Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-13T05:05:06.823Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Navigating the Path of Least Resistance: Financial Deregulation and the Origins of the Japanese Crisis

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 March 2016

Yves Tiberghien
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article reexamines the period of the Japanese bubble (1985–1990) and emphasizes ill-supervised and ill-sequenced financial deregulation as a key proximate factor. Given the subsequent costs of this political choice, what explains such a path of domestic financial deregulation without the establishment of corresponding supervisory institutions? I argue that the suboptimal Japanese outcome represents the equilibrium point for political leaders who had to balance global pressures to deregulate the economy, corporate pressures to liberalize finance, and domestic resistance by an array of politically connected interest groups. The government chose ill-supervised financial deregulation as the path of least political resistance and the golden bullet that could both defuse trade tensions with the United States and readjust the Japanese political economy in a harmless way. Instead, as they interacted with other factors, the choices made in the early 1980s destabilized the Japanese system and carried the seeds of the ensuing financial crisis.

Keywords

financial deregulationJapanfinancial bubblefinancial supervisionfinancial globalizationinterest groupsYen-Dollar AgreementEast Asian Financial Crisis
Type
Articles
Information
Journal of East Asian Studies , Volume 5 , Issue 3 , December 2005 , pp. 427 - 464
Copyright
Copyright © East Asia Institute 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

The related fieldwork in Japan (1999–2000) was generously supported by the Japan Foundation.Google Scholar

1. World Bank, The East Asian Miracle (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993).Google Scholar

2. International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook, Spring 2003, available at http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2003/01/data/index.htm#2.Google Scholar

3. Baumgartner, Ulrich and Meredith, Guy, “Saving Behavior and the Asset Price ‘Bubble’ in Japan,” IMF Occasional Paper, International Monetary Fund, 1995; Kamikawa, Ryunoshin, “Baburu keizai to nihonginko no dokuritsusei” [The bubble economy and autonomy of the Bank of Japan]. In Muramatsu, Michio and Okuno, Masahiro, eds., Heisei baburu no kenkyu: Baburu no hassei to sono haikei kouzou [The study of the Heisei bubble (vol. 1): The outbreak of bubble economy and background structures] (Tokyo: Toyokeizai shinposha, 2002), pp. 127–191; Noguchi, Yukio, “The Bubble and Economic Policies in the 1980s,” Journal of Japanese Studies 20, no. 2 (1994): 291–305; Wood, Christopher, The Bubble Economy (New York: Atlantic Monthly Press, 1992); Werner, Richard, Princes of the Yen: Japans Central Bankers and the Transformation of the Economy (Armonk, N.Y.: M. E. Sharpe, 2003); Grimes, William W., Unmaking the Japanese Miracle: Macroeconomic Politics, 1985–2000 (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2001); McKinnon, Ronald I. and Ohno, Kenichi, Dollar and Yen: Resolving Economic Conflict between the United States and Japan (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1997); Hartcher, Peter, The Ministry: How Japan's Most Powerful Institution Endangers World Markets (Boston: Harvard Business School, 1998).Google Scholar

4. Hartcher, , The Ministry ; Grimes, , Unmaking the Japanese Miracle ; Muramatsu, Michio and Okuno, Masahiro, eds., Heisei baburu no kenkyu: Baburun no hassei tosSonoh haikei kouzou [The study of the Heisei bubble (vol. 1): The outbreak of bubble economy and background structures] (Tokyo: Toyo Keizai shinposha, 2002); Posen, Adam Simon, Restoring Japans Economic Growth (Washington, D.C.: Institute for International Economics, 1998); Nakamura, Takafusa, The Postwar Japanese Economy (Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press, 1995).Google Scholar

5. Amyx, Jennifer Ann, Japan's Financial Crisis: Institutional Rigidity and Reluctant Change (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2004); Laurence, Henry, Money Rules: The New Politics of Finance in Britain and Japan (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2001); Fukao, Kyoji, “Ninon no chochikuchoka to baburu no hassei” [Excess savings in Japan and the outbreak of the bubble economy]. In Muramatsu, and Okuno, , Heisei baburu no kenkyu, vol. 1, pp. 217–247; Fukao, Mitsuhiro, “Japan's Lost Decade and Its Financial System,” The World Economy 26, no. 3 (2003): 365–384; Okazaki, Tetsuji and Takeo, Hoshi, “1980 nendai no ginko keiei: Senryaku soshiki, gabanansu” [Management of the banks in the 1980s: Strategies, organizations, and governance]. In Muramatsu, and Okuno, , Heisei baburu nokKenkyu, vol. 1, pp. 313–358; Meyer, Claude, La puissance financière du Japon (Paris: Economica, 1996).Google Scholar

6. Yoshikawa, Hiroshi, “Tochi baburu: Genin to jidai haikei” [The land bubble: The cause and the historical background]. In Muramatsu, and Masahiro, , Heiseib baburu no kenkyu, vol. 1, pp. 411–430; Aveline, Natacha, La bulle foncière au Japon (Paris: ADEF, 1995).Google Scholar

7. Kojo, Yoshihiko, “Baburu keisei, houkai no haikei toshiteno nichibeikeizai kankei: Purazagoi ikouno kokusai shushi kurogi zesei mondai to endaka kaihiron” [Japan-U.S. economic relations as the background for understanding the bubble formation and collapse: The problem of correcting the trade balance after the Plaza Accords and the theory of evasion of yen appreciation]. In Muramatsu, Michio and Okuno, Masahiro, eds., Heisei baburu no kenkyu: Houkaigo no fukyo to furyosaiken shori mondai [The study of the Heisei bubble (vol. 2): The recession after the collapse and non-performing loan problem] (Tokyo: Toyo keizai shinposha, 2002), pp. 345–371; Nakanishi, Hiroshi, “Kokusaishisutemu no henyo to nihon no baburu: seisaku kyocho no zasetsu to gurobarizeshon” [The change in the international system and the Japanese bubble: The failure of policy cooperation and globalization]. In Muramatsu, and Okuno, , Heisei baburu no kenkyu, vol. 2, pp. 299–344; McKinnon, and Ohno, , “The Exchange Rate Origins of Japan's Economic Slump in the 1990's”; Mototada Kikkawa, Mani-haisen [The lost money war] (Tokyo: Bunshun shinsho, 1998).Google Scholar

8. Meyer, , La puissance financière du Japon; Boyer, Robert and Yamada, Toshio, Japanese Capitalism in Crisis: A Regulationist Interpretation (London: Routledge, 2000); Hoshi, Takeo and Kashyap, Anil, Corporate Financing and Governance in Japan: The Road to the Future (Cambridge: MIT Press, 2001); Baumgartner, and Meredith, , “Saving Behavior and the Asset Price ‘Bubble’ in Japan.” Google Scholar

9. The political economy of financial deregulation (not in the context of the Japanese crisis) is well analyzed in Calder, Kent, “Assault on the Bankers' Kingdom: Politics, Markets, and the Liberalization of Japanese Industrial Finance.” In Loriaux, Michael et al., eds., Capital Ungoverned: Liberalizing Finance in Interventionist State (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1997); Laurence, , Money Rules; Frances Rosenbluth, Financial Politics in Contemporary Japan (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1989); Goodman, John and Pauly, Louis, “The Obsolescence of Capital Controls? Economic Management in an Age of Global Markets,” World Politics 46, no. 1 (1993): 50–82; Pauly, Louis, Opening Financial Markets: Banking Politics on the Pacific Rim (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1988). Several scholars include an analysis of financial deregulation but downplay its explanatory power relative to other structural features. Amyx, , Japan's Financial Crisis ; Laurence, , Money Rules. Google Scholar

10. McKinnon, Ronald, The Order of Economic Liberalization (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1993).Google Scholar

11. Stiglitz, Joseph, Globalization and Its Discontents (New York: Norton, 2002); Haggard, Stephan, The Political Economy of the Asian Financial Crisis (Washington, D.C.: Institute for International Economics, 2000). See also works by Ha-Joon, Chang and Jomo, KS.Google Scholar

12. I am grateful to Stephan Haggard for this concept of bad equilibrium.Google Scholar

13. Japan's Ministry of Finance (handout of the Banking Bureau).Google Scholar

14. Ibid.Google Scholar

15. A major plan to reduce regional inequities by relocating industries to the interior and to the Sea of Japan side and to link together the entire nation by constructing 9,000 kilometers of Shinkansen and 10,000 kilometers of superhighways. The plan's rationale was to spread more equally the fruits of high growth. See Nakamura, , The Postwar Japanese Economy, p. 203.Google Scholar

16. McKinnon, Ronald I. and Ohno, Kenichi, Dollar and Yen: Resolving Economic Conflict between the United States and Japan.Google Scholar

17. International Monetary Fund, Occasional Paper No. 124, Washington, D.C., 1995, p. 64.Google Scholar

18. Wood, , The Bubble Economy, p. 8.Google Scholar

19. First, the collapse in land prices and the ensuing recession led to the quasi-bankruptcy of many real estate companies and other recipients of bank loans. Second, the collapse in stock prices led to a huge reduction in bank reserves (which include a large amount of equity due to company shareholding) and in turn to the necessary lending reduction in order for banks to fulfill the 8 percent BIS asset-reserve adequacy ratio. Third, the reduction of interest rates to 0.5 percent by 1995 and 0.25 percent by 1998 made it nearly impossible for banks to earn a high enough margin on loans. McKinnon and Ohno, “The Exchange Rate Origins of Japan's Economic Slump in the 1990's.” Google Scholar

20. Krugman, Paul, “Setting Sun, Japan: What Went Wrong?” in The Dismal Science (Slate, 1998); Krugman, Paul, Further Notes on Japans Liquidity Trap, 1998 (accessed July 20, 2005); http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/liquid.html.Google Scholar

21. Cargill, Thomas, Hutchison, Michael, and Takatoshi, Ito, The Political Economy of Japanese Monetary Policy (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1997).Google Scholar

22. Werner, , Princes of the Yen.Google Scholar

23. Kamikawa, , “Baburu keizai to nihonginko no dokuritsusei.” See also Nakamura, , The Postwar Japanese Economy. Google Scholar

24. Grimes, , Unmaking the Japanese Miracle.Google Scholar

25. Hartcher, , The Ministry: How Japans Most Powerful Institution Endangers World Markets.Google Scholar

26. Ibid., p. 216.Google Scholar

27. Amyx, Jennifer, “Okurasho nettowaku: kenryoku no kakudai to seiyaku no kiketsu” [The MOF network: The expansion of authority and the outcome of restrictions]. In Muramatsu, and Okuno, , Heisei baburu no kenkyu, vol. 2, pp. 273–296; Amyx, , Japans Financial Crisis. Google Scholar

28. Katz, Richard, Japan: The System That Soured (Armonk, N.Y.: M. E. Sharpe, 1998).Google Scholar

29. Asher, and Smithers, , “Japan's Key Challenges for the 21st Century: Debt, Deflation, Default, Demography, and Deregulation,” in SAIS Policy Forum Series (The Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies of The Johns Hopkins University, 1998); Krugman, , “Setting Sun, Japan.” Google Scholar

30. Asher, and Smithers, , “Japan's Key Challenges for the 21st Century”; Gibney, Frank, ed., Unlocking the Bureaucrat's Kingdom (Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press, 1998); Ozawa, Ichiro, Blueprint for a New Japan: The Rethinking of a Nation (Tokyo: Kodansha International, 1994).Google Scholar

31. “How could the world's most acclaimed economic miracle have stumbled so badly? The root of the problem is that Japan is still mired in the structures, policies, and mental habits that prevailed in the 1950s and 1960s. What we have come to think as the ‘Japanese economic system’ was a marvelous system to help a backward Japan catch up with the West. But it turned into a terrible system once Japan had in fact caught up'. The Japanese ‘economic model’ that we see today is not, as some have suggested, a different kind of capitalism. It is rather a holdover from an earlier stage of capitalism. It is the spectacle of a country vainly trying to carry into maturity economic patterns better suited to its adolescence.” Quoted in Katz, , Japan: The System That Soured, pp. 4–6.Google Scholar

32. Aveline, , La bulle foncière au Japon; Wood, , The Bubble Economy ; Noguchi, , “The Bubble and Economic Policies in the 1980s”; Yoshikawa, , “Tochi baburu: Genin to jidai haikei.” Google Scholar

33. Fukao, Mitsuhiro, “1980 nendai kouhan no shizaikakaku baburu hassei to 90 nen dai no fukyo no genin: Kinyushisutemu no kinufuzen no kanten kara” [The outbreak of assets bubble in the late 1980s and the cause for the recession in the 1990s: Dysfunctional financial system]. In Muramatsu, and Masahiro, , Heisei baburu no kenkyu, vol. 1, pp. 87–126.Google Scholar

34. McKinnon, and Ohno, , “The Exchange Rate Origins of Japan's Economic Slump in the 1990's.”Google Scholar

35. International Monetary Fund, “The Japanese Banking of the 1990s: Sources and Lessons,” 2000, p. 1.Google Scholar

36. Baumgartner, and Meredith, , “Saving Behavior and the Asset Price ‘Bubble’ in Japan,” p. 258.Google Scholar

37. Hoshi, Takeo and Kashyap, Anil, Corporate Financing and Governance in Japan: The Road to the Future, p. 258.Google Scholar

38. Taniguchi, Tomohiko, “Japan's Banks and the ‘Bubble Economy’ of the Late 1980s,” Princeton University Monograph Series, 1993, p. 19.Google Scholar

39. Ibid., p. 18.Google Scholar

40. Dore, Ronald, “Goodwill and the Spirit of Market Capitalism,” British Journal of Sociology 34, No. 4 1983): 459–482.Google Scholar

41. Cargill, Hutchison, and Takatoshi, , The Political Economy of Japanese Monetary Policy, p. 104.Google Scholar

42. Osugi, , “Japan's Experience of Financial Deregulation Since 1984 in an International Perspective,” BIS Economic Papers, 1990; Taniguchi, “Japan's Banks and the ‘Bubble Economy’ of the Late 1980s.” Google Scholar

43. International Monetary Fund, Staff Country Report, 1996, p. 137.Google Scholar

44. Cargill, Hutchison, and Takatoshi, , The Political Economy of Japanese Monetary Policy, p. 103.Google Scholar

45. Taniguchi, , “Japan's Banks and the ‘Bubble Economy’ of the Late 1980s”; McKinnon, and Ohno, , “The Exchange Rate Origins of Japan's Economic Slump in the 1990's.” Google Scholar

46. Taniguchi, , “Japan's Banks and the ‘Bubble Economy’ of the Late 1980s,” p. 27.Google Scholar

47. Cargill, Hutchison, and Takatoshi, , The Political Economy of Japanese Monetary Policy, p. 105.Google Scholar

48. Osugi, , “Japan's Experience of Financial Deregulation Since 1984 in an International Perspective,” pp. 56–57.Google Scholar

49. Van Wolferen, Karel, The Enigma of Japanese Power (New York: Vintage Press, 1989), p. 22.Google Scholar

50. Ibid., p. 400.Google Scholar

51. Prestowitz, Clyde, Trading Places (New York: Basic Books, 1988).Google Scholar

52. Haggard, , The Political Economy of the Asian Financial Crisis.Google Scholar

53. Krugman, Paul, Currencies and Crises (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1995).Google Scholar

54. Goldstein, Morris, The Asian Financial Crisis: Causes, Cures, and Systemic Implications (Washington, D.C.: Institute for International Economics, 1998).Google Scholar

55. Park, Yong-shik, “The Asian Financial Crisis and Its Effects on Korean Banks,” paper presented at “The Korean Economy in an Era of Global Competition,” a symposium sponsored by George Washington University, the Korean Economic Institute of America, and the Korean Institute for International Economic Policy (Korean Economic Institute of America: Joint US-Korea Academic Studies, 2000).Google Scholar

56. Noland, Marcus, “An Overview of South Korea Economic Reforms in Korean Economic Institute of America,” paper presented at “The Korean Economy in an Era of Global Competition” symposium; see note 55.Google Scholar

57. Krugman, Paul, The Return of Depression Economics (New York: Norton, 1999).Google Scholar

58. Soros, George, The Crisis of Global Capitalism: Open Society Endangered (New York: BBS/Public Affairs, 1998).Google Scholar

59. Lamfalussy, Alexander, Financial Crises in Emerging Markets (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2000).Google Scholar

60. Blustein, Paul, The Chastening: Inside the Crisis That Rocked the Global Financial System and Humbled the IMF (New York: Public Affairs, 2001), p. 124.Google Scholar

61. See, for example, Woo-Cumings, Meredith, “The State, Democracy, and the Reform of the Corporate Sector in Korea.” In Pempel, T. J., ed., The Politics of the Asian Economic Crisis (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1999), p. 120; Clifford, Mark L., Troubled Tiger: Businessmen, Bureaucrats, and Generals in South Korea (Armonk, N.Y.: M. E. Sharpe, 1998); Kang, Myung Hun, The Korean Business Conglomerate: Chaebol Then and Now (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1996).Google Scholar

62. Woo-Cumings, Meredith, “Slouching Toward the Market: The Politics of Financial Liberalization in South Korea.” In Loriaux, Michael, Woo-Cumings, Meredith, and Calder, Kent, eds., Capital Ungoverned: Liberalizing Finance in Interventionist State (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1997), p. 90.Google Scholar

63. See an example account of the chaebol debate in Yoo, Yoo Seong-Min, “Corporate Restructuring in Korea: Policy Issues Before and During the Crisis,” Korean Development Institute Working Paper (Seoul: Korean Development Institute, 1999). “The democratization since 1987 and the consequent instabilities put an end to the past patriarchal authoritarianism” (p. 142). Yoo also argues that the “chaebol problem” includes six major failures: failure of corporate governance, failure of the financial market, failure of the exit market, political influence of chaebol economic power over government policy decisions, misconceptions on the nature of business corporations, and failure of law enforcement (p. 146). See also Jung, Ku-hyun and Kim, Dong-jae, “Globalization and International Competitiveness: The Case of Korea.” In Moon, Chung-in and Mo, Jongryn, eds., Democratization and Globalization in Korea: Assessments and Prospects (Seoul: Yonsei University Press, 1999) for an argument that combines deregulation, globalization, and democratization.Google Scholar

64. Stiglitz, , Globalization and Its Discontents.Google Scholar

65. For the contrast between liberal and nonliberal systems, see Streeck, Wolfgang and Yamamura, Kozo, The Origins of Nonliberal Capitalism (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2001). Zysman further differentiates state-led economies such as France and Japan from bank-centered systems such as Germany: Zysman, John, Governments, Markets, and Growth (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1983).Google Scholar

66. Zysman, , Governments, Markets, and Growth.Google Scholar

67. On institutional complementarity and institutional crisis, see Aoki, Masahiko, “Japan in the Process of Institutional Change” (Miyakodayori: Letter from the Capital: RIETI, 2002). Aoki, however, does not put the emphasis solely on financial deregulation as the agent of perturbation in the initial system.Google Scholar

68. On the review of the literature on sequencing and an application to financial liberalization in East Asia, see the excellent paper by Walter, Andrew, “Financial Liberalization and Prudential Regulation in East Asia: Still Perverse?” Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies Working Paper (Singapore: Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies, 2002).Google Scholar

69. Rosenbluth, , Financial Politics in Contemporary Japan, pp. 14–15.Google Scholar

70. See an excellent analysis in Frankel, Jeffry, The Yen/Dollar Agreement: Liberalizing Japanese Capital Markets (Washington, D.C.: Institute for International Economics, 1984).Google Scholar

71. Calder, , “Assault on the Bankers' Kingdom.”Google Scholar

72. Ibid., pp. 17–18.Google Scholar

73. Ibid., pp. 19–20.Google Scholar

74. Ibid., p. 24.Google Scholar

75. Ibid., p. 25.Google Scholar

76. Osugi, , “Japan's Experience of Financial Deregulation”; Frankel, , The Yen/Dollar Agreement. Google Scholar

77. Pauly, , Opening Financial Markets: Banking Politics on the Pacific Rim, pp. 73–78.Google Scholar

78. Kindleberger, Charles Poor, Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Financial Crises, 4th ed. (New York: Wiley, 2000).Google Scholar

79. Osugi, , “Japan's Experience of Financial Deregulation.”Google Scholar

80. Frankel, , The Yen/Dollar Agreement, p. ix.Google Scholar

81. Osugi, , “Japan's Experience of Financial Deregulation,” p. 9.Google Scholar

82. Frankel, , The Yen/Dollar Agreement, p. 2.Google Scholar

83. Ibid., pp. 71–72.Google Scholar

84. Rosenbluth, , Financial Politics in Contemporary Japan, p. 44.Google Scholar

85. See Rosenbluth, , Financial Politics in Contemporary Japan, for the full account.Google Scholar

86. Ibid., p. 131.Google Scholar