Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-mkpzs Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T03:09:43.258Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Structures of Politics in Early Tudor England

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 February 2009

Steven Gunn
Steven Gunn
Affiliation:
The University of Glasgow
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Something of the atmosphere of trench warfare, with its immobility and its desperation, has overcome the historiography of early Tudor politics. The most spectacular impasse concerns the fall of Anne Boleyn. Three scholars have recently set out and defended against one another divergent explanations of her fall. Professor Ives and Professor Warnicke can agree that Dr Bernard is wrong: Anne cannot possibly have been destroyed by a masterful and jealous king who may reasonably have believed her guilty of multiple adultery as charged. Dr Bernard and Professor Ives can agree that Professor Warnicke is wrong: Anne's fall cannot be attributed to her miscarriage of a deformed foetus, awakening the king's fears of witchcraft and its sixteenth-century stablemates, sodomy and incest. Professor Warnicke and Dr Bernard can agree that Professor Ives is wrong: Anne cannot have been ousted by a factional plot at court, coordinated by Thomas Cromwell and cynically using fabricated charges of adultery to hustle the king into destroying the queen and her partisans at a single blow.

Type
Research Article
Information
Transactions of the Royal Historical Society , Volume 5 , December 1995 , pp. 59 - 90
Copyright
Copyright © Royal Historical Society 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Ives, E.W., Anne Boleyn (Oxford, 1986) [hereafter Ives, Anne Boleyn], 335–418Google Scholar; Warnicke, R.M., The Rise and Fall of Anne Boleyn (Cambridge, 1989) [hereafter Warnicke, Rise and Fall], 191–233Google Scholar; Bernard, G.W., ‘The fall of Anne Boleyn’, English Historical Review [hereafter EHR], CVI (1991) [hereafter Bernard, ‘Fall’], 584–610CrossRefGoogle Scholar; E.W. Ives, ‘The fall of Anne Boleyn reconsidered’, ibid., CVII (1992), 651–64; G. W. Bernard, ‘The fall of Anne Boleyn: a rejoinder’, ibid., CVII (1992) [hereafter Bernard, ‘Rejoinder’], 665–74; R. M. Warnicke, ‘The fall of Anne Boleyn revisited’, ibid., CVIII (1993) [hereafter Warnicke, ‘Fall revisited’], 653–65. For the subsidiary debate on Anne's religion, see Bernard, G.W., ‘Anne Boleyn's religion’, Historical Journal [hereafter HJ, XXXVI (1993), 1–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar; E. W. Ives, ‘Anne Boleyn and the early reformation in England: the contemporary evidence’, ibid., XXXVII (1994), 389–400. I am very grateful to Simon Adams, George Bernard and Cliff Davies for their comments on this paper, though they are by no means responsible for the opinions it expresses.

2 As another recent writer on the politics of Henry VIII's reign has put it, in a footnote discussing the difference between his understanding of the subject and ProfessorWarnicke's, , ‘We often use the same evidence but reach contradictory conclusions.’ Block, J.S., Factional Politics and the English Reformation 1520–1540 (Woodbridge, 1993) [hereafter Block, Factional Politics], 7Google Scholarn.

3 Warnicke, R.M., ‘The fall of Anne Boleyn: a reassessment’, History, LXX (1985) [hereafter Warnicke, ‘Reassessment’], 1–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar: idem, ‘Sexual heresy at the court of Henry VIII’, HJ, XXX (1987), 247–68.

4 Starkey, D.R., The Reign of Henry VIII: Personalities and Politics (1985) [hereafter Starkey, Reign of Henry VIII], 9, 30Google Scholar; Gwyn, P., The King's Cardinal: The Rise and Fall of Thomas Wolsey (1990) [hereafter Gwyn, King's Cardinal], 210–11Google Scholar.

5 Ives, E.W, Faction in Tudor England, second edition (1986) [hereafter Ives, Faction], 25Google Scholar; idem, ‘The fall of Wolsey’ [hereafter Ives, ‘Fall of Wolsey’], in Cardinal Wolsey: Church, State and Art, eds. S.J. Gunn and P.G. Lindley (Cambridge, 1991) [hereafter Cardinal Wolsey], 302.

6 Adams, S.L., ‘Eliza enthroned? The court and its polities’, in The Reign of Elizabeth I, ed. Haigh, C.A. (1984) [hereafter Reign of Elizabeth], 55–77Google Scholar; Doran, S., ‘Religion and politics at the court of Elizabeth I: the Habsburg marriage negotiations of 1559–1567’, EHR, CIV (1989), 908–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Bernard, , ‘Rejoinder’, 673–4Google Scholar; Moote, A.L., Louis XIII, The Just (Berkeley, CA, 1989)Google Scholar; Stradling, R.A., Philip IV and the Government of Spain, 1621–1655 (Cambridge, 1988)Google Scholar; Rodríguez-Salgado, M., The Changing Face of Empire: Charles V, Philip II and Habsburg Authority, 1551–1559 (Cambridge, 1988)Google Scholar; Kollmann, N.S., ‘The grand prince in Muscovite politics: the problem of genre in sources on Ivan's minority’, Russian History, XIV (1987), 293–313CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Bernard, , ‘Rejoinder’, 672–3Google Scholar; Ives, , ‘Fall of Wolsey’, 289–90Google Scholar.

9 Warnicke, , ‘Reassessment’, 2Google Scholar.

10 Clark, J.C.D., Revolution and Rebellion: State and Society in England in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries (Cambridge, 1986)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 McFarlane, K.B., ‘Parliament and “bastard feudalism”’, in his England in the Fifteenth Century: Collected Essays (1981), 19Google Scholar.

12 Hicks, M.A., ‘Idealism in late medieval English polities’, in his Richard III and His Rivals: Magnates and their Motives in the Wars of the Roses (1991), 41–59Google Scholar; Carpenter, C., Locality and Polity: A Study of Warwickshire Landed Society, 1401–1499 (Cambridge, 1992) [hereafter Carpenter, Locality and Polity], 3–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Powell, E., ‘After “After McFarlane”: the poverty of patronage and the case for constitutional history’, in Trade, Devotion and Governance: Papers in Later Medieval History, eds. Clayton, D.J., Davies, R.G., McNiven, P. (Stroud, 1994), 1–16Google Scholar; Cust, R., Hughes, A., ‘Introduction: after revisionism’, in Conflict in Early Stuart England: Studies in Religion and Politics 1603–1642, eds. Cust, R. and Hughes, A. (1989) [hereafter Cust and Hughes, ‘After revisionism’], 1–46Google Scholar.

13 Harris, B.J., ‘Women and politics in early Tudor England’, HJ, XXXIII (1990) [hereafter Harris, ‘Women and politics’], 259–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cust, and Hughes, , ‘After revisionism’, 17Google Scholar; Smith, L.B., Treason in Tudor England: Politics and Paranoia (1986) [hereafter Smith, Treason], 40–117Google Scholar.

14 Mayer, T.F., Thomas Starkey and the Commonweal Humanist Politics and Religion in the Reign of Henry VIII (Cambridge, 1989), 18–26, 112–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Cavendish, G., The Life and Death of Cardinal Wolsey, ed. Sylvester, R. S. (Early English Text Society CCXLIII, 1959), 35Google Scholar.

16 Starkey, D.R., ‘Intimacy and innovation: the rise of the privy chamber, 1485–1547’, in The English Court from the Wars of the Roses to the Civil War, ed. Starkey, D.R. (1987) [hereafter Starkey, ‘Intimacy and innovation’], 101–2Google Scholar; Redworth, G., In Defence of the Church Catholic: The Life of Stephen Gardiner (Oxford, 1990) [hereafter Redworth, Gardiner], 3, 89Google Scholar.

17 Brigden, S.E., London and the Reformation (Oxford, 1989) [hereafter Brigden, London], 325–77Google Scholar; Redworth, , Gardiner, 232Google Scholar.and passim.

18 The Anglica Historic of Polydore Vergil A.D. 1485–1537, ed. Hay, D. (Camden Society, 3rd series, LXXIV, 1950), 325–33Google Scholar.

19 Calendar of State Papers, Spanish, eds. Bergenroth, G.A., de Gayangos, P., Hume, M.A.S. and Mattingiy, G. (15 vols., 1862–1954) [hereafter CSPS, all references to document numbers], III, ii, 621Google Scholar.

20 Correspondance du Cardinal Jean du Bellay, ed. Scheurer, R. (2 vols., Société de l'Histoire de France, Paris, 1969–1973) [hereafter Correspondance Du Bellay], I, 22Google Scholar.

21 Public Record Office [hereafter PRO], PRO31/18/2/1, fo. 390V (CSPSV, 132).

22 Correspondence politique de MM. de Castillon et de Marillac, ed. Kaulek, J. (Paris, 1888), 187–8Google Scholar.

23 Ambassades en Angleterre Jean du Bellay, eds. Bourrilly, V.-L., de Vaissière, P. (Archives de l'istoire Religieuse de la France, Paris, 1905) [hereafter Ambassades Du Bellay], 257–8, 373–5Google Scholar; Correspondance Du Bellay, 38, 107.

24 Knecht, R.J., Francis I (Cambridge, 1982), 410–11Google Scholar; State Papers, King Henry the Eighth (11 vols., 1830–1852) [hereafter State Papers], XI, 278Google Scholar.

25 Elton, G.R., ‘Thomas Cromwell's decline and fall’, in his Studies in Tudor and Stuart Politics and Government (4 vols. to date, Cambridge, 1974–1992), 219Google Scholarn; Moreau, J.-P., Rome ou L'Angkterre? Les réactions politiques des catholiques anglais au moment du schisme (1529–1553) (Paris, 1984), 109Google Scholarn; Ives, , Anne Boleyn, 74–5Google Scholar.

26 Warnicke, , Rise and Fall, 1–3, 66, 88, 97, 114, 126, 135, 142, 145–6, 174, 181, 184, 200Google Scholar.

27 Gwyn, , king's Cardinal, 575–8Google Scholar; the outstanding example is found in Ambassades Du Bellay, 359–65. For apparently similar behaviour in 1515 and the early 1520s, see Calendar of State Papers, Venetian, eds. Brown, R., Bentinck, C. and Brown, H. (9 vols., 1864–1898) [hereafter CSPV, all references to document numbers], II, 635Google Scholar. and Walker, G., John Skelton and the Politics of the 1520s (Cambridge, 1988) [hereafter Walker, Skelton], 166–7Google Scholar.

28 Ives, , Anne Boleyn, 73Google Scholar; Archives Générales du Royaume, Brussels, EA 16303, unnumbered letter of Sebastian Bourgeois to Mary of Hungary, 26 September 1544.

29 Warnicke, , Rise and Fall, 88Google Scholar.

30 CSPS, III, ii, 614.

31 CSPV, II, 875.

32 Ives, , ‘Fall of Wolsey’, p. 305Google Scholar; Gunn, S.J., Charles Brandon, duke of Suffolk c. 1484–1545 (Oxford, 1988) [hereafter Gunn, Charles Brandon], 107–9Google Scholar; Letters and Papers, Foreign and Domestic, of the Reign of Henry VIII, eds. Brewer, J.S., Gairdner, J. and Brodie, R.H. (22 vols. in 35, 1862–1932) [hereafter LP, all references to document numbers], IV, iii, 5523, 5535, 5541, 5547, 5579, 5584Google Scholar; CSPS, V. 16; CSPV IV, 464; Potter, D.L., War and Government in the French Provinces: Picardy 1470–1560 (Cambridge, 1993), 74CrossRefGoogle Scholar. cf. 258.

33 Mattingly, G., Renaissance Diplomacy (Harmondsworth, 1965 edn), 146–53Google Scholar.

34 CSPV, I, 822; Gunn, S.J., ‘The courtiers of Henry VII’, EHR, CVIII (1993) [hereafter Gunn, ‘Courtiers’], 34, 47CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

35 Scarisbrick, J.J., Henty VIII (Harmondsworth, 1971 edn), 522–43Google Scholar; Nicholson, G., ‘The act of appeals and the English reformation’ in Law and Government under the Tudors: Essays presented to Sir Geoffrey Elton, eds. Cross, C., Loades, D.M. and Scarisbrick, J.J. (Cambridge, 1988), 21Google Scholar; Redworth, G., ‘A study in the formulation of policy: the genesis and evolution of the act of six articles’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, XXXVII (1986) [hereafter Redworth, ‘Six articles’], 45–7, 61–6Google Scholar; State Papers, I, 115–49, 174n, 891–2; Gunn, S.J., ‘Wolsey's foreign policy and the domestic crisis of 1527–8’, in Cardinal Wolsey, 157–60Google Scholar; PRO, E163/12/7.

36 Starkey, , Reign of Henry VIII, 60Google Scholar.

37 Bernard, G.W., War, Taxation and Rebellion in Early Tudor England: Henry VIII, Wolsey, and the Amicable Grant of 1525 (Brighton, 1986) [hereafter Bernard, War, Taxation and Rebellion], 76–107Google Scholar; Gwyn, , King's Cardinal, 565–70Google Scholar.

38 Smith, , Treason, 42–55Google Scholar; Machiavelli, N., The Prince (Harmondsworth, 1961 edn), 99–102Google Scholar.

39 Harris, , ‘Women and polities’, 279Google Scholar.

40 Original Letters illustrative of English History, ed. Ellis, H. [hereafter Original Letters], 1st series (2nd edn, 3 vols., 1825), I, 309–10Google Scholar.(LP, IV, iii, 5953).

41 PRO, SP1/69, fo. 56 (LP, V, 728).

42 PRO, SP1/28, fo. 245 (LP, III, ii, 3378).

43 Gunn, , Charles Brandon, 27, 33, 35–6Google Scholar; see especially LP, I, ii, 3376.

44 State Papers, I, 347–8; LP, XV, 776, 824; Original Letters, 2nd series (4 vols., 1827), II, 163Google Scholar.

45 British Library [hereafter BL], Cotton Manuscript Vespasian FXIII, fo. 153 (LP, II, i, 367); Cotton Manuscript Caligula DVI, fo. 184V (LP, II, i, 80).

46 LP, XIII, ii, 765, 772, 800, 802, 804, 827, 876, 960.

47 Harris, B.J., Edward Stafford, Third duke of Buckingham, 1478–1521 (Stanford, CA, 1986) [hereafter Harris, Buckingham], 170–2, 176Google Scholar.

48 Sturge, C., Cuthbert Tunstall (1938) [hereafter Sturge, Tunstall], 371Google Scholar.

49 Walker, , Skelton, 5–34, 124–87Google Scholar.

50 Whittinton, R., Libellus Epygrammaton (London, 1519)Google Scholar. sig. Bv v.

51 Walker, G., Plays of Persuasion: Drama and Politics at the Court of Henry VIII (Cambridge, 1991)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Axton, M., The Queen's Two Bodies: Drama and the Elizabethan Succession (1977)Google Scholar.

52 Starkey, D.R., ‘The age of the household: politics, society and the arts c. 1350–c. 1550’, in The Later Middle Ages, ed. Medcalf, S. (1981), 225–90Google Scholar; Harris, , ‘Women and politics’ 260–5, 280–1Google Scholar; Ives, , Faction, 6–7Google Scholar.

53 Ives, , Anne Boleyn, 84–7, 365–8Google Scholar.(though for qualifications see Warnicke, , ‘Fall revisited’, 654–9Google Scholar.; PRO, SP1/138, fos. 224r., 243v. (LP, XIII, ii, 804 (iii), 818); LP, XIII, ii, 765, 772.

54 Baldwin, T.W., William Shakspere's Small Latine & Lesse Greek (2 vols., Urbana, In., 1944), I, 255Google Scholar; Ives, , Anne Boleyn, 316–26Google Scholar; for supporting evidence see Dowling, M., Humanism in the age of Henry VIII (1986) [hereafter Dowling, Humanism], 146Google Scholar.and Hoak, D., The King's Council in the Reign of Edward VI (Cambridge, 1976) [hereafter Hoak, King's Council], 243Google Scholar .

55 Gunn, S.J., ‘Chivalry and the politics of the early Tudor court’, in Chivalry in the Renaissance, ed. Anglo, S. (Woodbridge, 1990) [hereafter Gunn, ‘Chivalry and polities’], 110, 119Google Scholar.

56 Hicks, M.A., ‘Bastard feudalism: society and politics in fifteenth-century England’, in his Richard III and His Rivals: Magnates and the Motives in the Wars of the Roses (1991), 21–8Google Scholar.

57 PRO, E210/10759; SP1/143, fo. 53 (LP, XIV, i, 263, though the calendar does not mention the bond); Cameron, A., ‘Sir Henry Willoughby of Wollaton’, Transactions of the Thoroton Society, LXXIV (1970) [hereafter Cameron, ‘Willoughby’], 17Google Scholar.

58 Such as the £6,300 forfeited by thirteen sureties for Sir Robert Curson's performance as keeper of Hammes Castle: between June 1503 and June 1506, at least eight of them made arrangements to pay £500 or £600 each to the king: Calendar of the Close Rolls, Henry VII (2 vols., 1953–1963) [hereafter CCR Henry VII, all references to document numbers], I, 1060Google Scholar; BL, Additional Manuscript [hereafter Add. MS] 21480, fos. 42V., 92r., 117V.; Lansdowne Manuscript 127, fos. 4r., 18r., 21v.

59 Heal, F.M., Hospitality in Early Modern England (Oxford, 1990), 54–90CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Harris, , Buckingham, 92Google Scholar; Vokes, S.E., ‘The early career of Thomas, Lord Howard, earl of Surrey and third duke of Norfolk, 1474–c. 1525’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Hull, 1988), 312–15Google Scholar.

60 Jordan, W.K., Edward VI: The Threshold of Power (1970) [hereafter Jordan, Threshold of Power], 73Google Scholar.

61 Rowse, A.L., ‘Thomas Wriodiesley, first earl of Southampton’, Huntington Library Quarterly, XXVIII (1965), 126, 128Google Scholar; Hoak, , King's Council, 239–58Google Scholar; History of Parliament: The Commons 1509–1558, ed. Bindoff, S.T. (3 vols., 1982) [hereafter HP], II, 342Google Scholar.

62 Gunn, , Charles Brandon, 198Google Scholar.

63 LP, X, 284; Ives, , Anne Boleyn, 380–2Google Scholar; Bernard, , ‘Fall’, 598Google Scholar.

64 Gunn, , ‘Chivalry and polities’ 113–16Google Scholar; The Register of the Most Noble Order of the Garter, ed. Anstis, J. (2 vols., 1724), I, 435Google Scholar; Wilson, D., A Tudor Tapestoy: Men, Women and Society in Reformation England (1972), 220–3Google Scholar.

65 Cambridge University Library, Ely Diocesan Records, D/5/8, fos. 4v.-21r., unfoliated entries at end; D/5/9; Ives, , Anne Boleyn, 303–4, 311, 373Google Scholar.

66 Longleat House, Miscellaneous volumes 18–19 (I am grateful for permission to cite these); Starkey, , Reign of Henry VIII, 113, 118, 121, 137Google Scholar; Brigden, , London, 307, 327, 330–2Google Scholar.

67 Longleat House, Miscellaneous volume 18.

68 Gunn, , Charles Brandon, 112–13, 115–17, 121–7, 165Google Scholar.

69 PRO, SP1/191, fo. 46 (LP, XIX, ii, 36); SP1/115, fo. 175 (LP, XII, i, 318).

70 PRO, SP1/75, fo. 245V. (LP, VI, 415).

71 Jordan, W.K., Edward VI: The Young King (1968), 500–2Google Scholar.

72 Bush, M.L., ‘The Lisle- Seymour land disputes: a study of power and influence in the 1530s’, HJ, IX (1966), 255–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Slavin, A.J., ‘Cromwell, Cranmer and Lord lisle: a study in the politics of reform’, Albion, IX (1977) [hereafter Slavin, ‘Cromwell, Cranmer and Lord lisle’], 320–30Google Scholar.

73 Clifford Letters of the Sixteenth Century, ed. Dickens, A.G. (Surtees Society CLXXII, 1962), 106Google Scholar.

74 Plumpton Correspondence, ed. Stapleton, T. (Camden Society IV, 1839) [hereafter Plumpton Correspondence], cxiii, 177–8Google Scholar.

75 LP, XXI, ii, 541.

76 Willen, D., John Russell, first earl of Bedford: One of the King's Men (1981) [hereafter Willen, Russell], 52–6Google Scholar.

77 Redworth, , Gardiner, 176–207Google Scholar; Block, , Factional Politics, 149–50Google Scholar; Slavin, , ‘Cromwell, Cranmer and Lord lisle’, 325, 332Google Scholar.

78 HP, II, 276; Starkey, , Reign of Henry VIII, 118, 144Google Scholar.

79 Lincolnshire Archives Office [hereafter LAO], Bishop's Register [hereafter Reg.] 26, fo. 236V.; Miller, H., Henry VIII and the English Nobility (Oxford, 1986) [hereafter Miller, English Nobility], 44, 125, 204Google Scholar: Dowling, , Humanism, 68Google Scholar.

80 Ives, E.W., ‘Court and county palatine in the reign of Henry VIII: the case of William Brereton of Malpas’, Transactions of the Historic Society of Lancashire and Cheshire, CXXIII (1972), 1–38Google Scholar; Letters and Accounts of William Brereton of Malpas, ed. idem (Record Society of Lancashire and Cheshire CXVI, 1976); idem, ‘Crime, sanctuary and royal authority under Henry VIII: the exemplary sufferings of the Savage family’, in On the Laws and Customs of England: Essays in Honor of Samuel E. Thome, ed. M.S. Arnold, S.A. Scully and T.D. White (Chapel Hill, NC, 1981) [hereafter Ives, ‘Savage family’] 304–11; Warnicke, , Rise and Fall, 104–7, 135–40, 147–8, 158–62Google Scholar.

81 Condon, M.M., ‘Ruling elites in the reign of Henry VII’, in Patronage, Pedigree and Power in Later Medieval England, ed. Ross, C.D. (Gloucester, 1979), 113Google Scholar; Ives, , ‘Savage family’, 304–11Google Scholar; Ross, C.D., Edward IV (1974), 96, 319–20Google Scholar.

82 Descriptive Catalogue of Ancient Deeds in the Public Record Office (6 vols., 1890–1915)Google Scholar.[hereafter CAD, all references to document numbers], III, C3170, D1308, VI, C7345; CCR Henry VII, II, 720, 737, 953, 984; Feet of Fines for Essex, IV, ed. Reaney, P.H. and Fitch, M. (Colchester, 1964), 108, 125Google Scholar; Herts Genealogist and Antiquary, I (1895), 82Google Scholar; BL, Additional Charter 5674; Add. MS 21480, fo. 80v.; PRO, E36/215, fo. 298V.; C1/303/62.

83 Richard Wyatt: Norfolk and Norwich Record Office [hereafter NNRO], Reg. 12, fo. 183r; Canterbury Sede Vacante Institutions (Kent Archaeological Society records branch VIII, 1924), 57Google Scholar; Emden, A.B., A Biographical Register of the University of Cambridge to 1500 (Cambridge, 1963), 661–2Google Scholar; Victoria County History [hereafter VCH] Lancashire (8 vols., 1906–1914), IV, 62Google Scholar; Christopher Lytton: LAO, Reg. 23, fo. 183r.; NNRO, Reg. 13B, fo. 20r.; Guildhall Library, MS 9531/8, fo. 73V.; Dudley, Richard: Calendar of Patent Rolls, Henry VII (2 vols., 1914–1916) [hereafter CPR Henry VIII], II, 534, 539, 586Google Scholar; Emden, A.B., A Biographical Register of the University of Oxford to A.D. 1500 (3 vols., Oxford, 1957–1959) I, 598–9Google Scholar.

84 Chope, R.P., ‘The last of the Dynhams’, Transactions of the Devonshire Association, L (1918), 474–5Google Scholar.

85 HP, III, 290–1; Select Cases in the Council of Henry VII, eds. Bayne, C.G., Dunham, W.H. (Selden Society LXXV, 1958), cxlii–iiiGoogle Scholar; LP, II, ii, 3748, III, ii, 2288, 2352, 2956 (28), 3504, 3583, App. 45*, IV, i, 214, 547, ii, 4276; I hope to discuss the Lovell brothers in a forthcoming book.

86 Clark, P., English Provincial Society from the Reformation to the Revolution: Religion, Politics and Society in Kent, 1500–1640 (Hassocks, 1977), 14–16Google Scholar; Cameron, A., ‘The giving of livery and retaining in Henry's VII's reign’, Renaissance and Modem Studies, XVIII (1974), 31–4Google Scholar; Select Cases in the Council of Henry VII, xxix–xxx, cxlii–iii, 138–49; BL, Lansdowne MS 127, fo. 11r.; Gairdner, J. and Leadham, I.S., ‘A supposed conspiracy against Henry VII’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, n.s. XVIII (1904), 179–80Google Scholar; PRO, E101/414/16, fo. 256r.; HP, II, 263; PRO, SP1/88, fo. 88v. (LP, VII, 1647).

87 Rawcliffe, C. and Flower, S., ‘English noblemen and their advisers: consultation and collaboration in the later middle ages’, Journal of British Studies, XXV (1986), 157–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar; James, M.E., ‘A Tudor magnate and the Tudor state: Henry fifth earl of Northumberland’, in his Society, Politics and Culture: Studies in Early Modem England (Cambridge, 1986) [hereafter James, Society, Politics and Culture] 50–5, 68–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Hoyle, R.W., ‘The first earl of Cumberland: a reputation reassessed’, Northern History, XXII (1986), 63–72Google Scholar; Gunn, , Charles Brandon, 24–5, 45–53, 83–8, 127–30, 154–9, 204–6, 210–19Google Scholar; idem, ‘Henry Bourchier, earl of Essex (1472–1540)’, in The Tudor Nobility, ed. G W. Bernard (Manchester, 1992) [hereafter Tudor Nobility], 151–2, 159–65; Smith, R.B., Land and Politics in the England of Henry VIII: The West Riding of Yorkshire 1530–1546 (Oxford, 1970), 137–9Google Scholar; Bernard, G.W., The Power of the Early Tudor Nobility: a study of the fourth and fifth earls of Shrewsbury (Brighton, 1985), 157–62Google Scholar; Coward, B., The Stanleys, Lords Stanley and earls of Derby 1385–1672: The Origins, Wealth and Power of a Landowning Family (Chetham Society, 3rd series XXX, 1983), 84–97, 117–22Google Scholar.

88 Cameron, , ‘Willoughby’, 16–17Google Scholar; MacCulloch, D.N.J., Suffolk and the Tudors: Politics and Religion in an English County 1500–1600 (Oxford, 1986), 72–3, 93–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

89 Report on the Manuscripts of his Grace the Duke of Rutland, IV (Historical Manuscripts Commission XXIV, 1908), 559–66Google Scholar; Adams, S.L., ‘The Dudley clientèle, 1553–1563’, in Tudor Nobility, 138Google Scholar; Guy, J.A., ‘Wolsey and the Tudor polity’, in Cardinal Wolsey, 70Google Scholar; Robertson, M.L., ‘“The art of the possible”: Thomas Cromwell's management of West Country government’, HJ, XXXII (1989), 799Google Scholar; Smith, A.G.R., Servant of the Cecils: The Life of Sir Michael Hickes, 1543–1612 (1977), 29–50Google Scholar.

90 PRO, PROB11/16/16.

91 Hope, W.H. St John, ‘The last testament and inventory of John de Veer, thirteenth earl of Oxford’, Archaeologia, LXVI (1914–1915), 313, 318Google Scholar; PRO, PROB2/199, mm. 2, 3.

92 Testamenta Vetusta, ed. Nicolas, N.H. (2 vols., 1826), II, 709Google Scholar; LP, XIII, i, 795; PRO, E192/2; Emmison, F.G., Tudor Secretary: Sir William Petre at Court and at Home (1961), 52, 54, 56, 60–1Google Scholar; Gammon, S.R., Statesman and Schemer: William, First Lord Paget—Tudor Minister (Newton Abbot, 1973) [hereafter Gammon, Paget], 97, 122, 204, 212, 224Google Scholar.

93 Willen, , Russell, 32–5, 41–3Google Scholar; Gunn, , Charles Brandon, 227Google Scholar; Redworth, , Gardiner, 77, 181, 209–13, 239Google Scholar; Brigden, S.E., ‘Henry Howard, earl of Surrey, and the “conjured league”’, HJ, XXXVII (1994) [hereafter Brigden, ‘Surrey’], 509–10, 520–2, 526–7Google Scholar.

94 CPR Henry VII, II, 188; CCR Henry VII, II, 501, 521, 927; PRO, E101/414/6, fos. 13v, 37v; Alsop, J.D., ‘Government, finance and the community of the exchequer’, in Reign of Elizabeth, 111–12Google Scholar.

95 Walker, , Skelton, 29Google Scholar.

96 ‘The letters of Richard Scudamore to Sir Philip Hoby, September 1549–March 1555’, ed. Brigden, S.E., in Camden Miscellany XXX (Camden Society, 4th series XXXLX, 1990), 97, 114Google Scholar.

97 CPR Henry VII, II, 396, 542, 594; CCR Henry VII, II, 143, 283, 617, 629, 762, 972; CAD, I, A1492; BL, Add. MS 21480, fos. 98V., 120v.; Wedgwood, J.C., History of Parliament: Biographies of Members of the Commons House, 1439–1509 (1936) [hereafter Wedgwood, Commons], 565–6Google Scholar; Cheshire Record Office [hereafter CRO], DCH/B/43, 44; Cooper, J.P., ‘Henry VII's last years reconsidered’, HJ, II (1959), 120–1Google Scholar.

98 Gunn, S.J., ‘The accession of Henry VIII’, Historical Research, LXIV (1991) [hereafter Gunn, ‘Accession’], 285–6Google Scholar; Wedgwood, , Commons, 55, 286–7, 975Google Scholar; CPR Henry VII, II, 589.

99 CCR Henry VII, II, 616, 617, 663, 726, 759, 762, 972; CRO, DCH/B/44; Wedgwood, , Commons, 286–7Google Scholar; BL, Add. MS 21480, fo. 125V.; CPR Henry VII, II, 591; University of Durham, Department of Palaeography, Priory Register V, fo. 102.

100 Dudley, E., The Tree of Commonwealth, ed. Brodie, D.M. (Cambridge, 1948) [hereafter Dudley, Tree of Commonwealth], 3Google Scholar; CAD, III, A3987; Horowitz, M.R., ‘Richard Empson, minister of Henry VII’, Bulletin of the Institute of Historical Research, LV (1982), 39, 41Google Scholar; Jones, M.K., Underwood, M., The King's Mother: Lady Margaret Beaufort, Countess of Richmond and Derby (Cambridge, 1992), 222Google Scholar.

101 Dudley, Tree of Commonwealth, passim.

102 Gunn, , ‘Accession’, 283–6Google Scholar.

103 Harris, , Buckingham, 52–4Google Scholar; Gunn, , ‘Courtiers’, 34–5Google Scholar; Bernard, G.W., ‘The downfall of Sir Thomas Seymour’, in Tudor Nobility, 212–40Google Scholar.

104 PRO, SP1/104, fo. 81r. (LP, XI, 601).

105 The Lisle Letters, ed. Byrne, M. StC. (6 vols., 1981), VI, 118nGoogle Scholar.

106 Dewar, M., Sir Thomas Smith: A Tudor Intellectual in Office (1964), 5, 39–44Google Scholar; Gammon, , Paget, 119, 206Google Scholar.

107 PRO, SC1/44/83.

108 BL, Add. MS 45131, fo. 150r.; Brigden, , London, 72Google Scholar.

109 Redworth, , Gardiner, 41, 108–9, 210Google Scholar; Loades, D.M., ‘Thomas Cranmer and John Dudley: an uneasy alliance, 1549–53’, in Thomas Cranmer: Churchman and Scholar, ed. Ayris, P., Selwyn, D. (Woodbridge, 1993), 157–72Google Scholar.

110 Brigden, , ‘Surrey’, 513–20Google Scholar.

111 Goodman, A., ‘Henry VII and Christian renewal’, in Religion and Humanism, ed. Robbins, K. (Studies in Church History XVII, 1981), 115–25Google Scholar; CSPS, I, 552, 577; Tyerman, C., England and the Crusades, 1095–1588 (1988), 318–19, 343–4, 350–2, 358Google Scholar; Phmpton Correspondence, 268–9; James, M.E., ‘Obedience and dissent in Henrician England: the Lincolnshire rebellion, 1536’ in James, , Society, Politics and Culture, 243–4Google Scholar; PRO, SP1/118, fo. 123r.-v. (LP, XII, i, 899).

112 Redworth, , Gardiner, 238Google Scholar.

113 Redworth, , Gardiner, 108–9Google Scholar.

114 Gunn, , Charles Brandon, 159–64, 198–201, 214Google Scholar.

115 Ives, , Faction, 18Google Scholar; Ives, , ‘Fall of Wolsey’, 312Google Scholar.

116 Letters of Richard Fox, 1486–1527, ed. Allen, P.S., Allen, H.M. (Oxford, 1929), 44Google Scholar; LP, XVIII, i, 741.

117 Report on the Manuscripts of the Most Honourable the Marquess of Bath, IV (Historical Manuscripts Commission LVIII, 1968), 103Google Scholar.

118 Sturge, , Tunstall, 370Google Scholar.

119 LP, XIX, ii, 423.

120 Ives, E.W., ‘Henry VIII's will—a forensic conundrum’, HJ, XXXV (1992), 779–804CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

121 MacCaffrey, W.C., ‘Place and patronage in Elizabethan polities’, in Elizabethan Government and Society: essays presented to Sir John Neale, ed. Bindoff, S.T., Hurstfield, J., Williams, C.H. (1961), 95–126Google Scholar.

122 Ives, , ‘Court and county palatine’, 11–15Google Scholar; Bernard, , ‘The rise of Sir William Compton, early Tudor courtier’, EHR, XCVI (1981), 758–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Carpenter, , Locality and Polity, 560–96Google Scholar.

123 Starkey, , ‘Intimacy and innovation’, 107Google Scholar; Gunn, , ‘Courtiers’, 45Google Scholar; Surrey Record Office, 281/2/1, fo. 6r.

124 Block, , Factional Politics, 68–83, 97–106Google Scholar; Thomson, J.A.F., The Early Tudor Church and Society, 1485–1529 (1993). 75–7Google Scholar.

125 Canterbury Record Office, FA7, fo. 138r.

126 Wall, A., ‘Patterns of politics in England, 1558–1628’, HJ, XXXI (1988), 947–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

127 Redworth, , ‘Six articles’, 53Google Scholar.

128 Strype, J., Ecclesiastical Memorials (3 Vols, 1721) [hereafter Strype, Ecclesiastical Memorials], I, ii, 257Google Scholar; Correspmdance Du Bellay, 104–5.

129 Ives, , ‘Fall of Wolsey’, 295–300Google Scholar.

130 Redworth, , Gardiner, 106–29Google Scholar; Brigden, , London, 308–24Google Scholar.

131 Ives, , Anne Boleyn, 357, 372–3, 416Google Scholar.

132 Strype, , Ecclesiastical Memorials, II, ii, 430Google Scholar.

133 Arthurson, I., The Perkin Warbeck Conspiracy 1491–1499 (Stroud, 1994)Google Scholar.

134 PRO, C1/373/31.

135 The Records of the Borough of Northampton, ed. Markham, C.A., Cox, J.C. (2 vols, 1898), I, 354Google Scholar. For similar examples, see The Tudor Constitution, Documents and Commentary, ed. Elton, G.R. (2nd edition, Cambridge, 1982), 61–2Google Scholar; Gunn, , Charles Brandon, 40Google Scholar .

136 Elton, G.R., Policy and Police: The Enforcement of the Reformation in the age of Thomas Cromwell (Cambridge, 1972), 110–12, 333–4, 350–64, 375–80Google Scholar.

137 LP, XIII, ii, 968.

138 Starkey, T., A Dialogue between Pole and Lupset, ed. Mayer, T.F. (Camden Society, 4th series, XXXVII, 1989), 81–2Google Scholar; Letters and Papers illustrative of the reigns of Richard III and Henry VII, ed. Gairdner, J. (2 vols., Rolls series XXIV, 1861–1863) [hereafter Richard III and Henry VII], I, 235Google Scholar.

139 Richard III and Heray VII, I, 363–4.

140 BL, Add. MS 21480, fo. 18Iv.

141 Richard III and Henry VII, I, 234.

142 Smith, L.B., Henry VIII: The Mask of Royalty (1971), 28–37, 88–90Google Scholar; Redworth, , Gardiner, 200–2, 233–4Google Scholar.

143 For the coinage of ‘lightning conductor’ in this context, see Walker, , Skelton, 174Google Scholar; Bernard, , War, Taxation and Rebellion, 62Google Scholar.

144 Carpenter, , Locality and Polity, 583–8Google Scholar; Gunn, , ‘Courtiers’, 47Google Scholar.

145 PRO, SP1/130, fo. 43r. (LP, XIII, i. 504).

146 Gwyn, , King's Cardinal, 581, 595–6Google Scholar; Ives, , ‘Fall of Wolsey’, 303Google Scholar; Starkey, , ‘Intimacy and innovation’, 117Google Scholar; Walker, , Plays of Persuasion, 229Google Scholar.