Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dk4vv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T07:44:04.611Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Incomplete Engagement: Reagan's South Africa policy Revisited

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 November 2008

Alex Thomson
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Events in Southern Africa during the early 1990s have re-opened a debate over the effectiveness of the Reagan Administration's policy of ‘Constructive Engagement’. This was a controversy that had previously been laid to rest with the US Congress passing its Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act in October 1986, since the ensuing punitive sanctions imposed by the enactment of this legislation scuttled Ronald Reagan's strategy of using friendly persuasion to encourage the South African Government away from its practice of apartheid. Yet, with hindsight, it may appear that the President's method of drawing the Pretoria regime into the international community, through offering recognition and encouragement in exchange for reform, has been triumphantly vindicated. After all, has not the African National Congress (ANC) come to power via a democratic process, thereby avoiding a bloodbath on the scale that so many had predicted?

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Modern African Studies , Volume 33 , Issue 1 , March 1995 , pp. 83 - 101
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Finnegan, William, ‘Coming Apart Over Apartheid: the story behind the Republicans' split on South Africa’, in Mother Jones (San Francisco), 04–05 1986, p. 42.Google Scholar

2 Crocker, Chester A., ‘South Africa:strategy for change’, in Foreign Affairs (New York), 59, 2, 1980, p. 324.Google Scholar

3 Crocker, Chester A., ‘The Quest for an Africa Policy’, in The Washington Review of Strategic and International Studies (Washington, DC), 1, 2, 1978, p. 63.Google Scholar

4 Crocker, loc. cit. 1980, p. 345.

5 Ibid. p. 337.

6 Ibid. p. 350.

7 US Department of State, A U.S. Policy Toward South Africa: the report of the Secretary of State's Advisory Committee on South Africa (Washington, DC, 1987), p. 1.Google Scholar

8 SeeCrocker, Chester A., ‘Southern Africa in Global Perspective’, in CSIS Africa Notes (Washington, DC), 105, 1989, pp. 1–5,Google Scholar and especially High Noon in Southern Africa: making peace in a rough neighbourhood (New York, 1992).Google Scholar

9 Crocker, Chester A., ‘Southern Africa: eight years later’, in Foreign Affairs, 68, 4, 1989, p. 147.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

10 Ibid. p. 152. See also, Crocker, Chester A., ‘Peacemaking in Southern Africa: the Namibia-Angola settlement of 1988’, in Newson, Daniel (ed.), The Diplomatic Record, 1989–1990 (Boulder, CO, 1991), pp. 9–34,Google Scholar and Freeman, Chas W., ‘The Angola/Namibian Accords’, in Foreign Affairs, 68, 3, 1989, pp. 126–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

11 Crocker, op. cit. 1992.

12 US Congress, Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, and Subcommittee on International Finance and Monetary Policy, The Anti-Apartheid Act of 1985: hearings. Ist Session: April, May, and June 1985 (Washington, DC 1985), p. 53.Google Scholar

13 Chakaodza, Austin was not alone in believing that Constructive Engagement was a ‘policy designed to appease the white minority’, seeking the ‘delay self-determination in South Africa’. International Diplomacy in Southern Africa: from Reagan to Mandela (London, 1990), pp. 105 and 3.Google Scholar

14 Crocker, loc. cit. 1980, p. 337. See also, Crocker, Chester A., ‘Africa Policy in the 1980s’, in The Washington Quarterly, 3, 3, 1980, p. 85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

15 Personal interview with Crocker, Chester, Washington, DC, 5 October 1993.Google Scholar

16 The New York Times, 11 January 1983, p. A9.

17 US Administration's press conference of 28 August 1981, quoted by Minter, William, King Solomon's Mines Revisited: Western interests and the burdened history of Southern Africa (New York, 1986), p. 315,Google Scholar See also, The New York Times, 27 August 1981, p. A10.

18 Crocker, op. cit. 1992, p. 170.

19 Quoted by Hanlon, Joseph, Beggar Your Neighbours: apartheid power in Southern Africa (London, 1986), p. 35.Google Scholar As explained by P. S. Mmusi, Vice-President of Botswana: ‘It is not much use to develop ports and pipelines, and roads and railways, and then to watch in silence as they are blown up. We cannot ignore the continuing, indeed escalating, acts of sabotage which are being directed at our member states.’ Quoted by Kibble, Steve and Bush, Ray, ‘Reform of Apartheid and Continued Destabilisation in Southern Africa’, in The Journal of Modern African Studies (Cambridge), 24, 2, 06 1986, p. 213.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

20 Reagan, Ronald's news conference of 21 03 1985, in U.S. Department of State Bulletin (Washington, DC), 85, 2098, 1985, p. 11.Google Scholar

21 Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs, Chester Crocker, interviewed on ABC's ‘This Week with David Brinkley’, quoted by Sawyer, Kathy, ‘South Africa's Rule by Guns Hit’ in The Washington Post, 25 March 1985, p. A14.Google Scholar

22 Ronald Reagan interviewed on WBS Radio, Atlanta, 24 August 1985, quoted by Sampson, Anthony, Black and Gold: tycoons, revolutionaries and apartheid (London, 1987), p. 188.Google Scholar Also, Reagan's meeting with newspaper editors and broadcasters, June 1986, quoted by Baker, Pauline H., The United States and South Africa: the Reagan years (New York, 1989), p. 25,Google Scholar and Reagan's news conference of 24 February 1988, in U.S. Department of State Bulletin, 88, 2134, 1988, p. 10.Google Scholar

23 Address before the Wold Affairs Council and Foreign Policy Association, White House, Washington, DC, 22 July 1986, published as Reagan, Ronald, ‘Ending Apartheid in South Africa’, in U.S Department of State Bulletin, 86, 2114, 1986, pp. 1–5.Google Scholar

24 Crocker, op. cit. 1992, p. 319.

25 Reagan's press interview, 1 April 1985, published in Department of State, Bureau of Public Relations, Office of the Historian, The United States and South Africa: U.S. public statements and documents, 1977–1985 (Washington, DC, 1985), p. 308;Google ScholarGoshko, John M., ‘U.S. Influence in Region is Limited, Administration Says’, in The Washington Post, 29 August 1985, p. A32; Editorial, ‘The President, as Amended’, in The New York Times, 31 August 1985, p. 22;Google Scholar and Julie Johnson, ‘U.S. Officials Move to Clarify Reagan's Remarks’, in ibid. 26 February 1988, p. A8.

26 Lugar, Richard G., Letters to the Next President (New York, 1988), p. 238.Google Scholar

27 McHenry, Donald F., ‘Southern Africa Policy’, in The New York Times, 10 July 1981, p. A23. This incident is alluded to by Crocker, op. cit. 1992, p. 95.Google Scholar

28 El-Khawas, Mohamed A., ‘Reagan's Africa Policy: a turn to the right’, in A Current Bibliography on African Affairs (Farmingdale, NY), 16, 3, 1983–1984, pp. 213–14;Google ScholarThe New York Times, 20, 22, 24, 25, and 27 March 1981; US Congress, House of Representatives, Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittee on Africa, Enforcement of the United States Arms Embargo Against South Africa: hearings (Washington, DC, 1982), pp. 24–6; and personal interview, Crocker, October 1992.Google Scholar

29 See, for example, Crocker, op. cit. 1992, p. 314.

30 Personal interview with Nickel, Herman, US Ambassador to South Africa, 1982–1986, Washington, DC, 9 October 1992.Google Scholar

31 Boyd, Gerald M., ‘U.S. is Reported to Warn Pretoria’, in The New York Times, 10 August 1985, pp. 1–4,Google Scholar and ‘U.S. Official Says South Africans in Vienna Offered Power-sharing’, in ibid. 22 August 1985, pp. A1 and A10.

32 Lugar, op. cit. pp. 218–19.

33 Boyd, Gerald M., ‘Botha Speech Said to Disappoint U.S.’, in The New York Times, 17 August 1985, p. 4.Google Scholar

34 McFarlane, Robert C.'s ABC-TV interview, 18 August 1985, ‘his Week with David Brinkley’, in US Department of State Bulletin, 85, 2103, 1985, p. 7.Google Scholar

35 Crocker, loc. cit. 1989, p. 160.

36 Ibid.

37 See Dam's testimony in The Anti-Apartheid Act of 1985, p. 53.

38 ‘Whites Only Talks’, in Financial Times (London), 14 04 1981, p. 3.Google Scholar Also, ‘Press Guidance–Crocker Meetings in South Africa’, US Embassy unclassified cable, 15 April 1981,Google Scholar published in Mokoena, Kenneth (ed.), South Africa: the making of U.S. policy, 1962–1989 (Alexandria, VA, 1991), Document No. 01195.Google Scholar

39 Testimony of Crocker, Chester, US Congress, Senate, Committee on Foreign Relations, Subcommittee on Africa Affairs, in U.S. Policy on South Africa: hearings (Washington, DC, 1985), p. 26.Google Scholar

40 Testimony of Crocker, Chester during 04 and 05 1981, US Senate, Committee on Foreign Relations, in Nomination of Chester A. Crocker (Washington, DC, 1981).Google Scholar

41 Personal interview with Gosende, Bob, Counsellor for Public Affairs, US Embassy, Pretoria, 1981–1986, Washington, DC, 14 October 1992.Google Scholar

42 Personal interview with Cabelly, Robert, Personal Assistant to Chester Crocker, State Department, 1981–1989, Washington, DC, 13 October 1992.Google Scholar

43 Personal interview, Gosende, October 1992.

44 Thula, Gibson quoted by Pogrund, Bengamin, ‘Reagan's Shift: the view from Pretoria’, in Washington Quarterly, 5, 1, 1982, p. 182.Google Scholar

45 Desmond Tutu quoted by Pogrund, loc. cit. p. 182.

46 Testimony of Frank Wisner, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs, September 1983, US Congress, House of Representatives, Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittee on Africa, Internal Political Situation in South Africa (Washington, DC, 1984), p. 104.Google Scholar

47 Personal interview, Cabelly, October 1992.

48 Personal interview with McHenry, Donald F., US Ambassador to the United Nations, 1979–1981, Washington, DC, 20 October 1992.Google Scholar

49 See Commonwealth Group of Eminent Persons, Mission to South Africa: the Commonwealth report (London, 1986).Google Scholar

50 Personal interview with Nickel, Herman W., US Ambassador to South Africa, 1982–1986, Washington, DC, 9 October 1992.Google Scholar

51 Welsh, David and Wiechers, Marinus, ‘The 1983 Constitutional Referendum and the Future of South Africa: two views’, in South Africa International (Johannesburg), 14, 3, 1984, p. 433.Google Scholar

52 Razis, Vic, The American Connection: the influence of United States business on South Africa (London, 1986), p. 130.Google Scholar

53 Ibid. p. 88.

54 Sullivan, Leon H., ‘The Sullivan Principles and Change in South Africa’, in Africa Report (New York), 29, 3, 1984, pp. 48–9.Google Scholar See testimony of Sullivan, Leon H., US Congress, House of Representatives, Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittees on International Economic Policy and Trade and on Africa, in U.S. Corporate Activities in South Africa: hearings, Septemer and October 1981, and May and June 1992 (Washington, DC, 1983), pp. 7–8.Google Scholar

55 US corporate spending on welfare projects in South Africa was reported to have risen from $10 million in 1984 to $33 million by 1987. See Task Group of the Signatories, Sullivan, Meeting the Mandate for Change: a progress report on the application of the Sullivan Principles by U.S.companies in South Africa (New York, Industry Support Unit, 1984),Google Scholar and Venter, D. J., South Africa, Sanctions and the Multinationals (Chichester, 1989), pp. 160–2.Google Scholar

56 Testimony of Randall Robinson, Executive Director of Trans Africa, US Congress, House of Representatives, Committee on Banking, Finance and Urban Affairs, Subcommittees on Financial Institutions Supervision, Regulation and Insurance, South African Restrictions: hearings (Washington, DC, 1983), p. 126.Google Scholar

57 See Cooper, Alison, U.S. Business in South Africa, 1992 (Washington, DC, 1992), pp. 193–5.Google Scholar

58 Auerbach, Stuart, ‘Sullivan Abandons S. African Code’, in The Washington Post, 4 June 1987, pp. E1 and E4.Google Scholar

59 Dam's testimony, loc. cit. p. 53.

60 See US Agency for International Development, Congressional Presentation Fiscal Year…Annex one:Africa (Washington, DC, Annual editions);Google Scholar US Department of State, Special Working Group on South and Southern Africa, AID in South Africa: making a difference (Washington, DC, 1987);Google Scholar and address by the Under-Secretary of State for Political Affairs prepared for the World Affairs Council, Cleveland, Ohio, 15 June 1987, published as Armacost, Michael H., ‘The U.S. and Southern Africa: a current appraisal’, in U.S. Department of State Bulletin, 87, 2125, 1987, p. 49.Google Scholar

61 Coker, Christopher, The United States and South Africa, 1968–1985: Constructive Engagement and its critics (Durham, NC, 1986), p. 188.Google Scholar

62 Ibid.

63 Baskin, Jeremy, ‘AFL-CIO-AALC-CIA’, in South African Labour Bulletin (Durban), 8, 3, 1982, pp. 51–60.Google Scholar

64 US Department of State, Special Working Group on South and Southern Africa, AID in South Africa: making a difference (Washington, DC, 1987),Google Scholar and US Agency for International Development, Congressional Presentation Fiscal Year 1989. Annex one: Africa (Washington, DC, 1989).Google Scholar

65 Telephone conversation with Perkins, Edward J., US Ambassador to South Africa, 1986–1989, 30 December 1992.Google Scholar

66 Personal correspondence with Barrett, Dennis P., Director, South Africa Programmes, US AID, 4 March 1993.Google Scholar

67 Mark Edelman quoted by Baker, Pauline H., ‘Facing Up to Apartheid’, in Foreign Policy (Washington, DC), 64, 1986, p. 49.Google Scholar

68 Personal interview with de Llerk, J. H., Director, Americas, South African Department of Foreign Affairs, Pretoria, 23 April 1993.Google Scholar

69 ‘U.S. Envoy in South Africa’, in The New York Times, 19 November 1986, p. A15,Google Scholar and ‘Envoy Says Pretoria Barred Visit to Priest’, in ibid. 16 January 1987, p. A2.

70 Department of State briefing, 2 March 1988, published as ‘South Africa's Proposal to Ban Foreign Funds’, in US Department of State Bulletin, 88, 2134, 1988, p. 23.Google Scholar

71 Colugh, Michael, ‘Southern Africa: challenges and choices’, in Foreign Affairs, 66, 5, 1988, p. 1084.Google Scholar

72 Crocker, loc. cit. 1989, p. 160.

73 Crocker, op. cit. 1992, p. 76, original emphasis.

74 Personal interview, Gosende, October 1992.

75 Personal interview, Crocker, October, 1992.