Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-t5tsf Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T12:06:00.222Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Darwin, artificial selection, and poverty: Contemporary implications of a forgotten argument

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 May 2016

Luis Sanchez
Luis Sanchez*
Affiliation:
Research School of Social Sciences Australian National University St. Bribie Island, Queensland 4507 Australia luis.sanchez@anu.edu.au
Get access

Abstract

This paper argues that the processes of evolutionary selection are becoming increasingly artificial, a trend that goes against the belief in a purely natural selection process claimed by Darwin's natural selection theory. Artificial selection is mentioned by Darwin, but it was ignored by Social Darwinists, and it is all but absent in neo-Darwinian thinking. This omission results in an underestimation of probable impacts of artificial selection upon assumed evolutionary processes, and has implications for the ideological uses of Darwin's language, particularly in relation to poverty and other social inequalities. The influence of artificial selection on genotypic and phenotypic adaptations arguably represents a substantial shift in the presumed path of evolution, a shift laden with both biological and political implications.

Keywords

Natural selectionartificial selectionevolutiongenetically modified organismspovertysocial constructionjustice
Type
Perspective
Information
Politics and the Life Sciences , Volume 29 , Issue 1 , March 2010 , pp. 61 - 71
Copyright
Copyright © Association for Politics and the Life Sciences 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1.Potthast, Thomas, “Transgenic organisms and evolution: Ethical implications,” in Transgenic Organisms: Biological and Social Implications, Tomiuk, Jürgen, Wöhrmann, Klaus, and Sentker, Andreas, eds. (Basel: Birkhäuser Verlag, 1996), pp. 227–240.Google Scholar
2.UNEP, Global Biodiversity Outlook 2, March 20, 2006, http://www.biodiv.org/gbo2/default.shtmlGoogle Scholar
3.World Resources Institute, Millennium Ecosystem Assessment: Ecosystems and Human Weil-Being—Biodiversity Synthesis (Washington, DC, 2005), p. 4.Google Scholar
4.Heywood, Vernon H., ed., Global Biodiversity Assessment (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1995), pp. 733–763.Google Scholar
5.World Resources Institute.Google Scholar
6.Bradt, Steve, “Ernst Mayr, giant among evolutionary biologists, dies at 100,” Harvard Gazette February 4, 2005, http://www.news.harvard.edu/gazette/.Google Scholar
7.Mayr, Ernst, What Evolution Is (New York: Basic Books, 2001), p. 202.Google Scholar
8.Herring, Ronald J., Transgenics and the Poor: Biotechnology in Development Studies (New York: Routledge, 2007) p. 4.Google Scholar
9.Mukunda, Gautam, Oye, Kenneth A., and Mohr, Scott C., “What rough beast? Synthetic biology, uncertainty, and the future of biosecurity,” Politics and the Life Sciences 2009, 28(2):2–26.Google Scholar
10.Depew, David, “Genetic biotechnology and evolutionary theory: Some unsolicited advice to rhetors,” Journal of Medical Humanities 2001, 22(1):15–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
11.Barta, Tony, “Mr. Darwin's shooters: On natural selection and the naturalizing of genocide,” Patterns of Prejudice 2005, 39(2):116–137.Google Scholar
12.Glad, John, Future of Human Evolution: Eugenics in the Twentieth Century (Schuylkill Haven, PA: Hermitage Publishers, 2007).Google Scholar
13.Darwin, Charles R., On the Origin of Species, Peckman, Morse, ed. (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1959/1859), pp. 168, 169–202.Google Scholar
14.Mayr, Ernst, One Long Argument: Charles Darwin and the Genesis of Modern Evolutionary Thought (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1991), p. 87.Google Scholar
15.Gould, Stephen C., The Structure of Evolutionary Theory (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2002), p. 31.Google Scholar
16.CARE, Facts about Hunger, 2007, February 20, 2007, http://uwnews.washington.edu/ni/article.asp?articleID=27760Google Scholar
17.World Health Organization, World Health Statistics, August 21, 2009, http://www.who.int/whosis/whostat/EN_WHS09_Full.pdfGoogle Scholar
18.UNDP, Informe sobre Desarrollo Humano, 2006, http://www.undp.org/spanish/publicaciones/informeanual2006/desarrollo-humano.shtmlGoogle Scholar
19.Williams-Myers, A. J., “Biological differences, social inequality, and distributive goods: An exploratory argument,” Journal of Black Studies 1983, 13(4): 399–416.Google Scholar
20.Smith, George Davey, Dorling, Daniel, and Shaw, Mary, eds., Poverty, Inequality, and Health in Britain: 1800–2000. A reader (Bristol: The Policy Press, 2001).Google Scholar
21.Suárez-Berenguela, Rubén M., Health System Inequalities and Inequities in Latin America and the Caribbean: Findings and Policy Implications, Working document prepared for the Health and Human Development Division of the Pan American Health Organization, World Health Organization. January 25, 2000, http://www.paho.org/English/HDP/HDD/suarez.pdfGoogle Scholar
22.Norberto, J.Dachs, W., Ferrer, Marcela, Florez, Carmen Elisa, Barros, Aluisio J. D., Narváez, Rory, and Valdivia, Martin, “Inequalities in health in Latin America and the Caribbean: Descriptive and exploratory results for self-reported health problems and health care in twelve countries,” Revista Panamericana de Salud Pública 2002, 11(5–6):335–355.Google Scholar
23.Marmot, Richard, “Health in an unequal world,” Lancet 2006, 368:2081–2094.Google Scholar
24.Wilkinson, Richard G., “The impact of inequality,” Social Research 2006, 73(2):711–729.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
25.Strate, John M., “Review of social stratification and socioeconomic inequality, vol. I: A comparative biosocial analysis by Lee Ellis,” Politics and the Life Sciences 1994, 13(1):158–159.Google Scholar
26.MacIntire, Sally, “Social inequalities and health in the contemporary world: Comparative overview,” in Human Biology and Social Inequality, Strickland, Simon and Shetty, Prakash, eds., (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), pp. 20–35.Google Scholar
27.Strickland, and Shetty, , p. 7.Google Scholar
28.Murali, Vijaya and Oyebode, Femi, “Poverty, social inequality, and mental health,” Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 2004, 10:216–224.Google Scholar
29.The World Bank, World Development Indicators, 2006, http://data.worldbank.org/data-catalog/world-development-indicators/wdi-2006Google Scholar
30.Davies, James B., Sandstrom, Susanna, Shorrocks, Anthony, and Wolff, Edward N., The World Distribution of Household Wealth (New York: New York University Press, 2006).Google Scholar
31.Ruse, Michael, “Charles Darwin and artificial selection,” Journal of the History of Ideas 1975, 36(2):339–350.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
32.Snooks, Graeme Donald, The Collapse of Darwinism, or The Rise of a Realist Theory of Life (Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, 2003), p. 9.Google Scholar
33.Wilner, Eduardo, “Darwin's artificial selection as an experiment,” Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 2006, 37:26–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
34.Cleveland, David A. and Soleri, Daniela, “Extending Darwin's analogy: Bridging differences in concepts of selection between farmers, biologists, and plant breeders,” Economic Botany 2007, 61(2):121–136.Google Scholar
35.Mayr, , One Long Argument.Google Scholar
36.Darwin, , p. 111.Google Scholar
37.Darwin, , p. 202.Google Scholar
38.Darwin, , quoted inRuse, , p. 339.Google Scholar
39.Eldredge, Niles, Reinventing Darwin: The Great Debate at the High Table of Evolutionary Theory (New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1995), p. 34.Google Scholar
40.Potthast, , p. 230.Google Scholar
41.Sterrett, Susan, “Darwin's analogy between artificial and natural selection: How does it go?” Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 2002, 33(1). http://www.elsevier.com/locate/shpscGoogle Scholar
42.Snooks, .Google Scholar
43.Pigliuci, Massimo and Kaplan, Jonathan, Making Sense of Evolution: The Conceptual Foundations of Evolutionary Biology (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006), p. 13.Google Scholar
44.Snooks, , pp. 36–49.Google Scholar
45.Darwin, , quoted inMayr, , One Long Argument, p. 83.Google Scholar
46.Paul, Crook, Darwinism, War, and History (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994), pp. 13–14.Google Scholar
47.Young, Robert M., “Evolutionary biology and ideology: Then and now,” Social Studies of Science 1971, 1(2):177–206.Google Scholar
48.Gale, Barry G., “Darwin and the concept of a struggle for existence: A study in the extrascientific origins of scientific ideas,” Isis 1972, 63(3):321–344.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
49.Bowler, Peter J., “Malthus, Darwin, and the concept of struggle,” Journal of the History of Ideas 1976, 37(4):631–650.Google Scholar
50.Crook, Paul, “Recent historical writing on Darwinism: A review article,” Australian Journal of Politics and History 1999, 45(1):110–118.Google Scholar
51.Stack, David, The First Darwinian Left: Socialism and Darwinism, 1859–1914 (Cheltenham, UK: New Clarion Press, 2003), p. 12.Google Scholar
52.Barta, .Google Scholar
53.Darwin, , quoted inBarta, , p. 121.Google Scholar
54.Darwin, , quoted inBarta, , p. 125.Google Scholar
55.Darwin, , quoted inRuse, , p. 339.Google Scholar
56.Dobzhansky, , p. 111.Google Scholar
57.Bowler, , p. 631.Google Scholar
58.Crook, .Google Scholar
59.Claeys, Gregory, “The ‘survival of the fittest’ and the origins of social Darwinism,” Journal of the History of Ideas 2000, 61(2):223–240.Google Scholar
60.Gordon, Scott, “Darwin and political economy: The connection reconsidered,” Journal of the History of Biology 1989, 22(3):437–459.Google Scholar
61.Gale, , p. 341.Google Scholar
62.Darwin, , chapter 3.Google Scholar
63.Bowler, , pp. 631–633.Google Scholar
64.Darwin, , introduction.Google Scholar
65.Claeys, , p. 227.Google Scholar
66.Snooks, , pp. 61–65.Google Scholar
67.Darwin, Charles R., The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation with Sex, Vol. I (London: John Murray, Albemarle Street, 1871), p. 131.Google Scholar
68.Crook, , Darwinism, War and History, p. 24.Google Scholar
69.Crook, Paul, Darwin's Coat-Tails: Essays on Social Darwinism (New York: Peter Lang, 2007), p. 6.Google Scholar
70.Quammen, David, The Reluctant Mr. Darwin: An Intimate Portrait of Charles Darwin and the Making of his Theory (New York: Atlas Books, 2006), pp. 44–45.Google Scholar
71.Stack, David, p. 86.Google Scholar
72.Rogers, James Allen, “Darwinism and social Darwinism,” Journal of the History of Ideas 1972, 33(2):265–280.Google Scholar
73.Crook, , Darwinism, War, and History, p. 24.Google Scholar
74.Gale, , p. 339.Google Scholar
75.Stack, , p. 86.Google Scholar
76.Rogers, , pp. 265–280.Google Scholar
77.Suzuki, David and Knudtson, Peter, Genethics: The Ethics of Engineering Life (Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 1989).Google Scholar
78.Phelps, Bob, “Opposing genetic manipulation: The genethics campaign,” in Altered Genes II: The Future? Hindmarsh, Richard and Lawrence, Geoffrey, eds. (Melbourne: Scribe Publications, 2001).Google Scholar
79.Burley, Justine C. and Harris, John A., eds., A Companion to Genethics: Philosophy and the Genetic Revolution (Oxford: Blackwell, 2002).Google Scholar
80.Mooney, Harold A., Introduction of Genetically Modified Organisms into the Environment (New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1990).Google Scholar
81.Wührmann, Klaus, Sentker, Andreas, and Tomiuk, Jürgen, “Epilogue,” in Transgenic Organisms: Biological and Social Implications, Tomiuk, Jürgen, Wöhrmann, Klaus, and Sentker, Andreas, eds. (Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 1996), pp. 255–263.Google Scholar
82.Potthast, , p. 231.Google Scholar
83.Nicholas, Frank W. and Robertson, Alan, “The conflict between natural and artificial selection in finite populations,” Theoretical and Applied Genetics 1980, 56(1–2): 57–64.Google Scholar
84.Brakefield, Paul M., “Artificial selection and the development of ecologically relevant phenotypes,” Ecology 2003, 84(7):1661–1671.Google Scholar
85.Cooner, Jeffrey, “Artificial selection: A powerful tool for ecologists,” Ecology 2003, 84(7):1650–1660.Google Scholar
86.Carlson, Stephanie et al., “Four decades opposing natural and artificial selection,” Ecology Letter 2007(10):512–521.Google Scholar
87.Mayr, , One Long Argument, p. 105.Google Scholar
88.Dobzhansky, Theodosius, Evolution, Genetics, and Man (New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1967), p. 112.Google Scholar
89.Dobzhansky, , p. 119.Google Scholar
90.Mayr, , One Long Argument, p. 164.Google Scholar
91.Luca Cavalli-Sforza, L., “Introduction,” in Genes, Culture, and Human Evolution: A Synthesis, Stone, Linda and Lurquin, Paul, eds. (Maiden, MA: Blackwell, 2007), pp. xiv–xxi.Google Scholar
92.Dover, Gabriel, Dear Mr. Darwin: Letters on the Evolution of Life and Human Nature (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 2000).Google Scholar
93.Pigliuci, Massimo and Kaplan, Jonathan, Making Sense of Evolution: The Conceptual Foundations of Evolutionary Biology (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006), p. 15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
94.Somit, Albert, “Biopolitics,” British Journal of Political Science 1972, 2(2):209–238.Google Scholar
95.Wilson, Edward O., Sociobiology: The New Synthesis, 25th anniv. ed. (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2000/1975).Google Scholar
96.Pigliuci, and Kaplan, , pp. 14–15.Google Scholar
97.Cavalli-Sforza, .Google Scholar
98.Dawkins, Richard, The Selfish Gene (New York: Oxford University Press, 2006/1976).Google Scholar
99.Lewontin, Richard C., “The units of selection,” Annual Reviews of Ecology and Systematics 1970, 1:1–18.Google Scholar
100.Mayr, Ernst, One Long Argument, p. 142.Google Scholar
101.Sober, Elliot, Philosophy of Biology (New York: Oxford University Press, 1993), p. 91.Google Scholar
102.Snooks, , pp. 87, 98.Google Scholar
103.Hodgson, Geoffrey M., “Darwinism in economics: From analogy to ontology,” Journal of Evolutionary Economics 2002, 12(3):259–281.Google Scholar
104.Broswimmer, Franz J., Ecocide: A Short History of the Mass Extinction of Species (London: Pluto Press, 2002), p. 103.Google Scholar
105.World Resources Institute, p. 4.Google Scholar
106.Bensaude-Vincent, Bernadette and Newman, William R., The Artificial and the Natural: An Evolving Polarity (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2007).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
107.Wilson, Edward O., Consilience: The Unity of Knowledge (New York: Knopf, 1998), pp. 53–55.Google Scholar
108.Baldi, Pierre, The Shattered Self: The End of Natural Evolution (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2001).Google Scholar
109.Broswimmer, .Google Scholar
110.Arber, Werner, “Impact of human civilization on biological evolution,” in Introduction of Genetically Modified Organisms into the Environment, Mooney, Harold A., ed. (Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, 1990), pp. 17–26.Google Scholar
111.Ward, Peter Douglas, The End of Evolution: A Journey in Search of Clues to the Third Mass Extinction Facing Planet Earth (New York: Bantam Books, 1995).Google Scholar
112.Bostrom, Nick, “The future of human evolution,” in Death and Anti-Death: Two Hundred Years After Kant, Fifty Years After Turing, Tandy, Charles, ed. (Ria University Press: Palo Alto, CA, 2004): pp. 339–371.Google Scholar
113.Fumento, Michael, Bioevolution: How Biotechnology is Changing Our World (San Francisco: Encounter Books, 2003).Google Scholar
114.Hirshleifer, Jack, “Economics from a biological viewpoint,” Journal of Law and Economics 1977, 20(1):1–52.Google Scholar