Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-jkksz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-25T06:40:21.331Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Guy Merchant, Why writing still matters: Written communication in changing times. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2023. Pp. 280. Hb. £80.

Review products

Guy Merchant, Why writing still matters: Written communication in changing times. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2023. Pp. 280. Hb. £80.

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 October 2024

Sky Marsen*
Affiliation:
College of Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences, Flinders University, Bedford Park, South Australia, Australia sky.marsen@flinders.edu.au
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Type
Book Notes
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press

The book takes a ‘sociomaterial approach’, discussing writing in terms of history, technology, and social functions. It presents writing as a mode of communication, focusing on its distinctiveness and the ways in which it combines with other modes. Defining communication as ‘movement of meaningful information’, it describes writing as a ‘visible language’ and outlines major phases of its historical development and the positive and negative aspects of its uses. The book also challenges ethnocentric assumptions, such as the idea that writing was only invented once, that it makes us more intelligent, or that it is central to civilization. Part 1, ‘Impressions’, consists of four chapters focusing on pertinent definitions and the delineation of writing as a visible language. Part 2, ‘Expressions’, consists of five chapters focusing on uses and functions of writing in social settings. The two parts compose the book's overall approach, which distinguishes between the ‘technology for writing’, tools and instruments used by writers, and ‘technology of writing’, ways in which we use writing to achieve different purposes.

Part 1 distinguishes writing from speech and other modes, such as images and sounds. It emphasises the visible nature of the written sign and introduces some pertinent terms such as multimodality, writing systems, and machine learning. It considers writing as physical activity, involving hand and eye coordination, and describes the development of artefacts that accompany writing, from clay and stone, to pens and keyboards. These artefacts support the emergence of different functions of writing and its physical appearance, named ‘graphic space’. The first four chapters introduce and explain three heuristic concepts for the study of writing: the ‘display principle’, the way writing is seen, the ‘design principle’, the possibilities and constraints of the material elements on which writing is seen, and the ‘mark-making principle’, the use of tools to produce notations.

Part 2 discusses what we do with writing, highlighting reflection, connection, and elucidation. This part elaborates on genres, their social functions and ensuing power relations, represented in such actions as book burning, censorship, and, more recently, the use of hashtags to direct readers to specific information. It overviews narrative and presents writing as the mode that enabled long narratives, such as novels, to develop and promote a ‘narrative consciousness’—the representation of the world through narrative. Writing also enabled the development of organizing, labelling, and categorizing through the production of workplace texts. The last two chapters explore the effects of digital technology, which enabled the separation of storage from text and the ability to distribute text to many readers simultaneously. Throughout the book, the author presents both strengths and weaknesses of forms of writing; for example, technology brings in elements of access and availability, which depend on political factors.

The author uses a colloquial style with descriptions of facts and historical events, giving examples from a range of contexts, interspersed with personal vignettes. Despite several generalizations, due to its extensive coverage of topics, the book is a useful introduction to important concepts in the study of writing for an undergraduate and non-specialist audience.