Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T13:15:38.423Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Revolutionary legality and the Burkinabè insurrection

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 August 2021

Peter Brett*
Affiliation:
Queen Mary – University of London, LondonEN1 4NS, UK

Abstract

Coup leaders often purport to restore constitutional order. During Burkina Faso's 2014 ‘insurrection', however, Blaise Compaoré's opponents advanced detailed (international) legal arguments that significantly constrained their subsequent conduct. Theirs was to be a legal revolution. This article situates this stance within Burkina Faso's distinctive history of urban protest, whilst emphasising under-analysed international sources for the insurrection. ‘Insurgent’ lawyers, it argues, used international instruments to reinvigorate longstanding activist attempts to reconcile constitutional rights with a language of popular justice promoted by the revolutionary regime of Thomas Sankara (1983–7). After the insurrection, however, their emphasis on legality was used by Compaoré's supporters to expose the transitional authorities’ double-standards. Meanwhile, insurgent lawyers working for the transition had to work hard to reconcile (international) legal justifications for the insurrection with the expedient politics needed to defend the new dispensation.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

This manuscript benefited from excellent comments on earlier versions. The journal's anonymous reviewers were exceptionally helpful and generous with their time. The text was also much improved by feedback from Eloïse Bertrand, Emillie Flower and participants in Queen Mary's TheoryLab workshop. The greatest thanks, however, must go to Anselme Asseghna Somda, for all manner of help and support over the last five years.

References

REFERENCES

Bancé, A-L. 2014. ‘Editorial: Il faut soigner Blaise de la boulimie du pouvoir’, Bendré, 10 February. <https://www.facebook.com/CitoyenBalayeur/posts/272158162940045>, accessed 30.3.2020.,+accessed+30.3.2020.>Google Scholar
Banégas, R. 2015. ‘Putsch et politique de la rue au Burkina Faso: quand les étudiants débattent du Régiment de sécurité présidentielle’, Politique Africaine 139, 3: 147–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bassolé, H.F. 2018. ‘Procès du putsch manqué de septembre 2015: vers un nouveau renvoi ce 25 mai?’, Lefaso.net, 25 May. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article83608>, accessed 2.4.2020.,+accessed+2.4.2020.>Google Scholar
Bayala, B.E. 2018. Les Tribunaux Populaires de la Révolution et les Droits de l'Homme. Paris: l'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Baye, M. 2014. ‘Quelle transition au Burkina Faso? Le point de vue de Mame Madior BOYE, ancienne Premier Ministre de la République du Sénégal’, Lefaso.net, 2 November. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article61628>, accessed 31.3.2020.,+accessed+31.3.2020.>Google Scholar
Beucher, B. 2010. ‘La naissance de la communauté nationale burkinabè ou comment le Voltaïque devint un ‘Homme intègre’’, Politique Africaine 118, 2: 165–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beucher, B. 2018. ‘‘À comportement du berger, réponse du mouton’? Éléments pour une économie morale du soulèvement d'octobre 2014 au Burkina Faso’, Afrique Contemporaine 265, 1: 3958.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Branch, A. & Mampilly, Z.. 2015. Africa Uprising: popular protest and political change. London: Zed Books.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brett, P. & Gissel, L.E.. 2020. Africa and the Backlash Against International Courts. London: Zed Books.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, N. & Waller, J.. 2016. ‘Constitutional courts and political uncertainty: constitutional ruptures and the rule of judges’, International Journal of Constitutional Law 14, 4: 817–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Conseil National pour la Démocratie (CND). 2015. ‘Proclamation du Conseil National pour la Démocratie’, lefaso.net, 17 September. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article66901>, accessed 1.4.2020.,+accessed+1.4.2020.>Google Scholar
Chouli, L. 2015. ‘The popular uprising in Burkina Faso and the transition’, Review of African Political Economy 42, 144: 325–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dersso, S. 2019. ‘The status and legitimacy of popular uprisings in the AU norms on democracy and constitutional governance’, Journal of African Law 63, 1: 107–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Diallo, M. 2017. ‘Haute cour de justice du Burkina: la loi modifiée pour se conformer à la constitution’, Lefaso.net, 5 July. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article78118>, accessed 2.10.2020.,+accessed+2.10.2020.>Google Scholar
Dwyer, M. 2017. ‘Situating soldiers’ demands: mutinies and protests in Burkina Faso’, Third World Quarterly 38, 1: 219–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Engels, B. 2015. ‘Different means of protest, same causes: popular struggles in Burkina Faso’, Review of African Political Economy 42, 143: 92106.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Engels, B. 2019. ‘A stolen revolution: popular class mobilisation in Burkina Faso’, Labor History 60, 2: 110–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fau-Nougaret, M. 2015. ‘Une leçon burkinabè. Eléments de réflexion juridique sur l'insurrection burkinabè des 30 et 31 octobre 2014’, Constitutions 2/3: 221–8.Google Scholar
Frère, M-S. & Englebert, P.. 2015. ‘Briefing: Burkina Faso – the fall of Blaise Compaoré’, African Affairs 114, 455: 295307.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gabriel, M-C. 2017. ‘Quand les frondeurs deviennent des héros nationaux’, Cahiers d'études Africaines 227: 691718.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
de Groof, E.H.D. & Wiebusch, M., eds. 2020. International Law and Transitional Governance: critical perspectives. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hagberg, S. 2002. ‘‘Enough is Enough’: an ethnography of the struggle against impunity in Burkina Faso’, Journal of Modern African Studies 40, 2: 217–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hagberg, S. 2007. ‘Comprendre sans légitimer: corruption, impunité et une anthropologie engagée’, in Bierschenk, T., Blundo, G., Jaffré, Y. & Tidjani Alou, M., eds. Une anthropologie entre rigueur et engagement: essais autour de l'oeuvre Jean-Pierre Olivier de Sardan. Paris: Karthala. 355–69.Google Scholar
Hagberg, S. 2015. ‘‘Thousands of New Sankaras': resistance and struggle in Burkina Faso’, Africa Spectrum 50, 3: 109–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hagberg, S., Kibora, L., Barry, S. & Gnessi, S.. 2018. ‘Nothing will be as Before!’: Anthropological perspectives on political practice and democratic culture in ‘a new Burkina Faso’. Uppsala: Uppsala University Press.Google Scholar
Harsch, E. 2017. Burkina Faso: a history of power, protest and revolution. London: Zed Books.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
de Heredia, M.I. 2015. ‘Acephalous movements in Sub-Saharan Africa: the real basis for change?’ Cambridge: CGHR Research Group Seminar, 2 March.Google Scholar
Hilgers, M. & Mazzocchetti J, J.. 2006. ‘L'après Zongo: entre ouverture politique et fermeture des possibles’, Politique Africaine 101: 518.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hilgers, M. & Loada, A.. 2013. ‘Tensions et protestations dans un régime semi-autoritaire: croissance des révoltes populaires et maintien du pouvoir au Burkina Faso’, Politique Africaine 131, 3: 187208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kiendrebeogo, C. 2018. Thomas Sankara, les témoignages en toute vérité. Ouagadougou: Les Editions la République.Google Scholar
Laoundiki, C.M. 2019. ‘Procès du putsch du CND: la légalité du régime de la transition remise en cause’, Lefaso.net, 13 August. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article91352>, accessed 4.2.2020.,+accessed+4.2.2020.>Google Scholar
Larmer, M. 2015. ‘Historicising activism in late colonial and post-colonial Sub-Saharan Africa’, Journal of Historical Sociology 28: 6789.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lawson, G. 2015. ‘Revolutions and the international’, Theory and Society 44, 4: 299319.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lefaso.net. 2014. ‘Mobilisation citoyenne: Sept OSC annoncent la création du mouvement ‘AYO’’, 29 April. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article58968>, accessed 27.3.2020.,+accessed+27.3.2020.>Google Scholar
Lefaso.net. 2019. ‘Procès du putsch: ‘Blaise Compaoré a voulu violer un seul article, ceux qui lui reprochaient cela ont violé toute la Constitution’, soulève Me Degli’, 6 August. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article91213>, accessed 30.3.2020.,+accessed+30.3.2020.>Google Scholar
Lefaso.net. 2020. ‘Des citoyens interpellent le Conseil constitutionnel sur les risques et dangers du nouveau Code électoral’, 29 September. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article99615>, accessed 2.10.2020.,+accessed+2.10.2020.>Google Scholar
Loada, A. 1999. ‘Réflexions sur la société civile en Afrique: Le Burkina de l'après-Zongo’, Politique Africaine 76, 4: 136–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Loada, A. 2003. ‘La limitation du nombre de mandats présidentiels en Afrique francophone’, Revue électronique Afrilex 3: 139–74.Google Scholar
Loada, A. 2015. ‘Quelques brefs propos sur les enjeux de la transition démocratique au Burkina Faso à la lumière de la charte africaine de la démocratie, des élections et de la gouvernance’, 28 May. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article64986>, accessed 2.10.2020.,+accessed+2.10.2020.>Google Scholar
Martens, L. 1989. Sankara: Compaoré et la révolution burkinabè. Berchem: EPO.Google Scholar
Massoud, M.F. 2013. Law's Fragile State: colonial, authoritarian, and humanitarian legacies in Sudan. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moestrup, S. 2019. ‘Presidential term limits in Burkina Faso’, in Baturo, A. & Elgie, R., eds. The Politics of Presidential Term Limits. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 363–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Moustafa, T. 2011. ‘Law in the Egyptian revolt’, Middle East Law and Governance 3: 181–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mueller, L. 2018. Political Protest in Contemporary Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Otayek, R. 1989. ‘Burkina Faso: between feeble state and total state, the swing continues’, in O'Brien, D.C., Cruise, D.B., Dunn, J. & Rathbone, R., eds. Contemporary West African States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1330.Google Scholar
Ouaga Flash Info. 2019. ‘Procès Putsch Manqué: Supposé appel téléphonique entre Bassolet et Soro pendant les évènements de septembre 2015’, 21 March. <https://www.facebook.com/ouagaflashinfo/posts/2292155884391462>, accessed 1.4.2020.,+accessed+1.4.2020.>Google Scholar
Ouattara, V. 2006. L'ère Compaoré: crimes, politique et gestion du pouvoir. Paris: Klanba.Google Scholar
Ouédraogo, B. 2014. Droit, Démocratie et Développement en Afrique: un parfum de jasmin souffle sur le Burkina Faso. Paris: L'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Ouédraogo, O. 2017. ‘Procès de l'insurrection populaire: Le Conseil constitutionnel à l'épreuve de la protection des droits de l'homme et de la reconstruction d'une société post-crise’, Lefaso.net, 28 June. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article77992>, accessed 4.2.2020., accessed 4.2.2020.' href=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Ouédraogo,+O.+2017.+‘Procès+de+l'insurrection+populaire:+Le+Conseil+constitutionnel+à+l'épreuve+de+la+protection+des+droits+de+l'homme+et+de+la+reconstruction+d'une+société+post-crise’,+Lefaso.net,+28+June.+,+accessed+4.2.2020.>Google Scholar
Ouédraogo, S. & Ouédraogo, D.. 2015. ‘Libres propos sur la transition politique au Burkina Faso: du contexte au texte de la Charte de la Transition’, Revue Afrilex. <http://afrilex.u-bordeaux4.fr/libres-propos-sur-la-transition.html>..>Google Scholar
Ouédraogo, Y. 2016. ‘Retour sur une décision controversée: l'arrêt de la Cour de justice de la CEDEAO du 13 juillet 2015, CDP et autres c/ État du Burkina‘, Les Annales de Droit 10: 197232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Oulon, A.S. 2018. Insurrection Populaires d'octobre 2014 au Burkina Faso: les trahisons. Ouagadougou: Courrier Confidentiel.Google Scholar
Pacere, T.F. 2009. Les Origines Africaines des Avocats sans Frontière. Paris: L'Harmattan.Google Scholar
Parliamentary Group: Turnover, Democracy and Justice [AJD]. 2014. ‘Rapport general des premieres journees parlementaires 2014 du groupe parlementaire adj alternance-democratie et justice’, 23 February. <http://news.aouaga.com/h/21669.html>, accessed 2.10.2020.,+accessed+2.10.2020.>Google Scholar
Pommerolle, M-E. 2006. ‘Selective memory and universal claims: a comparative perspective on the politics of opposition in postcolonial Kenya’, Africa Today 53, 1: 7493.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
RFI. 2020. ‘France authorises Francois Compaoré extradition to Burkina Faso’, 6 March. <https://www.rfi.fr/en/africa/20200306-france-authorises-francois-compaore-extradition-burkina-faso>, accessed 2.10.2020.,+accessed+2.10.2020.>Google Scholar
RTB Télé. 2019. ‘Précisions du président de la Haute cour de Justice, Mathieu Bêbrigda Ouédraogo’, 31 October. <https://www.facebook.com/Justice.BurkinaFaso/videos/413799949556558>, accessed 2.10.2020.,+accessed+2.10.2020.>Google Scholar
Saidou, A.K. 2018. ‘‘We have chased Blaise, so nobody can resist us’: civil society and the politics of ECOWAS intervention in Burkina Faso’, South African Journal of International Affairs 25, 1: 3960.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Saliou, I. 2018. ‘La justice dans la transition politique au Burkina Faso’, Délibérée 5, 3: 64–9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sankara, T. 1984. ‘Les Tribunaux populaires de la révolution – 3 January 1984’, Sidwaya, n.d. <http://www.thomassankara.net/les-tribunaux-populaires-de-la-revolution-3-janvier-1984/>, accessed 10.9.2020.,+accessed+10.9.2020.>Google Scholar
Santiso, C. & Loada, A.. 2003. ‘Explaining the unexpected: electoral reform and democratic governance in Burkina Faso’, Journal of Modern African Studies 41, 3: 395419.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sawadogo, T.C. 2019. ‘Procès du putsch: Me Hervé Kam clôt les plaidoiries des parties civiles’, Lefaso.net, 14 June. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article90242>, accessed 2.4.2020.,+accessed+2.4.2020.>Google Scholar
Soma, A. 2015. ‘Réflexion sur le changement insurrectionnel au Burkina Faso’, Revue CAMES/SJP 1, 1: 114.Google Scholar
Soma, A. 2016. ‘Le crime international de changement anticonstitutionnel de gouvernement’, Swiss Review of International and European Law 26, 3: 417–43.Google Scholar
Sultany, N. 2017. Law and Revolution: legitimacy and constitutionalism after the Arab Spring. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Sy, C. 2017. Burkindlum: Mes Cahiers de la Résistance au Putsch de Septembre 2015 au Burkina Faso. Ouagadougou: Les éditions Bendré.Google Scholar
Traoré, E. 2014. ‘Du dialogue initié par le Président Compaoré: peut-on trouver des solutions justes à des problèmes mal posés, qui plus est, par un arbitre lui-même joueur?’, lefaso.net, 28 September. <https://lefaso.net/spip.php?article61023>, accessed 30.3.2020.,+accessed+30.3.2020.>Google Scholar
Wiebusch, M., Aniekwe, C.C., Oette, L. & Vandeginste, S.. 2019. ‘The African Charter on democracy, elections and governance: past, present and future.Journal of African Law 63, 1: 938.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wienkoop, N.-K. & Bertrand, E.. 2018. Popular Resistance to Authoritarian Consolidation in Burkina Faso, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. <https://carnegieendowment.org/2018/05/16/popular-resistance-to-authoritarian-consolidation-in-burkina-faso-pub-76363>, accessed 27.3.2020.,+accessed+27.3.2020.>Google Scholar
Winter, A. 2018. ‘Judicial review and democratization in Francophone West Africa: the case of Burkina Faso’, Verfassung und Recht in Übersee 51, 2: 140–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Witt, A. 2019. ‘Where regional norms matter: contestation and the domestic impact of the African Charter on democracy, elections and governance’, Africa Spectrum 54, 2: 106–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yaméogo, H. 2014. ‘La problématique de la Révision de la Constitution Burkinabè…’, 17 October. <http://news.aouaga.com/h/35792.html>, accessed 30.3.2020.,+accessed+30.3.2020.>Google Scholar
Yonaba, S. 1997. Indépendance de la justice et droits de l'homme: le cas du Burkina Faso. Leiden: PIOOM.Google Scholar
Zida, Y.I. 2018. ‘Je sais qui je suis’. Ouagadougou: Golan.Google Scholar
Zouré, A. 2014. ‘CDP, ADF/RDA et FEDAP/BC suspendus: Lectures croisées’, 17 December. <https://www.burkina24.com/2014/12/17/cdp-adfrda-et-fedapbc-suspendus-lectures-croisees/>, accessed 1.4.2020.,+accessed+1.4.2020.>Google Scholar
Zouré, A. 2015. ‘Luc Marius Ibriga: ‘La décision de la Cour vient résoudre un problème important’’, 13 July. <https://www.burkina24.com/2015/07/13/luc-marius-ibriga-la-decision-de-la-cour-vient-resoudre-un-probleme-important/>, accessed 1.4.2020.,+accessed+1.4.2020.>Google Scholar

Interviews

Kassoum Kambou, President of the Constitutional Council [group interview], Ouagadougou, 21.2.2016.Google Scholar
Ollo Mathias Kambou, Balai Citoyen, Ouagadougou, 18.4.2016, 7.8.2019.Google Scholar
David Moyenga, National Transitional Council (2014–15), Ouagadougou, 18.4.2016, 7.8.2019.Google Scholar
Anselme Asseghna Somda, National Transitional Council (2014–15), Paris and Ouagadougou, 22.2.2016, 18.4.2016, 8.2.2018, 7.8.2019.Google Scholar
Anonymous EU diplomat, Ouagadougou, 20.4.2016.Google Scholar
Anonymous ex-majority parliamentarian, Ouagadougou, 15.4.2016.Google Scholar
Anonymous former National Transitional Council member, Ouagadougou, 13.4.2016.Google Scholar