Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T20:50:02.113Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The People's Rôle in Allocating Provincial Commands in the Middle Roman Republic*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 July 2017

Simon Day
Simon Day*
Affiliation:
Wadham College, Oxford
*
simon.chris.day@gmail.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Mommsen — followed more recently by Brennan and Ferrary — proposed that laws were passed in around 228 and in 198 that constitutionally ‘fixed’ Sicily and Sardinia, and later Hispania Citerior and Hispania Ulterior, as praetorian prouinciae. This paper challenges that theory. It first examines the ancient evidence, comprising two ambiguous passages from Livy's Ab Vrbe Condita. It then offers a counter-hypothesis that elucidates the people's rôle in forestalling and/or resolving political disputes over the allocation of provincial commands. It will show that this rôle was crucial for mitigating the harmful effects of élite competition and, in turn, maintaining political stability in Rome.

Keywords

provincesRoman SenateRoman Peopleélite competitiondispute resolutionpolitical consensus‘regular’ prouinciae
Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Roman Studies , Volume 107 , November 2017 , pp. 1 - 26
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2017. Published by The Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

The dates used throughout this paper are b.c.e. unless otherwise indicated. I wish to thank John Rich for challenging me to think further about the notion of constitutionally ‘fixed’ prouinciae several years ago and for his valuable feedback on an earlier draft of this article. I am also very grateful to Christopher Mallan, Jonathan Prag and the Journal's Editor and anonymous reviewers for their advice and comments on various drafts of this article.

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Arena, V. 2012: Libertas and the Practice of Politics in the Late Roman Republic, Cambridge Google Scholar
Arnold, T. W. 1914: The Roman System of Provincial Administration to the Accession of Constantine the Great (3rd edn), Oxford Google Scholar
Beck, H. 2005: Karriere und Hierarchie: die römische Aristokratie und die Anfänge des cursus honorum in der mittleren Republik, Berlin Google Scholar
Beck, H. 2011: ‘Consular power and the Roman constitution: the case of imperium reconsidered’, in Beck et al. (eds) 2011, 77–96Google Scholar
Beck, H. 2016: ‘Money, power, and class coherence. The ambitus legislation of the 180s B.C.’, in Beck, H., Jehne, M. and Serrati, J. (eds), Money and Power in the Roman Republic, Brussels, 131–52Google Scholar
Beck, H., Duplá, A., Jehne, M., and Pina Polo, F. 2011: ‘The republic and its highest office: some introductory remarks on the Roman consulate’, in Beck et al. (eds) 2011, 1–15Google Scholar
Beck, H., Duplá, A., Jehne, M., and Pina Polo, F. (eds) 2011: Consuls and Res Publica: Holding High Office in the Roman Republic, Cambridge Google Scholar
Bergk, A. 2011: ‘The development of the praetorship in the third century BC’, in Beck et al. (eds) 2011, 61–74Google Scholar
Bertrand, J.-M. 1989: ‘À propos du mot provincia: Étude sur les modes d’élaboration du langage politique’, Journal des Savants 3–4, 191–215 Google Scholar
Brennan, T. C. 2000: The Praetorship in the Roman Republic, Vols I–II, Oxford Google Scholar
Brennan, T. C. 2004: ‘Power and process under the Republican “constitution”’, in Flower, H. (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to the Roman Republic, Cambridge, 31–65 Google Scholar
Briscoe, J. 2012: ‘Notes on the functions of the peregrine praetor in the Republic’, Latomus 71.4, 996–9Google Scholar
Brodersen, K. 2016: ‘The Geographies of Pliny and his “Ape” Solinus’, in Bianchetti, S., Catuadella, M. and Gehrke, H.-J. (eds), Brill's Companion to Ancient Geography: The Inhabited World in Greek and Roman Tradition, Leiden, 298–310 Google Scholar
Cornell, T. J. 1995: The Beginnings of Rome: Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000–264 BC), London Google Scholar
Cornell, T. J. 2004: ‘Deconstructing the Samnite Wars: an essay in historiography’, in Jones, H. (ed.), Samnium and Cultural Change: The Proceedings of the Third E. Togo Salmon Conference on Roman Studies, Providence, 115–31Google Scholar
Cotton, H. M., and Rogers, G. M. (eds) 2002: Rome, the Greek World, and the East, Vol. 1: The Roman Republic and the Augustan Revolution, Chapel Hill Google Scholar
Crawford, M. H. 1990: ‘Origini e sviluppi del sistema provinciale romano’, in Clemente, G., Coarelli, F. and Gabba, E. (eds), Storia di Roma, II.i, Turin, 91–121 Google Scholar
Crawford, M. H. 1992: The Roman Republic (2nd edn), London Google Scholar
Dahlheim, W. 1977: Gewalt und Herrschaft: Das provinziale Herrschaftssystem der römischen Republik, Berlin Google Scholar
Day, S. C. 2014: ‘The use of the prouincia classis in the third and second centuries B.C. and the concept of the prouincia ’, in Dubouloz, J., Pittia, S. and Sabatini, G. (eds), L'imperium Romanum en perspective. Les savoirs d'empire dans la République romaine et leur héritage dans l'Europe médiévale et moderne (Actes du colloque de Paris, 26–28 Novembre 2012) , Besançon, 211–29Google Scholar
De Sanctis, G. 1917: Storia dei Romani, Vol. III.ii, Turin Google Scholar
Derow, P. 1979: ‘Polybius, Rome and the East’, Journal of Roman Studies 69, 1–15 Google Scholar
Derow, P. 2007: ‘ Imperium, imperial space and empire’, in Yanguas, J. Santos and Pagola, E. Torregaray (eds), Laudes Provinciarum. Retórica y política en la representación del imperio romano, Vitoria-Gasteiz, 13–22 Google Scholar
Drogula, F. K. 2011: ‘The Lex Porcia and the development of legal restraints on Roman governors’, Chiron 41, 91–124 Google Scholar
Drogula, F. K. 2015: Commanders and Command in the Roman Republic and Early Empire, Chapel Hill Google Scholar
Ebel, C. 1976: Transalpine Gaul: the Emergence of a Roman Province, Leiden Google Scholar
Eckstein, A. M. 1987: Senate and General: Individual Decision Making and Roman Foreign Relations, 264–194 B.C., London Google Scholar
Ferrary, J.-L. 1988: Philhellénisme et impérialisme: aspects idéologiques de la conquête romaine du monde hellénistique, de la seconde guerre de Macédoine à la guerre contre Mithridate, Paris Google Scholar
Ferrary, J.-L. 2003: ‘La législation romaine dans les livres 21 à 45 de Tite-Live’, in Hantos, T. (ed.), Laurea internationalis. Festschrift für Jochen Bleicken zum 75. Geburtstag, Stuttgart, 107–42Google Scholar
Ferrary, J.-L. 2008: ‘Provinces, magistratures et lois: la création des provinces sous la République’, in Piso, I. (ed.), Die römischen Provinzen. Begriff und Gründung: Colloquium Cluj-Napoca (28 September–1 Oktober 2006), Cluj-Napoca, 7–18 Google Scholar
Ferrary, J.-L. 2010: ‘La législation comitiale en matière de création, d'assignation et de gouvernement des provinces’, in Barrandon, N. and Kirbihler, F. (eds), Administrer les provinces de la République romaine (Actes du colloque de l'Université de Nancy II 4–5 juin 2009), Rennes, 33–44 Google Scholar
Flaig, E. 2003: Ritualisierte Politik: Zeichen, Gesten und Herrschaft im alten Rom, Göttingen Google Scholar
Flower, H. I. 2010: Roman Republics, Princeton Google Scholar
Flower, H. I. 2014: Consensus and Community in Republican Rome (The Twentieth Todd Memorial Lecture, delivered at the University of Sydney, 18 July 2013), Sydney Google Scholar
Fronda, M. P. 2010: Between Rome and Carthage: Southern Italy during the Second Punic War, Cambridge Google Scholar
Grainger, J. D. 2002: The Roman War of Antiochos the Great, Leiden Google Scholar
Gruen, E. S. 1984: The Hellenistic World and the Coming of Rome, London Google Scholar
Harris, W. V. 1979: War and Imperialism in Republican Rome: 327–70 B.C., Oxford Google Scholar
Hermon, E. 1993: Rome et la Gaule Transalpine avant César: 125–59 av. J.-C., Québec Google Scholar
Hermon, E. 1996: ‘Formes de domination et formes d'administration provinciale dans l'empire romain républicain’, in Hermon, E. (ed.), Pouvoir et “imperium” (IIIe av. J.-C.–Ier ap. J.-C.), Actes du Colloque tenu dans le cadre du Congrès de la Fédération Internationale des Etudes Classiques (F.I.E.C.) du 24 au 26 août 1994, à l'Université Laval, Naples, 7–27 Google Scholar
Hölkeskamp, K.-J. 1993: ‘Conquest, competition and consensus: Roman expansion in Italy and the rise of the “nobilitas”’, Historia 12.1, 12–39 Google Scholar
Hölkeskamp, K.-J. 2000: ‘The Roman Republic: government of the people, by the people, for the people?’, Scripta Classica Israelica 19, 203–33Google Scholar
Hölkeskamp, K.-J. 2010: Reconstructing the Roman Republic: An Ancient Political Culture and Modern Research, trans. Heitmann-Gordon, H., Princeton Google Scholar
Hölkeskamp, K.-J. 2011: ‘The Roman Republic as theatre of power: the consuls as leading actors’, in Beck et al. (eds) 2011, 161–81Google Scholar
Hoyos, D. 1998: Unplanned Wars: the Origins of the First and Second Punic Wars, Berlin Google Scholar
Humm, M. 1999: ‘Le Comitium du forum romain et la réforme des tribus d'Appius Claudius Caecus’, Mélanges de l’École française de Rome. Antiquité 111.2, 625–94Google Scholar
Hurlet, F. 2012: ‘ Pro consule uel pro praetore? À propos des titres et des pouvoirs des gouverneurs prétoriens d'Afrique, de Sicile et de Sardaigne-Corse sous la République romaine (227–52 av. J.-C.)’, Chiron 42, 97–108 Google Scholar
Jehne, M. 2006: ‘Methods, models, and historiography’ (trans. R. Morstein-Marx and B. Wolkow), in Rosenstein and Morstein-Marx 2006, 3–28Google Scholar
Kallet-Marx, R. M. 1995: Hegemony to Empire: the Development of the Roman Imperium in the East from 148 to 62 B.C., Oxford Google Scholar
Keaveney, A. 2005: Sulla: The Last Republican (2nd edn), London Google Scholar
Kondratieff, E. 2010: ‘The urban praetor's tribunal in the Roman Republic’, in de Angelis, F. (ed.), Spaces of Justice in the Roman World, Leiden, 89–126 Google Scholar
Levene, D. S. 2010: Livy on the Hannibalic War, Oxford Google Scholar
Linke, B., and Stemmler, M. (eds) 2000: Mos Maiorum: Untersuchungen zu den Formen der Identitätsstiftung und Stabilisierung in der römischen Republik, Stuttgart Google Scholar
Lintott, A. 1981: ‘What was the “Imperium Romanum”?’, Greece and Rome 28.1, 53–67 Google Scholar
Lintott, A. 1993: Imperium Romanum: Politics and Administration, London Google Scholar
Lintott, A. 1999: The Constitution of the Roman Republic, Oxford Google Scholar
Loreto, L. 2007: La grande strategia di Roma nell'età della prima guerra punica (ca. 273–ca. 229 a.C.): L'inizio di un paradosso, Naples Google Scholar
Lushkov, A. H. 2014: ‘Narrative and notice in Livy's fourth decade: the case of Scipio Africanus’, Classical Antiquity 33.1, 102–29Google Scholar
Manuwald, G. 2007: Cicero, Philippics 3–9, Berlin Google Scholar
Milan, A. 1973: ‘I «socii nauales» di Roma’, Critica Storica 10, 193–221 Google Scholar
Millar, F. 1998: The Crowd in Rome in the Late Republic, Ann Arbor Google Scholar
Millar, F. 2002a: ‘Political power in mid-Republican Rome: curia or comitium?’, in Cotton and Rogers 2002, 85–108 (originally printed in Journal of Roman Studies 79 (1989), 138–50)Google Scholar
Millar, F. 2002b: ‘The political character of the Classical Roman Republic, 200–151 B.C.’, in Cotton and Rogers 2002, 109–42 (originally printed in Journal of Roman Studies 74 (1984), 1–19)Google Scholar
Millar, F. 2002c: ‘Politics, persuasion, and the people before the Social War (150–90 B.C.)’, in Cotton and Rogers 2002, 143–61 (originally published in Journal of Roman Studies 76 (1986), 1–11)Google Scholar
Millar, F. 2002d: ‘Popular politics at Rome in the late Republic’, in Cotton and Rogers 2002, 162–82 (originally printed in Malkin, I. and Rubinsohn, Z. W. (eds), Leaders and Masses in the Roman World: Studies in Honor of Zvi Yavetz, Leiden (1995), 91–113)Google Scholar
Millar, F. 2006: ‘Polybius between Greece and Rome’, in Cotton, H. M. and Rogers, G. M. (eds), Rome, the Greek World, and the East, Vol. 3: The Greek World, the Jews, and the East, Chapel Hill, 91–105 (originally published in J. T. A. Koumoulides and J. Brademas (eds), Greek Connections: Essays on Culture and Diplomacy, Notre Dame (1987), 1–18)Google Scholar
Mommsen, T. 1887: Römisches Staatsrecht, Vol. II (3rd edn), Leipzig Google Scholar
Mommsen, T. 1894: The History of Rome, Vols. I–V, trans. Dickson, W. P., London Google Scholar
Mommsen, T. 1906: ‘Die Rechtsfrage zwischen Caesar und dem Senat’, in Gesammelte Schriften, Vol. IV (Historische Schriften, Vol. I), Berlin, 92–145 Google Scholar
Morstein-Marx, R., and Rosenstein, N. 2006: ‘The transformation of the Republic’, in Rosenstein and Morstein-Marx 2006, 625–37Google Scholar
Nicolet, C. (ed.) 1978: Rome et la conquête du monde méditerranéen, 264–27 avant J.-C., Vol. I, Paris Google Scholar
Nicolet, C. 1991: Space, Geography, and Politics in the Early Roman Empire, trans. Leclerc, H., Ann Arbor Google Scholar
North, J. A. 2004: ‘Democratic politics in Republican Rome’, in Osborne, R. (ed.), Studies in Ancient Greek and Roman Society, Cambridge, 140–58 (originally printed in Past and Present 126 (1990), 3–21)Google Scholar
Oakley, S. P. 1997: A Commentary on Livy: Books VI–X, Vol. I: Introduction and Book VI, Oxford Google Scholar
Oakley, S. P. 1998: A Commentary on Livy: Books VI–X, Vol. II: Books VII–VIII, Oxford Google Scholar
Oakley, S. P. 2005: A Commentary on Livy: Books VI–X, Vol. IV: Book X, Oxford Google Scholar
Paananen, U. 1993: ‘Legislation in the comitia centuriata ’, in Paananen, U., Heikkilä, K., Sandberg, K., Savunen, L. and Vaahtera, J. (eds), SENATVS POPVLVSQVE ROMANVS: Studies in Roman Republican Legislation (Acta Instituti Romani Finlandiae, Vol. XIII), Helsinki, 9–73 Google Scholar
Pina Polo, F. 2011: The Consul at Rome: the Civil Functions of the Consuls in the Roman Republic, Cambridge Google Scholar
Pinzone, A. 2004: ‘I socii navales siciliani’, in Caltabiano, M. Caccamo, Campagna, L. and Pinzone, A. (eds), Nuove prospettive della ricerca sulla Sicilia del III sec. a.C. Archeologia, numismatica, storia: Atti dell'incontro di studio (Messina 4–5 Iuglio 2002), Messina, 11–34 Google Scholar
Prag, J. R. W. 2007: ‘ Auxilia and gymnasia: a Sicilian model of Roman imperialism’, Journal of Roman Studies 97, 68–100 Google Scholar
Prag, J. R. W. 2012: ‘Sicily and Sardinia-Corsica: the first provinces’, in Hoyos, D. (ed.), A Companion to Roman Imperialism, Leiden, 53–65 Google Scholar
Prag, J. R. W. forthcoming: ‘τέλη τὰ θαλάσσια in Appian Sik. 2.6 and Roman taxation in Sicily between the Punic Wars’Google Scholar
Quinn, J. C. 2004: ‘The role of the 146 settlement in the provincialization of Africa’, in Khanoussi, M., Ruggeri, P. and Vismara, C. (eds), L'Africa romana: ai confini dell'impero contatti, scambi, conflitti. Atti del xv convegno di studio Tozeur (11–15 dicembre 2002), Rome, 1593–1601 Google Scholar
Rich, J. W. 1976: Declaring War in the Roman Republic in the Period of Transmarine Expansion, Brussels Google Scholar
Rich, J. W. 1988: Review of J. Richardson, Hispaniae: Spain and the Development of Roman Imperialism, 218–82 BC , Journal of Roman Studies 78, 212–14Google Scholar
Rich, J. W. 1993: ‘Fear, greed and glory: the causes of Roman war-making in the middle Republic’, in Rich, J. W. and Shipley, G. (eds), War and Society in the Roman World, London, 38–68 Google Scholar
Rich, J. W. 2005: ‘Valerius Antias and the construction of the Roman past’, Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 49, 137–61CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rich, J. W. 2008: ‘Treaties, allies and the Roman conquest of Italy’, in de Souza, P. and France, J. (eds), War and Peace in Ancient and Medieval History, Cambridge, 51–75 Google Scholar
Rich, J. W. 2011: ‘Structuring Roman history: the consular year and the Roman historical tradition’, Histos 5, 1–43, available at http://research.ncl.ac.uk/histos/Histos_BackIssues2011.html (accessed March 2017)Google Scholar
Rich, J. W. 2014: ‘The triumph in the Roman Republic: frequency, fluctuation and policy’, in Lange, C. H. and Vervaet, F. J. (eds), The Roman Republican Triumph Beyond the Spectacle, Rome, 197–258 Google Scholar
Richardson, J. S. 1975: ‘The triumph, the praetors and the Senate in the early second century B.C.’, Journal of Roman Studies 65, 50–63 Google Scholar
Richardson, J. S. 1986: Hispaniae: Spain and the Development of Roman Imperialism, 218–82 BC, Cambridge Google Scholar
Richardson, J. S. 1994: ‘The administration of the Empire’, in Crook, J. A., Lintott, A. and Rawson, E. (eds), The Cambridge Ancient History, Vol. IX (2nd edn), Cambridge, 564–98Google Scholar
Richardson, J. S. 2008: The Language of Empire: Rome and the Idea of Empire from the Third Century BC to the Second Century AD, Cambridge Google Scholar
Rosenstein, N. 1995: ‘Sorting out the lot in Republican Rome’, American Journal of Philology 116.1, 43–75 Google Scholar
Rosenstein, N., and Morstein-Marx, R. (eds) 2006: A Companion to the Roman Republic, Oxford Google Scholar
Ryan, F. X. 1998: Rank and Participation in the Republican Senate, Stuttgart Google Scholar
Santangelo, F. 2007: Sulla, the Elites and the Empire: A Study of Roman Policies in Italy and the Greek East, Leiden Google Scholar
Santangelo, F. 2014: ‘Roman politics in the 70s B.C.: a story of realignments?’, Journal of Roman Studies 104, 1–27 Google Scholar
Satterfield, S. 2012: ‘Livy and the timing of expiation in the Roman year’, Histos 6, 67–90, available at http://research.ncl.ac.uk/histos/HISTOS62012.html (accessed March 2017)Google Scholar
Scullard, H. H. 1973: Roman Politics. 220–150 B.C. (2nd edn), Oxford Google Scholar
Simmel, G. 1992: Soziologie. Untersuchungen über die Formen der Vergesellschaftung, Frankfurt am Main Google Scholar
Steel, C. 2013: The End of the Roman Republic, 146 to 44 BC: Conquest and Crisis, Edinburgh Google Scholar
Steel, C. 2014a: ‘Rethinking Sulla: the case of the Roman Senate’, The Classical Quarterly 64.2, 657–68Google Scholar
Steel, C. 2014b: ‘The Roman Senate and the post-Sullan res publica ’, Historia 63.3, 323–39Google Scholar
Steel, C., and van der Blom, H. 2013: ‘Introduction’, in Steel, C. and van der Blom, H. (eds), Community and Communication: Oratory and Politics in Republican Rome, Oxford, 1–7 Google Scholar
Stewart, R. 1998: Public Office in Early Rome: Ritual Procedure and Political Practice, Ann Arbor Google Scholar
Straumann, B. 2016: Crisis and Constitutionalism: Roman Political Thought from the Fall of the Republic to the Age of Revolution, New York Google Scholar
van der Blom, H. 2010: Cicero's Role Models: the Political Strategy of a Newcomer, Oxford Google Scholar
Vervaet, F. J. 2006: ‘The scope of the Lex Sempronia concerning the assignment of the consular provinces (123 BCE)’, Athenaeum 94, 625–54Google Scholar
Vervaet, F. J. 2012: ‘The praetorian proconsuls of the Roman Republic (211–52 BCE). A constitutional survey’, Chiron 42, 45–96 Google Scholar
Vervaet, F. J. 2014: The High Command in the Roman Republic: The Principle of the summum imperium auspiciumque from 509 to 19 BCE, Stuttgart Google Scholar
Walbank, F. W. 1957: A Historical Commentary on Polybius, Vol. I: Commentary on Books I–VI, Oxford Google Scholar
Walbank, F. W. 1979: A Historical Commentary on Polybius, Vol. 3: Commentary on Books XIX–XL, Oxford Google Scholar
Warrior, V. M. 1996: The Initiation of the Second Macedonian War: An Explication of Livy Book 31, Stuttgart Google Scholar
Willems, P. 1885: Le Sénat de la République romaine: sa composition et ses attributions, Vol. II (2nd edn), Louvain Google Scholar
Yakobson, A. 2006: ‘Popular power in the Roman Republic’, in Rosenstein and Morstein-Marx 2006, 383–400Google Scholar
Yakobson, A. 2009: ‘Public opinion, foreign policy and “just war” in the late Republic’, in Eilers, C. (ed.), Diplomats and Diplomacy in the Roman World, Leiden, 45–72 Google Scholar
Yakobson, A. 2010: ‘Traditional political culture and the people's role in the Roman Republic’, Historia 30, 1–21 Google Scholar