Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gvvz8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-01-04T04:10:18.808Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Required Reconsideration of “Do-Not-Resuscitate” Orders in the Operating Room and Certain other Treatment Settings

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 April 2021

Cynthia B. Cohen  and
Peter J. Cohen
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Incoming patients across the country, as a requirement of the Patient Self-Determination Act,’ are met on the threshold of hospitals and informed of their right to accept or refuse treatment. They are also offered information about formulating advance directives to govern the use of lifesustaining treatment should they lose decision-making capacity. It is generally assumed that instructional directives covering specific treatment interventions must be followed in every setting within the hospital.’ This assumption is reinforced by the requirements of the Patient Self-Determination Act, since options accepted by patients at the portals of a health care institution are likely to be perceived as in force throughout the facility.

The “Do-Not-Resuscitate” (DNR) order is a specific directive mandating that cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), a dramatic intervention that can restore breathing and heartbeat to patients who have experienced cardiac arrest, should not be performed on patients. Patients or their surrogates who agree to the entry of DNR orders into their medical records usually do so because they believe CPR would be useless or disproportionately burdensome.

Type
Article
Information
Law, Medicine and Healthcare , Volume 20 , Issue 4 , Winter 1992 , pp. 354 - 363
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 1992

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990. Pub L No. 101–508.Google Scholar
See, for example, President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Deciding to Forego Life-Sustaining Treatment: A Report on the Ethical, Medical, and Legal Issues in Treatment Decisions (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1983), 231–55; The Hastings Center, “Guidelines on Advance Directives,” Guidelines on the Termination of Life-Sustaining Treatment and the Care of the Dying: A Report. (New York: The Hastings Center, 1987), 76–84; Miles, Steven H., Gomez, Carlos F., Protocols for Elective Use of Life-Sustaining Treatments: A Design Guide (New York: Springer, 1989), 48–49; Moskop, John C., “Advance Directives in Medicine: Choosing among the Alternatives,” in Hackler, Chris, Moseley, Ray, Vawter, Dorothy E., eds., Advance Directives in Medicine: Studies in Health and Human Values (New York: Praeger, 1989), 9–19; LaPuma, John, Orentlicher, David, Moss, Robert J., “Advance Directives on Admission: Clinical Implications and Analysis of the Patient Self-Determination Act of 1990,” Journal of the American Medical Association 166 (1991): 401–405; Emanuel, Linda L. et al., “Advance Directives for Medical Care—A Case for Greater Use,” New England Journal of Medicine 324 (1991): 889–95; Society for the Right to Die. Refusal of Treatment Legislation: A State by State Compilation of Enacted and Model Statutes (New York: Society for the Right to Die, 1991).Google Scholar
Veatch, Robert M., “‘Do Not Resuscitate’ Orders: An Ethical Analysis,” in Veatch, Robert M., The Patient-Physician Relation: The Patient as Partner, Part 2 (Bloomington: Indiana University, 1991) 240–249.Google Scholar
Miles, Steven H., Cranford, Ronald E., Schultz, A.L., “The Do-Not-Resuscitate Order in a Teaching Hospital: Considerations and a Suggested Policy,” Annals of Internal Medicine 96 (1982): 660–4; Evans, Andrew L., Brody, Baruch A., “The Do-Not-Resuscitate Order in Teaching Hospitals,” Journal of the American Medical Association 253 (1985): 2236–39; Youngner, Stuart J. et al., “‘Do Not Resuscitate Orders’: Incidence and Implications in a Medical Intensive Care Unit,” Journal of the American Medical Association 253 (1985): 54–57; La Puma, John et al., “Life-Sustaining Treatment: A Prospective Study of Patients with DNR Orders in A Teaching Hospital,” Archives of Internal Medicine 148 (1988): 2193–98.Google Scholar
Miles, supra note 4; Evans, , supra note 4; Lo, Bernard et al., “‘Do Not Resuscitate’ Decisions: A Prospective Study at Three Teaching Hospitals,” Archives of Internal Medicine 145 (1985): 1115–17; Lipton, Helene Levens, “Do-Not-Resuscitate Decisions in A Community Hospital: Incidence, Implications, and Outcomes,” Journal of the American Medical Association 256 (1986):1164–69; Uhlmann, Richard F., McDonald, Walter J., Inui, Thomas S., “Epidemiology of No-Code Orders in an Academic Hospital,” Western Journal of Medicine 140 (1984):114–16; La Puma, , supra note 4; Jonsson, P.V., McNamee, M., Campion, E.W., “The ‘Do Not Resuscitate’ Order: A Profile of Its Changing Use,” Archives of Internal Medicine 148 (1988):2373–76.Google Scholar
Jonsson, , supra note 5.Google Scholar
LaPuma, , supra note 4.Google Scholar
President's Commission, supra note 2; Youngner, Stuart J., “Decisions Not to Resuscitate,” in Youngner, Stuart J., ed., Human Values in Critical Care Medicine. (New York: Praeger, 1986) 15–33; “Standards and Guidelines for Cardiopulmonary (CPR) and Emergency Cardiac Care (ECC),” Journal of the American Medical Association 155 (1986) 2905–908; Hastings Center, Guidelines, supra note 2; Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals, Accreditation Manual for Hospitals, (Chicago: American Hospital Association, 1988) 90–98; Veatch, , supra note 3.Google Scholar
Youngner, Stuart J., “Advance Directives and the Denial of Death: Should the Conflict Be Resolved?” in Hackler, Chris, Moseley, Ray, Vawter, Dorothy E., eds., Advance Directives in Medicine. (New York: Praeger, 1989) 128–39.Google Scholar
Ramsey, Paul, The Patient as Person: Explorations in Medical Ethics (New Haven: Yale, 1970) 113–57; Uhlmann, Richard F., Cassel, Christine K., McDonald, Walter J., “Some Treatment-Withholding Implications of No-Code Orders in an Academic Hospital,” Critical Care Medicine 12 (1984): 879–81; Lo, supra note 5; LaPuma, supra note 4; Jonsson, supra note 5.Google Scholar
Rabkin, Mitchell T., Gillerman, G., Rice, N.R., “Orders Not to Resuscitate,” New England Journal of Medicine 295 (1976)364–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Evans, supra note 4; Jonsson, supra note 5.Google Scholar
Wachter, Robert M. et al., “Decisions about Resuscitation: Inequities among Patients with Different Diseases but Similar Prognoses,” Annals of Internal Medicine in (1989) 525–32.Google Scholar
Youngner, , supra note 4.Google Scholar
Charlson, Mary E. et al., “Resuscitation: How Do We Decide?” Journal of the American Medical Association 255 (1986) 1316–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Youngner, , supra note 8; Lo, , supra note 5.Google Scholar
President's Commission, supra note 2; Hastings Center, supra note 2; Miles, , supra note 4; Charlson, , supra note 15, La Puma, , supra note 4.Google Scholar
Hastings Center, supra note 2; Wolf, Susan M., “Conflict between Doctor and Patient,” Law, Medicine & Health Care 16 (1988) 197–203; Youngner, Stuart J., “Who Defines Futility?” Journal of the American Medical Association 260 (1988) 2094–95; Tomlinson, Tom, Brody, Howard, “Ethics and Comunication in Do-Not Resuscitate Orders,” New England Journal of Medicine 318 (1988): 43–46; Lantos, John D. et al., “The Illusion of Futility in Clinical Practice,” American Journal of Medicine 87 (1989): 81–84; Tomlinson, Tom, Brody, Howard, “Futility and the Ethics of Resuscitation,” Journal of the American Medical Association 264 (1990): 1276–80; Youngner, Stuart J., “Futility in Context,” Journal of the American Medical Association 264 (1990): 1295–96; Schneiderman, Lawrence J., Jecker, Nancy S., Jonsen, Albert R., “Medical Futility: Its Meaning and Ethical Implications,” Annals of Internal Medicine 112 (1990): 949–54; Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs, American Medical Association, “Guidelines for the Appropriate Use of Do-Not-Rcsuscitate Orders,” Journal of the American Medical Association 265 (1991) 1868–71; Callahan, Daniel, “Medical Necessity, Medical Futility: The Problem-Without-A-Name,” Hastings Center Report 21 (1991): 30–35.Google Scholar
Tomlinson, (1990), supra note 18.Google Scholar
Uhlmann, , supra note 10; Evans, , supra note 4; Charlson, , supra note 15; Taffet, George E., Teasdale, Thomas A., Luchi, Robert J., “In-Hospital Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation,” Journal of the American Medical Association 260 (1988): 2069–72; Youngner, (1988) supra note 18; Lantos, , supra note 18; Youngner, (1990), supra note 18.Google Scholar
Pearlman, Robert A., Inui, T.S., Carter, W.B., “Variability in Physician Bioethical Decision Making,” Annals of Internal Medicine 97: (1982) 420–23; Lantos, , supra note 18; Hammond, J., Ward, C.G., “Decision Not to Treat: ‘Do Not Resuscitate’ Order for the Burn Patient in the Acute Setting,” Critical Care Medicine 17 (1989): 136–40; Schneiderman, , supra note 18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blackhall, Leslie J., “Must We Always Use CPR?” New England Journal of Medicine 317 (1987): 1281–84; Youngner (1990), supra note 18.Google Scholar
McGrath, R.B., “In-House Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation—After a Quarter of a Century,” Annals of Emergency Medicine 16 (1987):1365–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
DeBard, M.L., “Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation: Analysis of Six Years' Experience and Review of the Literature,” Annals of Emergency Medicine 10 (1981) 408; Hershey, C.O., Fisher, L., “Why Outcome of Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in General Wards is Poor,” Lancet 1 (1982): 31–36; Bedell, Susanna E. et al., “Survival after Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Hospital,” New England Journal of Medicine 309 (1983): 569–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bedell, , supra note 24.Google Scholar
Blackball, , supra note 22.Google Scholar
Bjork, R.J. et al., “Medical Complications of Cardiopulmonary Arrest.” Archives of Internal Medicine 142 (1982) 500–505.Google Scholar
Youngner, , supra note 8.Google Scholar
Miles, , supra note 4.Google Scholar
In re Dinnerstein, 380 N.E.2d 134 (Mass. App. 1978).Google Scholar
Cohen, Cynthia B., Cohen, Peter J., “Do-Not-Resuscitate Orders in the Operating Room,” New England Journal of Medicine 325 (1991): 1879–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
President's Commission, supra note 2; Standards and Guidelines, supra note 8.Google Scholar
Hovi-Viander, M., “Death Associated with Anaesthesia in Finland,” British Journal of Anaesthesia 52 (1980): 483–88; Keenan, Richard L., Paul Boyan, C., “Cardiac Arrest due to Anesthesia: A Study of Incidence and Causes,” Journal of the American Medical Association 253 (1985): 2372–77; Olsson, G.L., Hall, B., “Cardiac Arrest during Anaesthesia. A Computer-Aided Study in 250,543 Anaesthetics,” Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica 32 (1988): 653–64; Caplan, Robert A. et al., “Unexpected Cardiac Arrest during Spinal Anesthesia: A Closed Claims Analysis of Predisposing Factors,” Anesthesiology 68 (1988) 5–11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
“Summary of the National Halothane Study,” Journal of the American Medical Association 197 (1966) 775–78.Google Scholar
Hovi-Viander, , supra note 33; Keenan, , supra note 33; Olsson, , supra note 33; Truog, Robert D., “‘Do-Not-Resuscitate’ Orders during Anesthesia and Surgery,” Anesthesiology 74 (1991): 606–608.Google Scholar
Olsson, , supra note 33.Google Scholar
Hershey, , supra note 24.Google Scholar
Peatfield, R.C. et al., “Survival after Cardiac Arrest in Hospital,” Lancet 1 (1977): 1223–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cohen, , supra, note 31.Google Scholar
Bosk, Charles, Forgive and Remember: Managing Medical Failure. (Chicago: University of Chicago, 1979), 29–30.Google Scholar
Bosk, , supra note 40.Google Scholar
Youngner, , supra, note 4; Jonsson, , supra note 5.Google Scholar
See, for example, “It's Over Debbie,” Journal of the American Medical Association 259 (1988):272; deWachter, M.A.M., “Active Euthanasia in the Netherlands,” Journal of the American Medical Association 262 (1989): 3316–19; Kass, Leon R., “Neither for Love nor Money: Why Doctors Must Not Kill,” The Public Interest 94 (1989): 25–43; Singer, Peter A., Siegler, Mark, “Euthanasia—A Critique,” New England Journal of Medicine 322 (1990): 1881–83; Quill, Timothy E., “Death and Dignity—A Case of Individualized Decision Making. New England Journal of Medicine 324 (1991): 691–4; Humphry, Derek, Final Exit: The Practicalities of Self-Deliverance and Assisted Suicide for the Dying (Eugene, Oregon: The Hemlock Society, 1991); Misbin, Robert I., “Physicians' Aid in Dying,” New England Journal of Medicine 325 (1991): 1307–11.Google Scholar
Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health, 110 S. Ct. 1841 (1990).Google Scholar
Meisel, Alan et al., “Hospital Guidelines for Deciding about Life-Sustaining Treatment: Dealing with Death ‘Limbo’,” Critical Care Medicine 14 (1986): 239–43; Truog, supra note 38.Google Scholar
Walker, Robert M., “DNR in the OR: Resuscitation as an Operative Risk,” Journal of the American Medical Association 166 (1991): 2407–12.Google Scholar
Cohen, Cynthia B., “Interdisciplinary Consultation on the Care of the Critically Ill and Dying: The Role of One Hospital Ethics Committee,” Critical Care Medicine 10 (1982) 776–84; Ross, Judith W. et al., Handbook for Hospital Ethics Committees (Chicago: American Hospital Association, 1986).Google Scholar
Miller, A., Lo, Bernard, “How Do Doctors Discuss Do-Not-Resuscitate Orders?” Western Journal of Medicine 143 (1985): 256–61.Google Scholar
Appelbaum, P.S., Roth, Loren H., “Patients Who Refuse Treatment in Medical Hospitals,” Journal of the American Medical Association 250 (1983): 1296–99.Google Scholar
Weiner, Richard D., “Convulsive Therapies,” in Kaplan, Harold I., Sadock, Benjamin J., eds., Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry (Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins, 1985), vol. 2, 1558–63.Google Scholar
Donlon, John V. Jr., “Anesthesia for Eye, Ear, Nose, and Throat,” in Miller, Ronald D., Anesthesia (New York: Churchill Livingstone, 1986) 1837–1869.Google Scholar
Smith, Hugh C., Reeder, Guy S., “Cardiac Catheterization and Coronary Arteriography,” in Tarhan, Sait, ed., Anesthesia and Coronary Artery Surgery (Chicago: Year Book Medical, 1986): 58–59.Google Scholar
Richard, I. Mazze, “Anesthesia and the Renal and Genitourinary Systems,” in Miller, Ronald D., Anesthesia (New York: Churchill Livingstone, 1990): 1791–1800.Google ScholarPubMed
Weiner, , supra note 50.Google Scholar
Donlon, , supra note 51.Google Scholar
Smith, , supra note 52.Google Scholar
Mazze, , supra note 53.Google Scholar