Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-gbm5v Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T09:35:30.106Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Study of the Armenian Crisis of the late Ottoman Empire, or, “Seizing the Document by the Throat”

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 July 2015

Selim Deringil
Selim Deringil*
Affiliation:
Boğaziçi University, History Department
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

For a Turkish historian of the Ottoman Empire of the late nineteenth century, venturing into the Armenian crisis is like venturing into a minefield. It is fraught with dangers, the least of which is to be labeled a traitor by one's countrymen, and the worst of which is to be accused of being a “denialist” by one's Armenian colleagues. Even “balanced” analysis seems to have become politically incorrect of late, at least in some circles. The basic problem in the Armenian-Turkish polemic is that the sides do not actually address each other. They seize upon various capsule phrases, clichés and assumed political positions to heap opprobrium and abuse upon one another, to the point where we are confronted by something resembling a blood-feud. Thus Richard Hovanissian's obsession is to have the “Turkish side” admit, in a great ceremony of mea culpa, the claim of Genocide. On the other hand, Turkish historians and their like-minded foreign colleagues, at best, do contortionist acts to show that what happened to the Armenian people in 1915 does not fit the UN definition of genocide, which was fashioned after the Second World War to account for the Jewish Holocaust.

Type
Articles
Information
New Perspectives on Turkey , Volume 27 , Fall 2002 , pp. 35 - 59
Copyright
Copyright © New Perspectives on Turkey 2002

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Akarlı, Engin. 1998. “Particularities of History: A Response to Ronald Grigor Suny,” Armenian Forum, 2 (Summer), pp. 53–64.Google Scholar
Akçam, Taner. 1999. Insan Hakları ve Ermeni Sorunu, Istanbul: İmge Yayınevi.Google Scholar
Assembly of Turkish American Associations. 1987. Armenian Allegations: Myth and Reality. A Handbook of Facts and Documents. Washington: The Assembly of Turkish American Associations.Google Scholar
Behar, Cem. 1998. “Qui compte? Recensements et statistiques démographiques dans l'Empire ottoman du XVIe au XX siècle,” Histoire et Mesure 13/1-2, pp. 135–146.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Başbanlık Osmanlı, Arşivi (hereafter, BOA), Prime Ministry, Ottoman Archives Istanbul, BOA Dahiliye Nezareti Hukuk Müşavirliği (DH. HMŞ) 17/41, 29 Şevval 1311/5 May 1894. Bureau of Legal Advisors of the Ministry of the Interior.Google Scholar
BOA Yıldız Hususi Maruzat Y.A HUS 291/63, 26 Şaban 1311/3 March 1894. Sublime Porte Office of the Grand Vizier no. 3008. Signed by Grand Vizier and Imperial ADC Cevad Paşa.Google Scholar
BOA Y.A HUS 304/56, 18 Muharrem 1310/22 July 1894. Sublime Porte Foreign Ministry no. 1327.Google Scholar
BOA Y.A HUS 352/89, 22 Zilkade 1313/5 May 1896. Cipher communication no. 240 from the Ottoman Legation in Washington to the Sublime Porte Foreign Ministry.Google Scholar
BOA Yıldız Resmi Maruzat (Y.A RES) 110/22, 9 Şaban 1318/1 November 1900. Memorandum penned by Imperial Private Secretary Tahsin Paşa.Google Scholar
BOA Yıldız Esas Evrakı (YEE) 14/1359/126, 27 Teşrin-i Evvel 1316/10 November 1900. Tarhan Paşa to the Yıldız Palace Imperial Secretariat BOA Yıldız Mütenevvi Maruzat (Y.Mtv) 57/38, 15 Cemaziyelevvel 1309/17 December 1891. Imperial Chief of Staff Rıza Paşa to Sublime Porte.Google Scholar
BOA Y.Mtv 86/72, 20 Teşrin-i Evvel 1309/2 November 1893. Cipher telegram from Müşir Zeki Paşa Commander of the Fourth Army in Erzincan to General Staff.Google Scholar
BOA. Y.Mtv 97/76 25, Şevval 1311/2 May 1894. Report from Minister of Police Nazım Bey.Google Scholar
BOA Y.Mtv 131/109, 23 Cemaziyelevvel 1313/11 November 1895. Mutasarrıf of Amasya Bekir Sıdkı to Yıldız Palace.Google Scholar
BOA Y.Mtv 138/92, 7 Şevval 1313/23 March 1896. Imperial General Staff Commander of Cavalry Forces Osman Ferid Paşa.Google Scholar
BOA Y.Mtv 188/118, 22 Zilkade 1316/4 April 1899.Google Scholar
BOA. Y.Mtv 255/157, 18 Zilkade 1321/5 February 1904. Telegram from Ottoman Ambassador in Petersburg, Hasan Hüseyin Paşa, to Yıldız Palace Imperial Secretariat.Google Scholar
Dadrian, Vahakn. 1998a. “Empire and Nation: Armenians, Turks, and the End of the Ottoman Empire,” Armenian Forum 2 (Summer), pp. 17–51.Google Scholar
Dadrian, Vahakn. 1998b. “The Pitfalls of a ‘Balanced Analysis,’” Armenian Forum 2 (Summer), pp. 73–130.Google Scholar
Dadrian, Vahakn. The History of the Armenian Genocide. Providence and Oxford.Google Scholar
Deringil, Selim. 1998. The Well Protected Domains: The Legitimation of Power in the Ottoman Empire 1876-1909. London and Oxford: I.B Tauris.Google Scholar
Eldem, Edhem. 1999. The Imperial Ottoman Bank. Istanbul: Osmanlı Bankası Yayınları.Google Scholar
Foreign Policy Institute. 1982. The Armenian Issue in Nine Questions and Answers. Ankara: The Foreign Policy Institute.Google Scholar
Gökalp, Altan. 1980, Têtes rouges et bouches noires: Une confrérie tribale de l'ouest anatolien. Paris.Google Scholar
Hasluck, William. 1929. Christianity and Islam under the Sultans. Vol. 1. New York: Octagon Books (reprint of the 1929 edition).Google Scholar
Hovannisian, Richard (Ed.). 1992. The Amenian Genocide: History, Politics and Ethics. New York: St. Martin's Press.Google Scholar
Kaiser, Hilmar. Forthcoming. “The Ottoman Empire to the Turkish Republic: The Continuities of Denial,” Armenian Genocide Conference.Google Scholar
Kutay, Cemal. 1962. Birinci Dünya Savaşında Teşkilatı Mahsusa. Istanbul: Ercan Matbaası.Google Scholar
Ocak, Ahmet Yaşar. 1999. Osmanlı İmpaı atorluğu'nda Mülhidler ve Zındıklar, Istanbul: Tarih Vakfı Yurt Yayınları.Google Scholar
Ortaylı, İlber. 1987 İmparatorluğun En Uzun Yüzyılı. Hil Yayınları, Istanbul.Google Scholar
Sami Fraşeri, Şemseddin. 1306/1896. Kamus-u Alam. Istanbul.Google Scholar
Shaw, Stanford, and Shaw, Ezer Kural. 1977. The History of the Ottoman Empire and Modern Turkey Vol. 2. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sonyel, Salahi. 1978. Displacement of the Armenians: Documents (pamphlet in English, French, and Turkish). Ankara.Google Scholar
Suny, Ronald Grigor. 1993. Looking Toward Ararat: Armenia in Modern History. Bloomington, Ill.: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Müdürlüğü, T.C. Devlet Arşivleri Genel, Başkanlığı, Osmanlı Arşivi Daire. 1994. Osmanlı Belgelerinde Ermeniler (1915-1920) Yayın no. 14. Ankara: T.C. Devlet Arşivleri Genel Müdürlüğü.Google Scholar
Tunaya, Tarık Zafer. 1984. Türkiye'de Siyasi Partiler, Istanbul: Hürriyet Vakfı Yayınları.Google Scholar