5 - Income Distribution and Labor Relations

Summary

The multinational enterprise's relationship to wages and income distribution raises questions at two levels of analysis. In general equilibrium, the MNE reallocates capital between nations. That transfer can alter the income distribution within the source and host countries. In the individual industry (partial-equilibrium analysis), the MNE can affect the labor-management bargain. We shall take up these two levels of analysis in turn; the concluding section will suggest some propositions about the relationship between them.

Income Distribution in General Equilibrium

In the early 1970s, U.S. labor unions campaigned strenuously to restrict foreign investment by U.S. corporations, in the name of saving American jobs. Nearly two decades later Glickman and Woodward (1989) argued that, while U.S. investment abroad destroys American jobs, foreign MNEs' investments in the United States do not create very many. Similar issues arise periodically in other countries, as in Japan's concern in the 1980s that foreign investment was “hollowing out” its manufacturing sector. Economic analysis does not accept the popular view that foreign investment permanently changes the level of unemployment, but it does affirm that short-run changes in unemployment and permanent changes in real wages can result. Exactly what changes are predicted depends sensitively on assumptions about the nature of direct investment and the structure of the economy. We start with the long-run effects on income distribution and wages and then treat employment effects as their short-run counterparts.

Theoretical Models

International-trade theory offers several models that relate international factor movements to the distribution of income.