Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-4rdpn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-13T02:39:14.453Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A meta-analytic review of the effects of psychotherapy control conditions for anxiety disorders

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 May 2008

J. A. J. Smits  and
S. G. Hofmann
J. A. J. Smits*
Affiliation:
Department of Psychology, Southern Methodist University, Dallas, TX, USA
S. G. Hofmann
Affiliation:
Department of Psychology, Boston University, Boston, MA, USA
*
*Address for correspondence: J. A. J. Smits, Ph.D., Department of Psychology, Southern Methodist University, Dedman College, PO Box 750442, Dallas, TX 75275, USA. (Email: jsmits@smu.edu)
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Background

Little is known about the magnitude of improvement associated with psychotherapy control conditions for adult anxiety disorders. This information is important for the design of psychosocial treatment efficacy studies.

Method

We performed a computerized search of treatment outcome studies of anxiety disorders conducted between the first available year and 1 March 2007. In addition, we examined the reference lists from identified articles and asked international experts to identify eligible studies. We included studies that randomly assigned adult patients suffering from anxiety disorders to either cognitive–behavioral treatment or psychotherapy control condition. For each study, the two authors independently selected psychometrically sound measures of anxiety disorder severity. In addition, we collected data on attrition and treatment response.

Results

Of the 1165 studies that were initially identified, 19 studies (454 patients) met inclusion criteria and were included in the analyses. The random effects analysis yielded a pre- to post-treatment Hedges' g effect size of 0.45 (95% confidence interval 0.35–0.46, z=8.50, p<0.001). The mean weighted response and attrition rates were 25.0% and 14.2%, respectively. There was no evidence for publication bias, nor was there a significant relationship between the effect size and diagnostic group, study year or number of treatment sessions.

Conclusions

Psychotherapy control conditions are associated with significant improvements when administered to adults suffering from anxiety disorders. In addition, they are associated with a relatively low attrition rate. These findings can inform the design of future psychotherapy outcome studies.

Keywords

Anxiety disordersmeta-analysisplacebopsychotherapytreatment outcome
Type
Original Articles
Information
Psychological Medicine , Volume 39 , Issue 2 , February 2009 , pp. 229 - 239
Copyright
Copyright © 2008 Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Bailar, JC (2001). The powerful placebo and the Wizard of Oz. New England Journal of Medicine 344, 1630–1632.Google Scholar
Baker, SL, Heinrichs, N, Kim, HJ, Hofmann, SG (2002). The Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale as a self-report instrument: a preliminary psychometric analysis. Behaviour Research and Therapy 40, 701–715.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Barlow, DH, Gorman, JM, Shear, MK, Woods, SW (2000). Cognitive–behavioral therapy, imipramine, or their combination for panic disorder: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Medical Association 283, 2529–2536.Google Scholar
Beck, AT, Epstein, N, Brown, G, Steer, RA (1988). An inventory for measuring clinical anxiety: psychometric properties. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 56, 893–897.Google Scholar
Beecher, HK (1955). The powerful placebo. Journal of the American Medical Association 159, 1602–1606.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Blake, DD, Weathers, FW, Nagy, LM, Kaloupek, DG, Gusman, FD, Charney, DS, Keane, TM (1995). The development of a clinician administered PTSD scale. Journal of Traumatic Stress 8, 75–90.Google Scholar
Blanchard, EB, Hickling, EJ, Devineni, T, Veazey, CH, Galovski, TE, Mundy, E, Malta, LS, Buckley, TC (2003). A controlled evaluation of cognitive behavioral therapy for posttraumatic stress in motor vehicle accident survivors. Behaviour Research and Therapy 41, 79–96.Google Scholar
Borenstein, M, Hedges, L, Higgins, J, Rothstein, H (2005). Comprehensive Meta-Analysis, version 2. Biostat, Inc.: Englewood, NJ.Google Scholar
Borkovec, TD, Costello, E (1993). Efficacy of applied relaxation and cognitive–behavioral therapy in the treatment of generalized anxiety disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 61, 611–619.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bruce, SE, Yonkers, KA, Otto, MW, Eisen, JL, Weisberg, RB, Pagano, M, Shea, MT, Keller, MB (2005). Influence of psychiatric comorbidity on recovery and recurrence in generalized anxiety disorder, social phobia, and panic disorder: a 12-year prospective study. American Journal of Psychiatry 162, 1179–1187.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bryant, RA, Harvey, AG, Dang, ST, Sackville, T, Basten, C (1998). Treatment of acute stress disorder: a comparison of cognitive–behavioral therapy and supportive counseling. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 66, 862–866.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bryant, RA, Moulds, ML, Guthrie, RM, Dang, ST, Nixon, RD (2003 a). Imaginal exposure alone and imaginal exposure with cognitive restructuring in treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 71, 706–712.Google Scholar
Bryant, RA, Moulds, ML, Guthrie, RM, Nixon, RDV (2005). The additive benefit of hypnosis and cognitive-behavioral therapy in treating acute stress disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 73, 334–340.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bryant, RA, Moulds, ML, Nixon, RVD (2003 b). Cognitive behaviour therapy of acute stress disorder: a four-year follow-up. Behaviour Research and Therapy 41, 489–494.Google Scholar
Bryant, RA, Sackville, T, Dang, ST, Moulds, M, Guthrie, R (1999). Treating acute stress disorder: an evaluation of cognitive behavior therapy and supportive counseling techniques. American Journal of Psychiatry 156, 1780–1786.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Bystritsky, A (1990). Development of a multidimensional scale of anxiety. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 4, 99–115.Google Scholar
Cohen, J (1988). Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences, 2nd edn. Erlbaum: Hillsdale, NJ.Google Scholar
Cooper, H, Hedges, LV (1994). Combining estimates of effect size. In The Handbook of Research Synthesis, pp. 261–281. Russell Sage Foundation: New York, NY.Google Scholar
Cottraux, J, Note, I, Albuisson, E, Yao, SN, Note, B, Mollard, E, Bonasse, F, Jalenques, I, Guérin, J, Coudert, AJ (2000). Cognitive behavior therapy versus supportive therapy in social phobia: a randomized controlled trial. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 69, 137–146.Google Scholar
Craske, MG, Maidenberg, E, Bystritsky, A (1995). Brief cognitive–behavioral versus nondirective therapy for panic disorder. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 26, 113–120.Google Scholar
Derogatis, LR (1977). SCL-90 Administration, Scoring, and Procedures Manual for the Revised Version. Johns Hopkins University Press: Baltimore, MD.Google Scholar
Derogatis, LR, Melisaratos, N (1983). The Brief Symptom Inventory: an introductory report. Psychological Medicine 13, 595–605.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
DiNardo, PA, Barlow, DH (1988). Anxiety Disorder Interview Schedule – Revised (ADIS-R). Phobia and Anxiety Disorders Clinic, State University of New York: Albany, NY.Google Scholar
DiNardo, PA, Brown, TA, Barlow, DH (1994). Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule for DSM-IV. Center for Anxiety and Related Disorders at Boston University: Boston, MA.Google Scholar
Foa, EB (1995). Post-Traumatic Stress Diagnostic Scale (PDS). National Computer Systems: Minneapolis, MN.Google Scholar
Foa, EB, Riggs, DS, Dancu, CV, Rothbaum, BO (1993). Reliability and validity of a brief instrument for assessing post-traumatic stress disorder. Journal of Traumatic Stress 6, 459–473.Google Scholar
Foa, EB, Rothbaum, BO, Riggs, DS, Murdock, TB (1991). Treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder in rape victims: a comparison between cognitive–behavioral procedures and counseling. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 59, 715–723.Google Scholar
Frisch, MB, Cornell, J, Villanueva, M, Retzlaff, PJ (1992). Clinical validation of the Quality Of Life Inventory: a measure of life satisfaction for use in treatment planning and outcome assessment. Psychological Assessment 4, 92–101.Google Scholar
Glass, CR, Merluzzi, T, Biever, JL, Larsen, K (1982). Cognitive assessment of social anxiety: development and validation of a self-statement questionnaire. Cognitive Therapy and Research 6, 37–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goodman, WK, Price, LH, Rasmussen, SA, Mazure, C, Fleischmann, RL, Hill, CL, Heninger, GR, Charney, DS (1989). The Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale, I: development, use, and reliability. Archives of General Psychiatry 46, 1006–1011.Google Scholar
Greist, JH, Marks, IM, Baer, L, Kobak, KA (2002). Behavior therapy for obsessive–compulsive disorder guided by a computer or by a clinician compared with relaxation as a control. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 63, 138–145.Google Scholar
Guy, W (1976). ECDEU Assessment Manual for Psychopharmacology, publication ADM 76-338 (ed. Guy, W.), pp. 217–222. Department of Health, Education and Welfare: Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Hamilton, M (1959). The measurement of anxiety states by rating. British Journal of Medical Psychology 32, 50–55.Google Scholar
Harding, TW, de Arango, MV, Baltazar, J, Climent, CE, Ibrahim, HH, Ladrido-Ignacio, L, Murthy, RS, Wig, NN (1980). Mental disorders in primary health care: a study of their frequency and diagnosis in four developing countries. Psychological Medicine 10, 231–241.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hedges, LV, Olkin, I (1985). Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis. Academic Press: New York, NY.Google Scholar
Hedges, LV, Vevea, JL (1998). Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis. Psychological Methods 3, 486–504.Google Scholar
Heimberg, RG, Liebowitz, MR, Hope, DA, Schneier, FR, Holt, CS, Welkowitz, LA, Juster, HR, Campeas, R, Bruch, MA, Cloitre, M, Fallon, B, Klein, DF (1998). Cognitive behavioral group therapy vs phenelzine therapy for social phobia: 12-week outcome. Archives of General Psychiatry 55, 1133–1141.Google Scholar
Hodgson, RJ, Rachman, S (1977). Obsessive compulsive complaints. Behaviour Research and Therapy 15, 389–395.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hofmann, SG, Smits, JA (2008). Cognitive–behavioral therapy for adult anxiety disorders: a meta-analysis of randomized placebo-controlled trials. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry. Published online: 5 March 2008. PMID: 18363421.Google Scholar
Hofmann, SG, Weinberger, J (2007). The Art and Science of Psychotherapy. Routledge (Taylor and Francis): New York, NY.Google Scholar
Horowitz, MJ, Wilner, N, Alvarez, W (1979). Impact of Event Scale: a measure of subjective stress. Psychosomatic Medicine 41, 209–218.Google Scholar
Hrobjartsson, A, Gotsche, PC (2001). Is the placebo powerless? An analysis of clinical trials comparing placebo with no treatment. New England Journal of Medicine 344, 1594–1602.Google Scholar
Hrobjartsson, A, Gotsche, PC (2007). Wambold et al.'s reiterate spin in the conclusion of a re-analysis of placebo versus no-treatment trials despite similar results as in original review. Journal of Clinical Psychotherapy 63, 405–408.Google Scholar
Huppert, JD, Schultz, LT, Foa, EB, Barlow, DH, Davidson, JR, Gorman, JM, Shear, MK, Simpson, HB, Woods, SW (2004). Differential response to placebo among patients with social phobia, panic disorder, and obsessive–compulsive disorder. American Journal of Psychiatry 161, 1485–1487.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Jacobson, NS, Truax, P (1991). Clinical significance: a statistical approach to defining meaningful change in psychotherapy research. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 59, 12–19.Google Scholar
Jadad, AR, Moore, RA, Carroll, D, Jenkinson, C, Reynolds, DJM, Gavaghan, DJ, McQuay, HJ (1996). Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary? Controlled Clinical Trials 17, 1–12.Google Scholar
Keller, MB, Lavori, PW, Friedman, B, Nielsen, E, Endicott, J, Mcdonal-Scott, P, Andreasen, NC (1987). A longitudinal interval follow-up evaluation: a comprehensive method for assessing outcome and prospective longitudinal studies. Archives of General Psychiatry 44, 540–548.Google Scholar
Kellner, R, Sheffield, BF (1973). A self-rating scale of distress. Psychological Medicine 3, 88–100.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Khawaja, NG, Oei, TP (1992). Development of a catastrophic cognition questionnaire. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 6, 305–318.Google Scholar
Klein, DF (1996). Preventing hung juries about therapy studies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 64, 81–87.Google Scholar
Liebowitz, MR (1987). Social phobia. Modern Problems of Pharmacopsychiatry 22, 141–173.Google Scholar
Liebowitz, MR, Schneier, F, Campeas, R, Hollander, E, Hatterer, J, Fyer, A, Gorman, JM, Papp, L, Davies, S, Gully, R, Klein, DF (1992). Phenelzine vs. atenolol in social phobia: a placebo-controlled comparison. Archives of General Psychiatry 49, 290–300.Google Scholar
Lindsay, M, Crino, R, Andrews, G (1997). Controlled trial of exposure and response prevention in obsessive–compulsive disorder. British Journal of Psychiatry: Journal of Mental Science 171, 135–139.Google Scholar
Luborsky, L, Diguer, L, Seligman, D, Rosenthal, R, Krause, E, Johnson, S, Halperin, G, Bishop, M, Berman, JS, Schweizer, E (1999). The researcher's own therapy allegiances: a ‘wild card’ in comparisons of treatment efficacy. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 6, 96–106.Google Scholar
Lucas, RA (1994). A comparative treatment outcome study of social phobia. Dissertation Abstracts 54, 6465.Google Scholar
Marks, IM, Connolly, J, Hallam, RS (1973). The psychiatric nurse as therapist. British Medical Journal 2, 156–160.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marks, IM, Lovell, K, Noshirvani, H, Livanou, M, Thrasher, S (1998). Treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder by exposure and/or cognitive restructuring. Archives of General Psychiatry 55, 317–325.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Marks, IM, Mathews, AM (1979). Brief standard self-rating for phobic patients. Behaviour Research and Therapy 17, 263–267.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Mattick, RP, Clarke, JC (1998). Development and validation of measures of social scrutiny fear and social interaction anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy 36, 455–470.Google Scholar
Mavissakalian, MR, Jones, BA, Olson, SC (1990). Absence of placebo response in obsessive–compulsive disorder. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 178, 268–270.Google Scholar
McDonagh, A, Friedman, M, McHugo, G, Ford, J, Sengupta, A, Mueser, K, Demment, CC, Fournier, D, Schnurr, PP, Descamps, M (2005). Randomized trial of cognitive–behavioral therapy for chronic posttraumatic stress disorder in adult female survivors of childhood sexual abuse. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 73, 515–524.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Meyer, TJ, Miller, ML, Metzger, RL, Borkovec, TD (1990). Development and validation of the Penn State Worry Questionnaire. Behaviour Research and Therapy 28, 487–495.Google Scholar
Neuner, F, Schauer, M, Klaschik, C (2004). A comparison of narrative exposure therapy, supportive counseling, and psychoeducation for treating posttraumatic stress disorder in an African refugee settlement. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 72, 579–587.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Piercy, MA, Sramec, JJ, Kurtz, NM, Cutler, NR (1996). Placebo response in anxiety disorders. Annals of Pharmacotherapy 30, 1013–1019.Google Scholar
Quitkin, FM (1999). Placebos, drug effects, and study design: a clinicians' guide. American Journal of Psychiatry 156, 829–836.Google Scholar
Quitkin, FM, Rabkin, JG, Gerald, J, Davis, J, Klein, DF (2000). Validity of clinical trials of antidepressants. The American Journal of Psychiatry 157, 327–337.Google Scholar
Reiss, A, Peterson, R, Gursky, D, McNally, R (1986). Anxiety sensitivity, anxiety frequency, and the prediction of fearfulness. Behaviour Research and Therapy 24, 1–8.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, R (1979). The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results. Psychological Bulletin 86, 638–641.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, R (1991). Meta-Analytic Procedures for Social Research, revised edn. Sage Publications, Inc.: Thousand Oaks, CA.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sanavio, E (1988). Obsessions and compulsions: The Padua Inventory. Behaviour Research and Therapy 26, 169–177.Google Scholar
Smits, JA, Powers, MB, Buxkamper, R, Telch, MJ (2006). The efficacy of videotape feedback for enhancing the effects of exposure-based treatment for social anxiety disorder: a controlled investigation. Behavior Research and Therapy 44, 1773–1785.Google Scholar
Spielberger, CD, Gorsuch, RL, Lushene, RE (1970). State–Trait Anxiety Inventory, Manual. Consulting Psychologists Press: Palo Alto, CA.Google Scholar
Turner, SM, Beidel, DC, Dancu, CV, Stanley, MA (1989). An empirically derived inventory to measure social fears and anxiety: The Social Phobia and Anxiety Inventory. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1, 35–40.Google Scholar
Wampold, BE, Imel, ZE, Minami, T (2007). The placebo effect: ‘relatively large’ and ‘robust’ enough to survive another assault. Journal of Clinical Psychotherapy 63, 401–403.Google ScholarPubMed
Wampold, BE, Minami, T, Tierney, SC, Baskin, TW, Bhati, KS (2005). The placebo is powerful: estimating placebo effects in medicine and psychotherapy from randomized clinical trials. Journal of Clinical Psychotherapy 61, 835–854.Google Scholar
Ware, J Jr., Kosinski, M, Keller, SD (1996). A 12-Item Short-Form Health Survey: construction of scales and preliminary tests of reliability and validity. Medical Care 34, 220–233.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Watson, D, Friend, R (1969). Measurement of social-evaluative anxiety. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 33, 448–457.Google Scholar
Weathers, FW, Litz, B, Huska, JA, Keane, TM (1995). PCL-C for DSM-IV (PTSD Checklist). National Center for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: Boston, MA.Google Scholar
Wetherell, JL, Gatz, M, Craske, MG (2003). Treatment of generalized anxiety disorder in older adults. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 71, 31–40.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
World Health Organization (1997). World Health Organization, Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI) Researcher's Manual. American Psychiatric Press Inc.: Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Zung, WWK (1975). A rating instrument for anxiety disorders. Psychosomatics: Journal of Consultation Liaison Psychiatry 12, 371–379.Google Scholar