Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-28T17:49:37.240Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The United Nations and Antarctica, 1992: still searching for that elusive convergence of view

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 October 2009

Peter J. Beck
Peter J. Beck
Affiliation:
Faculty of Human Sciences, Kingston University, Kingston upon Thames KT1 2EE
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The tenth successive annual UN session on the ‘Question of Antarctica’ took place at the close of 1992. The UN First Committee considered the topic during the week following the close of the Seventeenth Antarctic Treaty Consultative Meeting held at Venice. The passage of yet another resolution critical of the Antarctic Treaty System (ATS) suggested that little had changed as compared to previous sessions. However, during 1992, UN reports and discussions displayed evidence of a growing acknowledgement of a range of ‘positive’ developments on the part of the ATS, most notably the benefits accruing from the Protocol on Environmental Protection's designation of Antarctica as ‘a natural reserve, devoted to peace and science’ in which mining is prohibited. Significantly, both critics and the German spokesman for the Antarctic Treaty parties (ATPs) — individual ATPs still refused to participate in either the UN discussions or vote because of their belief that the UN has no meaningful role to play in the affairs of a region subject to a valid international legal regime—expressed satisfaction with the concerted approach towards Antarctica embodied in Agenda 21 of the UN Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), which met at Rio de Janeiro in June 1992. As a result, ATPs agreed to ensure that research products were freely available to the international community. In December 1992 the adoption of UN resolution A47/57 reaffirmed the continuing divide between ATPs and other members of the international community regarding the management of Antarctica, even if the UNCED–type formula offers one route back to consensus when the UN takes up the topic again at the close of 1993.

Type
Articles
Information
Polar Record , Volume 29 , Issue 171 , October 1993 , pp. 313 - 320
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1993

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

ATCPs. 1991. Final Report of the Sixteenth Antarctic Treaty Consultative Meeting. Bonn 7–18 10 1991. Bonn: Federal Republic of Germany.Google Scholar
ATCPs. 1992. Draft Report of the Seventeenth Antarctic Treaty Consultative Meeting. Venice 11–20 11 1992. Rome: Republic of Italy.Google Scholar
Beck, P.J. 1988. Another sterile annual ritual? The United Nations and Antarctica 1987. Polar Record24 (150): 207–212.Google Scholar
Beck, P.J. 1991. Why study Antarctica? Kingston upon Thames: Apex Centre, Kingston University.Google Scholar
Beck, P.J. 1992. The 1991 UN session: the environmental protocol fails to satisfy the Antarctic Treaty System's critics. Polar Record 28 (167): 307–314.Google Scholar
Beck, P.J. 1993. ‘A natural reserve, devoted to peace and science’: Antarctica today. Boundary andSecurity Bulletin 1 (1): 80–87.Google Scholar
Hussain, R. 1992. The Antarctic: common heritage of mankind? In: Verhoeven, J., Sands, P., and Bruce, M. (editors). The Antarctic environment and international law. London: Graham & Trotman: 89–92.Google Scholar
Lyons, D. 1993. Environmental impact assessment in Antarctica underthe Protocol on Environmental Protection. Polar Record 29 (169): 111–120.Google Scholar
SCAR. 1992. SCAR Bulletin, No 108, January 1993. Polar Record 29 (168): 79–92.Google Scholar
SCAR-COMNAP. 1992. Environmentalmonitoring in Antarctica–a discussion document. Prepared for Meeting of Experts on Environmental Monitoring of the Antarctic Treaty, Buenos Aires, 06 1992.Google Scholar
Suy, E. 1992. Antarctica: common heritage of mankind? In: Verhoeven, J., Sands, P., and Bruce, M. (editors). The Antarctic environment and international law. London: Graham & Trotman: 93–96.Google Scholar
UN. 1987. United Nations General Assembly Records 42nd Session. Report of the SecretarynGeneral, 30 09 1987, A42/587.Google Scholar
UN. 1991. United Nations General Assembly Records 46th Session. Report of Secretary-General on the state of the environment in Antarctica, 25 10 1991, A46/590.Google Scholar
UN. 1992a. United Nations General Assembly Records 47th Session. 40th meeting of the First Committee, 25 11 1992, A47/C1/PV40.Google Scholar
UN. 1992b. United Nations General Assembly Records 47th Session. Report of the Secretary-General on Question of Antarctica, 20 10 1992, A47/541.Google Scholar
UN. 1992c. United Nations General Assembly Records 47th Session. 38th meeting of the First Committee, 23 11 1992, A47/C1/PV38.Google Scholar
UN. 1992d. United Nations General Assembly Records 47th Session. Report of the Secretary-General on the Question of Antarctica, 20 10 1992, A47/542.Google Scholar
UN. 1992e. United Nations General Assembly Records 47th Session. Report of the Secretary-General on the State of the Environment in Antarctica, 11 11 1992, A47/624.Google Scholar
UN. 1992f. Protecting the Earth's greatwildemess: Antarctica. New York: UN Department of Public Information, DP11222.Google Scholar
UN. 1992g. United Nations General Assembly Records 47th Session. Report of the UN Conference on Environment and Development, Rio de Janeiro, 3–14 06 1992, A/CONF/151 /26/Rev.1, volume 1.Google Scholar
UN. 1992h. The Earth summit: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. UN Chronicle XXlX(2): 40–63.Google Scholar
UN. 1992i. United Nations General Assembly Records 47th Session. 39th meeting of the First Committee, 24 11 1992, A47/C1/PV39.Google Scholar
UN. 1992j. United Nations General Assembly Records 47th Session. Letter from Indonesia to UN, 11 11 1992, A47/675. Tenth Conference of Heads of State or Government of Non–Aligned Countries, Final Document: Political Issues, paragraphs 83–84.Google Scholar
UN. 1992k. United Nations General Assembly Records 47th Session. 24th meeting of General Assembly, 5 10 1992, A47/PV24.Google Scholar
UN. 1993. Resolutions and Decisions adopted by the General Assembly during the first part of its 47th Session 1992, 1 02 1993, GA/8470.Google Scholar
UNEP. 1992. Regional Seas Reports and Studies no. 129.Google Scholar
Watts, A. 1992. International law and the Antarctic Treaty System. Cambridge: Grotius Publications.Google Scholar