Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T03:44:19.013Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The “O'Brien Ethic” as an Interpretative Problem

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 November 2013

John M. Regan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The necessity of adopting or redefining illiberal measures—such as torture, internment, or targeted-killings of terrorists—to protect states places burdens on the meaning of liberalism around the world. After 1969, liberal intellectual responses to the so-called Troubles in Northern Ireland identified two conflicted groups of Irish liberals. Then academic and politician Conor Cruise O'Brien attempted to reduce responses to the crisis to the choice between supporting the state and condoning terrorism. “Consenting liberals” compromised professional practices in the law, journalism, broadcasting, and academia to support the state's counterinsurgency. Alternatively, “dissenting liberals” defended their “neutrality” alongside the freedom to criticize the counterinsurgency. Justifying infringements on individual freedoms, O'Brien and others said the democratic state was imperiled. But, anomalously, freedoms were sacrificed in defense of the Irish state, which in security terms did little to defend itself. Nevertheless, the counterinsurgency became an organizing principle in intellectual life, and over forty years colored self-perceptions of Irish society, past and present.

Type
Articles
Information
Journal of British Studies , Volume 52 , Issue 4 , October 2013 , pp. 908 - 939
Copyright
Copyright © The North American Conference on British Studies 2013 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Ignatieff, Michael, The Lesser Evil (Edinburgh, 2005)Google Scholar; Greenslade, Roy, foreword to Political Censorship and the Democratic State: The Irish Broadcasting Ban, ed. Corcoran, Mary P. and O'Brien, Mark (Dublin, 2005), 11–14Google Scholar; Ackerman, Bruce, Before the Next Attack: Preserving Civil Liberties in an Age of Terrorism (New Haven, 2006)Google Scholar; Bonner, David, Executive Measures and National Security: Have the Rules of the Game Changed? (Aldershot, 2007)Google Scholar; Bigo, Didier and Tsoukala, Anastassier, eds., Terror, Insecurity and Liberty: Illiberal Practices of Liberal Regimes After 9/11 (Oxford, 2008)Google Scholar; Meisels, Tamar, The Trouble with Terror: Liberty, Security and the Response to Terrorism (Cambridge, 2008)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2 For a polemical and negative critique of Ignatieff's position, see O'Keefe, Derrick, Michael Ignatieff: The Lesser Evil? (London, 2011)Google Scholar. For more thoughtful appraisals, see Jeffery, Renée, “Beyond Banality? Ethical Responses to Evil in Post–September 11 International Relations,” International Affairs 81, no. 1 (January 2005): 175–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

3 Ignatieff, Lesser, viii.

4 Dick Walsh, “O'Brien Assails ‘Confused’ Liberals,” Irish Times, 28 October 1974.

5 The term was coined in an Irish Times editorial. “The O'Brien Ethic,” Irish Times, 28 October 1974.

6 Ibid.

7 The following draws on Horgan, John, Mary Robinson: An Independent Voice (Dublin, 1997)Google Scholar; O'Leary, Olivia and Burke, Helen, Mary Robinson: The Authorised Biography (London, 1998)Google Scholar; O'Brien, Conor Cruise, Memoir: My Life and Themes (Dublin, 1999)Google Scholar; Akenson, D. H., Conor: A Biography of Conor Cruise O'Brien, 2 vols. (Ithica, 1994), 1:41–92Google Scholar; Whelan, Diarmuid, Conor Cruise O'Brien: Violent Notions (Dublin, 2009)Google Scholar.

8 Eileen O'Brien, “ Interment Meeting Causes Uproar,” Irish Times, 17 October 1974.

9 Walsh, “Assails.”

10 Ibid.

11 “O'Brien Position on Internment Supported by Conference,” Irish Times, 21 October 1974.

12 “The O'Brien Ethic,” Irish Times, 28 October 1974.

13 Tommy Murtagh, letter to the editor, Irish Times, 2 November 1974.

14 Ibid.

15 Walsh, “Assails.”

16 “Minister and Senator Differ on Role of Liberals,” Irish Times, 30 October 1974.

17 See Mary Robinson, Special Criminal Court (Dublin, 1974).

18 Horgan, Robinson, 54.

19 Mary Holland, “Dublin's Ulster Crisis,” New Statesman, 22 November 1974, 725; Murphy, John A., “Further Reflections on Irish Nationalism,” Crane Bag 2, no. 1–2 (1978): 156–63Google Scholar; Whelan, Diarmuid, “Conor Cruise O'Brien and the Legitimation of Violence,” Irish Political Studies 21, no. 2 (June 2006): 223–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar; O'Leary, Brendan and McGarry, John, Explaining Northern Ireland: Broken Images (Oxford, 1995)Google Scholar.

20 O'Brien, Conor Cruise, States of Ireland (London, 1972), 300–03Google Scholar.

21 Ibid., 302.

22 For an extension to the public debate on liberalism, see Liam de Paor, “Liberals and Irish History,” Irish Times, 5 November 1974.

23 “Minister and Senator Differ.”

24 R. F. Foster, “The Cruiser,” Standpoint (February 2009), http://standpointmag.co.uk/node/853/full (accessed 16 July 2013).

25 Kwapong, Alexander, “Conor Cruise O'Brien: A Legon Perspective,” in Ideas Matter: Essays in Honour of Conor Cruise O'Brien, ed. English, Richard and Skelly, Joseph (Dublin, 1998), 265–76Google Scholar.

26 See Regan, John M., “Southern Irish Nationalism as a Historiographical Problem,” Historical Journal 50, no. 1 (March 2007): 197–223CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

27 Foster, “Cruiser.”

28 See O'Brien, Conor Cruise, “An Unhealthy Intersection,” New Review 2, no. 16 (July 1975): 3–8Google Scholar.

29 O'Brien, States, 150.

30 Ibid.

31 Fischer, David Hackett, Historians' Fallacies: Toward a Logic of Historical Thought (New York, 1970), 41–43Google Scholar.

32 Dail Eireann printed debates (DEPD), vol. 258, 4 February 1972, col. 1128.

33 Akenson, Conor: A Biography, 1:419–20.

34 Ibid., 420.

35 FitzGerald, Garret, “The 1974–5 Threat of British Withdrawal from Northern Ireland,” Irish Studies in International Affairs 17, no. 1 (January 2006): 141–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

36 Ibid., 150.

37 Ibid., 143.

38 “Speculation on Military Phase Out Increases,” Irish Times, 25 April 1974.

39 Wilson, Speech to the House of Commons, 4 June 1974, Parliamentary Debates, Commons, 4th ser., vol. 874 (1972), col. 1051. The contemporary British records demonstrate Wilson wanted a long-term exit strategy and contemplated giving Northern Ireland dominion status. Paul Bew, drawing on Bernard Donoughue's oral testimony and memoirs, concludes that “The Prime Minister's own leaning was certainly in favour of withdrawal.” See Richard Bourke, “Wilson Clearly Wanted to Disengage from the North,” Irish Times, 3 January 2005; Bew, Paul, Ireland: The Politics of Enmity, 1789–2006 (Oxford, 2007), 514–16Google Scholar.

40 Report of Interdepartmental Committee on Northern Ireland: Discussion Paper No. 3, July 1974, National Archives of Ireland (Hereafter NAI), DT/2005/7/658.

41 DEPD vol. 242, 27 November 1969, col. 2167; vol. 300, 12 October 1977, col. 338.

42 Commission of Investigation into the Dublin and Monaghan Bombings of 1974 Final Report (Dublin, 2007), 72–73.

43 FitzGerald, “Withdrawal,” 144.

44 NAI Report of Interdepartmental Committee.

45 Ibid.

46 Garret FitzGerald, Secret Memorandum to the Irish Government, June 1975, NAI, DT/2005/151/703.

47 Report of Interdepartmental Committee, NAI.

48 Taylor, Trevor, “European Harmonisation of National Security and Defence Policies,” in The Role of Ground and Air Forces After the Cold War, ed. de Nooy, Gert (Hague, 1997), 79–97Google Scholar; Rees, Nicholas, “Europe and Ireland's Changing Security Policy,” in Ireland and the European Union: Nice, Enlargement and the European Union, ed. Holmes, Michael (Manchester, 2005), 55–74Google Scholar; Castles, Francis G., Comparative Public Policy: Patterns of Post War Transformation (Cheltenham, 1998)Google Scholar; see comparative figures for non-European countries serving with the United Nations in Ishizuka, Katsuni, Ireland and International Peacekeeping Operations, 1960–2000 (London, 2004), 10–15Google Scholar.

49 FitzGerald, Garret, All in a Life: An Autobiography (Dublin, 1992), 313–14Google Scholar.

50 Dick Walsh, “No Garda Interogation Squad Exists—Cooney,” Irish Times, 18 February 1977.

51 Hibernia, 22 November 1974, 2.

52 Hibernia, 20 December 1974, 5.

53 See Hanley, Brian and Millar, Scott, The Lost Revolution: The Story of the Official IRA and the Worker's Party (Dublin, 2009), 298–300Google Scholar.

54 Irish Press, 11 July 1975.

55 “Murder Convictions against Two Cork Men Set Aside,” Irish Times, 17 November 1976.

56 “High Court Discharges Conditional Order against Irish Press Ltd. For Contempt,” Irish Times, 16 December 1976.

57 Ibid.

58 O'Brien, Memoir, 355.

59 Keating was elected as a Labour Party deputy and served as minister for industry and commerce (1973–77).

60 O'Brien, Memoir, 355.

61 See McGarry, Patsy, While Justice Slept: The True Story of Nicky Kelly and the Sallins Train Robbery (Dublin, 2006)Google Scholar.

62 John M. Regan interview with Martin Reynolds, Dublin, 17 August 2009.

63 Ibid.

64 See Hanley and Millar, Lost, 374.

65 “Cooney Scorns Complaints, Refuses Inquiry Machinery,” Irish Times, 6 September 1976.

66 “O'Brien Warns of Deadly and Immediate Threat to the State,” Irish Times, 8 September 1976.

67 “Solicitor in Murder Trial Tells Court He Is Frightened,” Irish Independent, 4 December 1975.

68 Patterson, Henry, Ireland Since 1939: The Persistence of Conflict (Dublin, 2006), 270–71Google Scholar.

69 Craig, Anthony, Crisis of Confidence: Anglo-Irish Relations and the Early Troubles (Dublin, 2010), 191Google Scholar.

70 FitzGerald, All, 316.

71 Dunn, John, Western Political Theory in the Face of the Future (Cambridge, 1993 edn.), 30Google Scholar.

72 Kelly, Paul, Liberalism (Cambridge, 2005), 61Google Scholar.

73 Gaus, Gerald, Justificatory Liberalism: An Essay on Epistemology and Political Theory (Oxford, 1996), 162–66Google Scholar.

74 O'Brien, “Liberalism in Ireland,” Sunday Press, 25 September 1977.

75 John Stewart Mill, On Liberty (London, 1867), 6.

76 O'Brien, “Liberalism in Ireland.”

77 O'Brien, Conor Cruise, foreword to The Dirty War, by Dillon, Martin (London, 1990), xvGoogle Scholar.

78 Ibid., xvi.

79 Berlin, Isaiah, Two Concepts of Liberty: An Inaugural Lecture Delivered Before the University of Oxford, 31 October 1958 (Oxford, 1958)Google Scholar.

80 Ibid., 46.

81 DEPD, vol. 292, 7 September 1976, col. 478.

82 “What the Washington Post Published,” Irish Times, 6 September 1976.

83 Bennett, Alan, The History Boys (New York, 2004), 74CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

84 Gkotzaridis, Evi, The Trials of Irish History: The Genesis and Evolution of a Reappraisal, 1938–2000 (New York, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; see also Kearney, Richard, “Myth and Terror,” Crane Bag 2, no. 1–2 (1978): 125–39Google Scholar.

85 Colm Tóibín, “On the Literary Wing: Review of Marilynn J. Richtarik, Acting Between the Lines,” Times Literary Supplement, 28 April 1995, 10.

86 Frank Shovlin, “A New View of Nationalism?” Irish Times, 14 March 2009.

87 “The Irish Historian,” Sean Ó Mordha dir., 27 November 2007, RTE 1 Television.

88 de Paor, Liam, Divided Ulster (London, 1970)Google Scholar; Moody, T.W., The Ulster Question, 1603–1973 (Dublin, 1974)Google Scholar; Stewart, A. T. Q., The Narrow Ground: Aspects of Ulster, 1609–1969 (London, 1976)Google Scholar.

89 “Miriam Meets,” RTE Radio 1, 28 August 2010, http://www.rte.ie/radio1/miriammeets/220810.html (accessed 17 October 2012).

90 See Garvin, Tom, “The Discreet Charm of the National Bourgeoisie,” Third Degree 1, no. 1 (1977): 16–17Google Scholar; Laffan, Michael, “Violence and Terror in Twentieth-Century Ireland,” in Social Protest, Violence and Terror in Nineteenth- and Twentieth-Century Europe, ed. Mommsen, Wolfgang J. and Hirschfeld, Gerhard (London, 1982), 172Google Scholar.

91 Papers from a conference held at Trinity College, Dublin on 21 and 22 April 2006, organized by the Ireland Institute and Dublin University History Society, http://www.theirelandinstitute.com/institute/p01-townshend_worst_page.html (accessed 20 January 2012).

92 Ibid.

93 Ibid.

94 O'Brien, “Unhealthy Intersection,” 3–8.

95 Ibid., 7.

96 These ideas are developed across the post-1970 O'Brien canon. See for examples: States; Ancestral Voices: Religion and Nationalism in Ireland (Dublin, 1994)Google Scholar; God Land: Reflections on Religion and Nationalism (London, 1999)Google Scholar; cf. Kearney, “Myth and Terror.”

97 See Bourke, Richard, “Languages of Conflict and the Northern Ireland Troubles,” Journal of Modern History 83, no. 3 (September 2011): 544–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

98 O'Brien, States, 303; from Albert Camus's La Peste (Paris, 1947), 248.

99 Seanad Eireann printed debates, vol. 79, 12 March 1975, col. 791.

100 Ibid.

101 Ibid., col. 796.

102 Lyon, F. S. L., Ireland Since the Famine (London, 1971)Google Scholar; Terence de vere White, “A Pride of Lions,” Irish Times, 1 May 1971.

103 Lyons, F. S. L., “The Dilemma of the Irish Contemporary Historian,” Hermathena 115 (Summer 1973): 53Google Scholar.

104 Ibid., 52.

105 See, for example, Regan, John M., “Michael Collins, General Commanding-in-Chief, as a Historiographical Problem,” History 92, no. 307 (July 2007): 318–46CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, “Irish Public Histories as an Historiographical Problem,” Irish Historical Studies 37, no. 146 (November 2010): 265–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, “‘The ‘Bandon Valley Massacre’ as a Historical Problem,” History 97, no. 325 (January 2012): 70–98CrossRefGoogle Scholar. See also Regan's review of Richard English's Irish Freedom: The History of Nationalism in Ireland (Basingstoke, 2006), and English's response, http://www.history.ac.uk/reviews/review/704 (accessed 30 September 2012).

106 Lyons's lecture was delivered to the Irish history society at University College Dublin in November 1971.

107 Lyons, “Dilemma,” 54.

108 Ibid., 52.

109 Farrell, Brian, ed., The Irish Parliamentary Tradition (Dublin, 1973)Google Scholar, especially Lyons, “The Meaning of Independence,” 223–33.

110 Brian Farrell, preface to Parliamentary, 10.

111 Lyons, “Meaning,” 224.

112 See Charles Townshend's review of Lyons, F. S. L.'s Culture and Anarchy in Ireland, 1890–1939 (Oxford, 1979)Google Scholar, English Historical Review 96, no. 378 (January 1981): 173–75Google Scholar.

113 Whelan, O'Brien, 112–13.

114 See Curtis, L. P. Jr., review of Charles Townshend, Political Violence in Ireland (Oxford, 1983)Google Scholar, Journal of Modern History 58, no. 3 (September 1986): 716–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

115 R. F. Foster, “Irish Histories: Revised and Unrevised Versions,” Times Literary Supplement, 6 March 1981, 257.

116 Curtis, L. P. Jr., “The Greening of Irish History,” Eire/Ireland 29, no. 2 (Summer 1994): 9Google Scholar.

117 Foster, R., “We Are All Revisionists Now,” Irish Review 1, no. 1 (1986): 3Google Scholar; cf. Maley, Willy, “Revisionism and Nationalism: Ambivilances and Dissensus,” in Ireland in Proximity: History, Gender, Space, ed. Brewster, Scott, Crossman, Virginia, Becket, Fiona, and Alderson, David (London, 1999), 12–27Google Scholar.

118 Foster, “Revisionists,” 5.

119 Ibid.

120 Fanning, Ronan, “‘The Great Enchantment:’ Uses and Abuses of Modern Irish History,” in Ireland and the Contemporary World: Essays in Honour of Garret FitzGerald, ed. Dooge, James (Dublin, 1988), 131–47Google Scholar.

121 Ibid., 142.

122 Ibid.

123 Farrell, Brian, “The New State and Irish Political Culture,” Administration 16, no. 3 (October 1968): 238–46Google Scholar; Ronan Fanning, “Leadership and Transition from the Politics of Revolution to the Politics of Party,” in Reports—14th International Congress of the Historical Sciences, 3 vols. (New York, 1977), 3:1741–68.

124 Ronan Fanning, Independent Ireland (Dublin, 1983).

125 Ibid., 1–34; cf. Regan, “Collins,” and, especially, idem, “Public Histories,” 282–89.

126 Cf. David Fitzpatrick, “Ethnic Cleansing, Ethical Smearing, and Irish Historians,” History 98, no. 329 (January 2013): 135–44.

127 Patterson, Ireland Since, 132–36.

128 Stanley Cohen, Folk Devils and Moral Panics (London, 1972), 9.

129 For accusations that academic historians critical of Peter Hart's interpretation of the “Bandon Valley massacre” (see below) support “IRA apologists” and for comparisons between these historians and Nazi collaborators, alongside clerics who failed to stop pedophilia inside the Roman Catholic Church (“Just as [Monsignor] O'Callaghan's first duty was to protect the children of the diocese who could not speak for themselves, so the first duty of academic historians is to protect past victims of the IRA who no longer have a voice”), see Eoghan Harris, Sunday Independent, 26 June and 17 July, 2011.

130 Cohen, Panics, 9.

131 For O'Brien's influence on a contemporary study, see Regan's review of English's Irish Struggle and Bourke, “Languages.”

132 Foster, R. F., Paddy and Mr Punch: Connections in Irish and English History (London, 1993), 17Google Scholar.

133 Foster, R. F., “History and the Irish Question,” Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 33 (1983): 169–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

134 Cf. O'Brien, States, 150.

135 Bourke, “Languages,” 550–62.

136 Ibid., 559–60.

137 See also The IRA at War (Oxford, 2003)Google Scholar and Mick: The Real Michael Collins (London, 2006)Google Scholar.

138 Hart, Peter, “Class, Community and the IRA in Cork, 1917–23,” in Cork History and Society: Interdisciplinary Essays on an Irish County, ed. Buttimer, Cornelius G. and O'Flanigan, Patrick (Dublin, 1993), 980Google Scholar; idem., “The Protestant Experience of Revolution in Southern Ireland,” in Unionism in Modern Ireland, ed. English, Richard and Walker, Graham (Dublin, 1996), 92CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

139 For a discussion of primitivism in Hart's work, see Regan, John M., “The History of the Last Atrocity,” Dublin Review of Books 22 (Summer 2012)Google Scholar, http://www.drb.ie/more_details/12-06-22/The_History_of_the_Last_Atrocity.aspx (accessed 17 October 2012).

140 See Regan, “Bandon.”

141 Hart, Enemies, 288; Brian P. Murphy, review of Hart's The IRA and Its Enemies in The Month: A Review of Christian Thought and World Affairs (September–October 1998): 381–83.

142 Fitzpatrick, David, Politics and Irish Life, 1913–1921: Provincial Experiences of War and Revolution (Dublin, 1977, 2nd ed., Cork, 1998), 27Google Scholar.

143 Ibid.

144 For an overview, see Regan, “Bandon,” 70–78.

145 Garvin, Tom, 1922: The Birth of Irish Democracy (Dublin, 1996), 48Google Scholar; cf. NAI S'1322, Winston Churchill to Michael Collins, 12 April 1922 (Churchill wrote, “[T]he threat of civil war, or a Republic followed by a state of war with the British Empire, hangs over [Ireland]”), reproduced in Churchill, W., The Aftermath (London, 1944, 1st ed., 1929), 324–26Google Scholar; for reviews of Garvin, see Mitchell, Arthur, American Historical Review 103, no. 2 (April 1998): 523–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Patrick Maume, Studia Hibernica 29 (1995–1997): 245–47; John Kirkaldy, Books Ireland 202 (March 1997): 52–53; Frank Barry, Irish Review 20 (Winter–Spring 1997): 157–61; Michael Hopkinson, Irish Historical Studies 20, no. 120 (November 1997): 628–29; John M. Regan, History Ireland 5, no. 2 (Summer 1997): 54–56.

146 See Strauss, Erich, Irish Nationalism and British Democracy (Oxford, 1951), 269Google Scholar; Bromage, Mary, Churchill and Ireland (Notre Dame, 1964), 79Google Scholar; The Earl of Longford and O'Neill, T. P., Eamon de Valera (London, 1971), 186Google Scholar; Towey, Thomas, “The British Reaction to the 1922 Collins–de Valera Pact,” Irish Historical Studies 22, no. 85 (March 1980): 66CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

147 For an example of marginalization, see McGarry, F., Eoin O'Duffy: Self-Made Hero (Oxford, 2006), 96Google Scholar.

148 (Dublin, 1998).

149 Ibid., 361–62. The aim of the documents project is stated to be “to make available . . . to people who may not be in a position to easily consult the National Archives, documents which are considered important or useful for an understanding of Irish foreign policy” (ibid., ix.). Funded by the Department of Foreign Affairs and the Higher Education Authority, between 1997 and 2011 the foreign documents project has spent 1.8 million euro. Information from the publishers, the Royal Irish Academy, 13 July 2012.

150 Howe, Stephen, “The Politics of Historical Revisionism: Comparing Ireland and Israel/Palestine,” Past & Present 168 (August 2000): 168CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

151 David Fitzpatrick, “The Spectre of Ethnic Cleansing in Revolutionary Ireland,” paper delivered to the Irish History Seminar, Hertford College Oxford, 6 February 2013.

152 See Fitzpatrick, “Ethical.”

153 Responding to Regan's published critique of state formation historiography alongside Hart's research on the “Bandon Valley massacre,” Professor Fitzpatrick writes that “[Regan's] suggestions and innuendoes have long been circulated by bloggers and republican apologists. . . . The enlistment in this unseemly chorus of Regan's voice . . . adds credibility to points hitherto dismissible, for the most part, as the fantasies of cranks.” David Fitzpatrick, “Dr Regan and Mr Snide,” History Ireland 20, no. 3 (May–June 2012): 12–13.

154 Seanad Eireann printed debates, vol. 79, 18 March 1975, col. 930.

155 O'Brien, Conor Cruise, “Some Encounters with the Culturally Free,” New Left Review 44 (July–August 1967): 62.Google Scholar

156 Brogan, Denis, introduction to Encounters: An Anthology from the First Ten Years of Encounter Magazine, ed. Spender, Stephen, Kristol, Irving, and Lasky, Melvin J. (London, 1963), xxivGoogle Scholar.

157 O'Brien, Conor Cruise, “Journal de Combat,” in Writers and Politics (London, 1976; 1st ed., 1965), 216Google Scholar.

158 O'Brien, “Encounters,” 60–61.

159 Reproduced as “The Homer Watt Lecture,” in D. H. Akenson, Conor: A Biography, 2:112–19.

160 O'Brien, Conor Cruise, introduction to Power and Consciousness, ed. O'Brien, Conor Cruise and Venech, William Dean (New York, 1969), 2Google Scholar.

161 Ibid.

162 O'Brien, “Journal,” 216.

163 “O'Brien Encounters”; “‘R,’ Column,” Encounter 27, no. 2 (August 1966): 43.

164 Ibid.

165 O'Brien, Power, 4.

166 Ibid.

167 Ibid., 6.

168 Ibid.

169 See Blauner, Bob, Resisting McCarthyism: To Sign or Not To Sign California's Loyalty Oath (Stanford, 2009), 3–12Google Scholar.

170 Quoted in Roazen, Paul, The Cultural Foundations of Political Psychology (New Jersey, 2003), 84Google Scholar.

171 Ignatieff, Michael, Isaiah Berlin: A Life (London, 1998), 199–200Google Scholar.

172 Richard English and Joseph Skelly, “Ideas Matter,” in English and Skelly, Ideas Matter, 13–14.

173 Berlin, Isaiah, Four Essays on Liberty (Oxford, 1969), 1–40Google Scholar.

174 Ibid., 39.

175 Ibid., 40.

176 Working for the British Foreign Office in Washington, DC in 1943, Berlin chose his Jewish allegiance over his British allegiance when leaking information to the Zionist lobby. Ignatieff, Berlin, 117–18.

177 Berlin, Four, 40.

178 See Regan's review of English's Irish Freedom.

179 See Bradshaw, Brendan and Graham, Tommy, “A Man with a Mission,” History Ireland 1, no. 1 (Spring 1993): 53Google Scholar; Fitzpatrick, David, “Une Histoire Très Catholique? Révisionnisme et Orthodoxie dans l'Historiographie Irlandaise,” Vingtième Siècle 2, no. 94 (April–June 2007): 121–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

180 O'Brien, “Politics and the Morality of Scholarship,” in O'Brien and Vanech, Power, 41.

181 O'Brien, “Scholarship,” 40–41.

182 Howe, “Revisionism,” 231.

183 Columnist John Waters writes: “Many of us [journalists] were convinced by the need to pull the historical rug from under the Provos and were therefore acquiescent in the rewriting of the past.” Irish Times, 10 April 2006.

184 For Berlin's influence on Ignatieff's lesser evil thesis, see Ignatieff, Lesser, 15–16.

185 Ignatieff, Lesser, xiv–xv.

186 Ibid., 11.

187 Ibid.

188 Ibid., 122.

189 English, Richard, Terrorism: How to Respond (Oxford, 2009), 140Google Scholar.

190 O'Brien, “Scholarship,” 41.

191 Berlin to O'Brien, 10 April 1991, reproduced in O'Brien, Conor Cruise, The Great Melody: A Thematic Biography of Edmund Burke (London, 1992), 612Google Scholar.

192 Ibid., 613.

193 Cf. O'Halpin, Eunan, The Irish State and Its Enemies Since 1922 (Oxford, 1999), 329–39Google Scholar.