Democracy for All: Restoring Immigrant Voting Rights in the
United States. By Ron Hayduk. New York: Routledge,
2006. 264p. $24.95 paper, $95.00 cloth.
The 50% American: Immigration and National Identity in an Age
of Terror. By Stanley A. Renshon. Washington, DC:
Georgetown University Press, 2005. 298p. $26.95 cloth.
Immigration is a powerful narrative in the history of the United
States, at times evoking optimism and at other times providing
fodder to foment xenophobia. These two books, authored by a pair of
New York City–based scholars, share a common vantage point in the
experience of the most racially and ethnically diverse city of
immigrants in the United States. At the same time, the books are a
study in contrasts, a neat fit to both ends of the spectrum between
hope and fear. One is concerned with enhancing freedom and the other
with maintaining order. One advocates expansion of political
expression in the form of the franchise, the other recommends
constraint. One looks to our nation's history—to our sometimes
ignominious past of exclusion, as well as to expansive practices
allowing noncitizen voting—and highlights inclusionary lessons to
draw, and the other looks to the future and sees danger in a
post-9/11 world of organized terror. Although distinctive in many
ways, both books are passionately written, and one is compelled to
read on whether cheering in agreement or taking umbrage, for the
arguments will resonate regardless of where one sits on the
political spectrum.