Book contents
- Reasons and Context in Comparative Law
- Reasons and Context in Comparative Law
- Copyright page
- Contents
- Contributors
- Foreword
- Preface: John Bell
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Introduction
- 2 What Can Law Schools Offer Other Disciplines?
- 3 Examining Vicarious Liability Comparatively
- 4 What’s in a Name?
- 5 ‘An Art Obscured with Difficult Cases’
- 6 Observations on the Reform of the French Law on Contractual Interpretation
- 7 Assessing (Divergent) Legal Development
- 8 Roundabout Law
- 9 A Comparative Reflection on Chilean Economic Torts
- 10 Judicial Identity Crises
- 11 Researching Judicial Cultures in the European Union
- John Bell’s Principal Publications
- Index
2 - What Can Law Schools Offer Other Disciplines?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 27 April 2023
- Reasons and Context in Comparative Law
- Reasons and Context in Comparative Law
- Copyright page
- Contents
- Contributors
- Foreword
- Preface: John Bell
- Acknowledgements
- 1 Introduction
- 2 What Can Law Schools Offer Other Disciplines?
- 3 Examining Vicarious Liability Comparatively
- 4 What’s in a Name?
- 5 ‘An Art Obscured with Difficult Cases’
- 6 Observations on the Reform of the French Law on Contractual Interpretation
- 7 Assessing (Divergent) Legal Development
- 8 Roundabout Law
- 9 A Comparative Reflection on Chilean Economic Torts
- 10 Judicial Identity Crises
- 11 Researching Judicial Cultures in the European Union
- John Bell’s Principal Publications
- Index
Summary
This chapter, stimulated by Professor Bell’s contribution to legal education (as well as to comparative law and legal reasoning), tackles the question of whether traditional doctrinal law has anything to offer, intellectually, to disciplines outside law. That is to say, does law export knowledge to other disciplines or does it just import knowledge? Despite John Bell’s positive agenda asserted some eighteen or so years ago, this examination presents a gloomy picture. This is not to argue that law faculties are making no contributions to the Academy in general – indeed, the opposite is true. But such contributions are largely founded on knowledge imported into law faculties. Comparative lawyers, or some of them such as Professor Bell, offer some hope.
Keywords
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Reasons and Context in Comparative LawEssays in Honour of John Bell, pp. 16 - 37Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2023