Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-lj6df Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T14:09:13.312Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Komi of the Kola Peninsula within ethnographic descriptions and state policies

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 November 2018

Petia Mankova
Petia Mankova*
Affiliation:
Department of Archaeology and Social Anthropology, UiT The Arctic University of Norway, Tromsø, Norway. Email: petia.mankova@uit.no
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

For more than 100 years, ethnographic accounts have highlighted the non-nativeness of the Komi diaspora to the Kola Peninsula, contrasting it with the indigenous Sami population. Their legal status there has been a vexed issue unresolved by Tsarist administrators, Soviet ethnic policies, present-day ideas of multiethnic civic nation, and global indigenous activism. In the everyday life, however, there are no apparent differences between the two ethnic groups and their traditional lifestyles in the rural area of Murmansk region. Juxtaposing historical ethnographic accounts on the Izhma Komi with my fieldwork experiences among the Komi on the Kola Peninsula, I show how ethnographers uphold dominant ideologies and promote different state policies. The ambiguous ethnic and indigenous categorizations from their accounts reverberate in popular stereotypes, political mobilizations from below, and state policies from above. In this way, they make an interesting case for the practical problems of generalization and essentialism.

Keywords

KomiSamiethnographersessentialismgovernment policyethnic stereotypesNorthwest Russia
Type
Articles
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 46 , Issue 1 , January 2018 , pp. 34 - 51
Copyright
Copyright © 2017 Association for the Study of Nationalities 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Allemann, Lukas. 2009. Die Samen der Kola-Halbinsel. Über das Leben einer ethnischen Minderheit in der Sowjetunion: Neue Perspektiven durch mündliche Selbstzeugnisse. Basel: Universität Basel.Google Scholar
Alymov, Vasilii K. 1924. “Vymiraiut li loparei?” Vestnik Karelo-Murmanskogo kraia 1924 (10): 20–22.Google Scholar
Anderson, David G., and Arziutov, Dmitry V. 2016. “The Construction of Soviet Ethnography and ‘The Peoples of Siberia'.” History and Anthropology 27 (2): 183–209.Google Scholar
Anokhin, Genrikh I. 1962. Sotsialisticheskie preobrazovaniia v materialnoy kulture saamov (Po materialam kolkhoza “Tundra”). Vol. XXXVI, Kratkie Soobshcheniia. Institut etnografii imeni N.N. Miklukho-Miklaia Moscow: Izdatelstvo Akademii Nauk SSSR.Google Scholar
Barth, Fredrik. 1969. Ethnic Groups and Boundaries the Social Organization of Culture Difference. Bergen: Universitetsforlaget.Google Scholar
Beldytskii, Nikolai P. 1910. “Neskolko dnei sredi izhemskikh zyrian.” IAOIRS 1910 (23): 1–14.Google Scholar
Brah, Avtar. 1996. Cartographies of diaspora: Contesting identities. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Bromlei, Iulian V. 1983. Ocherki teorii etnosa. Moscow: Nauka.Google Scholar
Budovnits, Isaak U. 1931. Olenevodcheskie kolkhozy Kol'skogo poluostrova. Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo selskokhoziaistvennoi i kolkhoznokooperativnoi literatury.Google Scholar
Charnoluskii, Vladimir V. 1930. Materialy po bytu loparei opyt opredeleniia kochevogo sostoianiia loparei vostochnoi chasti Kol'skogo poluostrova. Leningrad: GRGO.Google Scholar
Charnoluskii, Vladimir V. 1931. Olen'ia Izgorod'. Moskva, Leningrad: Sel'kolkhozgiz.Google Scholar
Charnoluskii, Vladimir V. 1972. V kraiu Letuchego kamnia. Zapiski etnografa. Moscow: Mysl'.Google Scholar
Cvetkovski, Roland, and Hofmeister, Alexis. 2014. An Empire of Others: Creating Ethnographic Knowledge in Imperial Russia and the USSR. Budapest: Central European University Press.Google Scholar
Donahoe, Brian. 2011. “On the Creation of Indigenous Subjects in the Russian Federation.” Citizenship Studies 15 (3–4): 397–417.Google Scholar
Donahoe, Brian, Otto Habeck, Joachim, Halemba, Agnieszka, and Sántha, István. 2008. “Size and Place in the Construction of Indigeneity in the Russian Federation.” Current Anthropology 49 (6): 993–1020.Google Scholar
Dragadze, Tamara. 1990. “Some Changes in Perspectives on Ethnicity Theory in the 1980's: A Brief Sketch.” Cahiers du monde russe et soviétique 31 (2–3): 205–212.Google Scholar
Elfimov, Alexei. 2014. “Russian Ethnography as a Science: Truths Claimed, Trails Followed.” In An Empire of Others: Creating Ethnographic Knowledge in Imperial Russia and the USSR, edited by Cvetkovski, Roland and Hofmeister, Alexis, 51–80. Budapest: Central European University Press.Google Scholar
Engelhardt, Alexander P. 1899. A Russian Province of the North. Westminster: Archibald Constable.Google Scholar
Fryer, Paul, and Lehtinen, Ari. 2013. “Iz'vatas and the Diaspora Space of Humans and Non-humans in the Russian North.” Acta Borealia 30 (1): 21–38.Google Scholar
Gerasimov, Nikon. 1932. “Natsionalnoe ustroystvo loparey v Murmanskom okruge.” Tayga i tundra 4(1): 17.Google Scholar
Habeck, Joachim Otto. 2005a. “Dimensions of Identity.” In Rebuilding Identities: Pathways to Reform in Post-Soviet Siberia, edited by Kasten, Erich, 9–25. Berlin: Reimer.Google Scholar
Habeck, Joachim Otto. 2005b. What It Means to be a Herdsman: The Practice and Image of Reindeer Husbandry among the Komi of Northern Russia. Halle Studies in the Anthropology of Eurasia, vol. 5. Münster: LIT Verlag.Google Scholar
Habeck, J. Otto, Vitebsky, Piers, Komaroff, Jean, Kostopulos, Andrei, and Navarrete, Federico. 2009. “Etnograficheskiye issledovaniia na severe i ikh vklad v global'nuiu antropologiiu: popytka otsenit’ sovremennuiu situatsiiu.” Problemy istorii, filologii, kul'tury: Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies 25 (3): 371–373.Google Scholar
Hallström, Gustaf. 1911. Kolalapparnas hotade existens. Stockholm: Svenska sällskapet för antropologi och geografi.Google Scholar
Hirsch, Francine. 2005. Empire of Nations: Ethnographic Knowledge and the Making of the Soviet Union. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Istomin, Kirill V, and Shabaev, Yuri P. 2016. “Izhma Komi and Komi-Permiak: Linguistic Barriers to Geographic and Ethnic Identity.” Region: Regional Studies of Russia, Eastern Europe, and Central Asia 5 (1): 53–74.Google Scholar
Ivanov-Diatlov, F. G. 1928. Nabliudeniia vracha na Kol'skom poluostrove (11 ianvaria −11 maia 1927g.), edited by Zolotarev, D. A. Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe Russkoe Geograficheskoe Obshchestvo.Google Scholar
Jääts, Indrek. 2009. “The Komi, Ethnic Stereotypes, and Nationalities Policy in Late Imperial Russia.” The Russian Review 68 (2): 199–220.Google Scholar
Kert, Georgii M. 1973. “Kol'skie Saamy.” Voprosy Istorii 1973 (8): 216–219.Google Scholar
Khalapsin, Nikolai V. 1927. “Lopari, zyriane i samoedy sela Lovozera v sanitarnom otnoshenii.” In Doklady i soobshcheniia Murmanskogo obshchestva krayevedeniia, 23–34. Murmansk: MGPU.Google Scholar
Khomich, Lyudmila V. 1977. “Nentsy i Komi Kolskogo Poluostrova (K voprosu o vzaimovliyanii kultur).” In Etnograficheskie issledovaniya Severozapada SSSR, 116–123. Leningrad: Nauka.Google Scholar
Kihlman, Alfred Oswald. 1889. “Bericht einer naturwissenschaftlichen Reise durch Russisch Lappland im Jahre 1889.” Fennia III (6): 28–40.Google Scholar
Kim, Khe Chzhin, Shabayev, Iurii P., and Istomin, Kiril V. 2015. “Lokal'naia gruppa v poiske identichnosti (komi-izhemtsy: dinamika kul'turnykh transformatsii).” Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniia 2015 (8): 85–92.Google Scholar
Kiseljov, Aleksej, and Kiseljova, Tatjana. 1996. “De nasjonale mindretall på Kolahalv⊘ya og russiske myndigeters politikk overfor dem.” In Frykt og forventning. Russland og Norge i det 20. århundre, edited by Goldin, Vladislav and Petter Nielsen, Jens, 278–300. Arkhangelsk: Pomoruniversitetets forlag.Google Scholar
Kiselov, Alexey. 2009. “Murmanskie Komi.” In Ocherki etnicheskoy istorii Kolsogo Severn, 26–42. Murmansk: MGPU.Google Scholar
Klokov, Konstantin B. 1997. “Traditsionnoye prirodopol'zovaniye narodov Severa: kontseptsiia sokhraneniia i razvitiia v sovremennykh usloviiakh.” Etnogeograficheskie i etnoekologicheskie issledovaniia 5: 1–44.Google Scholar
Sever, Kol'skiy. 2013. “Administrativno-territorial'noe ustroystvo kol'skogo severa.” http://lexicon.dobrohot.org/. Accessed September 15, 2016.Google Scholar
Konakov, Nikolai D. 1984. “Formirovanie lokalnoi gruppy Komi na Kol'skom poluostrove.” In Izhemskie Komi na Kolskom Poluostrove, edited by N. D. Konakov, O.V. Kotov and Rochev, Iu. G., 3–23. Sytykvar: Komi Filial AN SSSR.Google Scholar
Konakov, Nikolai D. 1986. “Stanovlenie krupnotabunnogo olenevodstva na Kol'skom poluostrove.” Trydy IlaLI Komi filiala AN SSSR 37: 42–56.Google Scholar
Konakov, Nikolai D. 1993. “Ecological Adaptation of Komi Resettled Groups.” Arctic Anthropology 30 (2): 92–102.Google Scholar
Konakov, Nikolai D., and Kotov, Oleg V. 1991. Etnoarealnye gruppy komi: formirovanie i sovremennoe etnokulturnoe sostoianie. Moscow: Nauka.Google Scholar
Konstantinov, Iulian. 2005. “From ‘Traditional’ to Collectivized Reindeer Herding on the Kola Peninsula: Continuity or Disruption?” Acta Borealia 22 (2): 170–188.Google Scholar
Konstantinov, Iulian. 2015. Conversations with Power: Soviet and Post-Soviet Developments in the Reindeer Husbandry Part of the Kola Peninsula. Uppsala Studies in Cultural Anthropology. Uppsala: Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis.Google Scholar
Kotov, Oleg V. 1988. Etnokul'turnyye protsessy u sovremennykh komi Kol'skogo poluostrova. Syktyvkar: Akademia Nauk SSSR.Google Scholar
Kozhevnikov, Aleksei. 1927. Chelovek-pesnia. Moscow: Krasnyi proletarii.Google Scholar
Kozhevnikov, Aleksei. 1928. Loparenok Olesa. Moskva: Krest'ianskaia gazeta.Google Scholar
Krupnik, Igor. 1993. Arctic Adaptations: Native Whalers and Reindeer Herders of Northern Eurasia. Hanover: University Press of New England. http://www.dartmouth.edu/˜library/digital/publishing/books/krupnik1993/.Google Scholar
Lebedev, Vsevolod. 1933. K severnym narodam: (Puteshestvie k lopariam). Moskva: Molodaia gvardiia.Google Scholar
Luk'ianchenko, Tat'iana. 2003. “Traditsionnye khoziaistvennye zaniatiia.” In Pribaltiysko-finskie narody Rossii, edited by Klement'ev, E.I. and Shlygina, N.V., 66–77. Moscow: Nauka.Google Scholar
Luk'ianchenko, Tat'iana. 2009. “Poyezdka v Murmanskuiu oblast’ letom 1958g.” In Polevyye issledovaniia Instituta etnologii i antropologii 2006, 234–254. Moskva: Nauka.Google Scholar
Maksimov, Sergei V. 1890. God na Severe. 4th ed. Moscow: P.K. Prianishnikov.Google Scholar
Martin, Terry. 2001. The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923–1939. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Mezak, Ernest. 2004. “Izhemtsy okazalis’ v bednykh rodstvennikakh u iaz'vintsev.” http://www.zyryane.info/articles/page-170.html.Google Scholar
Orekhova, Ekaterina. 2008. “Saamskoe naselenie i kolonizatsiia Murmanskogo berega Kol'skogo poluostrova vo vtoroy polovine XIX – nachale XX vv.” In Zhivushchie na Severe: opyt i prognozy, 43–58. Murmansk: MGPU.Google Scholar
Orlova, Yelisaveta. 1924. “Tri mesiatsa na Kol'skom poluostrove: (putevye zametki).” In Staryi i novyi byt: sbornik, edited by Tan-Bogoraz, V.G., 26–44. Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo.Google Scholar
Osinovskii, Viktor I. 1930. “Olenevocheskii Sovkhoz.” Karelo-Muramanskii Krai 1930 (4–5): 21–23.Google Scholar
Overland, Indra, and Berg-Nordlie, Mikkel. 2012. Bridging Divides: Ethno-Political Leadership among the Russian Sami. New York: Berghahn Books.Google Scholar
Pliss, David S. 1933. “O vnutrikhoziaystvennom planirovanni v olenevodcheskikh sovkhozakh.” Karelo-Murmanskiy Kray 1933 (7–8): 62–65.Google Scholar
Razumova, Irina A., and Petrov, Valentin P. 2005. “Problemy i perspektivy sotsial'no- antropologicheskikh issledovanii etnokul'turnoi situatsii na Kol'skom severe.” In Formirovanie osnov sovremennoy strategii prirodopol'zovaniia v Evro-Arkticheskom regione, 408–418. Apatity: Izd. KNTS RAN.Google Scholar
Rikhter, Zinaida V. 1925. Za poliarnym krugom: rasskazy. Leningrad: Molodaia gvardiia.Google Scholar
Rippas, Boris A. 1915. Na Kol'shorn Poluostrove: otchet o poezdke letom 1894. Petrograd: Tipografiia Ministerstva Putei Soobsheniia.Google Scholar
Robinson, Michael. 1998. Sami Potatoes: Living with Reindeer and Perestroika. Calgary: Bayeux Arts.Google Scholar
Rusanov, Vladimir A. 1945. Stat'i, Lektsii, Pis'ma. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo Glavsevmorputi.Google Scholar
Rutland, Peter. 2010. “The Presence of Absence: Ethnicity Policy in Russia.” In Institutions, Ideas and Leadership in Russian Politics, edited by Newton, Julie and Tompson, William, 116–136. London: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Shabaev, Iurii P. 2009. “Ethnic Conflicts in the European North of Russia.” Anthropology & Archeology of Eurasia 48 (3): 31–75.Google Scholar
Shabaev, Iurii P., Sadokhin, Aleksandr P., and Shilov, Nikolay V. 2009. “Etnonatsional'nye dvizheniia v novoi sotsiokul'turnoi real'nosti.” Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniia 10: 57–66.Google Scholar
Sharapov, V. E., and Zherebtsov, I. L. 2014. L.N. Zherebtsov o traditsiiakh trudovoy vzaimopomoshchi u Komi-Zyrian. Syktyvkar: IYaLI Komi NTs UrO RAN.Google Scholar
Slezkine, Yuri. 1994a. Arctic Mirrors: Russia and the Small Peoples of the North. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Slezkine, Yuri. 1994b. “The USSR as a Communal Apartment, or How a Socialist State Promoted Ethnic Particularism.” Slavic Review 53 (2): 414–452.Google Scholar
Sokolovskii, Sergei. 2015. “Indigenous Identity and the Construction of Indigeneity in Russian Political Practice and Law.” In Peoples, Identities and Regions. Spain, Russia and the Challenges of the Multi-Ethnic State, edited by Martynova, Marina, Peterson, David, Ignatiev, Roman, and Madariaga, Nerea, 191–208. Moscow: IEA RAS.Google Scholar
Ssorin-Chaikov, Nikolai. 2008. “Political Fieldwork, Ethnographic Exile, and State Theory: Peasant Socialism and Anthropology in Late-Nineteenth-Century Russia.” In A New History of Anthropology, edited by Kuklick, Henrika, 191–206. Malden, MA: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Tan-Bogoraz, Vladimir G. 1924. “Staryi i novyi byt.” In Staryi i novyi byt: sbornik, edited by Tan-Bogoraz, Vladimir G., 5–25. Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo.Google Scholar
Thompson, Niobe. 2008. Settlers on the Edge: Identity and Modernization of Russia's Arctic Frontier. Vancouver: UBC Press.Google Scholar
Tishkov, Valery A. 1992. “The Crisis in Soviet Ethnography.” Current Anthropology 33 (4): 371–382.Google Scholar
Tsing, Anna Lowenhaupt. 2005. Friction: An Ethnography of Global Connection. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Tsylev, Viktor R. 2013. “Osobennosti zhizni malykh narodov Kol'skogo Severa v sovremennykh usloviiakh (na primere sela Krasnoshchel'e).” Problemy razvitiia territorii 66 (4): 74–83.Google Scholar
Uchitel-Lopatin. 1928. “Radio v tundre.” Karelo-Muramanskiy Kray 1928 (2): 33.Google Scholar
Ushakov, Ivan F., and Dashchinskii, Sergei N. 1988. Lovozero. Murmansk: Knizhnoe izd-vo.Google Scholar
Vladimirova, Vladislava K. 2006. Just Labor: Labor Ethic in a Post-Soviet Reindeer Herding Community, Uppsala Studies in Cultural Anthropology. Uppsala: Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis.Google Scholar
Vladimirova, Vladislava K. 2011. “'We are Reindeer People, We Come from Reindeer’ Reindeer Herding in Representations of the Sami in Russia.” Acta Borealia 28 (1): 89–113. doi:10.1080/08003831.2011.575661.Google Scholar
Vlasova, Viktoriia V., and Denisenko, Valentina N. 2012. “Sokhranenie i reprezentatsiia etnichnosti v lokal'nykh gruppakh (saamy i izhemtsy sela Lovozero).” In Evropeiskii sever: lokal'nye gruppy i etnicheskie granitsy, 99–120. Syktyvkar: Trudy IyaLI Komi NTs URO RAN.Google Scholar
Volkov, Nikolay N., Lasko, Lars-Nila, and Taksami, Chuner. 1996. The Russian Sami: Historical-Ethnographic Essays. Guovdageaidnu (Kautokeino): Nordic Sami Institute.Google Scholar
V-r. 1909. “Iz oblasti olenevodstva.” IAOIRS 1909 (7): 35–50.Google Scholar
Yelkin, I. 1928. “Olenevodstvo na Kol'skom Poluostrove (Murmanskaia Guberniia).” Komi Mu (Zyrianskii krai) 47 (1): 12–15.Google Scholar
Zasodimskii, Pavel V. 1901. V zyrianskom kraiu. Moskva: I.N. Kushnerev i K.Google Scholar
Zhakov, Konstantin. 1901. “Etnologicheskii ocherk zyrian.” Zhivaia Starina 11 (1): 3–36.Google Scholar
Zherebtsov, Liubomir N. 1976. “Istoriko-kul'turnye vzaimootnosheniia komi i saamov v kontse XIX-pervoy chetverti XX v.” Trudy IYaLI Komi filiala AN SSSR 17 (Etnografiia i folklor Komi): 32–43.Google Scholar
Zherebtsov, Igor L. 2007. Iz istorii rasseleniia izhemskikh komi po Izhmo-pechorskomu kraiu. Syktyvkar: IlaLI Komi NTs UrO RAN.Google Scholar
Zhilinskiy, Aleksey A. 1914. “Lopari i nashe zakonodatel'stvo.” IAOIRS 20 (December 15): 1–7.Google Scholar
Zolotarev, David A. 1928. Kol'skie Lopari. Leningrad: Izdanie Akademii Nauk.Google Scholar