Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jn8rn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T16:32:24.188Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Coleman-Hilton Scholarship: Poisoning in Roman society and literature

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 December 2024

Caitlin McMenamin*
Affiliation:
(University of Sydney) Caitlin.McMenamin@sydney.edu.au

Abstract

Type
Research Reports
Copyright
Copyright © British School at Rome 2024

During my residency at the British School at Rome, I conducted research related to my PhD project, which explores poisoning and poisoning allegations in Roman society and literature. I utilized the extensive collection of the BSR library and visited sites in Italy and Greece to inform the final stages of my work.

Scholarship on poisoning in ancient Rome is scant and generally limited to the stereotype of the female poisoner, which pervades Roman literature. The Romans believed that women were more likely to commit poisoning because it was a surreptitious and cowardly weapon suited to the ‘weaker sex’. Adulteresses and stepmothers were typical poisoners, and in cases of suspicious and unexpected deaths at a time before advanced toxicology, wives often faced blame and punishment. However, there are many stories about male poisoners in Ancient Rome. The conception of poison as a female-coded weapon and a symbol of moral decay made the accusation of poison's use a convenient way to discredit a personal or political opponent. It also created the opportunity for Roman authors and historians such as Cicero, Livy and Tacitus to utilize poisoning stories in ways that suited their unique purposes. My work reveals the existence of a complex sociopolitical discourse surrounding venenum (poison) and veneficium (poisoning) in Ancient Rome. The aim of my time at the BSR was to consult existing scholarship on poisoning and poisoners in Roman history and to broaden my approach by engaging with the multidisciplinary research environment of the BSR.

During my research residency, I read extensively in Cicero, Livy and Tacitus, alongside numerous scholarly works which I had previously been unable to access. My chapters on Cicero and Tacitus underwent considerable transformation thanks to the ability to consult legal texts and copies of the Corpus Inscriptionum Latinarum (CIL). Moreover, I gained a deep topographical knowledge of Ancient Rome and its environs through living in the city, exploring major archaeological sites and museums. I travelled to the Bay of Naples region twice to view and photograph important examples of Pompeian wall-painting which depict poison-making and poisoning, as well as supposed ‘pharmacies’ at Pompeii. I partnered with the Abbey Scholar in Painting, Tura Oliveira, to travel to Athens to view relevant sites and artefacts, including the prison of the Athenian agora where Socrates was imprisoned, the Areopagus and cups believed to have been used for hemlock. I met with scholars at the Australian Archaeological Institute at Athens, who contributed crucial advice to my chapter on Cicero, resulting in a re-interpretation of a critical passage pertaining to poisoning charges. I wrote and produced a play entitled ‘A Womanly Treachery? The Poisoners of 331 BCE’, which was acted by award-holders for the staff and residents of the BSR, an exciting collaborative opportunity which allowed me to explore the difficulties of writing and reconstructing history in a creative way. Finally, I presented the paper ‘The Effeminacy of Sejanus the Poisoner in Tacitus’ Annals’ at the Classical Association Conference 2024.

I would like to offer my sincere thanks to Ms Suzanne Coleman and Mr Jeffrey Hilton for sponsoring this award. I had an incredible and enriching experience. My work has been profoundly shaped by my time at the BSR. I am also deeply grateful to the award-holders with whom I shared my time, for their companionship, inspiration and support.