We studied the effects of trapping intensity and lure combinations on Scolytinae (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) collections, using funnel traps at 16 sites including forests and Christmas tree farms near Erie, Pennsylvania and Toledo, Ohio, United States of America. In 2002, using 16 or 64 traps per site, all baited with α-pinene + ethanol, we collected 146 627 specimens from 40 species altogether. With 16 traps, 15–24 scolytine species were collected per site, whereas 28–31 species were collected with 64 traps. On average, 55% of all scolytine species collected with 16 traps were collected when subsampling with one trap per site, 78% with four traps, 89% with eight traps, and 95% with 12 traps. A bootstrapping analysis indicated that relatively few new species were gained by subsampling more than six traps per site. On average, similar numbers of species were collected in forests and Christmas tree farms. In 2003, we compared scolytine captures in traps baited with α-pinene, ethanol, α-pinene + ethanol, a three-component exotic Ips lure, chalcogran + methyl 2,4-decadienoate, or lineatin, or in unbaited control traps at eight sites. Overall, 31 977 scolytine specimens from 38 species were collected. Traps baited with α-pinene + ethanol captured the most scolytine species and individuals per trap in absolute terms.