Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-m6dg7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-15T10:07:38.721Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

An overview of on-line assistance: from on-line documentation to intelligent help and training

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 July 2009

Barbara Wasson  and
Sigmund Akselsen
Barbara Wasson
Affiliation:
Norwegian Telecom Research, PO Box 1156, N-9001, Tromsø, Norway
Sigmund Akselsen
Affiliation:
Norwegian Telecom Research, PO Box 1156, N-9001, Tromsø, Norway
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

An important aspect of any interactive computer system is its ease of use. On-line assistance is a major contributor to software usability. Conventional on-line assistance includes on-line documentation, or keyword access to textual help descriptions. More sophisticated on-line assistance includes intelligent help which provides immediate assistance for a specific problem, and intelligent training whose main goal is to support the user in learning about the system. These contemporary forms of intelligent assistance represent knowledge about the particular application, the user and the particular tasks the user is to perform. In addition, they possess inferencing capabilities to model the individual user's goals, plans, intentions and knowledge. This paper provides an overview of on-line assistance research, from empirical studies that attempt to determine the nature of effective assistance, to the design of intelligent on-line assistance systems capable of tailoring the assistance to the individual user. For readers interested in more details, recommendations for further reading in the related areas of advice-giving and intelligent help, intelligent user interfaces, critiquing, intelligent tutoring systems, and on-line documentation and hypertext are given.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Knowledge Engineering Review , Volume 7 , Issue 4 , December 1992 , pp. 289 - 322
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

References

Akselsen, S, 1991. “Mediating knowledge. Case study: A computer-based learning environment for education and training of fish-health personnel” Dr. Scient. Thesis, University of Tromsø, Norway.Google Scholar
Aaronson, AP and Carroll, JM, 1987. “The answer is in the question: a protocol study of intelligent help” J. Behaviour and Information Technology 6 393–402.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brcuker, J (ed), 1990. “EUROHELP: Developing intelligent help systems” Final report on the P280 ESPRIT Project EUROHELP, Kopenhagen, Amsterdam/Manchester, Leeds, EC.Google Scholar
Brcuker, J, 1988. “Coaching in help systems” In: Self, J (ed) Artificial Intelligence and Human Learning 310–337, Chapman and Hall.Google Scholar
Breuker, J, Winkels, R and Sandberg, J, 1987. “A shell for intelligent help systems” Proc. 10th Int. Joint Conference on Artificial intelligence 1 167–173.Google Scholar
Carr, B and Goldstein, IP, 1977. “Overlays: a theory of modelling for computer-aided instruction” AI Lab Memo 406 MIT.Google Scholar
Carroll, JM and Aaronson, AP, 1988. “Learning by doing with simulated intelligent help” Communications of the ACM 31 1064–1079.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carroll, JM and McKendree, J, 1987. “Interface design issues for advice-giving expert systems” Communications of the ACM 30 14–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Carroll, JM and Rosson, MB, 1986. “Paradox of the active user” In: Carroll, JM (ed) Interfacing Thought: Cognitive aspects of human computer interaction 80–111, Bradford/MIT Press.Google Scholar
Conklin, J, 1988. “Hypertext: an introduction and survey” In: Grief, I (ed) Computer-supported cooperative work: a book of readings 423–475, Morgan Kaufmann.Google Scholar
Danielsen, T, Finseth, W, Flægstad, F, Hartvigsen, G and Steen, R, 1990a. “Ratatosk—et adaptivt brukergrensesnitt for datamaskinbasert kommuinikasjon” TF-report R35/90, Teledirektoratets forskningsavdeling, Kjeller, Norway (in Norwegian).Google Scholar
Danielsen, T, Finseth, W, Flægstad, F, Hartvigsen, G and Steen, R, 1990b. “Ratatosk—an adaptive user interface to computer-mediated communication” In: Message Handling Systems and Application Layer Communication Protocols Proceedings 345–354. (Also available as TF-lecture F16/90.)Google Scholar
DEC, 1978. Command Language User's Guide, Digital Equipment Corporation.Google Scholar
Eidsvik, AK, 1991. “Medisinske informasjonsdatabaser: et forsøk med søking i Medline” TF-report R30/91, Teledirektoratets forskningsavdeling (Norwegian Telecom Research), Kjeller, Norway (in Norwegian).Google Scholar
Engum, B, 1991. “MEDIS—medisinsk informasjonsservice” TF-report R22/91, Teledirektoratets forskningsavdeling (Norwegian Telecom Research), Kjeller, Norway (in Norwegian).Google Scholar
Finin, TW, 1983. “Providing help and advice in task oriented systems” In: Proc. 8th Int. Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence 176–178.Google Scholar
Fischer, G, 1988. “Enhancing incremental learning processes with knowledge-based systems” In: Mandi, H and Lesgold, A (eds) Learning Issues for Intelligent Tutoring Systems 138–163, Springer-Verlag.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fischer, G, 1987. “A critic for LISP” In: Proc. 10th Int. Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence 177–184.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fischer, G, Lemke, AC, Mastaglio, T and Morch, AI, 1991. “The role of critiquing in cooperative problem solving” ACM Transactions on Information Systems 19 123–151.Google Scholar
Fischer, G, Lemke, AC and Mastaglio, T, 1990. “Using critics to empower users” In: CHI'90 Conference Proceedings 337–347, ACM.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fischer, G, Lemke, A and Schwab, T, 1985. “Knowledge-based help systems” In: CHI'85 Conference Proceedings 161–167, ACM.Google Scholar
Fischer, G, McCall, R and Morch, A, 1989. “JANUS: integrating hypertext with a knowledge-based design environment” In: Hypertext '89 Proceedings 105–117.Google Scholar
Gwei, GM and Foxley, E, 1990. “Towards a consultative on-line help system” Int. J. Man-Machine Studies 32 363–383.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harley, JR and Smith, MJ, 1988. “Question answering and explanation giving in on-line help systems” In: Self, J (ed) Artificial Intelligence and Human Learning 338–360, Chapman and Hall.Google Scholar
Houghton, RC, 1984. “Online help systems: a conspectus” Communications of the ACM 27 126–133.Google Scholar
Johnson, P, Diaper, D and Long, J, 1984. “Task, skills and knowledge: task analysis for knowledge based descriptions” In: Shackel, B (ed) Interact84 North Holland.Google Scholar
Jones, J and Virvou, M, 1991. “User modelling and advice giving in intelligent help systems for UNIX” Information and Software Technology 33 121–133.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Journal of User Modelling and User-Adapted Interaction, 1991, (1,2).Google Scholar
Kearsley, G, 1988. Online Help Systems: Design and Implementation Ablex.Google Scholar
Kidd, AL, 1985. “What do users ask?—some thoughts on diagnostic advice” In: Proc. 5th Technical Conference of the British Computer Society Specialist Group on Expert Systems 9–19, CUP.Google Scholar
Kok, AJ, 1991. “A review and synthesis of user modelling in intelligent systems” The Knowledge Engineering Review 6 (1) 21–47.Google Scholar
Lemke, AC, 1989. “Design environments for high-functionality computer systems” Ph.D thesis, University of Colorado.Google Scholar
McKendree, J and Carroll, JM, 1986. “Advising roles of a computer consultant” In: CHI'86 Conference Proceedings 35–40, ACM.Google Scholar
Nielsen, J, 1992. “The usability engineering life cycle” Computer 25 (3) 12–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Olsen, DR, 1986. “MIKE: the menu interaction control environment” ACM Transactions on Graphics 5(4).Google Scholar
Pollack, ME, 1985. “Information sought and information provided: an empirical study of user/expert dialogues” In: CHI'85 Conference Proceedings 155–159, ACM.Google Scholar
Rada, R and Barlow, J, 1988. “Expert systems and hypertext” The Knowledge Engineering Review 285–301.Google Scholar
Rissland, EL, 1984. “Ingredients of intelligent user interfaces” Int. J. Man-Machine Studies 21 377–388.Google Scholar
Silverman, BG, 1992. “Survey of expert critiquing systems: practical and theoretical frontiers” Communications of the ACM 35 (4) 106–127.Google Scholar
Stehouwer, M and van Bruggen, J, 1986. “Performance interpretation in an intelligent help system” In: Proc. 6th Annual ESPRIT Conference 248–257.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sullivan, JW and Tyler, SW, 1991. “Foreword” In: Sullivan, JW and Sherman, WT (eds) Intelligent User Interfaces vii–viii, Addison-Wesley.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tuck, R and Olsen, DR, 1990. “Help by guided tasks; utilizing UIMS knowledge” In: CHI'90 Conference Proceedings 71–78, ACM.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
UNIX, 1987. Programmer's Manual, Bell Laboratories.Google Scholar
Wasson, BJ 1990. “Determining the focus of instruction: content planning for intelligent tutoring systems” Ph.D thesis, University of Saskatchewan. (Also available as ARIES Research Report 90–5.)Google Scholar
WINIX, 1991. System description version 1.10a for MS-DOS and UN IX system V operating systems The Royal Norwegian Ministry of Education, Research and Church Affairs, Oslo, Norway.Google Scholar

Further reading

Advice-giving and Intelligent Help

•Carroll, JM and McKendree, J, 1987. “Interface design issues for advice-giving expert systems” Communications of the ACM 30 14–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
•Hartley, JR and Smith, MJ, 1988. “Question answering and explanation giving in on-line help systems” In: Self, J (ed) Artificial Intelligence and Human Learning 338–360, Chapman and Hall.Google Scholar
•Breuker, J (ed), 1990. EUROHELP: Developing Intelligent Help Systems Kopenhagen, Amsterdam/Manchester, Leeds, EC.Google Scholar

Critiquing

•Silverman, BG, 1992. “Survey of expert critiquing systems: practical and theoretical frontiers” Communications of the ACM 35 106–127.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
•Fischer, G, Lemke, ACMastaglio, T. and Morch, AI, 1991. “The role of critiquing in cooperative problem solving” ACM Transactions on information Systems 19 123–151.Google Scholar

Intelligent user interfaces

•Rissland, EL, 1984. “Ingredients of intelligent user interfaces” Int. J. Man-Machine Studies 21 377–388.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
•Sullivan, JW, and Tyler, SW (eds), 1991. Intelligent User Interfaces Addison-Wesley.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Intelligent tutoring systems

•Wenger, E, 1987. Artificial intelligence and tutoring systems: Computational and cognitive approaches to the communication of knowledge Morgan Kaufmann.Google Scholar
•Polson, MC and Richardson, JJ (eds), 1988. Foundations of Intelligent Tutoring Systems Lawrence Erlbaum.Google Scholar

On-line documentation and hypertext

•Halasz, FG, 1987. “Reflections on NoteCards: Seven issues for the next generation of hypermedia systems” Communications of the ACM 31 836–852.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
•Conklin, J, 1988. “Hypertext: An introduction and survey” In: Grief, I (ed) Computer-Supported Cooperative Work: A book of readings 423–475, Morgan Kaufmann.Google Scholar

Bibliographies

•Wood, PH and Holt, PD, 1990. “Intelligent Tutoring Systems: An Annotated Bibliography” SIGART Bulletin 1(1) 21–42.Google Scholar
•Woods, DD, Johannesen, L and Potter, SS, 1991. “Human Interaction with Intelligent Systems: An Overview and Bibliography” SIGARI Bulletin 215) 39–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar