Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-fbnjt Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-13T01:08:59.754Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Planning and its discontents: contradictions and continuities in remaking China's great cities, 1950–2010

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 December 2012

SAMUEL Y. LIANG
SAMUEL Y. LIANG*
Affiliation:
School of Humanities, Shanghai Jiao Tong UniversityDepartment of Philosophy and Humanities, Utah Valley University, 800 West University Parkway, Orem, UT 84058, USA
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract:

This article offers a theoretical overview of the urbanization legacy of China's great cities since 1949. It shows a persistent contradiction between ideology/planning and urban sprawl/cellular urbanism. The symbolic function of city planning reflects official ideology giving the city a unified formal structure, but the implementation of the city plan is compromised in the process of urban development. The state governance fragments Chinese urban society into emplaced groups. This social division takes effect through the spatial division of various compounds that negotiate with rather than conform to city planning. Using a case-study of Guangzhou's urban development, the article shows how the state-led spatial practices continue in the post-socialist era and how a new kind of developmental ideology informs urban developments.

Type
Research Article
Information
Urban History , Volume 40 , Issue 3 , August 2013 , pp. 530 - 553
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2012 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Zhang Wei, ‘Chengshi renkou shou chao nongcun, BBC: Zhongguo chengshihua shixian zhi de feiyue’ (Urban population surpassed rural population for the first time, BBC: Chinese urbanization realizes a qualitative leap), http://intl.ce.cn/specials/zxxx/201201/17/t20120117_23007273.shtml (accessed 24 Jan. 2012).

2 Jiahua, Pan and Houkai, Wei (eds.), Zhongguo chengshi fazhan baogao: chengshi nanpi shu 2010 (The report on the development of Chinese cities: city blue book 2010) (Beijing, 2010)Google Scholar.

3 Wheatley, P., The Pivot of the Four Quarters: A Preliminary Enquiry into the Origins and Character of the Ancient Chinese City (Edinburgh, 1971)Google Scholar.

4 This phenomenon is called ‘invading streets’ (qinjie); see Jiang, Liang and Hui, Sun, Moshi yu dongyin: zhongguo chengshi zhongxin qu de xingtai yanbian (Pattern and mechanism: the urban transformation of the city centres in China) (Beijing, 2007), 74–7Google Scholar.

5 Perry, E.J., ‘Studying Chinese politics: farewell to revolution?’, China Journal, 57 (2007), 1–25CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

6 Logan, J.R. (ed.), The New Chinese City: Globalization and Market Reform (Oxford, 2002)Google Scholar; Ma, Laurence and Wu, Fulong (eds.), Restructuring the Chinese City: Changing Society, Economy and Space (London, 2005)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Wu, Fulong (ed.), Globalization and the Chinese City (London, 2006)Google Scholar; Wu, Fulong (ed.), China's Emerging Cities: The Making of New Urbanism (London, 2007)Google Scholar.

7 Logan, J.R. (ed.), Urban China in Transition (Oxford, 2008)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 Friedman, J., China's Urban Transition (Minneapolis, 2005), xviGoogle Scholar.

9 Yeh, Anthony Gar-On and Wu, Fulong, ‘The transformation of the urban planning system in China from a centrally-planned to transitional economy’, Progress in Planning, 51 (1999), 167–252Google Scholar.

10 Lü, Xiaobo, ‘Minor public economy: the revolutionary origins of the danwei’, in Lü, Xiaobo and Perry, E. (eds.), Danwei: The Changing Chinese Workplace in Historical and Comparative Perspective (Armonk, NY, 1997), 21–41Google Scholar; Selden, M., China in Revolution: The Yen'an Way Revisited (Armonk, NY, 1995)Google Scholar.

11 The city's planning authority then had to meet the demands of these units for immense lots of land, and Beijing's suburb was soon divided between them. Jun, Wang, Chengji (City records) (Beijing, 2003), 184–6Google Scholar; Dongping, Yang, Chengshi jiefeng: Beijing he Shanghai de wenhua jingsheng (City monsoon: the cultural spirits of Beijing and Shanghai) (Beijing, 2006), 174–5Google Scholar.

12 The great work units in the 1950s were built according to standardized plans but their later expansion were less uniformly controlled. Smaller work units were less well planned and some were more integrated into the old urban fabric. See Bray, D., Social Space and Governance in Urban China: The Work Unit System from Origins to Reform (Stanford, 2005), 123–56Google Scholar; Lu, Duanfang, Remaking Chinese Urban Form: Modernity, Scarcity and Space, 1949–2005 (London, 2006)Google Scholar. For a study of the work unit as a social institution, see Lü and Perry (eds.), Danwei.

13 Quite commonly, the work unit rather than the city provided housing and welfare to the workers/residents; by contrast, residents outside the work-unit system were not covered by the state benefits.

14 The spatial fragmentation of this cellular urbanism was a product of the state's ‘sectoral’ bureaucratic structure. The central government funded the constructions of the great work units, local governments provided free land, and Beijing's bureaucratic units directly managed the work units.

15 Yeh and Wu, ‘The transformation of the urban planning system’, 176–7. Chinese urban planners later criticized that these Soviet-influenced master plans ignored the local conditions of Chinese cities; see Lanhong, Hua, Chongjian zhongguo (Reconstructing China) (Beijing, 2006), 39–70Google Scholar.

16 Mao wrote this passage for the Party's journal Hongqi (Red flag) (1 (1958)) as an introduction to an article that documented a rural collectivization project. Part of this passage is quoted in Salaff, J., ‘The urban communes and anti-city experiment in communist China’, China Quarterly, 29 (1967), 91CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

17 Hua, Chongjian zhongguo, 71–92.

18 Yeh and Wu, ‘The transformation of the urban planning system’, 213.

19 Wang, Chengji, 122–6.

20 Their random locations were thought to be a defence against enemy air attacks.

21 Yeh and Wu, ‘The transformation of the urban planning system’, 175–6.

22 Lu, Remaking Chinese Urban Form, 85–97.

23 Wenda, Lu and Baorun, Xu (eds.), Shanghai fangdichan zhi (History of Shanghai real estate development) (Shanghai shehui kexueyuan chubanshe, 1999), 509–11Google Scholar.

24 Liangyong, Wu, Rehabilitating the Old City of Beijing: A Project in the Ju'er Hutong Neighbourhood (Vancouver, 1999), 105–19Google Scholar; Anyi, Wang, Xunzhao Shanghai (Searching for Shanghai) (Shanghai, 2001), 155–6Google Scholar.

25 In such cities as Shanghai, work units contributed funds to the municipal housing management bureau, which then built apartment buildings and allocated them to the work units; see Chuntao, Liet al., Shanghai zhuzhai jianshe zhi (History of Shanghai housing construction) (Shanghai, 1998)Google Scholar.

26 Wu, Fulong, Xu, Jiang and Gar-On Yeh, Anthony, Urban Development in Post-Reform China: State, Market and Space (London, 2007)Google Scholar; Lu, Remaking Chinese Urban Form, 74–9.

27 Yeh and Wu, ‘The transformation of the urban planning system’, 181–97.

28 Ibid., 213.

29 Abramson, D.B., ‘The dialectics of urban planning in China’, in Wu, (ed.), China's Emerging Cities, 66–86Google Scholar.

30 Liang, S.Y., ‘Amnesiac monument, nostalgic fashion: Shanghai's new heaven and earth’, Wasafiri, 23 (2008), 47–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Liang, S.Y., ‘Property-driven urban change in post-socialist Shanghai: reading the television series Woju’, Journal of Current Chinese Affairs, 39 (2010), 3–28Google Scholar.

31 Abramson, ‘The dialectics of urban planning in China’, 71.

32 Yeh, Anthony Gar-On, ‘Dual land market and internal spatial structure of Chinese cities’, in Ma, and Wu, (eds.), Restructuring the Chinese City, 59–79Google Scholar.

33 Bray, Social Space and Governance; Wu, Fulong, ‘Rediscovering the “gate” under market transition: from work-unit compounds to commodity housing enclaves’, Housing Studies, 22 (2005), 235–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

34 Pow, Choon-Piew, Gated Communities in China: Class, Privilege and the Moral Politics of the Good Life (London, 2009)Google Scholar; Wu, Fulong, ‘Gated and packaged suburbia: packaging and branding Chinese suburban residential development’, Cities, 27 (2010), 385–96CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

35 Huagang, Liu, ‘Guangzhou chengjiao daxing zhuqu de xingcheng ji qi yingxiang’ (The making and impact of Guangzhou's great suburban residential compounds), Chengshi guihua huigan (City Planning Journal), 147 (2003), 77–80Google Scholar.

36 Huang, Youqin, ‘From work-unit compounds to gated communities’, in Ma, and Wu, (eds.), Restructuring the Chinese City, 192–219.Google Scholar

37 Ziyuan, Yanget al., Guangzhou shi zhi (Guangzhou history), vol. III (Guangzhou, 1995), 41–59, 71–2Google Scholar; An, Pan, ‘Guangzhou chengshi guihua fazhan lichen’ (The history of Guangzhou city planning), in Feng, Dai, Zhiwu, Zhang and Xiaomei, Xu (eds.), Guangzhou chengshi guihua fazhan huiguo 1949–2005 (Retrospect on the development of Guangzhou city planning), vol. I (Guangzhou, 2006), 33–8Google Scholar.

38 Yeh and Wu, ‘The transformation of the urban planning system’, 210; Lo, C.P., ‘Economic reforms and socialist city structure: a case study of Guangzhou, China’, Urban Geography, 15 (1994), 128–49CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

39 Zhuobin, Li, Chengshi wenhua yu Guangzhou chengshi fazhan (Urban culture and Guangzhou urban development) (Guangzhou, 2001)Google Scholar.

40 Pan An, ‘Guangzhou shi chengshi zongti fazhan zhanyue guihua shishi zongjie’ (A summary of the implementation of the general strategic planning of Guangzhou city), in Dai, Zhang and Xu (eds.), Guangzhou chengshi guihua, vol. II, 494.

41 The renowned scientist Qian Xueseng envisioned the shanshui city ‘to make architecture and landscape that had been exclusively owned by the former emperor available to modern Chinese civilians’; Xueseng, Qian, ‘Shehui zhuyi zhongguo yinggai jian shanshui chengshi’ (Socialist China should build landscape city), Chenshi guihua (City planning), 17 (1993), 18–19Google Scholar. Qian's vision stimulated professional discourses on the shanshui city, see Shixing, Bao and Mengchao, Gu (eds.), Shanshui chengshi yu jianzhu kexue (Landscape city and architectural science) (Beijing, 1999)Google Scholar.

42 Chuanyi, Li and Xinyong, Deng, ‘Guangzhou daxuecheng guihua de xin linian yu chengshi jianshe xin jishu’ (New rationales and new urban construction technology in the planning of Guangzhou University Town), Jianzhu xue bao (Architectural journal), 439 (2005), 55Google Scholar.

43 Li and Deng, ‘Guangzhou daxuecheng guihua’; Guangzhou City Planning Bureau, ‘Guangzhou daxuecheng guihua zixun ji fazhan guihua zongshu’ (Summary of the planning consultation and development plan of Guangzhou University Town), Chengshi guihua (City planning review), 26 (2002), 90–3.

44 Xionghui, Nie, Qing, Chen and Feng, Ding, ‘Guangzhou daxuecheng xuanzhi, guihua ji shishi qingkuang’ (The planning and construction of Guangzhou University Town), in Dai, Zhang and Xu, (eds.), Guangzhou chengshi guihua, vol. III, 569–77Google Scholar.

45 The author's interviews with the teaching staff of Guangzhou University in Jul. 2008 and Dec. 2011.

46 In my interview with the teaching staff of Guangzhou University in Dec. 2011, I was told that there were commercial property developments in the University Town. The city sold land parcels in the shared town centre to commercial developers shortly after the opening of the University Town; Wu, Xu and Yeh, Urban Development in Post-Reform China.

47 Liang and Sun, Moshi yu dongyin. Elsewhere, I show urban spaces in treaty-port Shanghai were opened up and fluid; Liang, Samuel Y., Mapping Modernity in Shanghai: Space, Gender, and Visual Culture in the Sojourners’ City 1853–98 (London, 2010)Google Scholar.