Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T15:49:44.042Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Broadcasting Mainline Protestantism: The Chicago Sunday Evening Club and the Evolution of Audience Expectations from Radio to Television

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 June 2018

Michael Stamm
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article analyzes the broadcast activities of the Chicago Sunday Evening Club (CSEC), a mainline Protestant organization founded in 1908 and still active today. The CSEC began broadcasting its weekly meetings on the radio in 1922 and on television in 1956. Drawing on archival organizational records from the CSEC and from listener correspondence, this essay traces how the club's use of the new media of particular historical moments shaped its history as a public entity.

This study makes two claims. First, it argues that, though evangelicals and fundamentalists took to radio and television broadcasting with greater vigor, mainline Protestant groups did as well, and the persistence of a group like the CSEC offers a way to understand the challenges that broadcasting presented to religious organizations. Second, this article shows how audience expectations for religious programming evolved from radio to television. For many listeners, radio offered what they told the CSEC was a spiritual and even miraculous experience, and they marveled at being able to tune in to religious services from their homes. Television, however, prompted remarks often focused on visual style, and the club found itself struggling to compete with the newly emerging group of religious television programs not only on denominational terms (many were evangelicals and fundamentalists) but also on aesthetic terms. In contrast to radio, as many viewers wrote to the CSEC, television seemed to provide not a singular “experience” but rather spectatorial access to events taking place elsewhere. In the context of competition from the more telegenic programming of evangelicals and fundamentalists, these shifting audience expectations shaped both the history of the CSEC as a public entity and the broader history of mainline Protestantism in the mass media.

Keywords

Chicagonew mediaradioreligiontelevision
Type
Research Article
Information
Religion and American Culture , Volume 22 , Issue 2 , Summer 2012 , pp. 233 - 264
Copyright
Copyright © Center for the Study of Religion and American Culture 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Notes

For assistance with an earlier version of this essay, I thank Neil Harris, Michael Carriere, Moira Hinderer, and Matt Millikan. Ani Sarkissian offered very helpful feedback on a more recent version. Robert Black of the Chicago Sunday Evening Club generously offered his time to discuss the club's activities. The staffs at the Chicago History Museum, the Rosenthal Archives of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, and the Wheaton College Archives and Special Collections helped immensely in locating materials, especially Frank Villella at the Rosenthal Archives and David Malone at Wheaton.

1. Tichi, Cecelia, Civic Passions: Seven Who Launched Progressive America (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2009), chap. 6Google Scholar; Kloppenberg, James, Uncertain Victory: Social Democracy and Progressivism in European and American Thought, 1870–1920 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1986), 209–12Google Scholar.

2. The literature on religious broadcasting is extensive and multidisciplinary. In addition to works cited throughout, the following works have been particularly useful for this essay: Erickson, Hal, Religious Radio and Television in the United States, 1921–1991: The Programs and Personalities (Jefferson, N. C.: McFarland and Co., 1992)Google Scholar; Ferré, John, ed., Channels of Belief: Religion and American Commercial Television (Ames: Iowa State University Press, 1990)Google Scholar; Forbes, Bruce David and Mahan, Jeffrey H., eds., Religion and Popular Culture in America (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2000)Google Scholar; Fore, William, Television and Religion: The Shaping of Faith, Values, and Culture (Minneapolis: Augsburg Publishing House, 1987)Google Scholar; Hill, George H., Airwaves to the Soul: The Influence and Growth of Religious Broadcasting in America (Saratoga, Calif.: R&E Publishers, 1983)Google Scholar; Horsfield, Peter G., Religious Television: The American Experience (New York: Longman, 1984)Google Scholar; Wm.Sloan, David, ed., The Media and Religion in American History (Northport, Ala.: Vision Press, 2000)Google Scholar; Vries, Hent de and Weber, Samuel, eds., Religion and Media (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 2001)Google Scholar; and Ward, Mark, Air of Salvation: The Story of Christian Broadcasting (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1984)Google Scholar.

3. “Chicago Sunday Evening Club, About Us,” accessed December 18, 2009, http://www.csec.org/about.htm.

4. Kelley, Dean, Why Conservative Churches Are Growing: A Study in Sociology of Religion (New York: Harper and Row, 1972), 1 Google Scholar.

5. Roof, Wade Clark and McKinney, William, American Mainline Religion: Its Changing Shape and Future (New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1987), 45, 40Google Scholar; Wuthnow, Robert, The Restructuring of American Religion: Society and Faith since World War II (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1988), 10 Google Scholar. See also Rossinow, Doug, The Politics of Authenticity: Liberalism, Christianity, and the New Left in America (New York: Columbia University Press, 1998)Google Scholar; and Hutchison, William, Albanese, Catherine, Stackhouse, Max, and McKinney, William, “The Decline of Mainline Religion in American Culture,” Religion and American Culture: A Journal of Interpretation 1, no. 2 (Summer 1991): 131–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6. Fox, Richard Wightman, “The Culture of Liberal Protestant Progressivism, 1875–1925,” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 23 (Winter 1993): 640 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kelley, Why Conservative Churches Are Growing, 51. See also Leach, William, Land of Desire: Merchants, Power, and the Rise of a New American Culture (New York: Vintage, 1993)Google Scholar; Lears, T. J. Jackson, No Place of Grace: Antimodernism and the Transformation of American Culture, 1880–1920 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994 [1981])Google Scholar; May, Henry, The End of American Innocence: A Study of the First Years of Our Own Time, 1912–1917 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1992 [1959])Google Scholar; and Smith, Christian, ed., The Secular Revolution: Power, Interests, and Conflict in the Secularization of American Public Life (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2003)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7. Schultze, Quentin J., Christianity and the Mass Media in America: Toward a Democratic Accommodation (East Lansing: Michigan State University Press, 2003), 80 Google Scholar; Voskuil, Dennis, “Reaching Out: Mainline Protestantism and the Media,” in Between the Times: The Travail of the Protestant Establishment in America, 1900–1960, ed. Hutchison, William R. (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1989), 89, 72Google Scholar. On mainline Protestant broadcasting, see also Buddenbaum, Judith, “Mainline Protestants and the Media,” in Religion and Mass Media: Audiences and Adaptations, ed. Stout, Daniel and Buddenbaum, Judith (Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage, 1996), 51–60 Google Scholar; and Neuendorf, Kimberly, “The Public Trust versus the Almighty Dollar,” in Religious Television: Controversies and Conclusions, ed. Abelman, Robert and Hoover, Stewart (Norwood, N.J.: Ablex Publishing, 1990), 71–84 Google Scholar.

8. Schultze, Christianity and the Mass Media in America, 77

9. Hutchison, William R., “Protestantism as Establishment,” in Hutchison, , Between the Times, 3 Google Scholar.

10. Bartlett was a leading Chicago retailer, while Nuveen and Harris were prominent bankers. Hutchinson was the president of the Chicago Board of Trade, and McCormick the president of International Harvester. Pirie was an executive at the department store Carson, Pirie, Scott. Shedd served as president of the department store Marshall Field and, in the 1920s, founded the downtown aquarium that still bears his name today. See Paul Henry Heidebrecht, Faith and Economic Practice: Protestant Businessmen in Chicago, 1900–1920 (New York: Garland, 1989), 249–70.

11. Clifford W. Barnes, “Reminiscences of Clifford W. Barnes,” unpublished manuscript, 42, 48, Box 1, Folder Reminiscences and Articles, Clifford W. Barnes Papers, Chicago History Museum, Chicago, Illinois (hereafter CHM). On Barnes's civic activism, see “My War on the Mayor: Barnes Hints at Political Comeback after Slur on Committee of Fifteen,” Chicago Daily News, October 21, 1913, 3; Barnes, Clifford W., “The Story of the Committee of Fifteen of Chicago,” Social Hygiene 4 (April 1918): 145–56Google Scholar; “U.S. Leaders Hit Crime Here: Committee of 1,000 Begins Super-Drive,” Chicago Tribune, January 15, 1925, 1; and “Religion Only Cure for Crime, Barnes Avers,” Chicago Daily News, October, 13, 1930, 8. On Chicago philanthropy during this period, see Horowitz, Helen Lefkowitz, Culture and the City: Cultural Philanthropy in Chicago from the 1880s to 1917 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1976)Google Scholar.

12. Addams, Jane, Twenty Years at Hull-House (New York: Signet Classics, 1961 [1910]), 82 Google Scholar. Addams's remarks had originally been given in 1892 as “The Subjective Necessity for Social Settlements,” and she noted that she reproduced them in Twenty Years at Hull-House “because I have found it impossible to formulate with the same freshness those early motives and strivings.” Ibid., 74.

13. “Religion to Rival Theater,” Chicago Tribune, February 5, 1908, 1.

14. Vitrano, Steven, “The Chicago Sunday Evening Club: A Study in Contemporary Preaching” (Ph.D. diss., Michigan State University, 1966), 79 Google Scholar; Vitrano, Steven, An Hour of Good News: The Chicago Sunday Evening Club—A Unique Preaching Ministry (Chicago: Chicago Sunday Evening Club, 1974), 143–77Google Scholar; Taylor, Lynn, “An Hour of Good News,” Chicago Tribune, April 7, 1974, sec. 9, 43 Google Scholar.

15. Vitrano, An Hour of Good News, 6, 69; Vitrano, “The Chicago Sunday Evening Club,” 335. In carrying out his quantitative content analysis to assess the religious character of CSEC addresses, Vitrano read the addresses and tallied the number of times that Jesus or Christianity was mentioned, the number of times biblical examples were used, and the frequency of references to Christian precepts. The detailed results of Vitrano's research are in “The Chicago Sunday Evening Club,” 215–336.

16. Chicago Sunday Evening Club Program, 1918, Box 13, Folder Miscellaneous, Chicago Sunday Evening Club Records, CHM (hereafter CSEC-CHM); Barton, Bruce, “Chicago's Sunday Evening Club,” Home Herald 19 (November 18, 1908): 5 Google Scholar; Fried, Richard, The Man Everybody Knew: Bruce Barton and the Making of Modern America (Chicago: Ivan R. Dee, 2005), 93 Google Scholar. On the early popularity of the CSEC, see also Dodge, Wallace “The Chicago Sunday Evening Club,” Saturday Times, October 2, 1909, 3–5 Google Scholar; Randall, Roy, “The Twentieth Century Church,” Morrison's Chicago Weekly, January 12, 1911, 5, 29 Google Scholar; and Anderson, George, “Clubbing the People to Church,” Congregationalist, January 8, 1914, 48–49 Google Scholar.

17. Heidebrecht, Faith and Economic Practice, 4; Publicity Committee Report, October 10, 1913, 1, Box 1, Folder Minutes 5/9/13– 10/9/13, CSEC-CHM; Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, January 25, 1924, Box 2, Folder Minutes 5/25/23–5/27/26, CSEC-CHM.

18. Boyer, Paul, Urban Masses and Moral Order in America, 1820–1920 (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1978), 284–92Google Scholar.

19. Barnouw, Erik, A History of Broadcasting in the United States, vol. 1, A Tower in Babel, to 1933 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1966), 88–90 Google Scholar; Hilmes, Michele, Radio Voices: American Broadcasting, 1922–1952 (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1997), 44, 51–54Google Scholar; Stone, George, “Radio Has Gripped Chicago,” Radio Broadcast 1 (October 1922): 508 Google Scholar; Rodgers, W. W., “Broadcasting Church Services,” Radio Broadcast 1 (August 1922): 321–29Google Scholar; H. A. Fall to Clifford Barnes, September 29, 1926, Box 2, Folder Minutes 10/12/26–1/4/28, CSEC-CHM.

20. Letter excerpted in CSEC General Report, December 9, 1925, 2, Box 2, Folder Minutes 5/25/23–5/27/26, CSEC-CHM; Robert Hilliard to CSEC, quoted in CSEC General Report, January 9, 1923, 2, Box 2, Folder Minutes 5/26/21–4/27/23, CSEC-CHM.

21. Peters, John Durham, Speaking into the Air: A History of the Idea of Communication (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999), 7, 96–101CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Douglas, Susan, Listening In: Radio and the American Imagination (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2004 [1999]), chap. 2Google Scholar; Miller, Edward, Emergency Broadcasting and 1930s American Radio (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 2003)Google Scholar.

22. James, William, The Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human Nature (New York: Penguin, 1985 [1902]), 379–81, 419Google Scholar.

23. “The Sunday Evening Club,” Chicago Tribune, October 22, 1928, 23.

24. Goff, Philip, “’We Have Heard the Joyful Sound’: Charles E.Fuller's Radio Broadcast and the Rise of Modern Evangelicalism,” Religion and American Culture: A Journal of Interpretation 9, no. 1 (Winter 1999): 67–95 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hangen, Tona J., Redeeming the Dial: Radio, Religion, and Popular Culture in America (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2002), 49–52, 100–104Google Scholar; Hangen, Tona J., “Speaking of God, Listening for Grace: Christian Radio and Its Audiences,” in Radio Cultures: The Sound Medium in American Life, ed. Keith, Michael (New York: Peter Lang, 2008), 134–41Google Scholar. The letter from the Saskatchewan listener is from Hangen, Redeeming the Dial, 49.

25. Typescript, “A Few Typical Letters,” Box 2, Folder Minutes 1/30/29–5/27/31, CSEC-CHM; letter excerpted in CSEC General Report, December 9, 1925, 2, Box 2, Folder Minutes 5/25/23–5/27/26, CSEC-CHM; Naomi Questell to John Nuveen, letter excerpt in Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, June 16, 1948, Box 1, Folder 14, Chicago Sunday Evening Club Records (SC-47), Wheaton College Archives and Special Collections, Wheaton, Illinois (hereafter CSEC-WH); Clipping, “Attend Chicago Church by Radio,” Decatur Review, October 1923, Scrapbook vol. 11, CSEC-CHM.

26. Anderson, Benedict, Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism (London: Verso, 1991), 26, 6Google Scholar; Edward Steiner to CSEC, letter excerpt in Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, May 29, 1929, Box 2, Folder Minutes 1/30/29–5/27/31, CSEC-CHM; Angus Hibbard to CSEC, November 1932, Box 2, Folder Minutes 10/9/31– 6/7/33, CSEC-CHM.

27. Clipping, “Radio Extends Sunday Evening Club,” American, February 23, 1923, Scrapbook vol. 11, CSEC-CHM; Raymond William Taylor, “Sunday Evening Club, Formed to Relieve Loneliness of Visitors, Is Now a National Institution,” Chicago Today, February 8, 1930, 11; “Bandit Gets Religion via Radio Service,” Chicago Daily News, February 27, 1930, 28; Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, May 25, 1923, Box 2, Folder Minutes 5/25/23–5/27/26, CSEC-CHM; Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, May 27, 1926, Box 2, Folder Minutes 5/25/23– 5/27/26, CSEC-CHM; Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, November 28, 1928, Box 2, Folder Minutes 1/25/28–12/29/28, CSEC-CHM; Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, November 27, 1929, Box 2, Folder Minutes 1/30/29–5/27/31, CSEC-CHM; Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, January 29, 1930, 3, Box 2, Folder Minutes 1/30/29–5/27/31, CSECCHM; Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, February 4, 1931, Box 2, Folder Minutes 1/30/29–5/27/31, CSEC-CHM. On early radio audience measurement, see Craig, Douglas, Fireside Politics: Radio and Political Culture in the United States, 1920–1940 (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2000), chap. 10Google Scholar.

28. Minutes of the Trustees Meeting, February 15, 1928, 1, Box 2, Minutes 1/25/28–12/19/28, CSEC-CHM.

29. Vitrano, An Hour of Good News, 79–80; Hilmes, Radio Voices, 71–73, 86; Berry, Chad, “Introduction: Assessing the National Barn Dance,” in The Hayloft Gang: The Story of the National Barn Dance, ed. Berry, Chad (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2008), 5 Google Scholar. After 1936, the program aired on stations WIND, WAAF, WGN-FM, and WCFL.

30. Brinkley, Alan, Voices of Protest: Huey Long, Father Coughlin, and the Great Depression (New York: Vintage, 1983)Google Scholar; Hangen, Redeeming the Dial, 88, 74, 43–56; Goff, “’We Have Heard the Joyful Sound,’” 71–72; Sutton, Matthew Avery, Aimee Semple McPherson and the Resurrection of Christian America (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2007), 3 Google Scholar; Voskuil, Dennis, “The Power of the Air: Evangelicals and the Rise of Religious Broadcasting,” in American Evangelicals and the Mass Media: Perspectives on the Relationship between American Evangelicals and the Mass Media, ed. Schultze, Quentin J. (Grand Rapids: Academie, 1990), 74 Google Scholar.

31. W. L. Dunbar to Clifford Barnes, December 9, 1923, 1–3, Box 3, Folder CSEC Administration, CSEC-CHM.

32. Parker, Everett, “Religion on the Air in Chicago: A Study of the Religious Programs on the Commercial Radio Stations of Chicago,” Chicago Theological Seminary Register 32 (January 1942): 3–13 Google Scholar; Hangen, Redeeming the Dial, 116.

33. Duncan-Clark, S. J., “A Spiritual Power House,” Chicago Daily News, November 23, 1935, 6 Google Scholar; Kinsley, Philip, “Barnes Honored as Public Friend No. 1 of Chicago,” Chicago Tribune, November 29, 1940, 19 Google Scholar; Hangen, Redeeming the Dial, 113.

34. Doherty, Thomas, Cold War, Cool Medium: Television, McCarthyism, and American Culture (New York: Columbia University Press, 2003), 153–54Google Scholar; Sheen, Fulton J., Treasure in Clay: The Autobiography of Fulton J. Sheen (New York: Doubleday, 1980), 63 Google Scholar. The source of Sheen's metaphor is John 1:1 and 1:14: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God… . And the Word became flesh and lived among us, and we have seen his glory, the glory as of a father's only son, full of grace and truth.” The New Oxford Annotated Bible, ed. Bruce Metzger and Roland Murphy (New York: Oxford University Press, 1991), NT 125.

35. Rosenthal, Michele, “’Turn It Off!’: TV Criticism in the Christian Century Magazine, 1946–1960,” in Practicing Religion in the Age of Media: Explorations in Media, Religion, and Culture, ed. Hoover, Stewart M. and Clark, Lynn Schofield (New York: Columbia University Press, 2002), 140, 151Google Scholar; Rosenthal, Michele, American Protestants and TV in the 1950s (New York: Palgrave, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

36. Alton Motter, Evaluation Report to Board of Trustees, May 20, 1953, 3–4, Box 2, Folder 3, CSEC-WH; Ihde, Carlton, “Wanted: Throngs for Sunday Club,” Chicago Daily News, October 6, 1955, 9 Google Scholar.

37. Doherty, Cold War, Cool Medium, 4; Fiske, Irving, quoted in William Boddy, Fifties Television: The Industry and Its Critics (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1990), 19 Google Scholar.

38. “Sunday Club May Televise Services,” Chicago Sun-Times, October 1, 1955, 16; “Sunday Club to Be on TV for 17 Weeks,” Chicago Sun-Times, January 7, 1956, 12; “First Sunday Club Talk Going on TV,” Chicago Daily News, March 3, 1956, 6; WTTW, “TV Info for S.E.C.,” undated, 2–3, Box 20, Folder 1, CSEC-WH.

39. James W. Hammond to Joseph Hanson, October 21, 1957, Box 20, Folder 1, CSEC-WH; Parker, Everett C., Barry, David W., and Smythe, Dallas W., The Television-Radio Audience and Religion (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1955), 106–55Google Scholar; “200,000 See Evening Club TV Programs,” Chicago Sun-Times, April 29, 1957, 51.

40. Hangen, Redeeming the Dial, 152–53, 23–26 (quote on 153).

41. Bruce, Steve, Pray TV: Televangelism in America (London: Routledge, 1990), 36 Google Scholar; Schultze, Quentin, Televangelism and American Culture: The Business of Popular Religion (Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1991), 38 Google Scholar.

42. D. H. Hoffman to CSEC, January 31, 1968, Box 20, Folder 4, CSEC-WH; Beulah Vass to CSEC, October 19, 1964, 1–2, Box 20, Folder 2, CSEC-WH.

43. Helen Clark to CSEC, November 2, 1966, Box 20, Folder 2, CSEC-WH; Mrs. L. C. Richards to CSEC, April 22, 1968, 2–3, Box 20, Folder 4, CSEC-WH.

44. Joseph Hanson to John Taylor, June 3, 1968, Box 20, Folder 4, CSEC-WH; Orchestral Association, Minutes of the Board of Trustees, September 18, 1959, Box 3, Folder 4, TOA-B-3/4, Rosenthal Archives of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, Chicago, Illinois; John Taylor to Joseph Hanson, March 27, 1968, 2, Box 20, Folder 4, CSEC-WH; John Taylor to Joseph Hanson, June 5, 1968, 1, CSEC-WH.; John Taylor to Joseph Hanson, January 18, 1968, CSEC-WH; John Taylor to Joseph Hanson, February 2, 1968, 1, CSEC-WH.

45. Typescript, CSEC study of broadcast options, March 8, 1967, 1, Box 20, Folder 3, CSEC-WH; Kingman Douglass to Joseph Hanson, April 26, 1967, CSEC-WH.

46. CSEC Program, February 9, 1969, Box 9, Folder 6, CSEC-WH; Goff, “’We Have Heard the Joyful Sound,’” 85.

47. Taylor, “An Hour of Good News,” 30, 33, 46. On this trajectory of audience composition at the national level, see Johnstone, Ronald L., “Who Listens to Religious Radio Broadcasts Anymore?” Journal of Broadcasting 16 (Winter 1971/72): 91–102 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Gerbner, George, Gross, Larry, Hoover, Stewart, Morgan, Michael, and Signorielli, Nancy, Religion and Television: A Research Report by the Annenberg School of Communications, University of Pennsylvania, and the Gallup Organization, Inc. (Philadelphia: Annenberg School of Communications, 1984)Google Scholar.

48. Armstrong, Ben, The Electric Church (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 1979), 8–12 Google Scholar. For McLuhan's perspective on the relationship between religion and media, see McLuhan, Marshall, The Medium and the Light: Reflections on Religion (Toronto: Stoddart, 1999)Google Scholar.

49. Wuthnow, The Restructuring of American Religion, 195–97.

50. Bruce, Pray TV, 41, 43.

51. Postman, Neil, Amusing Ourselves to Death: Public Discourse in the Age of Show Business (New York: Penguin, 2005 [1985]), 118 Google Scholar.

52. Wuthnow, Robert, “The Social Significance of Religious Television,” Review of Religious Research 29 (December 1987): 134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar