Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-p9bg8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-27T06:10:13.544Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Dirty Politics: Public Employees, Private Contractors, and the Development of Nineteenth-Century Trash Collection in Pittsburgh and New Orleans

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 October 2015

Patricia Strach  and
Kathleen Sullivan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Nineteenth-century Pittsburgh and New Orleans were a mess: trash filled the streets impeding travel, hindering commerce, and spreading disease. City officials in Pittsburgh turned to private contractors to collect trash at public expense while in New Orleans they relied on city employees (through the mechanism of widows carts). Like Pittsburgh and New Orleans, nineteenth-century cities faced a mounting garbage problem and, like Pittsburgh, northern cities more often chose contract while southern cities more often chose city collection. In this paper, we look in depth at how Pittsburgh and New Orleans chose contract and city collection, what those solutions looked like in practice, and how these two cases might shed light on the North-South difference. We find that both cities rebuffed offers of assistance that may have led to better trash collection and instead based their collection practices on politics. Moreover, the solutions in practice defied the dichotomous labels of public and private and the assumptions that underlie each.

Type
Special Section: Public and Private Provision of Urban Public Goods
Information
Social Science History , Volume 39 , Issue 3 , Fall 2015 , pp. 387 - 407
Copyright
Copyright © Social Science History Association, 2015 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Andrews, H. A. (1896) “Atlanta garbage system: Collection and final disposal.” Annals of Hygiene 10 (1): 615–19.Google Scholar
Arensen, Eric (1994) Waterfront Workers of New Orleans: Race, Class and Politics: 1863–1923. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Bauman, John F., and Muller, Edward K. (2006) Before Renaissance: Planning in Pittsburgh, 1889–1943. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.Google Scholar
Bel, Germa, and Fageda, Xavier (2008) “Reforming the local public sector: Economics and politics in privatization of water and solid waste.” Journal of Economic Policy Reform 11 (1): 45–65.Google Scholar
Bel, Germa, and Miralles, Antonio (2003) “Factors influencing the privatization of urban solid waste collection in Spain.” Urban Studies 40 (7): 1323–34.Google Scholar
Chandler, Timothy D., and Feuille, Peter (1994) “Cities, unions, and the privatization of sanitation services.” Journal of Labor Research 15 (1): 53–71.Google Scholar
Chapin, Charles V. (1901) Municipal Sanitation in the United States. Providence, RI: Snow and Farnham.Google Scholar
City of Augusta (1906) Mayor's Message and Official Reports of the Departments of the City of Augusta. Augusta, GA: Press of the Augusta Chronicle Job Office.Google Scholar
City of Charleston (1866) Journal of the Commissioner of Streets and Lamps. Charleston: The Charleston Archive, Charleston Public Library.Google Scholar
City of Charleston (1917) Year Book. Charleston: South Carolina Historical Society.Google Scholar
City of Charleston (1918) Year Book. Charleston: South Carolina Historical Society.Google Scholar
City of Charleston (1920) Year Book. Charleston: South Carolina Historical Society.Google Scholar
City of Charleston (1921) Year Book. Charleston: South Carolina Historical Society.Google Scholar
City of New Orleans (1883) Payroll, Department of Public Works. New Orleans: City Archives, New Orleans Public Library.Google Scholar
City of New Orleans (1892–96) The Committee on Public Health, Reports and Actions. New Orleans: City Archives, New Orleans Public Library.Google Scholar
City of New Orleans (1900) City Records—Carts. New Orleans: City Archives, New Orleans Public Library.Google Scholar
City of Pittsburgh (1887) A Digest of the Acts of Assembly Relating to, and the General Ordinances of the City of Pittsburgh, from 1804 to September 1, 1886. Harrisburg, PA: B. K. Meyers.Google Scholar
City of Pittsburgh (1896) Eighth Annual Report of the Department of Public Safety. Pittsburgh: Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
City of Pittsburgh (1899) Annual Report of the Department of Public Safety. Pittsburgh: Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
City of Pittsburgh (1900) Annual Report of the Department of Public Safety. Pittsburgh: Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
City of Pittsburgh (1912) Pittsburgh Annual Reports. Pittsburgh: Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
City of Pittsburgh (1938) Digest of the General Ordinances and Laws of the City of Pittsburgh to March 1, 1938. Pittsburgh: Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
City of Savannah (1888) The Code of the City of Savannah. Savannah, GA: Savannah Times Publishing.Google Scholar
City of Savannah (1889) Annual Report of Rufus E. Lester, Mayor of the City of Savannah, for the Year Ending December 31, 1888. Savannah, GA: The Morning News Print.Google Scholar
City of Savannah (1890) Annual Report of John Schwarz, Mayor of the City of Savannah, for the Year Ending December 31, 1890. Savannah, GA: The Morning News Print.Google Scholar
City of Savannah (1892) Annual Report of John J. McDonough, Mayor of the City of Savannah, for the Year Ending December 31, 1891. Savannah, GA: The Morning News Print.Google Scholar
City of Savannah (1896) Annual Report of Herman Myers, Mayor of the City of Savannah, for the Year Ending December 31, 1895. Savannah, GA: The Morning News Print.Google Scholar
City of Savannah (1900) Report of the Hon. Herman Myers, Mayor, Together with the Reports of the City Officers of the City of Savannah, Ga., for the Year Ending December 31, 1899. Savannah, GA: M. S. and D. A. Byck.Google Scholar
City of Savannah (1903) City Treasurer. Time Book—Department of Public Works. 1903–1903. Record Series 5600CT-020. Savannah, GA: City of Savannah, Research Library and Municipal Archives.Google Scholar
Civic Club of Allegheny County (1903) “Sanitary complaints.” Civic Club of Allegheny County Records AIS 70:2, Box 39, Folder 40. Pittsburgh: Archives Service Center, University of Pittsburgh.Google Scholar
Civic Club of Allegheny County (1915) The Index: Celebrated Twentieth Anniversary Has Accomplished Much. Civic Club of Allegheny County Records AIS 70:2, Box 28, Folder 7. Pittsburgh: Archives Service Center, University of Pittsburgh.Google Scholar
Clemens, Elisabeth S. (2006) “Lineages of the Rube Goldberg state: Building and blurring public programs, 1900–1940,” in Shapiro, I., Skowronek, S., and Galvin, D. (eds.) Rethinking Political Institutions: The Art of the State. New York: New York University Press: 187–215.Google Scholar
Cohen, William (1976) “Negro involuntary servitude in the south, 1865–1940: A preliminary analysis.” The Journal of Southern History 42 (1): 31–60.Google Scholar
Connerly, Charles (2005) “The Most Segregated City in America”: City Planning and Civil Rights in Birmingham, 1920–1980. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.Google Scholar
Couvares, Francis G. (1984) The Remaking of Pittsburgh: Class and Culture in an Industrializing City. Albany: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
Daily Picayune (1892) “City garbage: The question of its collection and final disposition.” May 30.Google Scholar
Daily Picayune (1893a) “Garbage disposal.” April 21.Google Scholar
Daily Picayune (1893b) “The handling of garbage.” April 21.Google Scholar
Daily Picayune (1894a) “City hall: Get your garbage boxes.” March 4.Google Scholar
Daily Picayune (1894b) “The garbage job and garbage boxes.” March 15.Google Scholar
Daily Picayune (1894c) “A lady's plan to bring about a better system of garbage gathering.” March 10.Google Scholar
Dorr, Rheta Louise Childe (1910) What Eight Million Women Want. Boston: Small, Maynard and Co. Google Scholar
Dubin, Jeffrey A., and Navarro, Peter (1988) “How markets for impure public goods organize: The case of household refuse collection.” Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization 4 (2): 217–41.Google Scholar
Ellis, John (1992) Yellow Fever and Public Health in the New South. Lexington: University of Kentucky Press.Google Scholar
Epstein, Abraham (1918) The Negro Migrant in Pittsburgh. Pittsburgh: National Urban League.Google Scholar
Ettinger, Brian Gary (1985) “John Fitzpatrick and the limits of working-class politics in New Orleans, 1892–1896.” Louisiana History 26 (4): 341–67.Google Scholar
Ferris, James M. (1987) “The decision to contract: An empirical analysis.” Urban Affairs Quarterly 22 (2): 289–311.Google Scholar
Godshalk, David Fort (2005) Veiled Visions: The 1906 Atlanta Race Riot and the Reshaping of American Race Relations. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Haas, Edward (1981) “John Fitzpatrick and political continuity in New Orleans, 1896–1899.” Louisiana History 22 (1): 7–29.Google Scholar
Haider-Markel, Donald P. (2001) “Policy diffusion as a geographical expansion of the scope of political conflict: Same-sex marriage bans in the 1990s.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly 1 (1): 5–26.Google Scholar
Hall, Jacqueline Dowd (1993) Revolt Against Chivalry: Jessie Daniel Ames and the Women's Campaign Against Lynching. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Harris, Carl V. (1972) “Reforms in government control of negroes in Birmingham, Alabama, 1890–1920.” Journal of Southern History 38 (4): 567–600.Google Scholar
Hering, Rudolph (1897) “Report of the committee on the disposal of garbage and refuse.” Public Health Papers and Reports 23: 206–15.Google Scholar
Homaday, W. D. (1915) “Making fuel out of garbage.” Coal Age 8: 668–69.Google Scholar
Hoy, Suellen M. (1995) Chasing Dirt: The American Pursuit of Cleanliness. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Jackson, Joy (1969) New Orleans in the Gilded Age: Politics and Urban Progress, 1880–1896. New Orleans: Louisiana State University Press.Google Scholar
Jacobson, Charles D., and Tarr, Joel A. (1995) “Ownership and financing of infrastructure: Historical perspectives.” Policy Research Working Papers 1466. Washington, DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
Kemper, Peter, and Quigly, John M. (1976) The Economics of Refuse Collection. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.Google Scholar
Kohnke, Quitman (1898) “Disposal of garbage.” Municipal Journal and Public Works 5 (2): 66–67.Google Scholar
La Follette's Weekly Magazine (1909) “Eight million women.” August 28.Google Scholar
Larsen, Lawrence (1969) “Nineteenth-century street sanitation: A study in filth and frustration.” Wisconsin Magazine of History 52 (3): 239–47.Google Scholar
Lewis, W. David (1994) “The emergence of Birmingham as a case study of continuity between the antebellum planter class and industrialization in the ‘New South.’” Agricultural History 68 (2): 62–79.Google Scholar
Martin, Thomas (1902) Atlanta and Its Builders: A Comprehensive History of the Gate City of the South. Atlanta: Century Memorial Publishing.Google Scholar
McDavid, James C., and Mueller, Annette E. (2008) “A cross-Canada analysis of the efficiency of residential recycling services.” Canadian Public Administration 51 (4): 589–615.Google Scholar
Melosi, Martin V. (2005) Garbage in the Cities: Refuse, Reform, and the Environment. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.Google Scholar
Mintrom, Michael (1997) “Policy entrepreneurs and the diffusion of innovation.” American Journal of Political Science 41 (3): 738–80.Google Scholar
Mintrom, Michael, and Vergari, Sandra (1998) “Policy networks and innovation diffusion: The case of state education reforms.” Journal of Politics 60 (1): 126–48.Google Scholar
Mooney, Christopher Z., and Lee, Mei-Hsien (1995) “Legislating morality in the American states: The Case of pre-Roe abortion regulation reform.” American Journal of Political Science 39 (3): 599–627.Google Scholar
Mooney, Christopher Z., and Lee, Mei-Hsien (1999) “The temporal diffusion of morality policy: The case of death penalty legislation in the American states.” Policy Studies Journal 27 (4): 766–80.Google Scholar
Municipal Engineering 14 (1898) “Garbage disposal.” December–June.Google Scholar
Nelson, Michael A. (1997) “Municipal government approaches to service delivery: An analysis from a transactions cost perspective.” Economic Inquiry 35 (1): 82–96.Google Scholar
New Orleans Times Democrat (1893) “Garbage removal.” April 13.Google Scholar
New York Bureau of Municipal Research (1913) The City of Pittsburgh: Report on a Survey of the Department of Public Health. Prepared for the City Council. Historic Pittsburgh Full-Text Collection. New York: New York Bureau of Municipal Research.Google Scholar
“Notes on municipal government” (1897) Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 9 (2): 152–62.Google Scholar
Novak, William (1996) The People's Welfare: The History of Public Poor Relief in Nineteenth-Century America. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.Google Scholar
Osborn, Irwin (1912) “Disposal of garbage by the disposal method.” American Journal of Public Health 2 (12): 937–42.Google Scholar
Perry, James L., and Rainey, Hal G. (1988) “The public-private distinction in organization theory: A critique and research strategy.” Academy of Management Review 13 (2): 182–201.Google Scholar
Pittsburgh Post (1880a) “Sanitarians’ council.” May 1.Google Scholar
Pittsburgh Post (1880b) “The south side scourge.” April 5.Google Scholar
Pittsburgh Post (1895a) “Questions of sanitation.” January 3.Google Scholar
Pittsburgh Post (1895b) “Taxpayers growling.” January 2.Google Scholar
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (1931) “Garbage bids hearing today.” July 15.Google Scholar
Rabinowitz, Howard (1994) Race, Ethnicity, and Urbanization. Columbia: University of Missouri Press.Google Scholar
“Refuse collection in New Orleans” (1922) Public Works 52 (23): 419–20.Google Scholar
Report of the Health Officer of the District of Columbia (1896) Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
Savas, E. E. (1977) “An empirical study of compeitition in municipal service delivery.” Public Administration Review 37 (6): 717–24.Google Scholar
Schultz, Stanley K., and McShane, Clay (1978) “To engineer the metropolis: Sewers, sanitation, and city planning in late-nineteenth-century America.” The Journal of American History 65 (2): 389–411.Google Scholar
Shipan, Charles R., and Volden, Craig (2008) “The mechanisms of policy diffusion.” American Journal of Political Science 52 (4): 840–57.Google Scholar
Soloway, Stan, and Chvotkin, Alan (2009) “Federal contracting in context: What drives it, how to improve it,” in Freeman, J. and Minow, M. (eds.) Government by Contract: Outsourcing in American Democracy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Soper, George Albert (1909) Modern Methods of Street Cleaning. New York: The Engineering News Publishing Company.Google Scholar
Spann, Robert M. (1977) “Public versus private provision of governmental services?,” in Borcherding, T. (ed.) Budgets and Bureaucrats: The Sources of Government Growth. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
Steffens, Lincoln (1957 [1904]) The Shame of the Cities. New York: Sagamore Press.Google Scholar
Thompson, Hugh Miller (1880) “Method introduced by the Auxilary Sanitary Association for disposing of the garbage in New Orleans.” Public Health Reports and Papers Presented at the Meetings of the American Public Health Association in the Year 1879. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin.Google Scholar
Troesken, Werner (1999) “Typhoid rates and the public acquisition of private waterworks, 1880–1920.” Journal of Economic History 59 (4): 927–48.Google Scholar
United States Works Progress Administration (1939) Works Progress Administration Project 665–64–3–112. Biographies of the Mayors of New Orleans. New Orleans: City Archives, New Orleans Public Library.Google Scholar
Walker, Jack L. (1969) “The diffusion of innovations among the American states.” The American Political Science Review 63 (3): 880–99.Google Scholar
Walls, Margaret, Macauley, Molly, and Anderson, Soren (2005) “Private markets, contracts, and government provision: What explains the organization of local waste and recycling markets?” Urban Affairs Review 40 (5): 500–613.Google Scholar
Waring, George E. (1887) Report on the Social Statistics of Cities. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.Google Scholar
Woodward, William (1901) “Refuse disposal in the District of Columbia.” Public Health Papers and Reports 27: 194–203.Google ScholarPubMed
Young, Dennis (1972) How Shall We Collect the Garbage? Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.Google Scholar
Zimring, Carl A. (2009) Cash for Your Trash: Scrap Recycling in America. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar