Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jn8rn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T05:10:40.088Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Latin American Squatter Settlements: A Problem and a Solution

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 October 2022

William Mangin
William Mangin*
Affiliation:
Syracuse University
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

Squatter settlements have formed around large cities throughout the world, mushrooming particularly since the end of World War II. In an excellent preview to a forthcoming book, Turner (1966) has discussed some common features among squatter settlements in Latin America, Asia, Africa, and Europe. Morse (1965a) has also referred to squatter communities and to general characteristics of Latin American urbanization in an article in this journal. Without repeating the work of Turner and Morse I would like to present a preliminary survey of Latin American squatter settlements with a model of their formation, growth, and social development that contradicts many views held by planners, politicians, newspapermen, and much of the general population, including many residents of the settlements themselves.

Several writers have referred to various local names given to squatter communities: colonies proletarias in Mexico, barriadas brujas in Panama, ranchos in Venezuela, barriadas in Peru, callampas in Chile, cantegriles in Uruguay, favelas in Brazil, and, in other places, marginal areas, clandestine urbanizations, barrios of invasion, parachutists, phantom towns, etc. There are no general works on the subject, but some good descriptions of local conditions do exist. The major sources used are listed by country in note 2. Not many sources are available and, unfortunately, several appear only in mimeographed form. The reports point out that squatter populations consist mainly of low income families but all of the authors distinguish between squatter settlements and other types of lower class housing in tenements, alleys (callejones), shack yards tcoralones, jacales), and rented slum buildings. They agree, sometimes to their own surprise, that it is difficult to describe squatter settlements as slums. The differentiation of squatter settlements from inner-city slums is, in fact, one of the first breaks from the widely shared mythology about them. (See, for example, Patch, 1961; Mangin, 1965.) The purpose in noting this mythology is not merely to set up a straw man for the paper. A review of the “Chaos, Crisis, Revolution and Wither Now Latin America” literature, or, of most governmental, United Nations, or AID reports, or, of most newspapers and magazines in Latin America will show that it is the predominant position on squatter settlements.

Type
Topical Review
Information
Latin American Research Review , Volume 2 , Issue 3 , Summer 1967 , pp. 65 - 98
Copyright
Copyright © 1967 by the University of Texas Press

References

Abrams, Charles 1964 Man's Struggle for Shelter in an Urbanizing World. Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Abrams, Charles 1965 The use of land in cities. Scientific American. September. 151–161.Google Scholar
Arias B., Jorge 1965 La concentración urbana y las migraciones internas. In: Problemas de la Urbanización en Guatemala. 19–45. Ministerio de Educación.Google Scholar
Bemdoc (Brasil Estados Unidos Movimento de Desenvolvimento e Organização de Comunidade) 1965 Vial Proletaria da Penha. Rio de Janeiro.Google Scholar
Bendiner, Elmer 1967 Outside the kingdom of the middle class: La Vida by Oscar Lewis. The Nation. January 2.Google Scholar
Bernal A., Hernando 1963 Ritmos de vida en Buenaventura. Revista Colombiana de Antropología. 12:331— 355.Google Scholar
Bon Espasandin, Mario 1963 Cantegriles: Familia, Educación, Niveles Económicos—Laborales, Vivienda y Aspectos Generales que Componen el “Collar de Miserias” de Montevideo. Montevideo.Google Scholar
Bonilla, Frank 1961 Rio's favelas: the rural slum within the city. American Universities Field Staff Report. August.Google Scholar
Bourricaud, Francois 1964 Lima en la vida política peruana. América Latina. October-December.Google Scholar
Bradley, John 1966 The market system and urbanization in Lima. (Mimeographed).Google Scholar
Butterworth, Douglas 1962 A study of the urbanization process among the Mixtec migrants from Tilantongo in Mexico City. América Indígena. 22: 257–274.Google Scholar
Caretas 1963 Enero-Febrero.Google Scholar
Clark, Gerald 1963 The Coming Explosion in Latin America. New York City.Google Scholar
Corten, Andre 1965 Como vive la otra mitad de Santo Domingo: estudio de dualismo estructural. Caribbean Studies. 4: 3–19.Google Scholar
Cuevas, Marco Antonio 1965 Análisis de tres áreas marginales de la ciudad de Guatemala. In: Problemas de la Urbanización en Guatemala. Ministerio de Educación.Google Scholar
Davis, Kingsley 1965 The urbanization of the human population. Scientific American. September. 41–50.Google Scholar
Dorselaer, Jaime and Gregory, Alfonso 1962 La Urbanización en América Latina. Oficina Internacional de Investigaciones Sociales de FERES. Bogotá.Google Scholar
Fried, Jacob 1959 Acculturation and mental health among migrants in Peru. In: Culture and Mental Health. Marvin Opler ed. New York City.Google Scholar
Frieden, Bernard 1964 A program for housing and urban development in Mexico City. (Mimeographed). AID. Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Frieden, Bernard 1965 The search for housing policy in Mexico City. Town Planning Review. 35: July.Google Scholar
Foster, George 1965 Peasant society and the image of limited good. American Anthropologist. 67: 293–315.Google Scholar
Gans, Herbert 1962 The Urban Villagers. New York City.Google Scholar
Germani, Gino 1961 Inquiry into the social effects of urbanization in a working-class sector of Buenos Aires. In: Urbanization in Latin America. Philip Hauser ed. 206–233. UNESCO. New York City.Google Scholar
Goldrich, Daniel 1965 Toward the comparative study of politicization in Latin America. In: Contemporary cultures and societies of Latin America. Dwight Heath and Richard Adams eds. 361–378. New York City.Google Scholar
Goldrich, Daniel, Pratt, R. B., and Schuller, C. R. 1966 The political integration of lower class urban settlements in Chile and Peru. (Mimeographed). Annual Meeting of Aemrican Political Science Association. New York City.Google Scholar
Gutierrez, Samuel 1961 El problema de las barriadas brujas en la ciudad de Panama. Instituto de Vivienda y Urbanismo.Google Scholar
Halperin, Ernst 1965 The decline of communism in Latin America. Atlantic Monthly. May. 65–70.Google Scholar
Hammel, Eugene A. 1961 The family cycle in a coastal Peruvian slum and village. American Anthropologist. 63: 989–1005.Google Scholar
Hammel, Eugene A. 1964 Some characteristics of rural village and urban slum populations on the coast of Peru. Southwestern Journal of Anthropology. 20: 346–358.Google Scholar
Harth Deneke, Jorge 1966 The colonias proletarias of Mexico City, low income settlements on the urban fringe. Master's thesis in City Planning. Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Hauser, Philip M. ed. 1961 Urbanization in Latin America. UNESCO. New York City.Google Scholar
Heath, Dwight and Adams, Richard eds. 1965 Contemporary cultures and societies of Latin America. New York City.Google Scholar
Herrick, Bruce H. 1966 Urban Migration and Economic Development in Chile. Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Hoenack, Judith 1966 Marketing, supply and their social ties in Rio favelas. (Mimeographed).*Google Scholar
Jones, Emrys 1964 Aspects of urbanization in Venezuela. Ekistics. 18: 109.Google Scholar
Koth, Marcia, Silva, Julia and Dietz, Albert 1964 Housing in Latin America. Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Leeds, Anthony 1964 Brazilian careers and social structure: an evolutionary model and case history. American Anthropologist. 66:1321–1347.†Google Scholar
Leeds, Anthony 1966 The investment climate in Rio favelas. (Mimeographed).*Google Scholar
Lewis, Oscar 1952 Urbanization without breakdown. Scientific Monthly. 75:31–41.†Google Scholar
Lewis, Oscar 1959 Five Families. New York City.Google Scholar
Lewis, Oscar 1960 The Children of Sanchez. New York City.Google Scholar
Lewis, Oscar 1965 The folk urban ideal types. In: The Study of Urbanization. P. Hauser and L. Schnore eds. New York City.Google Scholar
Lewis, Oscar 1966a La Vida: A Puerto Rican Family in the Culture of Poverty. New York City.Google Scholar
Lewis, Oscar 1966b Even the saints cry. Trans-Action. November. 18–23.Google Scholar
Lewis, Oscar 1966c The culture of poverty. Scientific American. October. 19–25.Google Scholar
Lopez T., Jose and others 1965 Barrios Marginales. Informe Sobre La Colonia “La Verbena,” Ciudad de Guatemala. Dirección de Obras Públicas.Google Scholar
Ludwig, Armin K. 1966 The planning and creation of Brasilia. In: New Perspectives of Brazil. E. Baklanoff ed. Nashville.Google Scholar
Lutz, Thomas 1966 Some aspects of community organization and activity in the squatter settlements of Panama City. (Mimeographed).Google Scholar
Mallol de Recassens, Maria Rosa y Recassens, Jose 1963 Estudios comparativos de los niveles de vivienda en Buenaventura y Puerto Colombia. Revista Colombiana de Antropología. 12: 295–328.Google Scholar
Mangin, William 1959 The role of regional associations in the adaptation of rural population in Peru. Sociologus. 9:21–36.†Google Scholar
Mangin, William 1960 Mental health and migration to cities. Annals of the NY Academy of Sciences. 84: 17:911–917.†Google Scholar
Mangin, William 1963 Urbanization case history in Peru. Architectural Design. August.Google Scholar
Mangin, William 1964 Sociological, cultural and political characteristics of some rural Indians and urban migrants in Peru. Wenner-Gren Symposium on Cross-Cultural Similarities in the Urbanization Process. (Mimeographed).Google Scholar
Mangin, William 1965 The role of social organization in improving the environment. In: Environmental Determinants of Community Well-Being. Pan-American Health Organization.Google Scholar
Mangin, William 1967 Comunidades de la sierra de América Indígena. (In press).Google Scholar
Maria de Jesus, Carolina 1962 Child of the Dark. Translated from Portuguese by St. Clair Drake. New York City.Google Scholar
Matos Mar, Jose 1961 Migration and urbanization: the barriadas of Lima. In: Urbanization in Latin America. Philip M. Hauser ed. 170–190. New York City.Google Scholar
Miller, S. M. and Rein, Martin 1964 Poverty and social change. The American Child. March.Google Scholar
Mills, C. Wright 1943 The professional ideology of social pathologists. American Journal of Sociology. 49: 165–180.Google Scholar
Modesto, Helio 1966 Favelas-reflexoes sobre o problema. (Mimeographed).*Google Scholar
Morocco, David 1966 Carnaval groups-maintainers and intensifiers of the favela phenomenon in Rio. (Mimeographed). *Google Scholar
Morse, Richard M. 1965a Urbanization in Latin America. Latin American Research Review. 1:1:35–74.Google Scholar
Morse, Richard M. 1965b The sociology of San Juan: an exegesis of urban mythology. Caribbean Studies. 5: 45–55.Google Scholar
Nehemkis, Peter 1964 Latin America: Myth and Reality. New York City.Google Scholar
Oiga 1963 Enero.Google Scholar
O'Neill, Charles 1966 Some problems of urbanization and removal of Rio favelas. (Mimeographed).*Google Scholar
Paddock, John 1961 Oscar Lewis's Mexico. Anthropological Quarterly. 34: 129–149.Google Scholar
Padilla, Elena 1958 Up From Puerto Rico. New York City.Google Scholar
Paredes, Ernesto 1963 Fuentes de la población de la barriada Fray Martín de Porres. In: Migración e Integración en el Perú. H. Dobyns and M. Vasquez eds. Lima.Google Scholar
Parks, Gordon 1961 Freedom's fearful foe: poverty. Life. June 16.Google Scholar
Patch, Richard W. 1961 Life in a callejón. American Universities Field Staff Report. June.Google Scholar
Pearse, Andrew 1961 Some characteristics of urbanization in the city of Rio de Janeiro. In: Urbanization in Latin America. Philip M. Hauser ed. 191–205. New York City.Google Scholar
Peattie, Lisa 1962 A short ethnography of La Laja. (Mimeographed).Google Scholar
Peattie, Lisa 1966 Social issues in housing. Joint Center for Urban Studies. (Mimeographed). Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Pinto Barajas, Eugenio ed. 1966 Control y Erradicación de Tugurios en Bucaramanga. Santander, Colombia.Google Scholar
Powelson, J. P. 1964 The land-grabbers of Cali. The Reporter. January 16.Google Scholar
Ray, Talton 1966 The political life of a Venezuelan barrio. (Mimeographed).Google Scholar
Reina, Ruben E. 1964 The urban world view of a tropical forest community in the absence of a city, Petén, Guatemala. Human Organization. 23: 265–277.Google Scholar
Rodwin, Lloyd 1965 Ciudad Guayana: a new city. Scientific American. September. 122–132.Google Scholar
Rosenbluth L., Guillermo 1963 Problemas Socio-Económicos de la Marginalidad y la Integración Urbana: El Caso de las Poblaciones Callampas en el Gran Santiago. Santiago, Chile.Google Scholar
Rotondo, Humberto and others 1963 Un estudio comparativo de la conducta antisocial de menores en áreas urbanas y rurales. In: Estudios de Psiquiatría Social en el Perú. Lima.Google Scholar
Rotondo, Humberto 1965 Adaptability of human behavior. In: Environmental Determinants of Community Well-Being. Pan-American Health Organization.Google Scholar
Rycroft, W. Stanley and Clemmer, Myrtle 1963 A Study of Urbanization in Latin America. United Presbyterian Church. New York City.Google Scholar
Safa, Helen 1964 From shantytown to public housing: a comparison of family structure in two urban neighborhoods in Puerto Rico. Caribbean Studies. 4: 3–12.Google Scholar
Safa, Helen 1965 The female-based household in public housing: a case study in Puerto Rico. Human Organization. 24: 135–139.Google Scholar
SAGMACS 1960 Aspectos Humanos de Favela Carioca. Report of Mission of Father Lebret. Special Supplement to O Estado de Sao Paulo. April 13.Google Scholar
Salmon, Lawrence 1966 Report on Vila Kennedy and Vila Esperança. (Mimeographed). Cooperativa Habitacional (COHAB).Google Scholar
Schaedel, Richard P. 1966 Urban growth and ekistics on the Peruvian coast. 36th International Congress of Americanists. 1:531–539. Sevilla.Google Scholar
Schmitt, Karl and Burks, David 1963 Evolution or Chaos: Dynamics of Latin American Government and Politics. New-York City.Google Scholar
Schulman, Sam 1966 Latin American shantytown. N.Y. Times Magazine. January 16.Google Scholar
Silvert, Kalman H. 1966 The Conflict Society: Reaction and Revolution in Latin America. American Universities Field Staff. New York City.Google Scholar
Simmons, Ozzie G. 1952 El uso de los conceptos de aculturación y asimilación en el estudio del cambio cultural en el Perú. Perú Indígena. 2:40–47. Lima.Google Scholar
Smith, Nancy 1966 Eviction in a Rio favela-leadership, land tenure and legal aspects. (Mimeographed).*Google Scholar
Smith, T. Lynn 1960 Latin American Population Studies. University of Florida. Gainesville.Google Scholar
Stokes, Charles J. 1962 A theory of slums. Land Economics. 38: 3.Google Scholar
Thomas, William I. and Znaniecki, Florian 1920 The Polish Peasant in Europe and America. Chicago.Google Scholar
Turner, Charles Barton 1964 Squatter settlements in Bogotá. (Mimeographed). CINVA. Bogotá.Google Scholar
Turner, John F. C. 1963 Dwelling resources in South America. Architectural Design. August.Google Scholar
Turner, John F. C. 1966 Asentamientos Urbanos No Regulados. Cuadernos de la Sociedad Venezolana de Planificación. 36.Google Scholar
Usandizaga, Elsa and Havens, Eugene 1966 Tres Barrios de Invasión. Facultad de Sociología. Bogotá.Google Scholar
Wagner, Bernard, McVoy, David, and Edwards, Gordon 1966 Guanabara Housing and Urban Development. AID Housing Report. July 1.Google Scholar
Wakefield, Dan 1959 Island in the City. Boston.Google Scholar
Walsh, William, MD. 1965 Class, Kinship and Power in an Ecuadorean Town: The Negroes of San Lorenzo. Stanford.Google Scholar
Wiener, Myron 1966 Yanqui, Come Back! The Voyage of the U.S. Hope to Peru. New York City.Google Scholar
Whitten, Norman E. Jr. 1962 Urbanization and Political Extremism. (Mimeographed). Cambridge, Mass.Google Scholar
Willems, Emilio 1966 Religious mass movements and social change in Brazil. In: New Perspectives of Brazil. E. Baklanoff ed. Nashville.Google Scholar
Wilson, L. Albert 1965 Voice of the Villas. Foundation for Cooperative Housing. Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Wingo, Lowdon Jr. 1966 Some aspects of recent urbanization in Latin America. Resources for the Future. (Mimeographed). Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
Whyte, William Foote 1943 Street Corner Society. Chicago.Google Scholar
Wygand, James 1966 Water networks: their technology and sociology in Rio favelas. (Mimeographed).*Google Scholar