Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T08:37:27.442Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Muqdisho in the Nineteenth Century: A Regional Perspective1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

Edward A. Alpers
Edward A. Alpers
Affiliation:
University of California, Los Angeles
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

During the nineteenth century Muqdisho experienced a significant revival in its fortunes after several centuries of gradual decline from its medieval heyday. While it remained on the periphery of the Omani empire on the coast of East Africa, steady commercial penetration of Indian merchant capital based at Zanzibar inexorably drew the entire Benaadir coast into the Omani orbit. Massive infusions of slave labour transformed agricultural commodity production in the Benaadir hinterland and created a new basis for ruling-class collaboration between town and country. At Muqdisho these external factors intertwined with established internal rivalries which were based on moiety competition and the traditional search for supporting alliances in the hinterland. The end result of this complex process was increased competition and tension between the town moieties that affected both the spatial segregation of the two quarters and enabled first Omani Zanzibar and then Italy to insinuate themselves into a dominant mediating position within the urban community. At the end of the century the urban culture of Muqdisho had also been influenced by the incorporation of a large slave population. While all of these changes indicate that Muqdisho was integrally a part of the wider coastal region of East Africa, other cultural evidence establishes no less that it was still uniquely Soomaali within that context.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 24 , Issue 4 , October 1983 , pp. 441 - 459
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1983

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

2 Among many important recent papers, three which are especially pertinent here are De Vere Allen, James, ‘Swahili culture and the nature of east coast settlement’, International Journal of African Historical Studies, XIV, 2 (1981), 306–334CrossRefGoogle Scholar, ‘The “Shirazi” problem in east African coastal history’, Paideuma, XXVIII (1982), 9–27Google Scholar, and ‘Settlements on the East African coast: origins, development and spread’, draft chapter for inclusion in David, Brokensha and Merrick, Posnansky (eds.), The Indigenous African Town.Google Scholar I am grateful to my colleague, Merrick Posnansky, for permission to cite this paper before publication.

3 Pouwels, Randall Lee, ‘Islam and Islamic leadership in the coastal communities of East Africa, 1700 to 1920’, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, UCLA, 1979.Google Scholar

4 Cooper, Frederick, Plantation Slavery on the East Coast of Africa (New Haven and London, 1977)Google Scholar; Ylvisaker, Marguerite, Lamu in the Nineteenth Century: Land, Trade, and Politics (Boston, 1979)Google Scholar; Menon, Ramachandran, ‘Zanzibar in the nineteenth century: aspects of urban development in an East African coast town’, unpublished M.A. thesis, UCLA, 1978.Google Scholar

5 See, for example, Cooper, , ‘Africa and the world economy’, The African Studies Review, XXIV, 2/3 (1981), 13–15.Google Scholar

6 For a convenient summary of the evidence, see Nègre, Andre, ‘A propos de Mogadiscio au moyen âge’, Annuaire de l'Université d'Abidjan, série I (Histoire), tome V (1977), 5–38Google Scholar also Chittick, Neville, ‘Mediaeval Mogadishu’, Paideuma, XXVIII (1982), 45–62.Google Scholar

7 Cassanelli, Lee V., The Shaping of Somali Society: Reconstructing the History of a Pastoral People, 1600–1900 (Philadelphia, 1982), ch. 3.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

8 Documentos sobre os Portugueses em Moçambique e na Africa Central, I (Lisboa, 1962), 71, 537–9Google Scholar; v (Lisboa, 1966), 381.

9 John, R. Jensen (ed.), Journal and Letter Book of Nicholas Buckeridge 1651–1654 (Minneapolis, 1973), 46.Google Scholar

10 Cassanelli, , Shaping, 73–74, 93–94.Google Scholar

11 Ferrandi, Ugo, Lugh: Emporio commercial sul Giuba (Roma, 1903), 215.Google Scholar

12 India Office Records, London: Marine, L/MAR/c/s86, report of Lieutenant Hardy, M., September 1811, fl. 170 and v.Google Scholar

13 Ibid., report of Captain Smee, Thomas, 6 April 1811, fl. 93.Google Scholar The identity of this Soomaali chief cannot be determined, as a result of both Smee's corrupt rendering of his patronymic and the conflicting genealogies extant in Guillain, Charles,Documents sur l'histoire, la géographie et le commerce de l'Afrique Orientate, II (Paris, 1856–1858), 525Google Scholar; Robecchi-Bricchetti, Luigi, Somalia e Benadir (Milano, 1899), 389–390Google Scholar; and Caniglia, Giuseppe, Genti di Somalia (München, 1921), 58–65.Google Scholar

14 Smee's report, fl. 95.

15 Owen, W. F. W., Narrative of Voyages to Explore the Shores of Africa, Arabia, and Madagascar, I (London, 1833), 355, 359.Google Scholar

16 Nicholls, C. S., The Stuahili Coast (London, 1971), 297.Google Scholar

17 Owen, , Narrative, 1, 357–358.Google Scholar

18 See Alpers, Edward A., ‘Futa Benaadir: continuity and change in the traditional cotton textile industry of southern Somalia, c. 1840–1980’, forthcoming in Catherine, Coquery-Vidrovitch (ed.), Entreprises et entrepreneurs en Afrique aux 19eme et 20eme siècles (Paris, 1983), 79–100.Google Scholar

19 See Cassanelli, , Shaping, 156–159.Google Scholar

20 Guillain, , Documents, II, 590–591.Google Scholar

21 Ibid., II, 526, III, 142. According to Islao Mahadala there was a major drought in the nineteenth century that necessitated the importation of food from Zanzibar: interviewed in Shingaani, 15 November 1980. My research in Muqdisho has been carried out in collaboration with the Soomaali Academy of Arts and Science, whose officers provided invaluable support and who assigned me an energetic team of local counterparts without whose assistance all field work would have been impossible. To Maxamed Cabdi Allamagan, Axmed Yuusuf Faarax, and Ciismaan Yuusuf Maxamed I am thus indebted for carrying out and transcribing all of these interviews, as well as for translating some of them. At UCLA I am no less indebted to Saeed Muktag Samatar for translating the bulk of this material. My research began while teaching at the Somali National University, College of Education, Lafoole, with assistance from a Fulbright Senior Scholar Fellowship and has continued to be supported by the Research Committee of the Academic Senate of UCLA.

22 Cassanelli, , Shaping, 135–146, 187.Google Scholar

23 Caniglia, , Genti, 62.Google Scholar

24 Cerrina-Ferroni, G., Benadir (Roma, 1911), 27–28.Google Scholar

25 Guillain, , Documents, II, 527Google Scholar; Christopher, W., ‘Extracts from a Journal by Lieut. W. Christopher… on the E. Coast of Africa. Dated 8th May, 1843’, Journal of the Royal Geographical Society, XIV (1844), 93, 99Google Scholar, who also calls the rival to Imam Axmed a nephew.

26 Guillain, , Documents, II, 527Google Scholar; Christopher, , ‘Extract’, 90, 93, 99.Google Scholar Cf. interview with Islao Mahadala for general confirmation of this split.

27 See Ferrandi, , Lugh, 138–139.Google Scholar

28 Guillain, , Documents, II, 527, 528, n. 1; 547, n. 1.Google Scholar

29 Christopher, , ‘Extract’, 98Google Scholar; Guillain, , Documents, II, 511.Google Scholar

30 Ibid., II, 525–526.

31 Ibid, II, 504.

32 Ibid., II, 529–530.

33 Christopher, , ‘Extract’, 87–88.Google Scholar

34 Guillain, , Documents, II, 507, 514, 516, 520, 526.Google Scholar

35 Martin, Esmond B. and Ryan, T. C. I., ‘The slave trade of the Bajun and Benadir Coasts’, Transafrican Journal of History, IX, 1/2 (1980), 103–132.Google Scholar

36 Guillain, , Documents, II, 532–533Google Scholar; Archives Nationales, Section d'Outre-Mer, Paris: Océan Indien, 2/10 (2), Guillain, , ‘Exploration de la côte orientale d'Afrique… pendant les années 1846–47–48 & 49: Rapport commercial - Ière partie’, 7–9; British Parliamentary Papers (Slave Trade), 91 (cited hereafter as BPP 91, etc.), 268, ‘Produce of the Zanzibar Dominions on the Coast and adjacent islands imported in Zanzibar in 1867–68’ Zanzibar Blue Books 1875–1880, India Office Library, 96–7, cited inGoogle ScholarBrown, Walter, ‘A pre-colonial history of Bagamoyo’, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Boston University, 1971, 250, 253Google Scholar; Sorrentino, Giorgio, Ricordi del Benadir (Napoli, 1912), 381.Google Scholar

37 Cassanelli, , Shaping, 137, 140.Google Scholar

38 A.N.S.O.M., Océan Indien 2/10 (2), Guillain, , ‘Exploration’, 57.Google Scholar

39 Christopher, , ‘Extract’, 85, 87.Google Scholar

40 Guillain, , Documents, II, 530–531Google Scholar; A.N.S.O.M., Ocean Indien 2/10 (2), Guillain, , ‘Exploration’, 68, 13.Google Scholar

41 BPP 91,268.

42 Kirk, John, ‘Visit to the coast of Somali-land’, Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society, XXVII (1873), 341.Google Scholar

43 BPP 53, 337, Kirk, , ‘Memorandum on the Somali slave trade’, in Kirk to Granville, Zanzibar, 31 May 1873.Google Scholar

44 Brown, , ‘Bagamoyo’, 250, 253.Google Scholar

45 Sorrentino, , Ricordi, 381.Google Scholar

46 Cooper, , Plantation Slavery, esp. 84–86, 100–101.Google Scholar

47 Christopher, , ‘Extract’, 85, 79, 80.Google Scholar

48 Krapf, J. L., Travels, Researches, and Missionary Labours During an Eighteen Years' Residence in Eastern Africa (London, 1968; Ist ed., 1860), 112Google Scholar; Russell, C. E. B., General Rigby, Zanzibar and the Slave Trade (London, 1935), 190Google Scholar; BPP 92, 315, Minutes of Evidence taken before the Royal Commission on Fugitive Slaves, Captain Sullivan, George L., II March 1876Google Scholar, Q. 297–298; BPP 7, 28, ‘The slave trade on the east coast of Africa’, Select Committee Report, 1871, H. A. Sullivan, para. 357.Google Scholar

49 Kirk, , ‘Visit’, 342.Google Scholar

50 BPP 53, 337–8, Kirk, , ‘Memorandum’Google Scholar; BPP 91, 381, 440, Frere, H. B., ‘Report on a visit to Bagamoyo and the Somali Coast’, 5 April 1873Google Scholar; BPP 92, 315, Minutes of Evidence, Rear-Admiral Gumming, Arthur, II March 1876Google Scholar, Q. 202–206.

51 Martin, and Ryan, , ‘Slave trade’, 122.Google Scholar

52 BPP 53, 338, Kirk, , ‘Memorandum’Google Scholar; BPP 91, 440, Frere, , ‘Report'.Google Scholar

53 Cassanelli, , Shaping, 169–170.Google Scholar For the cholera epidemic, see also interview with Islao Mahadala and stories associated with the Xaji Cali Arbow Xuseenka mosque on the edge of Xamarweyn.

54 Revoil, Georges, ‘Voyage chez les Benadirs, les Çomalis, et les Bayouns en 1882–1883’, Le Tour du Monde, XLIX (1885), 39.Google Scholar

55 Ibid.. 36; cf. the illustration in Guillain's Atlas, which depicts a camel operating such a press.

56 Sorrentino, , Ricordi, 22Google Scholar interviews with Adde, Ciisman Nuur, Xamarweyn, 23 May 1981Google Scholar, and with Xamuud, Maolin Maow, Xamarweyn, 25 March 1981.Google Scholar

57 Interview with Islao Mahadala; Alpers, , ‘Futa Benaadir’, 79–84.Google Scholar

58 Lewis, I. M., Peoples of the Horn of Africa (London, 1955), 31–33, 51–55Google Scholar; Allen, ‘Settlements’, 72.Google Scholar

59 Sorrentino, , Ricordi, 203–204, 52.Google Scholar

60 Robecchi-Bricchetti, , Dal Benadir - Lettre illustrate alia Società Antischiavista d'Italia (Milano, 1904), 58.Google Scholar

61 Ibid. 68–69.

62 Ibid. 108, 63.

63 Quoted in Cassanelli, , Shaping, 225.Google Scholar

64 Guillain, , Documents, II, 530Google Scholar; Nicholls, , Siuahili Coast, 292.Google Scholar

65 Cooper, , Plantation Slavery, 140.Google Scholar

66 Guillain, , Documents, II, 529.Google Scholar

67 Ministère des Affaires Étrangères, Paris: Correspondence Politique, Zanzibar 3/109 and v., Jablonski, to M.A.E., Zanzibar, 11 January 1863Google Scholar; Russell, , Rigby, 96–97.Google Scholar

68 Guillain, , Documents, II, 527.Google Scholar

69 Cassanelli, , Shaping, 175Google Scholar; see also, BPP 51, 60, Captain S. M. Savine Pasley to Commodore Chas. T. Hillyar, 29 November 1866, which suggests from information gathered at Baraawe that the sultan of Geledi's attitude towards the sultan of Zanzibar may have reflected a diminution in his own political authority; Caniglia, , Genti, 64.Google Scholar

70 BPP 91, 381, Frere, , ‘Report’Google Scholar; Nicholls, , Swahili Coast, 292.Google Scholar

71 Revoil, , ‘Voyage’, 36, 38Google Scholar; cf. Allen, , ‘Settlements’, 6, 63–64.Google Scholar

72 Robecchi-Bricchetti, , Somalia, 593, n. I.Google Scholar

73 Cooper, , Plantation Slavery, 140 and n. I.Google Scholar

74 Sorrentino, , Ricordi, 425Google Scholar; see Robecchi-Bricchetti, , Somalia, 195Google Scholar, for a photograph of Tharia Topan's commercial establishment at Baraawe.

75 Sorrentino, , Ricordi, 13–14, 64–65, 84, 170–171, 388Google Scholar; for parallel practice at Luuq, see Ferrandi, , Lugh, 341–5.Google Scholar The Chief Kaadi of Muqdisho was at this time drawn from the reer Faaqi of Xamarweyn: Cerrina-Ferroni, , Benadir, 28.Google Scholar

76 Sorrentino, , Ricordi, 429, 134.Google Scholar

77 Robecchi-Bricchetti does not provide any specific figures for the vania population of Muqdisho, lumping them together with Arabs in both Shingaani (200) and Xamarweyn (270). He also includes an unknown category of people called Indavuena, which was a nickname for the Zanzibar governor of Muqdisho, Suliman bin Ahmed, and may have been applied to all of the Zanzibaris there, 50 of whom resided in Shingaani and 40 in Xamarweyn: Robecchi-Bricchetti, , Dal Benadir, 71Google Scholar; Bahasan, , ‘Mogadishu - down the corridors of history’ Heegan, 21 March 1981, 3.Google Scholar In 1907 the Italian Governor claimed that Indian traders lived exclusively in Xamarweyn: Cerrina-Ferroni, , Benadir, 22.Google Scholar

78 Revoil, , ‘Voyage’, 38, 49–50, 52.Google Scholar

79 Robecchi-Bricchetti, , Somalia, 107.Google Scholar See also, Mantegazza, Vico, Il Benadir (Milano, 1908), 135.Google Scholar

80 Allen, , ‘Settlements’, 59.Google Scholar

81 Pouwels, ‘Islam and Islamic leadership’, ch. 5, quoted at 212. See also, Ranger, T. O., Dance and Society in Eastern Africa (Berkeley & Los Angeles, 1975)Google Scholar; Landberg, Pamela Weaver, ‘Kinship and community in a Tanzanian coastal village (East Africa)’, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Davis, 1977, chs. II and 12.Google Scholar

82 Guillain, , Documents, II, 511–514, 546–547.Google Scholar

83 Revoil, , ‘Voyage’, 38.Google Scholar

84 Robecchi-Bricchetti, , Somalia, 114–117Google Scholar; Sorrentino, , Ricordi, 401, 33–34Google Scholar; Cerrina-Ferroni, , Benadir, 28–31, 23–28.Google Scholar

85 Cassanelli, , Shaping, ch. 6, especially 207–253.Google Scholar

86 Pouwels, , ‘Islam and Islamic leadership’, 223–224.Google Scholar

87 Revoil, , ‘Voyage’, 55, and engraving on 41.Google Scholar

88 Interview with Islao Mahadala; Lewis, , Peoples, 62, 64–65Google Scholar; Pàntano, Gherardo, Nel Benadir-La Città di Merca e la Regione Bimal (Livorno, 1910), 60Google Scholar; Gray, J. M., ‘Nairuzi or Siku ya Mwaka’, Tanganyika Notes and Records, XXXVII (1955), 1–21Google Scholar; Strobel, Margaret, Muslim Women in Mombasa 1890–1975 (New Haven, London, 1979), 81–84.Google Scholar

89 Sorrentino, , Ricordi, 340–341, 102–105Google Scholar, and photographs on 61 and 101; see Mantegazza, , Benadir, 141Google Scholar, for reference to the violence that sometimes marked Lab.

90 See, for example, Prins, A. H. J., The Swahili-Speaking Peoples of Zanzibar and the East African Coast (London, 1967), 115Google Scholar; Allen, J. W. T. (ed.), The Customs of the Swahili People (Berkeley, Los Angeles, 1981), 192–3.Google Scholar

91 Interview with Islao Mahadala; cf. Strobel, Muslim Women, ch. 8. I have developed this theme in a paper on ‘Dance and society in nineteenth-century Muqdisho’ for the Second Congress of the Somali Studies International Association, Hamburg, August 1983.Google Scholar

92 See Revoil, , ‘Voyage’, 62.Google Scholar

93 Interview with Islao Mahadala; Prins, , Swahili-Speaking Peoples, 115Google Scholar; El-Zein, Abdul Hamid, The Sacred Meadows (Evanston, 1974)Google Scholar; Wijeyewardene, G. E. T., ‘Some aspects of village solidarity in Ki-Swahili speaking communities of Kenya and Tanganyika’, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Cambridge University, 1961Google Scholar; Pouwels, , ‘Islam and Islamic leadership’, 593–598.Google Scholar

94 See, for example, Nimtz, August H. Jr, Islam and Politics in East Africa (Minneapolis, 1980), 98.Google Scholar