Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-94fs2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-10T07:15:03.495Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Counting the carnivores: Who ate meat in Republican-Era China?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 October 2022

Thomas David DuBois Open the ORCID record for Thomas David DuBois [Opens in a new window]
Thomas David DuBois*
Affiliation:
School of Chinese Language and Literature, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China
*
Email: thomas_dubois@yahoo.com, https://bnu.academia.edu/ThomasDavidDuBois
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

It is commonly asserted that Chinese diets before the market and production reforms of the 1980s contained little or no meat. Yet this nearly universal assumption remains untested: Unlike other forms of material consumption, the question of meat in Chinese diets has received almost no systematic attention from historians. Focusing on the early twentieth century, this article examines who in China ate meat, and how meat consumption was shaped by regional and household patterns. It combines insights from three sorts of data. First, Japanese price surveys from the 1920s show a high degree of variation in the preference for one type of meat over others, and the price availability of meat versus wages or other food products. Second, production data, including slaughterhouse tallies and industry estimates of animal by-products show the seasonality of animal slaughter and the vast scale and dispersed geography of China’s livestock production. Finally, nutrition and diet studies from the 1920 to the late 1940s examine actual household consumption, emphasizing how social forces and cyclical fortunes shaped individual choices. The composite picture from these three perspectives confirms that China’s meat consumption was hardly inconsequential. But more than simply triangulating a result, the exercise of comparing perspectives of price, production, and nutrition also highlights the collection of survey data as a series of historical moments.

Keywords

Chinameatpricesstockbreedingdietary surveyshistorical diets
Type
Research Article
Information
Social Science History , Volume 46 , Issue 4 , Winter 2022 , pp. 751 - 775
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Social Science History Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Archival sources

Chen, Leqing (1939) Chen Leqing chengsong zhitong shuoming shu [Chen Leqing’s memorial for planting tong trees]. Archival file: AS 28-03-03-028-05.Google Scholar
Shiyebu, Yumusi (1933–1934) [Fisheries and Husbandry Section of the Department of Industry] Xumu tuzai liang diaocha [Investigation of animal slaughter]. Archival file: AS 17-27-195-04.Google Scholar
JACAR (1910–1920) Nichijō seikatsuhin kakaku chōsa [Investigations of Prices of Daily Use Items]. Archival file: JACAR B11090351600.Google Scholar
JACAR (1920–1921) Shina ni okeru bukka, toku ni beika tōki ni kan suru [Prices in China, especially concerning inflation of rice prices]. Archival file: JACAR B11090356200.Google Scholar
JACAR (1923) Nyūseihin ni kan suru chōsa [Investigation of dairy products]. Archival file: JACAR B11092082800.Google Scholar
Chen, Leqing (1939) Chen Leqing chengsong zhitong shuoming shu [Chen Leqing’s memorial for planting tong trees]. Archival file: AS 28-03-03-028-05.Google Scholar
Shiyebu, Yumusi (1933–1934) [Fisheries and Husbandry Section of the Department of Industry] Xumu tuzai liang diaocha [Investigation of animal slaughter]. Archival file: AS 17-27-195-04.Google Scholar
JACAR (1910–1920) Nichijō seikatsuhin kakaku chōsa [Investigations of Prices of Daily Use Items]. Archival file: JACAR B11090351600.Google Scholar
JACAR (1920–1921) Shina ni okeru bukka, toku ni beika tōki ni kan suru [Prices in China, especially concerning inflation of rice prices]. Archival file: JACAR B11090356200.Google Scholar
JACAR (1923) Nyūseihin ni kan suru chōsa [Investigation of dairy products]. Archival file: JACAR B11092082800.Google Scholar

References

Adolph, William Henry (1925) “A study of North China dietaries.” Journal of Home Economics 17 (1): 1–7.Google Scholar
Allen, Robert, Bassino, Jean-Pascal, Ma, Debin, Moll-Murata, Christine, and Zanden, Jan (2011) “Wages, prices, and living standards in China, 1738–1925: In comparison with Europe, Japan, and India.” Economic History Review (64): 8–38.Google Scholar
Bramall, Chris (2011) “Agency and famine in China’s Sichuan Province, 1958-1962.” China Quarterly (208): 990–1008.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Braudel, Fernand (1981) Civilization and Capitalism 15th-18th Century. Vol. 1: The Structures of Everyday Life: The Limits of the Possible. New York: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
Bray, Francesca (1984) Science and Civilisation in China, Vol. 6, Biology and Biological Technology, Part 2: Agriculture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Buck, John Lossing (1937) Land Utilization in China: A Study of 16,786 Farms in 168 Localities, and 38,256 Farm Families in Twenty-two Provinces in China, 1929-1933. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Chayanov, A.V., Thorner, D., Kerblay, B., and Smith, R.E.F. (1986) A.V. Chayanov on the Theory of Peasant Economy. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Cheung, Sui-wai (2008) The Price of Rice: Market Integration in Eighteenth-Century China. Bellingham, WA: Western Washington University Press.Google Scholar
China Bureau of Foreign Trade, Ministry of Industry (1927a) “Currency Situation in Manchuria.” Chinese Economic Journal 1 (5): 491–99.Google Scholar
China Bureau of Foreign Trade, Ministry of Industry (1927b) “Retail Prices in Peking.” Chinese Economic Journal 1 (4): 313–19.Google Scholar
China Bureau of Foreign Trade, Ministry of Industry (1927c) “Study of the Sugar Industry in China.” Chinese Economic Journal 1 (9): 866–83.Google Scholar
China Haiguan zongshuiwu sishu (1937) Shanghai Annual Returns of Trade, 1936. Shanghai: Statistical Dept. of the Inspectorate General of Customs.Google Scholar
Chuan, Han-sheng, and Kraus, Richard A. (1975) Mid-Ch’ing Rice Markets and Trade: An Essay in Price History. Cambridge: Harvard University East Asian Monographs.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clark, James Hyde (1894) Story of China and Japan: Embracing their Geographical Positions, Enormous Resources, Wealth, Emperors and Courts, Governments and People, Manners and Customs, How the People of these Great Nations Live and Die and Maintain in Oriental Splendor the China and Japan of To-Day, Together with a Sketch of Corea, and the Coreans, and Causes Leading to the Conflict Of 1894. Philadelphia: Oriental Publication Co.Google Scholar
Cressey, George Babcock (1934) China’s Geographic Foundations: A Survey of the Land and its People. New York and London: McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc.Google Scholar
Critchell, James Troubridge, and Raymond, Joseph (1912) History of the Frozen Meat Trade. London: Constable & Co.Google Scholar
Dikötter, Frank (2010) Mao’s Great Famine: The History of China’s Most Devastating Catastrophe, 1958-1962. New York and London: Bloomsbury.Google Scholar
Doeppers, Daniel F. (2016) Feeding Manila in Peace and War, 1850-1945. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Du, Bosi [Thomas David DuBois] (2021) “Cong zhongjie shijiao lijie Zhongguo he Ouzhou de jianiu maoyi tixi” [Understanding Chinese and European cattle trade from the perspective of intermediation]. Shijie lishi pinglun (3): 269–85.Google Scholar
DuBois, Thomas David (2019a) “Many roads from pasture to plate: A commodity chain approach to China’s beef trade, 1732-1931.” Journal of Global History 14 (1): 22–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
DuBois, Thomas David (2019b) “Branding and retail strategy in the condensed milk trade: Borden and Nestlé in East Asia, 1870–1929.” Business History, doi: 10.1080/00076791.2019.1688302.Google Scholar
DuBois, Thomas David (2021a) “China slaughterhouse statistics 1933-1934.” Harvard Dataverse, V1, UNF:6:E+SGydOVbA8dJPB1q/DwMw== [fileUNF], https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/OCUCTU.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
DuBois, Thomas David (2021b) “China price data, 1910-1920.” Harvard Dataverse, V1, UNF:6:tPtt92VvlhoxEbU5tLoMtQ== [fileUNF], https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/XSRAY9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
DuBois, Thomas David (2021c) “China livestock populations late 1930s.” Harvard Dataverse, V1, UNF:6:EsB9maJ0PDwkun+EQVbuKw== [fileUNF], https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/QX1RPK.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
DuBois, Thomas David, and Gao, Alicia (2017) “Big meat: The rise and impact of mega-farming in China’s beef, sheep and dairy industries.” Asia-Pacific Journal/Japan Focus 15 (17) 1: 1–20.Google Scholar
Faure, David (2019) “They went to the people but did they hear them? Comments on field research in China in the 1920s and 1930s,” in Kiely, Jan, and DuBois, Thomas David (eds.) Fieldwork in Modern Chinese History: A Research Guide. New York: Routledge: 3–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fu, Jia-chen (2012) “Scientising relief: Nutritional activism from Shanghai to the Southwest, 1937–1945.” European Journal of East Asian Studies 11 (2): 259–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fu, Wangxin, Shangqiu, Chen (1946) “Junyi xuesheng shanshi diaocha’” [Investigation of military school student diets]. Zhongguo yingyangxue zazhi 1 (11): 11–19.Google Scholar
Gamsa, Marc (2006) “The epidemic of pneumonic plague in Manchuria 1910-1911.” Past & Present (190): 147–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gazeley, Ian, and Newell, Andrew (2013) “The First World War and working-class food consumption in Britain.” European Review of Economic History 17 (1): 71–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goossaert, Vincent (2005) L’interdit du Boeuf en Chine: Agriculture, Éthique et Sacrifice. Paris: Collège de France, Institut des Hautes Etudes Chinoises.Google Scholar
Griffin, Emma (2018) “Diets, hunger and living standards during the British Industrial Revolution.” Past & Present (239): 71–111.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grove, Linda (2019) “A brief history of Japanese field research on China,” in Kiely, Jan and DuBois, Thomas David (eds.) Fieldwork in Modern Chinese History: A Research Guide. New York: Routledge: 22–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hu, Cheng (2010) “Quarantine sovereignty during the pneumonic plague in Northeast China (November 1910-April 1911).” Frontiers of History in China 5 (2): 294–339.Google Scholar
Ikeda, Yoshinaga (1940) Shina Ni Okeru Jūyō Chikusan Shigen No Bunpu Ni Kansuru Chōsa [Investigation of the Distribution of Important Livestock Resources in China]. Tokyo: Tōa Kenkyūjo.Google Scholar
Institute of Pacific Relations, American Council (1933) Memorandum on Japanese Rice Control, Memorandum 2 (18): 3024721.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ito, Mikio, Maeda, Kiyotaka, and Noda, Akihiko (2017) “Market integration in the prewar Japanese rice markets.” Unpublished working paper, Keio University, Japan, www.arxiv.org/pdf/1604.00148.pdf.Google Scholar
Jin, Daxun, and Wang, Chengfa (1949) “Sichuan sheng Bishanxian Dingjiaxiang nongmin shanshi diaocha” [Peasant diets in Dingjia Township, Bishan county Sichuan]. Zhonghua yixue zazhi 35 (5): 191–206.Google Scholar
Jing, Libin, and Hou, Yuqing (1941) “Kunming shanshi zhi diaocha” [Investigation of diets in Kunming]. Kexue 25 (1/2): 33–37.Google Scholar
Kuo, Chung-hao (2013) “Pigs, Pork, and Ham: The Practice of Pig Farming and Consumption of Pork in Ming-Qing China.” PhD diss., New York University.Google Scholar
Lee, Seung-joon (2011) Gourmets in the Land of Famine: The Culture and Politics of Rice in Modern Canton. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Levine, C.O. (1920) “Sheep, swine and goats in the Orient.” Journal of Heredity 11 (3): 117–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Li, Lilian M. (2000) “Integration and disintegration in North China’s grain markets, 1738-1911.” Journal of Economic History 60 (3): 665–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Liu, Qinli, and Du, Bosi [Thomas David DuBois] (2022) “Minguo shiqi niufanzi de shangye fengsu yu maoyi wangluo” [Cattle trade customs and commercial networks in the Republican period: An experiment in wide-scale interview outsourcing]. Minsu yanjiu (2): 24–34.Google Scholar
Maddison, Angus (2007) Chinese Economic Performance in the Long Run: 960-2030 AD. Paris: OECD.Google Scholar
Meng, Ku (2019 [1187]) Dongjing menghua lu [Dream Journey through the Eastern Hua Capital]. Beijing: Zhongguo shudian.Google Scholar
Meng, T’ien-p’ei, and Gamble, Sidney D. (1926) Prices, Wages and the Standard of Living in Peking, 1900-1924. Peking: Peking Express Press.Google Scholar
Milman, Oliver, and Leavenworth, Stuart (2016) “China’s plan to cut meat consumption by 50% cheered by climate campaigners.” Guardian, June 20.Google Scholar
Nevis, John L. (1882) China and the Chinese, a General Description of the Country and its Inhabitants; its Civilization and Form of Government; its Religious and Social Institutions; its Intercourse with Other Nations; and its Present Condition and Prospects. Philadelphia: Presbyterian Board of Publication.Google Scholar
Ninomiya, Yuzuru (1932) Bei-Hi kan jiyū tsūshō bōeki mondai to Hirippin Guntō kokusai bōeki no sūsei ni suite [Problem of US-Philippines free trade and the direction of commerce in the Philippine archipelago]. Yokohama: Yokohama Specie Bank.Google Scholar
OECD (2021) Meat consumption (indicator), https://doi.org/10.1787/fa290fd0-en.Google Scholar
Ogasawara, Kota, Inoue, Tatsuki, and Nagaya, Ryo (2016) “Nutrition and diseases in the low-income households in Tokyo in 1930.” Tokyo Institute of Technology, Department of Industrial Engineering and Economics Working Paper No. 2016-3.Google Scholar
Perkins, Dwight H. (1969) Agricultural Development in China, 1368-1968. Chicago: Aldine Publishing.Google Scholar
Ruddle, Kenneth, and Zhong, Gongfu (1988) Integrated Agriculture-Aquaculture in South China: The Dike-Pond System of the Zhujiang Delta. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Schneider, Mindi (2014) “Developing the meat grab.” Journal of Peasant Studies 41 (4): 613–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schneider, Mindi, and Sharma, Shefali (2014) “China’s Pork Miracle? Agribusiness and Development in China’s Pork Industry.” Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy. www.iatp.org/documents/chinas-pork-miracle-agribusiness-and-development-chinas-pork-industry Google Scholar
Shen, Yanzhen (1937) “Zhongguo shanshi de yige diaocha” [Investigation of Chinese diets]. Xin yiyao zazhi, 5 (2): 70–77.Google Scholar
Simoons, Frederick J. (1991) Food in China: A Cultural and Historical Inquiry. Boca Raton: CRC Press.Google Scholar
Swislocki, Marc (2008) Culinary Nostalgia: Regional Food Culture and the Urban Experience in Shanghai. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Swislocki, Marc (2011) “Nutritional governmentality: Food and the politics of health in late Imperial and Republican China.” Radical History Review (110): 9–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Taussig, Stefan, and Moskovits, István (1939) World Production in Meat. Rome: Carlo Columbo.Google Scholar
Tawney, R. H. (1966) Land and Labor in China. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
Wang, Chengfa, Liao, Suqin, and Huang, Weijin (1948) “Zhanshi xuesheng yingyang zhuangkuang zhi yanjiu (Chongqing zhongxuesheng shanshi zhi diaocha)” [Research into the state of student nutrition during wartime (Investigation of Chongqing middle school diets)]. Zhonghua yixue zazhi 34 (10): 14–20.Google Scholar
Wang, Chengfa, Lin, Guohao, and Jin, Daxun (1943) “Zhanshi gongwuyuan shanshi diaocha” [Clerical workers” diets during wartime]. Shiyan weisheng jikan 1 (3–4): 25–31.Google Scholar
Wang, Chengfa, and Sun, Yanming (1944) “Zhanshi gaozhongji jiating shanshi diaocha chubu baogao” [Preliminary report on investigation of upper- and middle-class household diets during wartime]. Kexue 27 (3): 12–19.Google Scholar
Wang, Shixiong (2022 [1861]) Suixiju yinshi pu [Suixiju book of food and drink]. Beijing: Zhongguo zhongyiyao chubanshe.Google Scholar
Wang, Xin, and Chen, Shangqiu (1946) “Junyi xuesheng shanshi diaocha” [Investigation of military school student diets]. Zhongguo yingyangxue zazhi 1 (11): 11–19.Google Scholar
Wang, Youzhu (1947) “Sichuan Lizhuang renmin zhi shanshi diaocha” [Investigation of diets in Li village, Sichuan]. Zhongguo yingyangxue zazhi 2 (1): 21–31.Google Scholar
Watson, James L. (2014) “Meat: A cultural biography in (South) China,” In Klein, J. A. and Murcott, A. (eds.) Food Consumption in Global Perspective - Essays in the Anthropology of Food in Honour of Jack Goody. London: Palgrave Macmillan: 25–44.Google Scholar
Wu, Jen-shu (2018) “Dongporou de xingchen yu liuyan chutan” [Preliminary study of the origin and spread of Dongpo pork]. Journal of Chinese Dietary Culture 14 (1): 13–56.Google Scholar
Yu, Xiaohua, and Abler, David (2014) “Where have all the pigs gone? Inconsistencies in pork statistics in China.” China Economic Review (30): 469–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yuan, Mei (2015 [1792]) Suiyuan shidan [Gastronomy of the Sui Garden]. Nanjing: Jiangsu fenghuang wenyi chubanshe.Google Scholar
Zhang, Haifeng, Wang, Jun, and Martin, Wayne (2018) “Factors affecting households’ meat purchase and future meat consumption changes in China: A demand system approach.” Journal of Ethnic Foods 5 (1): 24–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zhang, Shaodan (2021) “Cattle slaughter industry in Qing China: State ban Muslim dominance and the western diet.” Frontiers of History in China 16 (1): 4–38.Google Scholar
Zhao, Shiying (1991 [1721]) Beijing Niujie zhi shu ‘Gang zhi’ [Gazetteer of the Beijing Cow Street ‘Gang zhi’]. Beijing: Xinhua.Google Scholar
Zheng, Ji (1940) “Xuesheng shanshi yanjiu (1): Chengdu zhongji xuesheng xiaji shanshi diaocha” [Research on student diets (1): Investigation of Chengdu middle school student summer season diet]. Kexue 24 (10): 742–47.Google Scholar
Zheng, Ji, and Gu, Xueqi (1940) “Songpan zhongdeng Han Hui ren shanshi zhi diaocha” [Diets of middle class Han and Hui in Songpan]. Kexue 24 (2): 110–16.Google Scholar
Zheng, Ji, Tao, Hong, and Zhu, Zhanggeng (1935) “Nanjing dongji shanshi diaocha” [Investigations of Nanjing winter diets]. Kexue 1 (9): 1753–58.Google Scholar
Zhongguo jumin shanshi zhinan [Chinese dietary guidelines] (2016) Guanyu “zhongguo jumin pingheng shanshi baota (2016)” guanfang banben [Concerning the official publication of the “Chinese people’s average diet pagoda, 2016”]. May 18, dg.cnsoc.org/article/04/8a2389fd54b964c80154c1d781d90197.html.Google Scholar
Zhou, Xiwu (1968 [1920]) Yushu diaocha ji [Record of a Survey of Yushu]. Taibei: Chengwen chubanshe.Google Scholar
Zhu, Zhenjun (1934) “Shanghai ren zhi shanshi” [Diets of Shanghai residents]. Kexue 18 (9): 1174–92.Google Scholar
Supplementary material: PDF

DuBois supplementary material

DuBois supplementary material

Download DuBois supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 141.1 KB