Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-g7gxr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-13T02:25:01.423Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Managing Opposition in a Hybrid Regime: Just Russia and Parastatal Opposition

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 January 2017

Luke March
Luke March*
Affiliation:
University of Edinburgh, Scotland.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In this article Luke March explores the Russian authorities’ efforts to “manage democracy” through the creation of “parties of power.” It focuses on the quasi-leftist party Just Russia, one of four parties currentiy represented in the Russian Duma and the only one that represents a “parastatal” opposition (opposition owned and controlled by the state). The history of Just Russia tells us much about the dynamics of what Andrew Wilson has described as Russia's “virtual politics“: the regime must continually organize manageable quasi-opposition parties in order to bolster its democratic credentials and channel real social discontent, yet whenever it does so effectively, it quickly creates a potential political threat that must be neutralized. Just Russia has parallels in other authoritarian party systems, such as Mexico under the Partido Revolucionario Institucional (PRI) or Nigeria under Abacha and Babangida; the main difference in contemporary Russia lies in the remarkable skill with which Russian state actors conjure up and promote ersatz parties. Nevertheless, even in Russia, virtual politics may become real politics in the longer term.

Type
Managing Political Society in Russia
Information
Slavic Review , Volume 68 , Issue 3 , Fall 2009 , pp. 504 - 527
Copyright
Copyright © Association for Slavic, East European, and Eurasian Studies. 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Some early examples of this view are: Diamond, Larry, “Thinking about Hybrid Regimes,” Journal of Democracy 13, no. 2 (April 2002): 21–35 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Levitsky, Steven and Way, Lucan A., “The Rise of Competitive Authoritarianism,” Journal of Democracy 13, no. 2 (April 2002): 51–65 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Gill, Graeme, “A New Turn to Authoritarian Rule in Russia?” Democratization 13, no. 1 (February 2006): 58–77 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

2. For some notable exceptions to the view that Russia is not a democracy, see “Russia Profile Weekly Experts Panel: Russian Presidential Election—Affirming Democracy or Confirming Autocracy?” at www.russiaprofile.org for 7 March 2008 (last accessed 15 May 2009). Sakwa, Richard, ‘“New Cold War’ or Twenty Years’ Crisis? Russia and International Politics,” International Affairs 84, no. 2 (March 2008): 241-67CrossRefGoogle Scholar insists that Russia's democratic potential is still rosier than its bleak international image suggests.

3. An excellent account of recent reforms to the party system can be found in Wilson, Kenneth, “Party-System Development under Putin,” Post-Soviet Affairs 22, no. 4 (October-December 2006): 314-48CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Studies of United Russia and its antecedents before diis volume include Hans Oversloot and Verheul, Ruben, “The Party of Power in Russian Politics,” Acta Political International Journal of Political Science 35, no. 2 (Summer 2000): 123-45Google Scholar; Regina Smyth, “Building State Capacity from the Inside Out: Parties of Power and the Success of the President's Reform Agenda in Russia,” Politics and Society 30, no. 4 (December 2002): 555-78; Zoe Knox, Pete Lentini, and Williams, Brad, “Parties of Power and Russian Politics: A Victory of the State over Civil Society?” Problems of Post-Communism 53, no. 1 (January-February 2006): 3–14 Google Scholar; and Konitzer, Andrew and Wegren, Stephen K, “Federalism and Political Recentralization in the Russian Federation: United Russia as the Party of Power,” Publius 36, no. 4 (Fall 2006): 503-22CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4. A notable exception is Gel'man, Vladimir, “Political Opposition in Russia: A Dying Species?” Post-Soviet Affairs 21, no. 3 (July-September 2005): 226-46CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5. Dahl, Robert Alan, ed., Political Oppositions in Western Democracies (New Haven, 1966)Google Scholar.

6. ‘Just Russia” is preferred to some other translations (e.g., “AJust Russia,” “Russia of Justice“) by analogy to “United Russia” and to others (e.g., “Fair Russia“) because its slogan “social justice” is a recognized, if disputed, left-wing term.

7. Pribylovskii, Vladimir, quoted in Nabi Abdullaev, “New Party Says Kremlin Knows Best,” Moscow Times, 30 October 2006 Google Scholar. Two other analysts holding this view are Boris Kagarlitskii and Boris Makarenko (partly).

8. For examples, see Bovt, Georgy, “A Test-Tube Party,” Russia Profile 4, no. 1 (27 February 2007): 10 Google Scholar; Makarkin, Alexei, “Election Speculations,” Russia Profile 4, no. 8 (3 September 2007): 7–8 Google Scholar. Vitalii Tretiakov and Igor Bunin expressed similar views.

9. Diamond, Larry, “Is the Third Wave Over?” Journal of Democracy 7, no. 3 (July 1996): 20–37 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Diamond, , “Thinking about Hybrid Regimes,” 21–35 Google Scholar.

10. On “feckless pluralism” and “dominant power politics,” see Carothers, Thomas, “The End of die Transition Paradigm,” Journal of Democracy 13, no. 1 (January 2002): 5–21 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. On “electoral audioritarianism,” see Schedler, Andreas, “The Menu of Manipulation,“ Journal of Democracy 13, no. 2 (April 2002): 36–50 CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Schedler, Andreas, “From Electoral Audioritarianism to Democratic Consolidation,” in Crandall, Russell, Paz, Guadalupe, and Roett, Riordan, eds., Mexico's Democracy at Work: Political and Electoral Dynamics (Boulder, Colo., 2004), 9–38 Google Scholar. On “competitive authoritarianism,” see Levitsky and Way, “The Rise of Competitive Authoritarianism.“

11. Diamond, “Is the Third Wave Over?” 25. For die concept of “hegemonic party systems,“ see Sartori, Giovanni, Parties and Party Systems: A Framework for Analysis (Cambridge, Eng., 1976), 230-38Google Scholar.

12. Schedler, , “Menu of Manipulation,” 36–37 Google Scholar.1 prefer the term electoral authoritarian to terms such as managed pluralism because it highlights that elite authority and control rather than pluralism are the driving rationales of the political regime and also embeds Russia widiin a rich comparative literature. This is, however, not at all to assert that an authoritarian Russia is a “USSR-lite” or has no democratic potential.

13. Solinger, Dorothy J., “Ending One-Party Dominance: Korea, Taiwan, Mexico,“ Journal of Democracy 12, no. 1 (January 2001): 31 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

14. Gvosdev, Nikolas K., “Mexico and Russia: Mirror Images?” Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of Post-Soviet Democratization 10, no. 4 (Fall 2002): 493 Google Scholar.

15. Ibid.

16. Giliomee, Hermann and Simkins, Charles, eds., The Awkward Embrace: One-Party Domination and Democracy (Amsterdam, 1999)Google Scholar.

17. For example, see Schedler, “Menu of Manipulation.“

18. Gvosdev, “Mexico and Russia.“

19. The term syncretic hegemony is my own but cf. Giliomee and Simkins, eds., The Awkward Embrace.

20. These parties included the Democratic Korean Party, the Democratic Society Party, and the Korean People's Party. Youngmi Kim, e-mail communication, 6 March 2008.

21. Wuhs, Steve, e-mail communication, 21 February 2008 Google Scholar.

22. Crespo, José Antonio, “Party Competition in Mexico: Evolution and Prospects,” in Middlebrook, Kevin J., ed., Dilemmas of Political Change in Mexico (London, 2003), 57–82 Google Scholar.

23. Egwaikhide, Festus O. and Isumonah, Victor Adefemi, “Nigeria Paralysed: Sociopolitical Life under General Sani Abacha,” Africa Development 26, nos. 3-4 (2001): 219-41Google Scholar.

24. Ihonvbere, Julius O., Nigeria: The Politics of Adjustment and Democracy (New Brunswick, N.J., 1994)Google Scholar.

25. Ionescu, Ghita, The Politics of the European Communist States (London, 1967)Google Scholar.

26. Ryzhkov, Vladimir, cited in Gel'man, Vladimir, “The Transformation of Russia's Party System,” Russian Analytical Digest, no. 19 (17 April 2007): 12–14 Google Scholar.

27. For example, White, Stephen, Russia's New Politics: The Management of a Postcommunist Society (Cambridge, Eng., 2000)Google Scholar, and Colton, Timothy J. and McFaul, Michael, Popular Choice and Managed Democracy: The Russian Elections of 1999 and 2000 (Washington, D.C., 2003)Google Scholar.

28. Wilson, “Party-System Development under Putin“; Oversloot and Verheul, “The Party of Power in Russian Politics“; Smyth, “Building State Capacity from the Inside Out“; Knox, Lentini, and Williams, “Parties of Power and Russian Politics“; and Konitzer and Wegren, “Federalism and Political Recentralization in the Russian Federation.“

29. For example, Knox, Lentini, and Williams, “Parties of Power and Russian Politics.“

30. Hale, Henry E., Why Not Parties in Russia ? Democracy, Federalism and the State (Cambridge, Eng., 2006)Google ScholarPubMed.

31. Sakwa, Richard, Putin: Russia's Choice, 2d ed. (London, 2007), 101-2Google Scholar.

32. Oversloot, Hans and Verheul, Ruben, “Managing Democracy: Political Parties and the State in Russia,“ Journal of Communist Studies and Transition Politics 22, no. 3 (September 2006): 383–405 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

33. Wilson, Andrew, Virtual Politics: Faking Democracy in the Post-Soviet World (New Haven, 2005)Google Scholar. On the concept of virtuality, see also Gaman-Golutvina, Oksana, “Politika: Partii i vlast',” Svobodnaia mysl’ 21, no. 9 (2004): 85–92 Google Scholar.

34. Wilson, , Virtual Politics, 38 Google Scholar.

35. As just one example, Wilson's allegation that communist leader Gennadii Ziuganov took money from “father of perestroika” Aleksandr Iakovlev is scarcely credible (they were political enemies), and its source is anticommunist kompromat. See Wilson, , Virtual Politics, 224 Google Scholar.

36. Ibid., 46.

37. For example, Andrew Wilson, “The Putin Succession” (unpublished paper, 2008).

38. Surkov's statement at “Vstrecha gruppy deputatov ot Rossiiskoi partii ZHIZNI s zamestitelem Rukovoditelia Administratsii Prezidenta Rossiiskoi Federatsii—pomoshchnikom Prezidenta Rossiiskoi Federatsii V. Iu. Surkovym,” at the Web site of Russian Party of Life, www.RPVITA.ru (accessed 22 May 2007; no longer available). This announcement was allegedly not for public consumption, see “Goszakaz na partiiu budushchego,” 16 August 2006, at www.lenta.ru/articles/2006/08/16/surkov/ (last accessed 15 May 2009).

39. “Mironov,Sergei,“Lentapediia, 19 December 2007, at www.lenta.ru/lib/14159448/full.htm (last accessed 15 May 2009). See also www.mironov.info/Publications/6226.html (last accessed 15 May 2009).

40. For more on the Russian Party of Life, see Wilson, , Virtual Politics, 93 Google Scholar.

41. Wilson, , Virtual Politics, 94 Google Scholar. See also Knox, Lentini, and Williams, “Parties of Power and Russian Politics,” and Laura Belin, “Ivan Rybkin: An Insider Falls Out,” RFE/RL special report The Russian Federation Voles 2003-04, at www.rferl.org/specials/russianelection/bio/rybkin.asp (accessed 14 March 2008; no longer available).

42. March, Luke, “The Russian Communist Party in 2000: A Cosmetic Opposition,“ Analysis of Current Events 12, no. 7-8 (December 2000): 15–19 Google Scholar.

43. Nikolaeva, Anna and Rudneva, Elena, “Urok predannosti,” Vedomosti, 29 June 2007, 2 Google Scholar.

44. Hale, , Why Not Parties in Russia? 229 Google ScholarPubMed.

45. Rogozin, Dmitrii, Vragnaroda (Moscow, 2006), 380 Google Scholar.

46. Putevoditel’ po vyboram: Politicheskaia Rossiia-2007 (Moscow, 2007), 211.

47. “Press-vypusk no 656: Sotsializm v Rossii: Vozmozhen li on? I nuzhen li?” at wciom.ru/arkhiv/tematicheskii-arkhiv/item/single/4243.html (last accessed 15 May 2009).

48. Quote from Bovt, Georgy, “Competition from Above,” Russia Profile 4, no. 2 (19 March 2007): 13 Google Scholar. For other discussion, see Buzgalin, Aleksandr, “Pokhorony KPRF okazalis' prezhdevremennym,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 16 March 2007, 3 Google Scholar, and Kiva, Aleksei, “Po modeli ‘suverennoi demokratii,'” Literatumaia gazeta, no. 10 (14-20 March 2007), at www.lgz.ru/archives/html_arch/lgl02007/Polosy/2_l.htm (last accessed 15 May 2009)Google Scholar.

49. Makarkin, Aleksei, vice president of the Center of Political Technologies, interview, Moscow, 16 April 2008 Google Scholar.

50. Markov quoted in Babich, Dmitry, “Another Vote, Same Results,” Russia Profic 4, no. 3 (April 2007): 7–8 Google Scholar.

51. Surkov's statement at “Vstrecha gruppy deputatov.“

52. Sergei Mironov quoted in Dmitrii Vladimirov, “Otkrytie solnechnoi sistemy: Mironov gotov ob“edinit’ vsekh levykh, krome kommunistov,” Rossiiskaiagazeta, 13 April 2007, at www.rg.ru/2007/04/13/mironov.html (last accessed 15 May 2009).

53. Jonas Bernstein, “Russia: Kremlin ‘Parties of Power’ Sweep Regional Ballots,“ 13 March 2007, RFE/RL Web site at www.rferl.org/featuresarticle/2007/03/9ac0ed04- a263-43e3-bc5c-f31176f51c3a.html (last accessed 15 May 2009).

54. See Titkov, Alexei, Party Number Four: Rodina: Whence and Why? (Moscow, 2006)Google Scholar.

55. For an overview of different scenarios, see interview with Aleksei Ziudin, “Novaia 'Zhizn” v polutorapartiinoi sisteme,” at Politkom.ru (accessed 10 September 2006; no longer available).

56. Sakwa, , Putin, 81 Google Scholar.

57. For example, Smirnov, Andrei, “Tatar Treaty Suggests Dissent Inside Kremlin on Regional Policy,” Eurasia Daily Monitor 4, no. 33 (15 February 2007)Google Scholar, at www.jamestown.org/programs/edrn/single/?tx_ttnews[tt_news]=32494&tx_ttnews[backPid]=171&no_cache=l (last accessed 15 May 2009), and “Sergei Mironov-lichnost’ neordinarnaia,“ Vechernaia Moskva, at www.vmdaily.ru/article.php?aid=43665 (last accessed 15 May 2009). Aleksei Makarkin sees the siloviki as fundamentally disinterested in party building and skeptical towards Just Russia. Just Russia originated largely due to Mironov's personal ini dative; he succeeded in persuading Putin and thereby Surkov. Makarkin, interview, Moscow, 16 April 2008.

58. Surkov's statement at “Vstrecha gruppy deputatov.“

59. For example “Vstrecha s Uchastimami Mezhdunarodnogo Diskussionnogo Kluba 'Valdai,'” at www.kremlin.ru/text/appears/2007/09/144011.shtml (last accessed 15 May 2009).

60. “Transcript of Press Conference with the Russian and Foreign Media, 1 February 2007, Round Hall, Kremlin, Moscow,” at www.kremlin.ru (last accessed 15 May 2009).

61. Surkov's statement at “Vstrecha gruppy deputatov.“

62. “Partiinyi peredel,” 15 August 2006, at lenta.ru/articles/2006/08/15/party/ (last accessed 15 May 2009).

63. “'Spravedlivaia Rossiia’ snova stanovit'sia Partiei zhizni,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 11 December 2007, atwww.ng.ru/politics/2007-12-ll/3_esery.html (last accessed 15 May 2009).

64. Kostenko, Natal'ia, “'Spravedlivaia Rossiia’ organizuet molodezhnyi front,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 15 October 2007, at www.ng.ru/politics/2007-10-15/3_esery.html (last accessed 15 May 2009)Google Scholar.

65. Romanov, Igor’, “Partiitsy rvut chlenov profsoiuzov na chasti,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 26 April 2007, at www.ng.ru/printed/77801 (last accessed 15 May 2009)Google Scholar.

66. Riskin, Andrei, “Pod raznymi znamenami na meste shagom marsh,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 12 March 2007, at www.ng.ru/ngregions/2007-03-12/13_region.html (last accessed 15 May 2009)Google Scholar.

67. “A Just Division,” Moscow News, 5 July 2007, at www.mnweekly.ru/politics/ 20070705/55260906.html (last accessed 15 May 2009). Babakov is also former chair of the board of directors of TsKA football club. Lebedev's personal fortune is estimated at $3.6 billion, while another prominent party supporter was Andrei Molchanov, former head of LSR, the largest construction company in northwest Russia, with a personal fortune estimated at $660 million. By 2008, Lebedev had split from Just Russia.

68. Shusharin, Dmitry, “Nationalism Gives Way to Social Promises in Russia,” RIA Novosti, 13 March 2007, at en.rian.ru/analysis/20070313/61934418.html (last accessed 15 May 2009)Google Scholar.

69. Natal'ia Morar', “'Chernaia kassa’ Kremlia,” 10 December 2007, at newtimes.ru/magazine/issue_44/article_7.htm (last accessed 15 May 2009).

70. “Predvybornaia programma: ‘Doverie vo imia budushchego,'” at www.spravedlivo.ru/information/section_ll/section_54 (last accessed 15 May 2009).

71. “Programmnoe zaiavlenie partii ‘Spravedlivaia Rossiia: Rodina/Pensionery/Zhizn,'” at spravedlivo.ru/about/documents/section_371 (accessed 1 March 2008; no longer available); and “Politicheskaia platform partii,” at www.spravedlivo.ru/about/documents/section_599 (accessed 1 March 2008; no longer available).

72. Boris Makarenko and Tatiana Stanovaia, “Sotsializm vmesto sotsial-demokratii,“ at Politkom.ru (accessed 10 March 2007; no longer available).

73. For example, see the interview with Mironov: “My nakhodims'ia v oppozitsii k politicheskomu monopolizmu,” at www.spravedlivo.ru/press/section_326/564.smx (accessed 13 February 2007; no longer available); “Sergei Mironov: Sotsialnyi ideal i sovremmenoi politike,” at www.spravedlivo.ru/press/section_326/1427.smx (accessed 25 February 2008; no longer available); and the party manifesto, at www.spravedlivo.ru/english?action=articles&id+3 (accessed 25 February 2008; no longer available).

74. Ivan Iartsev, “Esery podniali znamia pobedy,” at Politkom.ru (accessed 26 April 2007; no longer available).

75. Wilson, , Virtual Politics, 134 Google Scholar.

76. Data from Russian Central Electoral Commission, at www.cikrf.ru/cikrf/actual/regvibory_110507jsp (last accessed 15 May 2009).

77. For details on the 2007 elections, see Boris Makarenko and Aleksei Makarkin, “Regional'nye vybory-2007: Presentatsiia ‘Spravedlivoi Rossii,'” at Politkom.ru (accessed 12 March 2007; no longer available).

78. Schreck, Carl, “Dirty Tricks Popular in Campaign Battles,” Moscow Times, 9 March 2007, at www.themoscowtimes.com/stories/2007/03/09/011.html (last accessed 15 May 2009)Google Scholar. Chernogorov never recovered his authority after this defeat and resigned in April 2008.

79. Cited in Johnson's Russia List, no. 217 (28 September 2006) atwww.cdi.org/russia/johnson/default.cfm (accessed 25 March 2008; no longer available)

80. Korotkova, Olga, “General'naia repetitsiia vyborov v Gosdumu: Rossiia opiat' polevela,” Komsomolskaia pravda, 13 March 2007, at www.kp.ru/daily/23868.7/64403 (last accessed 15 May 2009)Google Scholar.

81. On the success of 31-year-old communist Roman Grebennikov in Volgograd's mayoral election on 20 May 2007, see “Volgogradskaia bitva,” 21 May 2007, at www.lenta.ru/articles/2007/05/21/red (last accessed 15 May 2009).

82. Ivan Iartsev, “Piterskaia partiia-edinaia i spravedlivaia,” at Politkom.ru (accessed 21 March 2007; no longer available).

83. “Vystuplenie Sergeia Mironova na Tsentral'nom sovete partii ‘Spravedlivaia Rossiia,'“ (12 April 2007) at www.spravedlivo.ru/about/secdon_10/section_297/1805.smx (accessed 14 February 2008; no longer available).

84. Igor’ Dmitriev, “Patriocheskii gambit,” Moskovskie novosti, 6-12 July 2007, at www .mn.ru/issue/2007-26-7 (accessed 19 March 2008; no longer available).

85. Kamakin, Andrei, “Operatsiia 's Novoi Dumoi,'” Itogi, 8 January 2007, at www.itogi.ru/Paper2007.nsf/Article/Itogi_2007_01_06_1534.html (last accessed 15 May 2009)Google Scholar.

86. Tat'iana Stanovaia, “Sud'ba ‘Spravedlivoi Rossii,'” at Politkom.ru (accessed 29 October 2007; no longer available).

87. Veretennikova, Kseniia, “'Ura!’ Tovarishchi,” Vremia novostei, 22 October 2007, at www.vremya.ru/2007/193/4/189654.html (last accessed 15 May 2009)Google Scholar.

88. For example, Aleksei Ziudin, “Ataka na Mironova,” Moskovskie novosti, 26 October- 1 November 2007, at www.mn.ru/issue/2007-42-7 (accesssed 19 March 2008; no longer available); by the end of 2007, Just Russia was only the fifth best-funded party widi assets of $14.98 million, see www.cikrf.ru/politparty/finance/rashod.jsp (last accessed 15 May 2009).

89. For allegations that Just Russia's result was artificially inflated, see Petrov, Nikolai, “The Consequences of the State Duma Elections for Russia's Electoral System,” Russian Analytical Digest, no. 32 (14 December 2007): 5–8 Google Scholar. For Just Russia compared with electoral forecasts, see “The Results of the Duma Elections,” Russian Analytical Digest, no. 32 (14 December 2007): 10.

90. Igor’ Romanov, Ivan Rodin, and Natal'ia Kostenko, “Eseram dali dobro: Novaia Duma skoree vsego okazhetsia chetyrekhpartiinoi,” Nezavisimaia gazeta, 29 November 2007, at www.ng.ru/politics/2007-ll-29/l_esery.html (last accessed 15 May 2009).

91. Ksenia Veretennikova and Andrei Denisov, “Natsproekt ‘Dmitrii Medvedev': Vladimir Putin nazval tret'ego prezidenta Rossii,” Vremia novostei, 11 December 2007, 1-2, at www.vremya.ru/2007/227/4/193865.html (last accessed 15 May 2009).

92. “Partiia regional'noi vlasti,” Kommersant”, 14 March 2008, at www.kommersant.ru/daily.aspx?date=20080304 (last accessed 15 May 2009).

93. Programma Partii “Spravedlivaia Rossiia “at the Just Russia Web site, www.spravedlivo.ru (last accessed 15 May 2009).

94. Especially proposals for an elected Federation Council and the restoration of the pre-2007 Duma electoral system.

95. Demokratiia: RazvitieRossiiskoi modeli (Moscow, 2008), at newtimes.ru/Files/lll/democratic.doc (last accessed 15 May 2009).

96. On Boris Gryzlov and Mironov's friendship, see “Mironov, Sergei,” Lentapediia, 19 December 2007, at www.lenta.ru/lib/14159448/full.htm (last accessed 15 May 2009).