Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-mlc7c Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T13:37:34.769Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

When Benefit-Cost Analysis Becomes Optional: Regulatory Analysis at the Consumer Product Safety Commission in the CPSIA Era

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  25 July 2019

Deborah V. Aiken
Deborah V. Aiken*
Affiliation:
U.S. Department of Transportation, 1200 New Jersey Avenue SE, Washington, DC20590, USA, e-mail: dtvaiken@gmail.com
*
e-mail: dtvaiken@gmail.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In this study, I examine how the regulatory analysis practices of the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), an independent regulatory agency, changed when the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA) of 2008 relaxed its statutory obligations to conduct benefit-cost analysis (BCA). When given discretion, the agency dropped the practice despite significant institutional experience in conducting regulatory BCA and a history of using BCA as a key input to regulatory decisions. While the decision reflects an agency belief that omitting BCA would speed rulemaking under the CPSIA, the results have been mixed. Moreover, choosing to forego BCA-based decision-making fundamentally changed the agency’s regulatory portfolio. In contrast to the typical rule CPSC historically supported with BCA findings, many of the CPSIA rules impose significant economic burdens yet appear to yield negligible benefits. The CPSC would have been unlikely to have pursued the CPSIA rulemakings on its own because it could not have made the necessary BCA findings.

Keywords

law and regulationother social policy.K32D18.
Type
Article
Information
Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis , Volume 10 , Issue 3 , Fall 2019 , pp. 404 - 433
Copyright
© Society for Benefit-Cost Analysis, 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

The author is the Director of Regulatory Analysis at the U.S. Department of Transportation and the former supervisor of the Economics Directorate at the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. All opinions are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the official position of the U.S. Department of Transportation or the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission.

References

Chronic Hazard Advisory Panel on Phthalates and Phthalate Alternatives. 2014. Report to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Available at https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/CHAP-REPORT-With-Appendices.pdf (accessed July 10, 2019)Google Scholar
Copeland, Curtis W. 2013. “Economic Analysis and Independent Regulatory Agencies.” Draft report for the consideration of the Administrative Conference of the United States.Google Scholar
Durrett, Jordan. 2015. A Decade of Data: An In-depth Look at 2014 and a Ten-Year Retrospective on Children’s Product Recalls. Available at http://www.kidsindanger.org/docs/research/2015_KID_Recall_Report.pdf. (accessed April 4, 2019)Google Scholar
Ellig, Jerry, and Horney, Michael. 2016. “Preventing a Regulatory Train Wreck: Mandated Regulation and the Cautionary Tale of Positive Train Control.” Mercatus Working Paper. Arlington, VA: Mercatus Center at George Mason University.Google Scholar
Flaherty, Eileen. 2009 “Safety First: The Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008.” Loyola Consumer Law Review, 21(3): 372–391.Google Scholar
Fraas, Arthur, and Lutter, Randall. 2011. “On the Economic Analysis of Regulations at Independent Regulatory Commissions.” Administrative Law Review, 63(Special Edition): 213–241.Google Scholar
Freedman, Seth, Kearney, Melissa, and Lederman, Mara. 2012. “Product Recalls, Imperfect Information, and Spillover Effects: Lessons from the Consumer Response to the 2007 Toy Recalls.” The Review of Economics and Statistics, 94(2): 499–516.Google Scholar
Logomasini, Angela. 2015. CPSC’s Scientific Shenanigans on Phthalates. Available at https://cei.org/blog/cpscs-scientific-shenanigans-phthalates. (accessed April 4, 2019)Google Scholar
Office of Management and Budget, and Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs. 2003. Circular A-4. Available at https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/whitehouse.gov/files/omb/assets/regulatory_matters_pdf/a-4.pdf. (accessed April 5, 2019)Google Scholar
Pogue, Eric R. 2007. “The Catastrophe Model of Risk Regulation and the Regulatory Legacy of Three Mile Island and Love Canal.” Penn State Environmental Law Review, 15(3): 463–493.Google Scholar
Schwartz, Jeff, and Nelson, Alexandrea. 2016. Cost-Benefit Analysis and the Conflict Minerals Rule.” Administrative Law Review, 68(1): 287–357.Google Scholar
Stegon, David. 2017. “NGOs File Lawsuit against CPSC over Phthalate Rule.” ChemicalWatch, January 3, 2017. Available at https://chemicalwatch.com/51887/ngos-file-lawsuit-against-cpsc-over-phthalate-rule.Google Scholar
Story, Louis, and Barbozaaug, David. 2007. “Mattel Recalls 19 Million Toys Sent From China.” New York Times, August 15, 2007. Available at http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/15/business/worldbusiness/15imports.html.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 1995a. Requirements for Child-Resistant Packaging; Mouthwash Packages Containing 3 Grams or More of Ethanol. 60 FR 4536.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 1995b. Requirements for Child-Resistant Packaging; Packages Containing 250 mg or More of Naproxen. 60 FR 38671.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 1995c. Requirements for Child-Resistant Packaging; Requirements for Products Containing Lidocaine or Dibucaine. 60 FR 17992.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 1997. Requirements for Child-Resistant Packaging; Packages Containing More Than 50 mg of Ketoprofen. 62 FR 28798.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 1998a. Requirements for Child-Resistant Packaging; Household Products With More Than 50 mg of Elemental Fluoride and More Than 0.5 Percent Elemental Fluoride; and Modification of Exemption for Oral Prescription Drugs with Sodium Fluoride. 63 FR 29949.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 1998b. Requirements for Child-Resistant Packaging; Minoxidil Preparations With More Than 14 mg of Minoxidil Per Package. 63 FR 63602.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 1999. Requirements for Child-Resistant Packaging; Household Products Containing Methacrylic Acid. 64 FR 32799.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2001. Child-Resistant Packaging for Certain Over-The-Counter Drug Products. 66 FR 4011.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2006a. CPSC Approves New Flammability Standard for Mattresses. Available at https://www.cpsc.gov/content/cpsc-approves-new-flammability-standard-for-mattresses-federal-standard-could-prevent-270. (accessed April 4, 2019)Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2006b. Standard for the Flammability (Open Flame) of Mattress Sets. 71 FR 13472.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2008. Certificates of Compliance (Proposed Rule). 73 FR 68328.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2009. Requirements for Consumer Registration of Durable Infant or Toddler Products. 74 FR 68668.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2010a. Safety Standard for Infant Bath Seats. 75 FR 31691.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2010b. Safety Standard for Infant Walkers. 75 FR 35266.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2010c. Safety Standards for Full-Size Baby Cribs and Non-Full-Size Baby Cribs. 75 FR 81766.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2011a. Safety Standard for Toddler Beds. 76 FR 22019.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2011b. Testing and Labeling Pertaining to Product Certification. 76 FR 69482.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2011c. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission Strategic Plan 2011-2016. Available at https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/2011strategic.pdf. (accessed April 4, 2019).Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2012a. Commissioner Nancy A, Nord. Statement before the Subcommittee on Commerce, Manufacturing, and Trade of the Committee on Energy and Commerce of the United States House of Representatives: August 2, 2012. Available at https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/nord08022012_0.pdf. (accessed April 8, 2019)Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2012b. Requirements for Child-Resistant Packaging: Products Containing Imidazolines Equivalent to 0.08 Milligrams or More. 77 FR 73294.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2012c. Safety Standard for Bassinets and Cradles (Supplemental Notice of Proposed Rulemaking). 77 FR 64055.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2012d. Safety Standard for Infant Swings. 77 FR 66703.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2012e. Safety Standard for Portable Bed Rails. 77 FR 12182.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2012f. Staff Report to Congress Pursuant to Section 104(e) of the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008: Recall Notification Technology. Available at https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/pdfs/blk_pdf_ReporttoCongressPursuantSection104(e)RecallNotificationEffectiveness.pdf. (accessed April 4, 2019)Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2013a. Certificates of Compliance. 78 FR 28080.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2013b. Safety Standard for Bassinets and Cradles. 78 FR 63019.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2013c. Safety Standard for Hand-Held Infant Carriers. 78 FR 73415.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2013d. Safety Standard for Play Yards. 78 FR 50328.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2014a. Prohibition of Children’s Toys and Child Care Articles Containing Specified Phthalates (Proposed Rule). 79 FR 78324.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2014b. Safety Standard for Bedside Sleepers. 79 FR 2581.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2014c. Safety Standard for Carriages and Strollers. 79 FR 13208.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2014d. Safety Standard for Soft Infant and Toddler Carriers. 79 FR 17422.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2015. Safety Standard for Frame Child Carriers. 80 FR 11113.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2016a. Commission Briefing Package. Ballot Vote: Final Rule – Safety Standard for Sling Carriers. Available at https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/Final%20Rule%20-%20Safety%20Standard%20for%20Sling%20Carriers%20-%20December%2021%202016.pdf. (Accessed April 8, 2019)Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2016b. Safety Standard for Portable Hook-On Chairs. 81 FR 17062.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2017a. Prohibition of Children’s Toys and Child Care Articles Containing Specified Phthalates. 82 FR 41163.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2017b. Safety Standard for Children’s Folding Chairs and Stools. 82 FR 59505.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2017c. Safety Standard for Infant Bath Tubs. 82 FR 15615.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2017d. Safety Standard for Infant Bouncer Seats. 82 FR 43470.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2017e. Safety Standard for Sling Carriers. 82 FR 8671.Google Scholar
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 2018. Recall Effectiveness Workshop Report. Available at https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/Recall_Effectiveness_Workshop_Report-2018.pdf?R1VyLltrl8M__id.2vkAklHoUZjaSCab. (accessed April 8, 2019)Google Scholar
U.S. Government Accountability Office. 1997. Consumer Product Safety Commission: Better Data Needed to Help Identify and Analyze Potential Hazards. Report GAO/HEHS-97-147.Google Scholar
USA Today. 2007. “Mattel Recalls 9M Chinese-Made Toys in the U.S.” USA Today. August 15, 2007. Available at https://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/world/2007-08-13-china-products_N.htm.Google Scholar
White, Joshua. 2016. “Quantified Cost-Benefit Analysis at the SEC.” Administrative Law Review Accord, 2(1): 53–79.Google Scholar