Published online by Cambridge University Press: 12 September 2019
The study considers the economics of the oil palm (Elaeis guinensis) to rural farmers in a rural community in south-eastern Nigeria. It compares the economic benefits of all products of the oil palm industry – palm oil, palm kernel, timber, palm wine and brooms. It posits that the most important product of the oil palm to the Enugu Ezike farmer is oil palm wine. This contrasts with the view that holds palm oil and palm kernel as the chief products of the oil palm. In a study conducted in Enugu Ezike, findings reveal that annual revenue from palm wine surpasses the six-yearly income from palm oil, palm kernel and brooms together. The study employs an eclectic framework of data collection, involving oral interviews, focus group discussions, participant observation, and the use of secondary sources. The oil palm is by every standard the most economically important tree crop and proceeds from it have positively influenced the socio-economic life of the rural communities, and as a result it has improved their living conditions.
1 Orewa, S. I., ‘Designing agricultural development projects for the small scale farmers: some lessons from the World Bank Assistance Small Holder Oil Palm Development Scheme in Nigeria’, Journal of Applied Sciences, 8 (2008), 295–301CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
2 Iloeje, N. P., A New Geography of Nigeria (Norwich, 1965), p. 145Google Scholar.
3 Miller, W., An Economic Analysis of Oil Palm Fruit Processing in Eastern Nigeria (High Wycombe, England, 1965), pp. 10–11Google Scholar.
4 B. N. Ukaegbu, ‘Production in the Nigerian Oil Palm Industry, 1900–1954’ (PhD thesis, University of London, 1974), pp. 31–6, cited in C. J. Korieh, ‘The invisible farmer? Women, gender, and colonial agricultural policy in the Igbo region of Nigeria, c. 1913–1954’, African Economic History, 29 (2001), 117–62.
5 The risky jobs of climbing the palms and cutting down palm fruits were performed by men, but the dissecting, picking of nuts, and processing into oil, as well as cracking the nuts for kernel, were carried out by women.
6 S. E. N. Anyanwu, ‘The Igbo Family Life and Cultural Change’ (PhD thesis, Phillipps-Universitat, Marburg, Germany, 1976), p. 200, cited in Korieh, ‘The invisible farmer’, 117–62. Interview with Eze Okpube, Umuagama, Enugu Ezike, 10th April 2013. The oil press was not welcomed for obvious reasons. See Kaniki, M., ‘Economical technology against technical efficiency in the oil palm industry of West Africa’, Development and Change, 2 (April 1980), 273–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
7 Interview with Ekere Eze, Aji, Enugu Ezike, 12th March 2017.
8 Interview with Ngozi Ogbu, Umuagama, Enugu-Ezike, 13th March 2017. This is also evident in other parts of Igboland as expressed in C. J. Korieh, ‘The invisible farmer?’. Despite the paucity of these presses where they were established, there were protests against the installations by women who felt cheated in the production process and remuneration.
9 Usoro, E. J., The Nigeria Oil Palm Industry (Ibadan, 1974), p. 8Google Scholar.
10 Martin, A., The Oil Palm Economy of the Ibibio Farmer (Ibadan, 1956)Google Scholar.
11 Mbagwu, T. C., ‘Trade in the Nsukka Area’, in Ofomata, G. E. K., ed., The Nsukka Environment (Enugu, 1978), p. 246Google Scholar.
12 Basden, G. T., Niger Ibos (London, 1966), p. 407Google Scholar.
13 Osim, E. E., Efem, S. E. and Etta, K. M., ‘The effect of fresh palm wine on human gastric acid secretion’, East African Medical Journal, 68:12 (December 1991), 959–62.Google ScholarPubMed
14 Martin, A., The Oil Palm Economy of the Ibibio Farmer (Ibadan, 1956)Google Scholar.
15 Helleiner, G. K., Peasant Agriculture, Government and Economic Growth in Nigeria (Homewood, IL, 1966)Google Scholar.
16 Lynn, M., ‘The profitability of the early nineteenth-century palm oil trade’, African Economic History, 20 (1992), 77–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
17 The National Archives, Kew, London, FO 2/47, Livingstone to Stanley, 1st October 1866, cited in Lynn, ‘The profitability of the early nineteenth-century palm oil trade’.
18 Basden, G. T., Among the Ibos of Nigeria (1982 edn).Google Scholar
19 Basden, G. T., Niger Ibos (London, 1966), p. 399Google Scholar.
20 Green, M. M., Ibo Village Affairs (London, 1964), p. 33Google Scholar.
21 Basden, Niger Ibos, p. 160.
22 Ibid.
23 T. C. Mbagwu, ‘The Oil Palm Economy in Ngwaland, Eastern Nigeria (PhD thesis, University of Ibadan, Nigeria, 1971), p. 27.
24 Leis, P. E., ‘Palm oil, illicit gin, and the moral order of the Ijaw’, American Anthropologist, 66 (1964), 828–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
25 The use of the term ‘cash crop’ should be discountenanced in rural economies as palm oil, palm kernel and palm wine also served as food crops as well as cash crops because they provided income to the rural farmers. While producing for subsistence, the rural farmers also produced for export or cash.
26 Ofomata, ed., The Nsukka Environment, p. 164.
27 A. A Mbam, ‘The Economics of Oil Palm Production: A Case Study of the Small Scale Oil Palm Processing Sub-sector in Orlu LGA of Imo State’ (unpublished B.Agr project, University of Nigeria, Nsukka, 1988), pp. 1–18.
28 Green, Ibo Village Affairs, p. 35.
29 Miller, An Economic Analysis of Oil Palm Fruit Processing in Eastern Nigeria, p. 3.
30 Small Holder Oil Palm Project, ‘Information Bulletin’, 4:1 (1975), 5.
31 Iloeje, A New Geography of Nigeria, p. 145.
32 Usoro, The Nigeria Oil Palm Industry, p. 3.
33 J. E. Robins, ‘Food and Drink: Palm Oil versus Palm Wine in Colonial Ghana’, Commodities of Empire Working Paper, No. 25 (SOAS, London, 2016), pp. 2–22. See also E. Akyeampong, Drink, Power, and Cultural Change: A Social History of Alcohol in Ghana, c. 1800 to Recent Times (Portsmouth, 1996). In Nigeria, the colonial authorities prohibited the production and consumption of local gins, perhaps to serve as a deterrent for the abuse of the oil palm, via The Illicit Distillation Ordinance. This was subsequently adopted by the postcolonial government. C. J. Korieh, ‘Alcohol and empire: “illicit” gin prohibition and control in colonial Eastern Nigeria’, African Economic History, 31 (2003), 111–34.
34 Palm wine from felled trees (Ekpo) is of low quality and does not attract consumer attention in Enugu Ezike. The Enugu Ezike farmer does not allow his economic resource (the oil palms) to be cut down, except in rare cases, for development reasons. In this case, there are traditional processes for doing that, because they recognise the importance of the tree to the community.
35 Interview with Ezeja Ugwuanyi, Umuagama Enugu Ezike, 5th March 2015.
36 The 2006 census figures were obtained from the National Population Commission, by computing the figures of the various communities in Enugu Ezike.
37 Eze, B., ‘Enugu Ezike from origin’, Nkpozi: Journal of Enugu Ezike History and Culture, 1:1 (1984), 5–7Google Scholar.
38 Afigbo, A. E., Ropes of Sand: Studies in Igbo Society and Culture (Ibadan, 1981), p. 75Google Scholar.
39 Ukaegbu, E. P., Osuaku, S. K. and Okolo, C. C., ‘Suitability assessment of soils supporting oil palm plantations in the coastal plains sand, Imo State Nigeria’, International Journal of Agriculture and Forestry, 5:2 (2015), 113–20Google Scholar.
40 Enwezor, W. O., Udo, E. J. and Sobulo, R. A., ‘Fertility Status and Productivity of the “Acid Sands”’, in Udo, E. J. and Sobulo, R. A., eds, ‘Acid Sands of Southern Nigeria’, SSSN Special Pub. Monograph, 1 (1981), pp. 56–73Google Scholar.
41 World Rainforest Movement, ‘Oil Palm in Africa’, <https://oilpalminafrica.wordpress.com/2010/08/06/oil-palm-in-nigeria/>[15th March 2016]. See also <http://www.fao.org/DOCREP/005/y4355e/y4355e03.htm>; <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/spl/hi/picture_gallery/08/africa_nigerian_palm_oil/html/1.stm>.
42 Okiy Dere, <http://www.nigerianbestforum.com/generaltopics/?p=52105> [15th March 2016).
43 Robins, ‘Food and Drink’.
44 Uzozie, L. C., ‘Agricultural Land Use in Nsukka Area’, in Ofomata, ed., The Nsukka Environment, p. 104Google Scholar.
45 Okereke, O., ‘The traditional system of oil palm wine production in Igbo Eze LGA of Anambra State, Nigeria’, Quarterly Journal of International Agriculture, 21:4 (1982), 250–1Google Scholar.
46 Mbagwu, T. C., ‘Trade in the Nsukka Area’, in Ofomata, ed., The Nsukka Environment, p. 225Google Scholar.
47 A. A. Apeh, ‘The Oil Palm Industry in Enugu Ezike Economy and Society, 1960–1993’ (MA thesis, Department of History, University of Nigeria, Nsukka, 2002), p. 51.
48 Ibid.
49 During festive periods, a bottle of Star larger is sold for $\[{\rm{\rlap{--} N}}\]$250 and Hero, Life, 33 Export beers are sold for $\[{\rm{\rlap{--} N}}\]$200, whereas a litre of palm wine is sold between $\[{\rm{\rlap{--} N}}\]$300 and $\[{\rm{\rlap{--} N}}\]$500, depending on the quality.
50 Wolcot, H. F., The African Beer Gardens of Bulawayo (New Brunswick, 1974), p. 234, cited in Pan, L., Alcohol in Colonial Africa: The Finnish Foundation for Alcohol Studies, vol. 22 (Helsinki & Uppsala, 1975), p. 105Google Scholar.
51 Apeh, A., ‘The 1990s palm wine revolution in Enugu Ezike: a study in a rural Igbo economy’, Unizik Journal of Arts and Humanities, 8 (September 2006).Google Scholar
52 Ugwoke, A., ‘Palm wine industry in Enugu Ezike’, Nkpozi: Journal of Enugu Ezike History and Culture, 1:1 (1984), 11–13Google Scholar.
53 Interview with a group of tappers John Ali, James Ugwudike, Livinus Ogbu, Fred Mama, Bala Ugwuanyi, Afor Umuagama, 10th October 2016.
54 Leis, P. E., ‘Palm oil, illicit gin, and the moral order of the Ijaw’, American Anthropologist, 66 (1964), 828–38CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
55 Gyasi, E. A., ‘Emergence of a new oil palm belt in Ghana’, Tijdschrift voor Econ. en Soc. Geografie, 83:1 (1992), 39–49CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
56 The gallon used in marketing palm wine in Enugu Ezike is the equivalent of five litres.
57 Interview with Celestine Aba, forty years old, palm wine tapper, Umuagama, 14th October 2014. This view was also corroborated by many other tappers interviewed in Amachalla, Uda, and Okata.
58 Interview with Vincent Atta Eeke, forty-five years old, palm wine tapper, Umuagama, 15th October 2014.