Social Movements and Organization Theory. Edited by Gerald F.
Davis, Doug McAdam, Richard Scott, and Mayer N. Zald. New York: Cambridge
University Press, 2005. 452p. $80.00 cloth, $36.99 paper.
Challenging Authority: How Ordinary People Change America. By
Frances Fox Piven. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 2006. 200p.
$21.95.
These two books, both important additions to the social movement
literature, represent two traditions at theoretical odds. Frances Fox
Piven's new book is an authoritative, updated restatement of Piven
and Richard Cloward's classic thesis that it is not lasting
organization but fleeting and overwhelming mass
disruption—literally, “the mob” in her new
work—that is the only source of progressive reform in American
politics. Meanwhile, the focus of Gerald Davis et al.'s new book is
squarely in the organization-centered tradition of social movement
scholarship. And yet, while the books are quite different, Doug McAdam and
Piven (with Cloward) were all pioneer scholars of the role of political
opportunity on movement emergence and outcomes. These two books are
testimony to how far research on social movements has come in the past 35
years.