Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T07:13:26.527Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

“Our Lady Sportsmen”: Gender Class, and Conservation in Sport Hunting Magazines, 1873-1920

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 November 2010

Andrea L. Smalley
Andrea L. Smalley
Affiliation:
Northern Illinois University
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In 1968 Outdoor Life ran a retrospective piece that examined the turn-of-the-century origins of this popular sportsmen's magazine. In the article, editor William Rae noted, with some dismay, that two out of the first three stories in the December 1905 issue featured women hunters, including the tale of a “tireless Diana” who left her corset at home in order to take to the fields. “One wonders,” Rae commented dryly, “whether men really were men in those days, as we have been led to believe.” Clearly, Rae found the spectacle of sport hunting women unusual, and he assumed that their presence in the pages of a hunting periodical called into question the masculinity of earlier sportsmen. The connection that Rae and Outdoor Life readers made in 1968 between hunting and masculinity remains a commonplace. As feminist scholar Mary Zeiss Stange argues, hunting “might be, in the popular mind, the most male-identified cultural pursuit.”

Type
Essays
Information
The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era , Volume 4 , Issue 4 , October 2005 , pp. 355 - 380
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Historians of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era 2005

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Rae, William, “Long Live Outdoor Life,” Outdoor Life, June 1968, 6Google Scholar . Other outdoor writers in the 1960s and 1970s commented on women's frequent appearance in earlier sportsmen's magazines and questioned the “men-only image” of field sports. See for example, Nichols, Margaret G., “The Proper Perspective,” Field and Stream, March 1973, 179Google Scholar , and Starnes, Richard, “To the Ladies,” Field and Stream, May 1972, 24Google Scholar ; Stange, Mary Zeiss, Woman the Hunter (Boston, 1997), 1Google Scholar .

2 Rotundo, E. Anthony, American Manhood: Transformations in Masculinityfrom the devolution to the Modern Era (New York, 1993), 227–32Google Scholar ; Bederman, Gail, Manliness and Civilization: A Cultural History of Gender and Race in the United States, 1880-1917 (Chicago, 1995), 23CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; Reiger, John F., American Sportsmen and the Origins of Conservation, revised ed. (Norman, Okla., 1986), 22Google Scholar . See for example, Altherr, Thomas L. and Reiger, John F., “Academic Historians and Hunting: A Call for More and Better Scholarship,” Environmental History Review 19 (Fall 1995): 39–56Google Scholar ; Dunlap, Thomas R., “Sport Hunting and Conservation, 1880-1920,” Environmental Review 12 (Spring 1988): 51–60Google Scholar ; Herman, Daniel Justin, Hunting and the American Imagination (Washington, D.C., 2001)Google Scholar ; Jacoby, Karl, Crimes Against Nature: Squatters, Poachers, Thieves, and the Hidden History of American Conservation (Berkeley, 2001)Google Scholar .

3 “To the Ladies,” Forest and Stream, August 14, 1873, 10Google Scholar ; “Salutatory,” Forest and Stream, January 11, 1877, 361Google Scholar ; Mott, Frank Luther, History of American Magazines, 1865-1885, vol. 3 (Cambridge, 1938), 210Google Scholar ; Rae, William E., A Treasury of Outdoor Life (New York, 1975), xiiiGoogle Scholar ; Hunter, Julia A. and Shettleworth, Earle G. Jr, Fly Rod Crosby: The Woman Who Marketed Maine (Gardiner, Maine, 2000), 52Google Scholar . Forest and Stream had six women upon its list of frequent contributors by 1874Google Scholar . Outdoor Life employed women as “lady representatives” in 1904 and 1914 to publicize the magazineGoogle Scholar . See ”Our Lady Representative,” Outdoor Life, December 1904, 879Google Scholar ; East, Ben, “Journey of the Outdoor life Girl,” Outdoor Life, July 1973, 61–62Google Scholar .

4 Dunlap, Thomas R., Saving America's Wildlife (Princeton, 1988), 9–12Google Scholar ; , Reiger, American Sportsmen, 26Google Scholar ; “Our Lady Sportsmen,” Forest and Stream, January 15, 1874, 361Google Scholar . For analyses of conservation and class conflict, see for example, Jacoby, Crimes Against Nature; Johnson, Benjamin Heber, “Conservation, Subsistence, and Class at the Birth of Superior National Forest,” Environmental History 4 (January 1999): 80–99CrossRefGoogle Scholar .

5 Fass, Paula, The Damned and the Beautiful: American Youth in the 1920s (New York, 1977)Google Scholar ; Lasch, Christopher, Haven in a Heartless World: The Family Besieged (New York, 1977)Google Scholar ; Erenberg, Lewis A., Steppin' Out: New York Nightlife and the Transformation of American Culture, 1890-1930 (Westport, Conn., 1981)Google Scholar . Fass, Lasch, and Erenberg identify the middle class as the locus of cultural change. Studies that focus on the urban working-class and challenge this “trickle-down” model of cultural transmission include: Peiss, Kathy, Cheap Amusements: Working Women and Leisure in Turn-of-the-Century New York (Philadelphia, 1986), 4–8, 184Google Scholar ; Rosenzweig, Roy, Eight Hours for What We Will: Workers and Leisure in an Industrial City, 1870-1920 (Cambridge, 1983), 4–5Google Scholar ; Meyerowitz, Joanne, Women Adrift: Independent Wage Earners in Chicago, 1880-1930 (Chicago, 1988), 116Google Scholar ; Enstad, Nan, Ladies of Labor, Girls of Adventure: Working Women, Popular Culture, and Labor Politics at the Turn of the Twentieth Century (New York, 1999), 6–14Google Scholar .

6 Studies of gender and culture that advance this interpretation of hunting include: Bederman, Manliness and Civilisation, 171-77, 207–15Google Scholar ; Kimmel, Michael, Manhood in America: A Cultural History (New York, 1996), 7, 125Google Scholar ; Rotundo, E. Anthony, “Boy Culture: Middle-Class Boyhood in Nineteenth-Century America,” in Meanings for Manhood: Constructions of Masculinity in Victorian America, ed. Carnes, Mark C. and Griffen, Clyde (Chicago, 1990), 17–18Google Scholar ; , Rotundo, American Manhood, 227Google Scholar ; Gorn, Elliott, The Manly Art (Ithaca, 1986), 187–88Google Scholar ; Slotkin, Richard, “Nostalgia and Progress: Theodore Roosevelt's Myth of the Frontier,” American Quarterly 33 (Winter 1981): 612, 633CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; Nash, Roderick, ed., Call of the Wild, 1900-1916 (New York, 1970), 317Google Scholar . For studies devoted more specifically to hunting, see Altherr, Thomas L., “The American Hunter-Naturalist,” Journal of Sport History 5 (Spring 1978): 7–21Google Scholar ; , Dunlap, Saving America's Wildlife, 5–17Google Scholar ; , Reiger, American Sportsmen, 25-49, 199Google Scholar ; Hahn, Steven, “Hunting, Fishing, and Foraging: Common Rights and Class Relations in the Postbellum South,” Radical History Revieivld (Oct. 1982): 37–64Google Scholar ; Jacoby, Crimes Against Nature. For explanations of women's place in hunting, see Marks, Stuart A., Southern Hunting in Black and White: Nature, History, and Ritual in a Carolina Community (Princeton, 1991), 6Google Scholar ; Ownby, Ted, Subduing Satan: Religion, Recreation, and Manhood in the Rural South, 1865-1920 (Chapel Hill, 1990), 22–24Google Scholar . Daniel Justin Herman's recent cultural history of American hunting devotes more attention to sport hunting women than most other studies. He argues that women's participation in sport hunting was a challenge to middle-class patriarchy and part of a broader movement for equality. See , Herman, Hunting and the American Imagination, 228–32Google Scholar .

7 , Reiger, American Sportsmen, 25-28, 30Google Scholar ; , Dunlap, Saving America's Wildlife, 10–11Google Scholar . American Sportsman, renamed Rod and Gun, was absorbed by Forest and Stream in 1877Google Scholar .

8 , Reiger, American Sportsmen, 30-33, 39–40Google Scholar ; , Altherr, “The American Hunter-Naturalist,” 13Google Scholar ; , Dunlap, Saving America's Wildlife, 9Google Scholar . See also Trefethen, James B., Crusadefor Wildlife: Highlights in Conservation Progress (New York, 1961)Google Scholar . Between 1873 and 1898 a number of Forest and Stream's conservation articles were reprinted by the New York Times, including a petition for the creation of Yellowstone National Park. See, for example, “To Preserve the National Park,” New York Times, March 18, 1888Google Scholar ; “The Yellowstone Park Scandal,” New York Times, May 4, 1890Google Scholar ; “How Our Forests Are Preserved,” New York Times, May 6, 1890Google Scholar .

9 Interestingly, Forest and Stream printed Fannie Pearson Hardy's polemic, “Six Years Under the Maine Game Laws,” in which she complained that rural people were oppressed by game laws that favored “out-of-state ‘sports’.” , Hunter and , Shettleworth, Fly Rod Crosby, 16–17Google Scholar ; , Altherr, “The American Hunter-Naturalist,” 1Google Scholar ; , Dunlap, “Sport Hunting and Conservation,” 58–59Google Scholar ; , Reiger, American Sportsmen, 30–33Google Scholar ; , Slotkin, “Nostalgia and Progress,” 612, 633Google Scholar ; “The Purpose of Field Sports,” Forest and Stream, February 16, 1882, 47Google Scholar ; “The Ethics of Hunting,” Forest and Stream, November 22, 1888, 341Google Scholar . Grinnell created, in partnership with Theodore Roosevelt, the exclusive Boone and Crockett club for well-to-do New York sportsmen. For the history of the Boone and Crockett Club, see Trefethen, Crusadefor Wildlife.

10 , Jacoby, Crimes Against Nature, 89Google Scholar ; Hammond, Henry, “Beech Island Farmers' Club, Minutes,” June 1875, June 6, 1876, 221–39Google Scholar ; quoted in , Hahn, “Hunting, Fishing, Foraging,” 46Google Scholar ; “The Ethics of Hunting,” Forest and Stream, November 22, 1888, 341Google Scholar ; Hallock, Charles, “Unclean Creatures,” Forest and Stream, June 17, 1875, 299Google Scholar ; “Sports and Sportsmen,” Forest and Stream, April 5, 1877, 132Google Scholar ; , Tripod, “Sojourn on Buck Bayou,” Forest and Stream, January 9, 1909, 49Google Scholar .

11 “Sportsmen vs. Poachers,” Forest and Stream, November 20, 1873, 232Google Scholar ; “The Purpose of Field Sports,” Forest and Stream, February 16, 1882, 47Google Scholar ; “New Facts on Game Protection,” Forest and Stream, January 26, 1882, 503Google Scholar ; , Mohigan, Forest and Stream, September 6, 1902, 185Google Scholar ; , Altherr, “The American Hunter-Naturalist,” 1Google Scholar ; , Reiger, American Sportsmen, 61Google Scholar ; ”New Facts on Game Protection,” Forest and Stream, March 24, 1881, 139Google Scholar ; ”Work and Sport,” Forest and Stream, March 16, 1912, 340Google Scholar .

12 Hallock, Charles, “Editorial,” Forest and Stream, August 14, 1873, 8Google Scholar ; “The Purpose of Field Sports,” 47-48; , Jacoby, Crimes Against Nature, 16Google Scholar .

13 , Hallock, “Unclean Creatures,” 299Google Scholar ; , Hallock, “Editorial,” 8Google Scholar ; “The Sportsman's Plea,” Forest and Stream, October 8, 1904, 301Google Scholar .

14 , Reiger, American Sportsmen, 22, 32Google Scholar ; , Altherr, “The American Hunter-Naturalist,” 9Google Scholar ; , Bederman, Manliness and Civilisation, 211–12Google Scholar ; , Herman, Hunting and the American Imagination, 229, 232Google Scholar .

15 “Woman Out Of Doors,” Forest and Stream, October 13, 1894, 309Google Scholar .

16 Hallock, Charles, “Editorial,” Forest and Stream, August 30, 1880, 81Google Scholar .

17 Hallock, Charles, “Editorial,” Forest and Stream, August 30, 1880, 81Google Scholar ; “Editorial,” Forest and Stream, October 30, 1873, 185–86Google Scholar ; “Lady Gunners,” Forest and Stream, June 3, 1911, 875Google Scholar ; “The Modern Sportswoman,” Forest and Stream, April 22, 1911, 605Google Scholar ; ”Woman Out Of Doors,” Forest and Stream, October 13, 1894, 309Google Scholar .

18 “Editorial,” Forest and Stream, July 2, 1885, 451Google Scholar ; Bradley, C. L., “Woman and Field Sports,” Forest and Stream, May 27, 1899, 404Google Scholar ; “The Modern Sportswoman,” Forest and Stream, April 22, 1911, 605Google Scholar .

19 , Peiss, Cheap Amusements, 179Google Scholar ; , Erenberg, Steppin' Out, 5Google Scholar ; “Podger's Commentaries,” Forest and Stream, February 10, 1894, 114Google Scholar ; , Brown, “Lady Campers,” 451Google Scholar ; “Our Ladies' Department,” Forest and Stream, January 11, 1877, 360Google Scholar ; “Women in Arcadia,” Forest and Stream, May 8, 1879, 270Google Scholar ; “The Lady Argonauts,” Forest and Stream, October 23, 1873, 169Google Scholar .

20 “Women in Camp,” Forest and Stream, July 24, 1909, 107Google Scholar ; Brown, “Lady Campers,”

21 “Women in Camp,”107; “Letter to the Editor,” Forest and Stream, December 25, 1873, 315Google Scholar ; Stevens, J. Arms & Tool Company Advertisement, Forest and Stream, January 30, 1909, 192Google Scholar ; Winchester Shotguns Advertisement, Forest and Stream, January 30, 1909, 189Google Scholar ; Ithaca Gun Advertisement, Forest and Stream, December 1917, 625Google Scholar ; Photo, Trapshooting, Forest and Stream, August 3, 1912, 150Google Scholar ; “A Western Diana,” Forest and Stream, September 13, 1877, 114Google Scholar ; Stange, E. A., “A Mountain Heroine,” Outdoor Life, February 1904, 89Google Scholar ; See also, for example, Deweese, Dall, “A Sportswoman in Alaska,” Outdoor Life, October 1899, 45Google Scholar ; Belknap, Orin, “Her First Deer,” Forest and Stream, March 4, 1898, 245Google Scholar . See, for example, Grinnell, George Bird, Heyond the Old Frontier: Adventures of Indian-Fighters, Hunters, and Fur Traders (New York, 1913)Google Scholar ; Roosevelt, Theodore, Hunting Trips of a Ranchman: Sketches of Sport on the Northern Cattle Plains (New York, 1885)Google Scholar .

22 Grinnell, George Bird and Reynolds, Charles B., quoted in Reiger, American Sportsmen, 71Google Scholar ; “Woman in the Field,” Forest and Stream, March 20, 1909, 427Google Scholar ; “The Modern Sportswoman,” Forest and Stream, April 22, 1911, 605Google Scholar ; , Jacoby, Crimes Against Nature, 16Google Scholar .

23 Rice, Arthur F., “The Sportswoman,” Forest and Stream, January 26, 1895, 62–63Google Scholar ; “Woman in the Field,” Forest and Stream, October 17, 1903, 293Google Scholar ; “Woman in the Field,” Forest and Stream, March 20, 1909, 427Google Scholar ; Brown, L. F., “Lady Campers: Beneficence of Angling and Hunting by Women,” Outdoor Life, November 1906, 444Google Scholar .

24 , Rice, “The Sportswoman,” 62–63Google Scholar ; “Woman in the Field,” Forest and Stream, March 20, 1909, 427Google Scholar ; , Brown, “Lady Campers,” 451Google Scholar .

25 , Altherr, “The American Hunter-Naturalist,” 7Google Scholar ; “The Purpose of Field Sports,” 47-48; “Editorial,” Forest and Stream, July 2, 1901, 41Google Scholar ; Theodore Roosevelt, “Nature Faker,” Everybody's Magazine, September 1907, 429Google Scholar ; , Bederman, Manliness and Civilization, 208Google Scholar ; “Sport and Its Critics,” Forest and Stream, July 20, 1901, 41Google Scholar .

26 Pepple, Ruth Alexander, “Famous Women Trapshooters and Writers,” Outdoor Life, February 1916, 123Google Scholar ; “Women's Column,” Forest and Stream, November 13, 1879, 809Google Scholar ; Bennett, Nellie, “My First Deer Hunt,” Outdoor Life, February 1903, 85Google Scholar ; A. W. C. “A Woman's First Moose Hunt,” Forest and Stream, June 18, 1904, 502–03Google Scholar ; Ridley, Margaret, “A Woman on the Trap Trail: Incidents of Outdoor Winter Life in the High Sierras of Idaho,” Forest and Stream, February 20, 1909, 288–90Google Scholar .

27 Mrs. Wheeler, H. C., “A Woodland Tragedy,” Outdoor Ufe, August 1906, 129–30Google Scholar ; Washburn, Hattie, “The Widow of the Prairie,” Outdoor Life, May 1905, 403–04Google Scholar .

28 Pepple, Ruth Alexander, “A Plains Tragedy,” Outdoor Life, October 1914, 310Google Scholar . For an example of men's arguments for wildlife legislation, see Grinnell, George Bird, “The Audubon Society,” Forest and Stream, February 11, 1886, 41Google Scholar . Grinnell founded the society for the preservation and propagation of non-game species. See , Reiger, American Sportsmen, 66–69Google Scholar .

29 “A Woman Who Wants To Hunt,” Outdoor Life, July 1915, 64–65Google Scholar ; “Woman in the Field,” Forest and Stream, July 1890, 126Google Scholar ; Mrs. , D., “Woman in the Wilds,” Forest and Stream, March 24, 1894, 245Google Scholar .

30 Knipe, Bertha McE., “The Out Of Door Life,” Outdoor Life, May 1909, 467Google Scholar ; Pepple, Ruth Alexander, “The Outdoor Woman,” Outdoor Life, March 1914, 3–4Google Scholar ; Simpson, Alice M., “The Woman as a Camper,” Outdoor Life, July 1907, 20Google Scholar ; “Women's Column,” Forest and Stream, November 27, 1879, 848Google Scholar ; “Trials and Tribulations of a Sportsman's Wife,” Forest and Stream, September 11, 1879, 626–27Google Scholar .

31 “Salutatory,” Forest and Stream, January 11, 1877, 361Google Scholar ; “Salutatory,” Forest and Stream, January 15, 1874, 361Google Scholar ; “A Woman's View of It,” Forest and Stream, September 29, 1894, 266Google Scholar ; “Woman Out Of Doors,” Forest and Stream, October 13, 1894, 309Google Scholar .

32 Women also began to write general interest columns in the early twentieth century, including Ruth Alexander Pepple's trapshooting column in Outdoor Life and Cornelia “FlyRod” , Crosby's “Maine Department,” which first appeared in Field and Stream in 1901Google Scholar . , A. W. C., “A Woman's First Moose Hunt,” Forest and Stream, June 11, 1904, 482–83Google Scholar ; , A. W. C., “A Woman's First Moose Hunt,” Forest and Stream, June 18, 1904, 502–03Google Scholar ; , Ridley, “A Woman on the Trap-Trail,” 248–49Google Scholar ; Bennett, Nellie, “A Colorado Outing,” Outdoor Life, August 1904, 511Google Scholar .

33 , A. W. C., “A Woman's Moose Hunt,” Forest and Stream, 482–83Google Scholar ; O'Hara, Julie Caroline, “My Camping Adventure,” Outdoor Life, June 1907, 559Google Scholar ; O'Hagan, Anne, “Camping for Women,” Forest and Stream, August 16, 1902, 125Google Scholar . For other examples see Scott, Laura A., “Hunting Jervis Inlet, B.C.,” Outdoor Life, February 1907, 155Google Scholar ; Doolitde, Dorothy, “A Girl's Version of a Turkey Hunt,” Outdoor Life, November 1905, 918Google Scholar ; Noel, Delma, “A Woman After Grizzlies,” Outdoor Life, October 1907, 347Google Scholar ; , M. S. W., “A Woman on a Game Preserve: A Superintendent's Wife Who Tried but Failed to Become Reconciled to a Life in the Forest,” Forest and Stream, October 2, 1909, 528–29Google Scholar .

34 “To the Ladies, Greeting!” Forest and Stream, December 11, 1879, 890Google Scholar ; “Women's Column,” Forest and Stream, December 25, 1879, 938Google Scholar ; Way, Jay, “Fro m a Sportsman's Daughter,” Forest and Stream, March 1918, 190Google Scholar .

35 “Salutatory,” Forest and Stream, January 11, 1877, 361Google Scholar ; “Woman's Column,” Forest and Stream, February 5, 1880, 17Google Scholar .

36 , Majorie, “A Breach of Convention I,” Outdoor Life, March 1900, 331Google Scholar ; , Marjorie, “A Breach of Convention II,” Outdoor Life, April 1900, 398Google Scholar .

37 , Herman, Hunting and the American Imagination, 228–32Google Scholar ; Pepple, Ruth Alexander, “Where the Ladies May ‘Speak Up in Meeting’,” Outdoor Life, March 1916, 314Google Scholar ; , Hunter and , Shettleworth, Fly Rod Crosby, 24, 27, 62, 67Google Scholar .

38 “Women in Arcadia,” Forest and Stream, May 8, 1879, 270Google Scholar ; “The Modern Sportswoman,” Forest and Stream, April 22, 1911, 605Google Scholar ; “A Hobby,” Forest and Stream, June 22, 1912, 792Google Scholar .

39 Lund, Thomas A., American Wildlife Law (Berkeley, 1980), 60–62Google Scholar ; , Dunlap, Saving America's Wildlife, 12, 37-38, 46Google Scholar ; , Altherr, “The American-Hunter Naturalist,” 17Google Scholar .

40 , Nichols, “10th Lordship Tops the Record,” Field and Stream, September 1938, 52–53Google Scholar .

41 , Stange, Woman the Hunter, 1Google Scholar ; , Rae, “Long Live Outdoor life,” 6Google Scholar . During and after World War II, sportsmen's magazines began to link explicitly hunting with masculinity and, more importantly, began to suggest that women could not be legitimate hunters. For the connection between World War II and masculinity in outdoor periodicals see Altherr, Thomas, “Mallards and Messerschmitts: American Hunting Magazines and the Image of American Hunting During World War II,” Journal of Sport History 14 (Summer 1987): 151–63Google Scholar ; Smalley, Andrea L., “‘I Just like to Kill Things’: Women, Men, and the Gender of Sport Hunting in the United States, 1940-1973,” Gender & History 17 (April 2005): 183–209CrossRefGoogle Scholar .