 1895, Bamako, AM 1 E 18.

61 Bamako, report of February 1901Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 1–14.

62 Miscellaneous reports for 1901 in ASAOF 2 G 1–14.Google Scholar

63 ASAOF 2 G 1–14; see 2 G 1–15 on Songhai; see also 15 G 139.

64 ASAOF 2 G 1–14 and 2 G 4–13.Google Scholar

65 Rapport du commandant du cercle sur l'affaire de Nyamina, 22 May 1901Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 4–13.

66 Rapport politique, Segu, April 1901Google Scholar, AM 1 E 71.

67 Rapport politique, Haut Sénégal Niger, April 1901Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 1–14.

68 Rapport du Commandant de Cercle sur I'affaire de Nyamina, 22 May 1901Google Scholar, AM 1 E19; politique, Rapport, Segu, April 1901Google Scholar, AM 1 E71; Interview, Turé, Cémoko, Segu, 5 March 1977Google Scholar. There was also an incident involving Bella slaves near Dori. Monthly report of July 1902. ASAOF 2 G 2–8.

69 Ponty, Wm., Rapport politique, Haut-Sénégal-Niger, April 1901Google Scholar, ASAOF 2, G 1–14.

70 Rapport politique, Bamako, Month of April, 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19.

71 Rapport politique, Bamako, Month of May, 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19; Rapport politique d'ensemble du Soudan, 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E 12. See also Renault, Abolition.

72 Rapport politique d'ensemble du Soudan, 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E12; Rapport politique, Bamako, May, 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E19.

73 Roume, Governor, instructions to administrators, 25 April 1905Google Scholar, ASAOF K 24, quoted in Renault, , 58.Google Scholar

74 Rapport politique, Bamako April 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19 and Fawtier's remarks to slaves, telgram to Governor General, 14 June 1904, Banamba, , ASAOF 15 G 170.Google Scholar

75 Roume, , Telegram to governor at Kayes, 26 May 1905Google Scholar, Gorée, , ASAOF 15 G 170.Google Scholar

76 Rapport politique, Bamako, May 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19.

77 Fawtier, , telegram, 29 May 1905Google Scholar, Kayes, , ASAOF 15 G 170.Google Scholar

78 Roume telegram, 26 May 1905Google Scholar, Gorée, , ASAOF 15 G 170Google Scholar. A similar note appears in Roume's telegram, 21 May 1905Google Scholar, Gorée, , ASAOF 15 G 170Google Scholar. Terms like serviteur and domestique were regularly used by the administrators for slaves during this period, apparently in the hope that changing the term would transform the thing itself.

79 Fawtier, , telegram, 29 May 1905Google Scholar, Kayes, ASAOF 15 G 170.

80 Fawtier, , Rapport, 26 June 1905Google Scholar, Kayes, ASAOF 1 5 G 170.

81 Rapport politique d'ensemble du Soudan, 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E 12. Thousands more arms were secretly dispatched to the Moors and other Maraka towns; see Fawtier, , Rapport, 26 June 1905Google Scholar, Kayes, ASAOF 15 G 170.

82 Rapport politique d'ensemble du Soudan, 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E 12; Fawtier, , Rapport, 26 June 1905Google Scholar, Kayes, ASAOF 15 G 170.

83 Fawtier, , Rapport, 26 June 1905Google Scholar, Kayes, ASAOF 15 G 170.

84 Ibid.

85 Rapport politique, Bamako, April 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19.

86 Rapport politique d'ensemble du Soudan, 1905Google Scholar, AM 1 E 12; Fawtier, , Rapport, 26 June 1905Google Scholar, Kayes, ASAOF 15 G 170.

87 Rapport sur la captivité, 10 June 1905Google Scholar, ASAOF K 16; this is the same position as Fawtier, , Rapport 26 June 1905Google Scholar, ASAOF 15 G 170.

88 Brevié, , Rapport sur l'esclavage, Bamako, 1904Google Scholar, ASAOF K 19; see also Deherme, , Afrique Occidentale Française, who quotes Brevié's figures, p. 295Google Scholar. For a similar analysis of related Soninke see March 1901 report from Médine ASAOF 2 G 1/14.

89 Rapport politique, Bamako, April 1906Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19.

90 Rapport politique, Bamako, April 1906Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19.

91 Lt. Gov. to Resident, Banamba, 7 May 1906Google Scholar, AM 1 R 17.

92 Rapport politique, Haut-Sénégal-Niger, May 1906Google Scholar ASAOF, 2 G 6–6.

93 Rapport politique, Bamako, May 1906Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19.

94 Rapport général sur la situation politique du cercle de Bamako pendant 1906Google Scholar, AM 1 E 19.

95 Renault, , 66–75 and 102–104.Google Scholar

96 Lt. Gov. to Gov. Gen., 24 July 1907Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 7–3.

97 Assorted political reports, ASAOF series 2 G.

98 Rapport politique, 4th quarter 1909Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 9–12.

99 Gov. Gen. to Min. Colonies, 11 July 1905Google Scholar, ASAOF 15 G 170.

100 Rapport politique, 17 May 1908Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 8–1.

101 Rapport politique d'ensemble du Soudan, 1910Google Scholar, AM 1 E 12.

102 Rapport politique, 17 May 1908Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 8–1.

103 Rapport politique, 20 June 1910Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 10–17.

104 Report of 30 March 1908Google Scholar, ASAOF K 29.

105 Bouche, , 162.Google Scholar

106 Gov. Gen. to Lt. Gov., July 1911Google Scholar, ASAOF K 28.

107 Lt. Gov. to Gov. Gen., 11 August 1911Google Scholar, ASAOF 2 G 11–11.

108 Note à M. le Governeur Général sur la captivité en A.O.F., 14 September 1909Google Scholar, ASAOF K 26.

109 Gov. Gen. to Consul Général d'Angleterre, 22 February 1911Google Scholar, ASAOF K 26.

110 Gov. Gen. to Min. Colonies, 23 Dec 1912Google Scholar, ASAOF K 26.

111 Thus, very few quarterly reports announce any cercle losing more than 1,000–2,000 at one time, and most are much lower. In 1908, the estimated annual departure for Haut-Sénégal-Niger was only 15,000. Rapport Politique, 5 February 1909, ASAOF 2 G 8–1. Of course, it is not clear that all slaves sought passes, and in 1906, it seems clear that the administration found itself unable to keep count.

112 Gov. Gen. to Min. Colonies, 14 January 1913Google Scholar, ANSOM AOF I 19.

113 Brevié, Rapport sur l'esclavage, Bamako, ASAOF K 19Google Scholar; Fawtier, to Gov. Gen., 26 June 1905Google Scholar, ASAOF 15 G 170.