Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-b95js Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-02-04T00:40:08.614Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Comparison of Unilateral and Bilateral ECT: Evidence for Selective Memory Impairment

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 January 2018

Delee Fromm-Auch
Delee Fromm-Auch*
Affiliation:
Alberta Hospital, Box 307, Edmonton, Alberta, T5J 2J7, Canada
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Summary

Review of studies from the past 16 years employing quantitative measurement of memory functions before and after ECT revealed the following trends: impairment of non-verbal memory functions after less than five unilateral non-dominant ECTs; improvement of non-verbal memory functions after five or more unilateral non-dominant ECTs; no change or improvement of verbal memory functions with unilateral non-dominant ECT; consistent impairment of verbal functions with unilateral dominant ECT, and impairment of both verbal and nonverbal functions with bilateral ECT. The relative lack of impairment in memory functions with unilateral non-dominant ECT is consistent with the theory of asymmetrical hemispheric disorganization in affective disorders, and supports the choice of unilateral non-dominant ECT over bilateral or unilateral dominant ECT in the treatment of depression.

Type
Research Article
Information
The British Journal of Psychiatry , Volume 141 , Issue 6 , December 1982 , pp. 608 - 613
Copyright
Copyright © Royal College of Psychiatrists, 1982 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Annett, M., Hudson, P. T. & Turner, A. (1974) Effects of right and left unilateral ECT in naming and visual discrimination analyzed in relation to handedness. British Journal of Psychiatry, 124, 260–4.Google Scholar
Baron, M. (1981) Genetic models of sex effect in unipolar affective illness. Acta Psychiatric Scandanavica, 64, 85–91.Google Scholar
Berent, S., Cohen, R. & Silverman, A. (1975) Changes in verbal and nonverbal learning following a single left or right unilateral electroconvulsive treatment. Biological Psychiatry, 10, 95–100.Google Scholar
Bidder, T. G., Strain, J. J. & Brunschwig, L. (1970) Bilateral and unilateral ECT: Follow-up study and critique. American Journal of Psychiatry, 127, 37–45.Google Scholar
Cannicott, S. M. & Waggoner, R. W. (1967) Unilateral and bilateral electroconvulsive therapy. Archives of General Psychiatry, 16, 229–32.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Cohen, B., Noblin, C. & Silverman, A. (1968) Functional asymmetry of the human brain. Science, 162, 475–7.Google Scholar
Costello, C. G., Belton, G. P., Abra, J. C. & Dunn, B. E. (1970) The amnestic and therapeutic effects of bilateral and unilateral ECT. British Journal of Psychiatry, 116, 69–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cronin, D., Bodley, P., Potts, L., Mather, M., Gradner, R. & Tobin, J. (1970) Unilateral and bilateral ECT: A study of memory disturbance and relief from depression. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 33, 705–13.Google Scholar
d'Elia, G. & Raotma, H. (1975) Is unilateral ECT less effective than bilateral ECT? British Journal of Psychiatry, 126, 83–9.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
d'Elia, G. Lorentzon, S., Raotma, H. & Widepalm, K. (1976) Comparison of unilateral dominant and non-dominant ECT on verbal and non-verbal memory. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 53, 85–94.Google Scholar
Dimond, S. J., Farrington, L. & Johnson, P. (1976) Differing emotional responses from right and left hemispheres. Nature, 261, 690–2.Google Scholar
Dornbush, R., Abrams, R. & Fink, M. (1971) Memory changes after unilateral and bilateral convulsive therapy (ECT). British Journal of Psychiatry, 119, 75–8.Google Scholar
Fink, M. (1974) Induced seizures and human behavior. In Psychobiology of Convulsive Therapy (eds. Fink, M., Kety, S. et al). Washington, D.C.: V. H. Winston.Google Scholar
Fleminger, J. J., Horne del Nair, N. P. & Nott, P. N. (1970) Differential effect of unilateral and bilateral ECT. American Journal of Psychiatry, 127, 430–6.Google Scholar
Flor-Henry, P. (1973) Psychiatric syndromes considered as manifestations of lateralized temporal-limbic dysfunction. In Surgical Approaches in Psychiatry (eds. Laitinen, L. V. and Livingston, K. E.). Lancaster: Medical and Technical Publishing.Google Scholar
Flor-Henry, P. (1976) Lateralized temporal-limbic dysfunction and psychopathology. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 280, 777–95.Google Scholar
Flor-Henry, P. (1978a) Gender, hemispheric specialization and psychopathology. Social Science and Medicine, 12B, 155–62.Google Scholar
Flor-Henry, P. (1978b) The endogenous psychoses: A reflection of lateralized temporal-limbic dysfunction. In The Limbic System Concept (eds. Livingston, K. and Hornykiewicz, O.). New York: Plenum Press.Google Scholar
Flor-Henry, P. (1979) On certain aspects of the localization of the cerebral systems regulating and determining emotion. Biological Psychiatry, 14, 677–98.Google Scholar
Fraser, R. M. & Glass, I. B. (1980) Unilateral and bilateral ECT in elderly patients. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 62, 13–31.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Fromholt, P., Christensen, A. & Stromgran, L. (1973) The effects of unilateral and bilateral electroconvulsive therapy on memory. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 49, 466–78.Google Scholar
Gainotti, G. (1972) Emotional behavior and hemispheric side of lesion. Cortex, 8, 41–55.Google Scholar
Halliday, A., Davison, K., Browne, M. & Kreeger, L. (1968) A comparison of the effects on depression and memory of bilateral ECT and unilateral ECT to the dominant and non-dominant hemispheres. British Journal of Psychiatry, 114, 997–1012.Google Scholar
Harper, R. G. & Wiens, A. N. (1975) Electroconvulsive therapy and memory. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 161, 245–54.Google Scholar
Hommes, O. R. & Panhuysen, L. H. H. M. (1971) Depression and cerebral dominance: A study of bilateral intracarotid amytal in eleven depressed patients. Psychiatrica Neurolgia and Neurochirurigia, 74, 259–70.Google Scholar
Jackson, B. (1978) The effects of unilateral and bilateral ECT on verbal and visual spatial memory. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 34 (1), 4–13.Google Scholar
Korin, H., Fink, M. & Kwalwasser, S. (1956) Relation of changes in memory and learning to improvement in electroshock. Confinia Neurology, 16, 88–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kronfol, Z., Hamsher, K. Des., Digre, K. & Waiziri, R. (1978) Depression and hemispheric function: Changes associated with unilateral ECT. British Journal of Psychiatry, 132, 560–7.Google Scholar
Lancaster, N., Steinert, R. & Frost, I. (1958) Unilateral electroconvulsive therapy. Journal of Mental Science, 104, 221–7.Google Scholar
Levy, R. (1968) Clinical evaluation of unilateral electroconvulsive therapy. British Journal of Psychiatry, 114, 459–63.Google Scholar
McCabe, M. S. (1975) Demographic differences in functional psychoses. British Journal of Psychiatry, 127, 320–3.Google Scholar
Martin, W., Ford, H., McDanald, E. & Towler, M. (1965) Clinical evaluation of unilateral ECT. American Journal of Psychiatry, 121, 1087–90.Google Scholar
Medlars, II (1967) National Library of Medicine Interactive Retrieval Service, Bethesda, Maryland.Google Scholar
Perria, L., Rosadini, G. & Ross, G. F. (1961) Determination of side of cerebral dominance with amobarbital. Archives of Neurology, 4, 173–81.Google Scholar
Pippard, J. & Ellam, L. (1981) Electroconvulsive treatment in Great Britain. British Journal of Psychiatry, 139, 563–8.Google Scholar
Polonio, P. (1966) L'analyse structural des psychoses endogenes au Portugal. In Proceedings of the IV World Congress of Psychiatry, Springfield: C. Thomas.Google Scholar
Robertson, A. & Inglis, J. (1973) Cerebral asymmetry and ECT. Reprinted from the Proceedings, 81st Annual Convention, American Psychological Association, pp 431–2. APA: 1200 17th Street NW, Washington DC, 20036, USA.Google Scholar
Robertson, A. & Inglis, J. (1978) Memory deficits after electroconvulsive therapy: Cerebral asymmetry and dual-encoding. Neuropsychologia, 16, 179–87.Google Scholar
Rosenthal, D. (1970) Genetic Theory and Abnormal Behavior. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Ross, E. D. & Mesulam, M. M. (1979) Dominant language functions of the right hemisphere. Archives of Neurology, 35, 144–8.Google Scholar
Rossi, G. F. & Rosadini, G. (1967) Experimental analysis of cerebral dominance in man. In Brain Mechanisms Underlying Speech and Language (eds. Millikan, C. H. and Karley, F. L.). New York: Grune & Stratton.Google Scholar
Small, I. F., Small, J. G., Milstein, V. & Moore, J. E. (1972) Neuropsychological observations with psychosis and somatic treatment. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 155, 6–13.Google Scholar
Squire, L. R. & Slater, P. C. (1978) Bilateral and unilateral ECT effects on verbal and nonverbal memory. American Journal of Psychiatry, 135, 1316–20.Google Scholar
Strain, J. J., Brunschwig, L., Duffy, J. P., Agle, D. P., Rosenbaum, A. L. & Bidder, T. G. (1968) Comparison of therapeutic effects and memory changes with bilateral and unilateral ECT. American Journal of Psychiatry, 125, 294–304.Google Scholar
Sutherland, E., Oliver, J. & Knight, D. (1969) EEG, memory and confusion in dominant, non-dominant, and bi-temporal ECT. British Journal of Psychiatry, 115, 1059–64.Google Scholar
Weeks, D., Freeman, C. P. L. & Kendell, R. E. (1980) ECT: III. Enduring cognitive deficits? British Journal of Psychiatry, 137, 26–37.Google Scholar
Zamora, E. & Kaelbling, R. (1965) Memory and electroconvulsive therapy. American Journal of Psychiatry, 122, 546–54.Google Scholar
Zinkin, S. & Birtchnell, J. (1968) Unilateral electroconvulsive therapy: Its effects on memory and its therapeutic efficacy. British Journal of Psychiatry, 114, 973–88.Google Scholar
Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.