Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-q99xh Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T19:54:11.609Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Why Tajiks Are (Not) Like Arabs: Central Asian Migration into Russia Against the Background of Maghreb Migration into France

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 April 2019

Vladimir Malakhov
Vladimir Malakhov*
Affiliation:
Moscow School of Social and Economic Sciences, Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (RANEPA), Moscow, Russian Federation
*
*Corresponding author. Email: vmalachov@yandex.ru
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The article aims to compare the conditions of migrants from Central Asia into Russia with that of migrants from the Maghreb into France. Despite many similarities in conditions (related to the experience of social exclusion), there are deep differences. The precarious legal status of the majority of Central Asian newcomers in Russia has prevented them from embarking on an effective struggle for public recognition; this is in sharp contrast with North African newcomers in France who have been engaged in such struggle since the 1980s. In addition, Islam plays different roles in the migrants’ perceptions by host societies and in identification of the migrants themselves. Whereas Islam has become a marker of overarching collective identity among the Maghreb migrants’ descendants, this is not the case with Central Asians in Russia, for whom Islam remains part of their individual identity, rather than the basis of social consolidation and political mobilization.

Keywords

immigration experienceMaghrebFranceCentral AsiaRussia
Type
Article
Information
Nationalities Papers , Volume 47 , Issue 2 , March 2019 , pp. 310 - 324
Copyright
© Association for the Study of Nationalities 2019 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abashin, Sergey. 2012. “Nation-construction in post-Soviet Central Asia.” In Soviet and Post-Soviet Identitie, edited by M. Bassin and C. Kelly, 150–168. New York and Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Abashin, Sergey. 2013. “Central Asian Migration: Practices, Local Communities, Transnationalism.” Russian Politics and Law 51 (3): 6–20.Google Scholar
Abashin, Sergey. 2014. “Nations and Post-Colonialism in Central Asia; Twenty Years Later.” In Development in Central Asia and the Caucasus: Migration, Democratization and Inequality in the Post-Soviet Era, edited by S. Hohman, C. Mouradian, S. Serano, and J.Torez, 80–97. London and New York: IB Tauris.Google Scholar
Adida, Claire L., Laitin, David D., and Valfort, Marie-Anne. 2010. “Identifying Barriers to Muslim Integration in France.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America December 28, Vol. 107 (52).Google Scholar
Alba, Richard. 2005. “Bright vs. Blurred Boundaries: Second-Generation Assimilation and Exclusion in France, Germany, and the United States.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 28 (1): 20–49.Google Scholar
Alba, Richard, and Silberman, Roxane. 2002. Decolonization Immigration and the Social Origins of the Second Generation: The Case of North Africans in France.” International Migration Review 36 (4): 1169–1193.Google Scholar
Alexandrov, Daniil, Baranova, Vlada, and Ivaniushina, Valeriia. 2015. “Etnicheskiy sostav I migratsionnyi status shkol’nikov Rossii.” [Ethnic composition and migrants’ status of school children in Russia], Voprossy obrazovaniya 2: 173–195.Google Scholar
Al’perovich, Vera, and Vera, Natalia. 2014. “The ultra-right shrugged: Xenophobia and Radical Nationalism in Russia, and Efforts to counteract them in 2013.” In Xenophobia, Freedom of Conscience and Anti-Extremism in Russia in 2013, edited by Alexander Verkhovsky, 5–55. Moscow: SOVA Center.Google Scholar
Andrienko, Yuri, and Guriev, Sergey. 2005. “Understanding Migration in Russia.” Policy Paper, Series no. 23, November. Moscow: Center for Economic and Finance Research of New Economic School.Google Scholar
Balibar, Etienne. 2007. “Uprising in the ‘banlieues.’” Constellations 14 (1): 47–71.Google Scholar
Balibar, Etienne. 1991. “Is there a ‘Neo-Racism?’.” In Race, Nation, Class: Ambiguous Identities, edited by Etienne Balibar and Immanuel Wallerstein, 82–88. London: Verso.Google Scholar
Beissinger, Mark. 1995. “The Persisting Ambiguity of Empire.” Post-Soviet Affaires 11 (2): 149–184.Google Scholar
Bessudnov, Alexey. 2016. “Ethnic Hierarchy and Public Attitudes towards Immigrants in Russia.” European Sociological Review 32 (5): 567–580.Google Scholar
Body-Gendrot, Sophie. 2010. “Police Marginality, Racial Logics, and the Discrimination in the Banlieurs of France.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 33 (4): 656–674.Google Scholar
Brednikova, Olga, and Tkach, Olga. 2010. “Dom dlya nomady.” [A House for a Nomad] Laboratorium 3: 72–95.Google Scholar
Brown, Daniel. 2004. “Rap and Censorship in France.” In Shoot the Singer: Music Censorship Today, edited by M. Korpe, 197–207. London and New York: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Dave, Bhavna. 2014. “Becoming ‘Legal’ through ‘Illegal’ Procedures: The Precarious Status of Migrant Workers in Russia.” Russian Analytical Digest 159: 2–8.Google Scholar
Dave, Bhavna. 1996. “National Revival in Kazakhstan: Language Shift and Identity Change,” Post-Soviet Affairs 12: 51–72.Google Scholar
Demintseva, Ekaterina. 2008. Byt’ “arabom” vo Frantsii [Being “Arab” in France]. Мoskow: Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie.Google Scholar
Demintseva, Ekaterina. 2017. “Labor migrants in post-Soviet Moscow: patterns of settlement.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, Feb.: 1–17.Google Scholar
Demintseva, Ekaterina and Kashnitsky, Daniel. 2016. “Contextualizing Migrants’ Strategies of Seeking Medical Care in Russia.” International Migration 54 (5): 29–42.Google Scholar
Demintseva, Ekaterina and Peshkova, Vera. 2014. “Migranty iz Sredney Azii v Moskve.” Demoskop Weekly N2 597-598. http://demoscope.ru/weekly/2014/0597/tema01.php.Google Scholar
Dikec, Mustafa. 2007. Badlands of the Republic: Space, Politics and Urban Policy. Oxford, UK: Wiley-Blackwell.Google Scholar
Diop, Moastapha A. 1997. “Negotiating Religious Difference: The Opinions and Attitudes of Islamic Associations in France.” In The Politics of Multiculturalism in the New Europe: Racism, Identity and Community, edited by T. Modood and P. Webner, 111–125. London and New York: Zed Books.Google Scholar
Escafre-Duplet, Angeline. 2010. “Art, Power and Protest: Immigrants’ Artistic Production and Political Mobilization in France.” Diversities 12 (1): 4–8.Google Scholar
Flynn, Moya, and Kosmarskaya, Nataya 2012. “Exploring ‘North’ and ‘South’ in Post-Soviet Bishkek: Discourses and Perceptions of Rural-Urban Migration.” Nationalities Papers 40 (3): 453–471.Google Scholar
Forsdrick, Charles, and Murphy, David. 2009. Postcolonial Thought in the French-speaking World. Liverpool University Press. http://liverpool.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.5949/UPO9781846319808/upso-9781846310546-chapter-25.Google Scholar
Gaspard, Françoise, and Khosrokhavar, Farkhad. 1995. Le foulard et la Repubique. [The Veil and the Republic] Paris: La Découverte.Google Scholar
Geisser, Vincent, and Soum, El Yamine. 2012. “The Legacies of Colonialism: Migrant-Origin Minorities in French Politics.” In Race and Representation in Western Europe, edited by T. E. Givens and R. Maxwell, 53–66. London and Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers.Google Scholar
Hargreaves, Alec G. 1991. “Writing for Others: Authorship and Authority in Immigrant Literature.” In Race, Discourse and Power in France, edited by M. Silverman, 111–119. Brookfield, MA: Avebury.Google Scholar
Hargreaves, Alec, and McKenney, Mark. 1997. Postcolonial Cultures in France. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hargreaves, Alec G. 1999. Immigration, “Race” and Ethnicity in Contemporary France. London, New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hargreaves, Alec G. 2007. Multi-Ethnic France: Immigration, Politics, Culture and Society. 2nd ed. New York and London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Heleniak, Timothy. 2008. “An Overview of Migration in the Post-Soviet Space.” In Homeland and Belonging in Eurasia, edited by C. J. Buckley, B. A. Ruble, and E. T. Hofmann, 29–68. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Hemmings, Hilary. 2010. Remittances, Recession…Returning Home? The Effects of the 2008 Economic Crisis on Tajik Migrant Labor in Moscow. Washington: WWICS.Google Scholar
Hohmann, Sophie, Mouradian, Claire, Serano, Silvia, and Torez, Julien. 2014. Development in Central Asia and the Caucasus: Migration, Democratization and Inequality in the Post-Soviet Era. London and New York: I.B. Tauris.Google Scholar
Hussey, Andrew. 2014. The French Intifada: The Long War Between France and Its Arabs. London: Granta Books.Google Scholar
Ireland, Patrick. 1994. The Policy Challenge of Ethnic Diversity: Immigrant Politics in France and Switzerland. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Ireland, Paul. 2000. “Reaping What the Sow: Institutions and Immigrant Political Participation in Western Europe.” In Challenging Immigration and Ethnic Relations Politics: Comparative European Perspectives, edited by R. Koopmans, and P. Statham, 233–282. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Jones, Rosemarie. 1991. “‘Un discourse de muette?’: problems of ‘la prise de parole’ ” in the fiction of Assia Djebar.” In Race, Discourse and Power in France, edited by M. Silverman, 120–127. Brookfield, MA: Avebury.Google Scholar
Joppke, Christian. 2009. Veil: Mirror of Identity. New York, USA: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Kappeler, Andreas. 2000. “Rossia – mnogonatsionalnaya imperia: nekotorye razmyshleniya 8 let spustya posle publikatsii knigi.” [Russia as a multinational Empire: rethinking the book 8 years after publication] Ab imperio, No.1: 15–32.Google Scholar
Kastoryano, Riva. 2002. Negotiating Identities: States and Immigrants in France and Germany. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Korobkov, Andrey. 2007. “Migration Trends in Central Eurasia: Politics versus Economics.” Communist and Post-Communist Studies 40 (2): 169–189.Google Scholar
Korobkov, Andrei V. 2008. “Post-Soviet Migration: New Trends at the Beginning of the Twenty-First Century.” In Homeland, and Belonging in Eurasia, edited by C. J. Buckley and B.A. Ruble, with E.T. Hofmann, 69–98. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press/Baltimore, MA: The Johns Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
Kozhevnikova, Galina. 2008. Ultra-Nationalism and Hate Crimes in Contemporary Russia. The 2004-2006 Annual Reports of Moscow’s SOVA Center (Soviet and post-Soviet Societies 77). Stuttgart: Ibidem verlag.Google Scholar
Laurence, Jonathan. 2006. “Managing Transnational Islam: Muslims and the State in Western Europe.” In Immigration and the Transformation of Europe, edited by C. Parsons and T.Smeeding, 253–275. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Liazu, Claud. 2005. “At War with France’s Past.” Le monde diplomatique, June 2005, http://mondediplo.com/2005/06/19colonisation.Google Scholar
Lisovskii, Vsevolod. 2014. “S metloi i mikrofonom: Gastarbaitery na scene Bolshogo teatra.” Lenta.ru, April 22, 2014. https://lenta.ru/articles/2014/04/22/akyyn_opera/.Google Scholar
Martinello, Marco. 2009. “Immigrants and Their Offspring in Europe as Political Subjects.” In Bringing Outsiders In: Transatlantic Perspectives on Immigrant Political Incorporation, edited by J. Hochfield and J. Mollenkopf, 33–47. Ithaka, NY: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Maxwell, Rahsaan. 2010. “Political Participation in France among Non-European-Origin Migrants: Segregation or Integration?” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 36 (3): 425–443.Google Scholar
Meurs, Dominique, Pailhé, Ariane and Simon, Patrick. 2006. “The persistence of intergenerational inequalities linked to immigration: Labor market outcomes for immigrants and their descendants in France.” Population (Paris) 61 (5/6): 645–682.Google Scholar
Mouradian, Claire. 2014. “The Origins of a Colonial Vision of Southern Russia from the Tsars to the Soviets: About Some Imperial Practices in the Caucasus.” In Development in Central Asia and the Caucasus: Migration, Democratization and Inequality in the Post-Soviet Era, edited by Hohman, C. Mouradian, S. Serano, and J. Torez, 17–46. London and New York: I.B. Tauris.Google Scholar
Naselenie Rossii za 100 let (1897–1997): Statisticheskii sbornik . 1998. [The population of Russia over 100 years (1897–1997): Statistical abstract]. Moscow: Goskomstat.Google Scholar
Nasritdinov, Emil and Schroeder, Philipp. 2016. “From Frunze to Bishkek: Soviet Territorial Youth Formations and Their Decline in the 1990s and 2000s.” Central Asian Affairs 3 (1): 1–28.Google Scholar
Naylor, Phillip Ch. 2000. France and Algeria: A History of Decolonization and Transformation. Gainesvill, Fla: University of Florida Press.Google Scholar
Noiriel, Gérard. 1996. The French melting pot: immigration, citizenship, and national identity. Translated and edited by Geoffroy de Laforcade; foreword by Charles Tilly. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.Google Scholar
Noiriel, Gérard. 2006. “Colonialism, Immigration, and Power Relations.” Quantitative Sociology 29 (1): 105–110.Google Scholar
Olimova, Saodat and Olimov, Muzaffar. 2008. “Evolyuciya obraza Rossii v Tadzhikistane” [The development of the image of Russia in Tajikistan]. In Rossiya i ES v Centralnoj Azii. Doklady Instituta Evropy RAN no. 222: 114–142. Moskva.: Izdatelstvo“Russkij suvenir .” Google Scholar
Olimova, Saodat, and Olimov, Musaffar. 2014. “Human Capital and Inequality in Tajikistan: Intercommunication and Interdependence.” In Development in Central Asia and the Caucasus: Migration, Democratisation and Inequality in the Post-Soviet Era, edited by S. Hohmann, C. Mouradian, S. Serrano, and J. Thorez, 151–182. London and New York.: IB Tauris.Google Scholar
Osipov, Alexander. 2010. “Ethnicity, Discrimination, and Extremism in Russia.” Problems of Post-Communism 57 (2): 50–60.Google Scholar
Peshkova, Vera. 2015. “Sredneaziatskie ‘etnicheskie kafe’ Moskvy: migrantskaia infrastruktura v gorodskom prostranstve” [Central Asian ‘ethnic cafés’ in Moscow: immigrants’ infrastructure in urban space]. In Etnicheskie rynki v Rossii prostranstvo torga I mesto vstrechi [Ethnic Markets in Russia: Spaces of Bargaining and Place of Meeting], edited by V.I.Dyatlov and K.V. Grigorichev, 186-201. Irkutsk: Izdatelstvo IGU.Google Scholar
Predotvrashchenie i protivodeistvie rasprostraneniiu rabstva i torgovli liud’mi v rossiiskoi federatsii. 2008. [Preventing and combating the spread of slavery and human trafficking in the Russian Federation. Final report on the research section of the European Union project, implemented by the Bureau of International Organization on Migration (MOM) in the Russian Federation, ‘Prevention of human trafficking in the Russian Federation’]. Moscow: Impala.Google Scholar
Reeves, Madeleine. 2013. “Clean fake: authenticating documents and persons in migrant Moscow.” American Ethnologist 40 (3): 508–524.Google Scholar
Reeves, Madeleine. 2014. Border work: Spatial Lives of the State in Rural Central Asia. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Roy, Olivier. 2007. Secularism Confronts Islam. Translated and edited by George Holoch. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Ruget, Vanessa, and Usmanalieva, Bugul. 2014. “Social and Political Transnationalism Among Central Asian Migrants and Return Migrants.” Problems of Post-Communism 58 (6): 48–60.Google Scholar
Sahadeo, Jeff. 2007. “ Druzhba Narodov or second-class citizenship? Soviet Asian migrants in a post-colonial world.” Central Asian Survey 26 (4): 559–579.Google Scholar
Sahadeo, Jeff. 2012. “Soviet “Blacks” and Place Making in Leningrad and Moscow.” Slavic Review 71 (2): 331–358.Google Scholar
Sarkorova, Anora. 2013. “Prichiny radikalizatsii migrantov-musulman v Rossii.” BBC Russian Service, Dushanbe, 4 June. http://www.bbc.com/russian/international/2013/06/130604_tajik_russia_extremism.Google Scholar
Schain, Martin. 1987. “The National Front and the Construction of Political Legitimacy.” West European Politics 10 (1): 229–252.Google Scholar
Schain, Martin. 2006. “The Extreme-Right and Immigration Policy-Making: Measuring Direct and Indirect Effects.” West European Politics 29 (2): 270–289.Google Scholar
Schain, Martin. 2012. “Prospects for Political Integration.” In Immigrant Politics: Race and Representation in Western Europe, edited by Terri E. Givens and Rahsaan Maxwell, 127–142. London, Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers.Google Scholar
Shabal, Emile. 2015. A Divided Republic: Nation, State and Citizenship in Contemporary France. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Silberman, Roxane, Alba, Richard, and Foutrnier, Irene. 2007. “Segmented Assimilation in France? Discrimination in the Labour Market against the Second Generation.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 30 (1): 1–27.Google Scholar
Silverman, Maxim. 1992. Deconstruction the Nation. Immigration, Racism and Citizenship in Modern France. London, New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Silverstein, Paul A. 2000. “Islam, Soccer, and the French Nation-State.” Social Text 65 (18), No.4: 25–53.Google Scholar
Silverstein, Paul. 2002. “‘Why Are We Waiting to Start the Fire?’: French Gangsta Rap and the Critique of State Capitalism.” In Black, Blanc, Beur: Rap Music and Hip Hop Culture in the Francophone World, edited by A.-Ph. Durand, 45–67. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Press.Google Scholar
Silverstein, Paul A. 2005. “Immigrant Racialization and The New Savage Slot: Race, Migration, and Immigration in the New Europe.” Annual Review of Anthropology 34: 363–384.Google Scholar
Simon, Patrick. 2003. “France and the Unknown Second Generation: Preliminary Results on Social Mobility.” International Migration Review 37 (4): 1091–1119.Google Scholar
Suny, Ronald Grigor. 2006. “Learning from Empire: Russia and the Soviet Union.” In Lessons of Empire: Imperial Histories and American Power, edited by Craig Calhoun, Frederick Cooper and Kevin W. Moore, 73–93. NY, London: The New Press.Google Scholar
Taguieff, Pierre-André.1990. “The New Cultural Racism in France.” Telos 83: 109–122.Google Scholar
Tishkov, Valery, Zaionchkovskaya, Zhanna, and Vitkovskaya, Galina. 2005. Migration in the Countries of the Former Soviet Union. Policy Analysis and Research Programme of the Global Commission on International Migration, September 2005. https://www.iom.int/jahia/webdav/site/myjahiasite/shared/shared/mainsite/policy_and_research/gcim/rs/RS3.pdf.Google Scholar
Tiuriukanova, Elena V. 2009. “Trudovye migranty v Moskve: ‘vtoroe’ obshchestvo.” In Immigranty v Moskve, edited by Zh. Zaionchkovskaya,148–175. Moskva: Tri kvadrata.Google Scholar
Verkhovsky, Alexander. 2014. “Language of Authorities and Radical Nationalism.” In Doublespeak. The Rhetoric of the Far Right since 1945, edited by Matthew Feldman and Paul Jackson, 271–300. Stuttgart: Ibidem-Verlag.Google Scholar
Vsesoiuznaia perepis’ naseleniia 1989. Natsional’nyi sostav naseleniia po regionam, Demoskop Weekly, 701-2. Moscow: (Rabochii Arkhiv Goskomstata Rossii. Tablitsa 9c. Raspredelenie Naseleniia po natsional’nosti i rodnomu iazyku) http://demoscope.ru/weekly/ssp/rus_nac_89.php?reg=18 Google Scholar
Wacquant, Loïc. 2008. Urban Outcasts: A Comparative Sociology of Advanced Marginality. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Weil, Patrick. 2008. How to be French? Nationality in Making since 1789. Translated and edited by Catherine Porter. Durham: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Wieviorka, Michel. 2002. “Race, Culture and Society: The French Experience of Muslims.” In Muslim Europe or Euro-Islam: Politics, Culture and Citizenship in the Age of Globalization, edited by Nezar AlSayyad, Manuel Castells, 131–147. Lanham, MD: Lexington.Google Scholar
Withol de Wenden, Catherine. 1991. “North African immigration and the French political imaginary.” In Race, Discourse and Power in France, edited by M. Silverman, 98–110. Brookfield, MA: Avebury.Google Scholar
Wihtol de Wenden, Catherine. 1994. “Immigrants as Political Actors in France.” West European Politics 17 (2): 91–109.Google Scholar
Wihtol de Wenden, Catherine. 2006. “Urban Riots in France.” SAIS Review of International Affairs 26 (2): 47–53.Google Scholar
Yusupova, Gusel and Ponarin, Eduard. 2016. “Social remittances in religion: Muslim migrants in Russia and transformation of Islamic practices.” Problems of Post-Communism, 27 October: 1–13.Google Scholar
Zakharov, Nikolay. 2015. Race and racism in Russia. UK: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
Zaionchkovskaya, Zhanna, Tiuriukanova, Elena, and Mkrtchian, Nikita. 2009. “Rossiia pered vyzovami immigratsii” [Russia’s Immigration Challenge]. In Postsovetskie transformatsii: otrazhenie v migratsiiakh, edited by Zh. Zaionchkovskaya and G. Vitkovskaya, 9–62. Moskva, Adamant; Tsentr migratsionnykh issledovanii. Institut narodnokhoziaistvennovo proghozirovaniia RAN.Google Scholar
Zaionchkovskaya, Zhanna, Tiuriukanova, Elena, and Florinskaya, Iuliya. 2011. Trudovaya migraciya v Rossiyu: kuda dvigatsya dalshe? Seriya specialnyh dokladov. Moscow: MAKS Press.Google Scholar
Zaslavsky, Viktor. 1997. “The Soviet Union”. In After Empire. Multiethnic Societies and Nation-Building: The Soviet Union and the Russian, Ottoman and Habsburg Empires / Edited by K. Barkley and M. von Hagen, 73–98. Boulder, Colo: Westview Press.Google Scholar