Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Series Editor's Preface
- 1 The Writer, his Contexts and his Themes
- 2 A Writer Situated in a History and in a Place: Ghosh's Non-fiction
- 3 A Tale of Two Riots: The Circle of Reason and The Shadow Lines
- 4 The Ebb and Flow of Peoples across Continents and Generations: In An Antique Land, The Glass Palace, The Hungry Tide
- 5 Subaltern Agency as Fiction or Science: The Calcutta Chromosome
- 6 Beyond the Commonwealth: Amitav Ghosh and Indian Writing in English
- Topics for Discussion
- Bibliography
Topics for Discussion
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 October 2011
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Series Editor's Preface
- 1 The Writer, his Contexts and his Themes
- 2 A Writer Situated in a History and in a Place: Ghosh's Non-fiction
- 3 A Tale of Two Riots: The Circle of Reason and The Shadow Lines
- 4 The Ebb and Flow of Peoples across Continents and Generations: In An Antique Land, The Glass Palace, The Hungry Tide
- 5 Subaltern Agency as Fiction or Science: The Calcutta Chromosome
- 6 Beyond the Commonwealth: Amitav Ghosh and Indian Writing in English
- Topics for Discussion
- Bibliography
Summary
The Circle of Reason
Considering the book's title, how might reason be seen as a central topic in the book? What are its strengths and appeal in today's world, and its limitations as portrayed in the novel? Circularity also plays a large thematic role, contrasted to Bhudeb Roy's strict linear logic. Which appears to be more powerful? More helpful?
How is chance a factor in the plot? Does it have “significance,” or is it merely serendipity?
How does traditional Indian literature play a part in the book? How does Ghosh use connotations from this earlier writing to enhance his themes?
Demonstrate the use of magic realism in the book. How helpful would you say these devices are in support of Ghosh's themes? How would you compare them to Salman Rushdie's writing, or to any of the Central and South American writers like Gabriel Garcia Marquez who frequently use similar techniques?
Is Jyoti Das a necessary character?
How would you characterise the portrayal of women in this book?
Discuss the clash of traditional and modern value systems in the book.
Does the direction of the flight/quest – westward – have any implications for the theme of this book? What is being sought by the various characters? How successful is each in this quest?
Is the book hopeful? Humanistic?
Does the book show evidence of being a first novel?
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Amitav GhoshAn Introduction, pp. 178 - 184Publisher: Foundation BooksPrint publication year: 2005